Controversy in spine care. Is fusion necessary after anterior cervical discectomy?

Anterior cervical discectomy is an effective and reliable treatment for nerve root or cord compression caused by disc herniation or spondylosis. Although physicians have traditionally included fusion as a part of this procedure, recent experience has suggested that this may not be necessary. Dr. Volker Sonntag and Dr. Peter Klara express opposing views on the need for fusion after discectomy and support their perspectives with clinical experience and a review of the pathoanatomy of disc disease. Dr. Sonntag believes that the majority of patients are well served with discectomy alone, avoiding the complications of graft harvest and potential nonunion. Dr. Klara feels that the interposed graft restores foraminal height and maintains cervical lordosis, both of which are important to a good outcome.     

The effect of post-injury spinal position on canal occlusion in a cervical spine burst fracture model

STUDY DESIGN: The canal space of burst-fractured, human cervical spine specimens was monitored to determine the extent to which spinal position affected post-injury occlusion. OBJECTIVE: To test the null hypothesis that there is no difference in spinal canal occlusion as a function of spinal positioning for a burst-fractured cervical spine model. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Although previous studies have documented the effect of spinal positioning on canal geometry in intact cadaver spines, to the authors' knowledge, none has examined this relationship specifically in a burst fracture model. METHODS: Eight human cervical spine specimens (levels C1 to T3) were fractured by axial impact, and the resulting burst injuries were documented using post-injury radiographs and computed tomography scans. Canal occlusion was measured using a custom transducer in which water was circulated through a section of flexible tygon tubing that was passed through the spinal canal. Any impingement on the tubing produced a rise in fluid pressure that was monitored with a pressure transducer. Each spine was positioned in flexion, extension, lateral (and off-axis) bending, axial rotation, traction, and compression, while canal occlusion and angular position were monitored. Occlusion values for each position were compared with measurements taken with the spine in neutral position. RESULTS: Compared with neutral position, compression, extension, and extension combined with lateral bending significantly increased canal occlusion, whereas flexion decreased the extent of occlusion. In extension, the observed mechanism of occlusion was ligamentum flavum bulge caused by ligament laxity resulting from reduced vertebral body height. CONCLUSIONS: Increased compression of the spinal cord after injury may lead to more extensive neurologic loss. This study demonstrated that placing a burst-fractured cervical spine into either extension or compression significantly increased canal occlusion as compared with occlusion in a neutral position.     

Enhanced surveillance for pesticide poisoning in the Western Cape--an elusive target

OBJECTIVE: To determine the effects of cervical flexion and traction on foraminal volume and isthmus area at the C5-C6 foraminal space in cadavers. DESIGN: This study evaluated the foraminal space at C5-C6 in cadaver specimens during flexion and traction of the cervical spine. SETTING: An orthopedic biomechanics laboratory and department of radiology of a university medical center. PATIENTS OR OTHER PARTICIPANTS: Nine cadaver cervical spines, C1 through T3, were used in the study. Superficial tissues were dissected, preserving the ligaments. INTERVENTIONS: Proximal and distal portions of the cadaver spines were potted using bone cement. Spines were mounted and imaged with computed tomography in neutral position, 15 degrees of flexion, and maximum flexion with and without 25lbs of axial traction. MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: The areas and volumes of the foramen were measured and calculated. RESULTS: Flexion alone significantly increased the foraminal volume and isthmus area at C5-C6. Traction resulted in little additional change. CONCLUSIONS: For cervical spines with mild to moderate degenerative changes at C5-C6, cervical flexion with or without traction produces significant increases in foraminal volume and area at the foraminal isthmus.     

Biomechanical aspects of the subarachnoid space and cervical cord in healthy individuals examined with kinematic magnetic resonance imaging

STUDY DESIGN: In vivo flexion-extension magnetic resonance imaging studies of the cervical spine were performed inside a positioning device. OBJECTIVE: To determine the functional changes of the cervical cord and the subarachnoid space that occur during flexion and extension of the cervical spine in healthy individuals. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: As an addition to static magnetic resonance imaging examinations, kinematic magnetic resonance imaging studies of the cervical spine were performed to obtain detailed information about functional aspects of the cervical cord and the subarachnoid space. The results were compared with published data of functional flexion-extension myelograms of the cervical spine. METHODS: The cervical spines of 40 healthy individuals were examined in a whole-body magnetic resonance scanner from 50 degrees of flexion to 30 degrees of extension, using a positioning device. At nine different angle positions, sagittal T1-weighted spin-echo sequences were obtained. The images were analyzed with respect to the segmental motion, the diameter of the subarachnoid space, and the diameter of the cervical cord. RESULTS: The segmental motion between flexion and extension was 11 degrees at C2-C3, 12 degrees at C3-C4, 15 degrees at C4-C5, 19 degrees at C5-C6, and 20 degrees at C6-C7. At flexion, a narrowing of the ventral subarachnoid space of up to 43% and a widening of the dorsal subarachnoid space of up to 89% (compared with the neutral position, 0 degrees) were observed. At extension, an increase in the diameter of the ventral subarachnoid space of up to 9% was observed, whereas the dorsal subarachnoid space was reduced to 17%. At flexion, there was a reduction in the sagittal diameter of the cervical cord of up to 14%, and, at extension, there was an increase of up to 15%, compared with the neutral position (0 degrees; these values varied depending on the cervical segment. Statistically significant differences (P < 0.05) were found between flexion and extension in the diameter of the ventral and dorsal subarachnoid space and in the diameter of the cervical cord. CONCLUSIONS: Compared with the results of previous studies using functional cervical myelograms, kinematic magnetic resonance imaging provides additional noninvasive data concerning the physiologic changes of the cervical subarachnoid space and the cervical cord during flexion and extension in healthy individuals.     

Regression of cervical disc herniation observed on magnetic resonance images

STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective study of cervical disc herniation using results of repeated magnetic resonance imaging examinations. OBJECTIVES: To clarify the cervical disc herniation morphological changes over time in order to establish a strategy for treatment. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: In the authors' previous magnetic resonance imaging follow-up study of patients with lumbar disc herniation, spontaneous regression was observed in the sequestration-type lesions, and it was found that the tendency toward regression differed based on the anatomic position of extruded disc material. METHODS: Thirty-eight patients with cervical disc herniation who underwent repeated magnetic resonance imaging examinations were studied. The changes over time in herniated disc size were evaluated using this imaging technique. Evaluation showed the characteristics of those in whom spontaneous regression was found, such as extrusion pattern, and the clinical outcome was evaluated by symptoms. RESULTS: In 15 patients (40%), the volume of herniated material was decreased. The interval from onset of symptoms to the initial examination was significantly shorter in the regression group than in the group that showed no change in disc herniation. By extrusion pattern, cervical disc herniation, which was divided into migration type on sagittal view and lateral type on axial view, most frequently exhibited spontaneous regression. All of the patients with radicular pain and upper limb amyotrophy were treated successfully with conservative therapy. CONCLUSION: Although the possibility of the combination of hemorrhage and disc material could not be denied, active resorption of herniated material probably occurred during the acute phase. Extruded material exposed to the epidural space may be resorbed more quickly than that beneath the ligament. Vascular supply probably plays a role in the mechanism of resorption. The phase and position of extrusion were the significant factors affecting cervical disc herniation resorption. It was demonstrated that examination performed during the acute phase using magnetic resonance imaging is necessary for elucidation of the pathogenesis of cervical disc herniation, and that migrating, lateral-type herniations regress so frequently that conservative treatment should be chosen not only for patients with radicular pain, but also for those with upper limb amyotrophy.     

Late results of cervical disc surgery

Late results of cervical disc surgery have been reported and statistically studied in 383 cases: 83% were lateral discs, 13% were central spondylosis discs, and 4% central soft discs. Central spondylosis occured at a higher spinal level, and caused cord compression with or without weakness of the hands, but no pain. A posterior approach was used in all lateral discs, and either an anterior or a posterior approach, with or without fusion, for central discs. Preoperative myelography was always done and is recommended postoperatively in central disc surgery to evaluate the results. Our results were good to excellent in 95% of lateral discs, in 64% of central spondylosis discs, and in an unexpected 91% of 11 cases of central soft discs. There were no recurrences and no serious complications, although 20% developed other cervical or lumbar disc herniations.     

The slump test: the effects of head and lower extremity position on knee extension

Maitland's slump test is a widely used neural tissue tension test. During slump testing, terminal knee extension is assessed for signs of restricted range of motion (ROM), which may indicate impaired neural tissue mobility. A number of refinements that modify hip and ankle position has been added to the basic slump test procedure, but no research to date has measured the effects of ankle and hip position on knee extension ROM during testing. The purpose of this study was to examine the effect of neural tension-producing movements of the cervical spine and lower extremity on knee extension ROM during the slump test. Thirty-four males with no significant history of low back pain were tested in the slump position with the cervical spine flexed and extended in each of three lower extremity test positions: neutral hip rotation with the ankle in a position of subject comfort (neutral), neutral hip rotation with ankle dorsiflexion (ankle dorsiflexion), and medial hip rotation with ankle dorsiflexion. Results showed significant decreases in active knee extension ROM (F1,198 = 29.53, p < 0.0001) in the cervical flexion compared with the cervical extension conditions. Subjects also exhibited significant decreases in active knee extension ROM (F2,198 = 56.76, p < 0.0001) as they were progressed from neutral to the ankle dorsiflexion to the medial hip rotation with ankle dorsiflexion positions of the lower extremity. The results of our study indicate that limitations in terminal knee extension ROM may be considered a normal response to the inclusion of cervical flexion, ankle dorsiflexion, or medial hip rotation in the slump test in young, healthy, adult males. In addition, the presence of a cumulative effect on knee extension ROM with the simultaneous application of these motions is noted. These findings may assist clinicians when assessing knee extension ROM during slump testing.     

A biomechanical evaluation of graft loading characteristics for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion. A comparison of traditional and reverse grafting techniques

STUDY DESIGN: A biomechanical study of graft loading characteristics for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion comparing the amount and location of transmitted forces. OBJECTIVES: To evaluate the difference between traditional iliac grafting and reverse iliac grafting used for anterior cervical discectomy and fusion in the amount and location of forces applied to the grafts. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Traditional fusion after anterior cervical discectomy involves placing a tricortical iliac crest strut into the disc space with the cortical portion facing anteriorly and the cancellous portion posteriorly. Recently, reverse iliac grafting has been introduced in which the cortical portion is placed in the posterior disc space and the cancellous portion in the anterior disc space. There is no biomechanical or clinical study showing an advantage of using one technique over the other. This study is the first to produce data supporting one technique as biomechanically superior. METHODS: Five fresh cadaveric cervical spines were tested using pressure-sensitive film placed between the bone graft and the vertebral endplate after an anterior discectomy was performed. A 10-pound load was applied to the cervical spine at predetermined sagittal positions. Recordings were made at neutral, 10 degrees of flexion, and 10 degrees and 20 degrees of extension after traditional and reverse iliac grafting. RESULTS: Graft forces were identical in both traditional and reverse grafting in the location and amount of force applied. Total force increased to the maximum in flexion and gradually decreased in more extended positions. The location of the forces was completely anterior with flexion, moving to the posterior portion of the graft with positions of extension. With 10 degrees of flexion, the load applied to the grafts was 20.4 N. In the neutral position, the load was 12 N. The loads decreased further with extension with forces of 11 N in 10 degrees extension, and 4 N in 20 degrees of extension. CONCLUSIONS: The optimal position of the tricortical iliac graft for an anterior cervical fusion is with the stronger cortical portion placed in the anterior disc space and the weaker cancellous portion placed in the posterior disc space. In this traditional position, the graft will best resist the loads applied to the cervical spine, preventing graft collapse.     

Intradiscal pressure recordings in the cervical spine

OBJECTIVE: Experimental investigations analyzing the biomechanics of the cervical spine are less common than similar studies of other regions of the spine. There are no reports on cervical intradiscal pressure (PID) measurements in vitro. We therefore wanted to establish normal values for PID under physiological conditions by simultaneous muscle force simulation. Moreover, the impact of ventral cervical fusion should be elucidated, because in clinical studies, it is a well-known phenomenon that the adjacent segments often show increased degenerative changes. We present a pilot study. METHODS: Seven human cervical spine specimens were tested biomechanically in a specially developed spine tester. Only pure moments were used for flexion/extension, axial rotation, and lateral bending (maximal moment +/- 0.5 Nm). PID was measured simultaneously in C3-C4 and C5-C6. The specimens were tested as intact specimens and after discectomy and fusion in C4-C5. Both test situations were repeated with simulation of muscle forces. RESULTS: We found characteristic load-pressure curves for each of the three motion axes. In neutral position, PID correlated well with former published data from in vivo measurements. After fusion of C4-C5, there was a marked increase of PID in both adjacent segments (e.g., < or = 180% for axial rotation). With muscle force simulation, the increase was even higher (e.g., < or = 400% for axial rotation). CONCLUSION: For the first time, PID could be measured in the cervical spine in an experimental setting. The results obtained using normal specimens under physiological conditions confirmed those reported in two clinical studies. After cervical fusion, a marked increase in PID could be found in both adjacent segments. Presuming that an increase in PID had a negative effect on metabolism of the intervertebral disc, our results may help to explain why progressive degeneration occurs in these segments.     

The antero-posterior diameter of the cervical spinal canal in cervical spondylosis (author's transl)

1. The antero-posterior diameter (APD) of the cervical spinal canals in 96 healthy adults, 108 cases of radiological cervical spondylosis (asymptomatic) and 96 cases of cervical spondylosis with radiculopathy or radiculomyelopathy was measured for each vertebra by the method of Burrows. (Filmfocus distance was 1.2m). 2. The APD in patients with symptomatic spondylosis was found to be significantly narrower than those of without. 3. Since the upper limit of APD at C4 to C6 vertebrae in symptomatic spondylosis was 16 mm, while the lower limit of APD in asymtomatic spondylosis was 14 mm, the following conclusion appears justified. 1) When the APD is narrower than 16 mm, the osteophytes along the posterior border of the spinal bodies or degenerative disc protrusions may produce cervical radiculomyelopathy, although the cord and the roots may escape from compression by the spondylotic changes even when the APD is wider than 14 mm. 2) When the APD is narrower than 13 mm, it is almost always certain that the osteophytes or herniated discs compress the cervical cord and roots.     

The stiffness of lumbar spinal motion segments with a high-intensity zone in the anulus fibrosus

STUDY DESIGN: Biomechanical and anatomic study of human cadaveric spinal motion segments. OBJECTIVES: To measure the stiffness of spinal motion segments by disc type and by load type (flexion, extension, axial rotation, or lateral bending). To compare stiffness in motion segments with and without a high-intensity zone or radial tear in the anulus fibrosus. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: The high-intensity zone, that is a linear zone of high-intensity on T2-weighted magnetic resonance images corresponding to a radial tear in the anulus fibrosus, is a marker for a painful disc at discography. The high-intensity zone is hypothetically associated with diminished stiffness of the motion segment. METHODS: Human cadaveric lumbar spinal motion segments with normal disc morphology or a high-intensity zone of the anulus fibrosus were selected on the basis of magnetic resonance imaging. The motion segments were subjected to incremental flexion, extension, rotation, and lateral bending torques. Rotation was measured with a kinematic system. Torque-rotation curves and stiffness were calculated for each motion segment and for each torque. The motion segments were sectioned on a cryomicrotome to verify the disc morphology as normal or as that of a radial tear. RESULTS: In four motion segments with normal discs, stiffness was greater in axial rotation (8.4 Nm/degree) than in lateral bending (2.3 Nm/degree), flexion (1.8 Nm/degree), or extension (2.6 Nm/degree). In 16 motion segments with a high-intensity zone, stiffness was 2.4 Nm/degree in axial rotation, and less severely reduced in lateral bending, flexion, and extension. Stiffness in motion segments with a high-intensity zone was significantly less with smaller than with larger axial rotation loads. CONCLUSIONS: The presence of a high-intensity zone in the intervertebral disc is associated with reduced stiffness of motion segments. The reduction is greater in axial rotation than in other torques. The reduction is more in smaller than in larger axial torques.     

Magnetic resonance imaging and clinical follow-up: study of 27 patients receiving chiropractic care for cervical and lumbar disc herniations

OBJECTIVE: To prospectively investigate the effect of chiropractic management on clinical and anatomical outcome of disc pathomorphology in previously magnetic resonance imaging (MRI)-documented disc herniation of the cervical and lumbar spine. SETTING: Private practice. SUBJECTS: Twenty-seven patients with MRI-documented and symptomatic disc herniations of the cervical or lumbar spine. A prospective clinical case series. DESIGN: All patients were evaluated before commencement of chiropractic care by MRI scans for presence of disc herniations. Precare evaluations also included clinical examination and visual analog scores. Patients were then treated with a course of care that included traction, flexion distraction, spinal manipulative therapy, physiotherapy and rehabilitative exercises. All patients were re-evaluated by postcare follow-up MRI scans, clinical examination and visual analog scores. Percentage of disc shrinkage on repeat MRI, resolution of clinical examination findings, reduced visual analog pain scores and whether the patient returned to work were all recorded. RESULTS: Clinically, 80% of the patients studied had a good clinical outcome with postcare visual analog scores under 2 and resolution of abnormal clinical examination findings. Anatomically, after repeat MRI scans, 63% of the patients studied revealed a reduced size or completely resorbed disc herniation. There was a statistically significant association (p < .005) between the clinical and MRI follow-up results. Seventy-eight percent of the patients were able to return to work in their predisability occupations. CONCLUSION: This prospective case series suggests that chiropractic care may be a safe and helpful modality for the treatment of cervical and lumbar disc herniations. A random, controlled, clinical trial is called for to further substantiate the role of chiropractic care for the nonoperative clinical management of intervertebral disc herniation.     

Postural changes of the cervical spine in patients with nontoxic goiter

PURPOSE: To investigate differences in cervical spine posture and range of motion and self-reported neck pain and headache between patients with nontoxic goiter compared with a matched control group. DESIGN: An observational, controlled, blinded study. SETTING: The ambulatory outpatient facility of a university hospital. PARTICIPANTS: Twenty-five nontoxic goiter patients and 25 matched nongoiterous control subjects from the Department of Endocrinology. INTERVENTION: Participants were X-rayed from a lateral position in neutral, full flexion and full extension, and the radiographs were evaluated by a blinded examiner for anterior head carriage, maximal flexion, maximal extension and the extent and severity of any degenerative changes in the cervical spine. The degree of postural neck muscle tenderness was evaluated by a blinded rheumatologist using a validated Total Tenderness Score system. In addition, the two groups were compared for their self-reported frequency of neck pain and headaches. RESULTS: A significant increase in anterior head carriage was found among the goiter patients (p = .01), together with a corresponding decrease in flexion (p = .01), whereas the corresponding increase in extension was not statistically significant (p = .16). A higher prevalence of headaches was found in the goiter group (p = .06), but there was no difference in neck muscle tenderness (p = .40) or frequency of neck problems (p = .40) between the groups. The severity of degenerative changes in the cervical spine (p = .22) and the number of vertebral levels with degenerative changes (p = .13) were similar in the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Goiters of > 100 g seem to alter the posture of the cervical spine, possibly resulting in a tendency for more frequent headaches. The changes do not seem to cause more neck pain, muscle tenderness or degeneration of the cervical spine.     

Cervical orthoses effect on cervical spine motion: roentgenographic and goniometric method of study

Movement of the cervical spine in the sagittal plane was studied in ten normal subjects from 20 to 30 years of age without and with four different cervical orthoses: (1) polyethylene Camp plastic collar with chin and occiput piece, (2) plastizote Philadelphia collar, (3) four-poster and (4) SOMI (sternal occipital mandibular immobilization). The effect of the orthoses on restricting sagittal motion was measured simultaneously using roentgenographic and bubble goniometric methods. The subject was immobilized in a straight back chair to eliminate trunk motion, and lateral cervical spine films were taken of each subject in neutral, flexion and extension without and with each orthotic device. Distortion forces exerted on the orthotic devices were standardized by measurement of pressures at the chin and occiput. Roentgenographic measurements of flexion and extension and anteroposterior displacement of the cervical spine were compared to the measurements obtained by bubble goniometry. The four-poster and SOMI were found to be most effective in restricting extension and flexion respectively. The polyethylene and plastizote orthoses were significantly less effective in restricting motion. The bubble goniometer is an adequate clinical tool in assessing overall flexion-extension of the cervical spine but is not so precise and does not give information on the degree of motion at an individual vertebral level.     

Neuropathology in cats experimentally infected with feline immunodeficiency virus: a morphological, immunocytochemical and morphometric study

Head flexion and extension movements near the natural head position (NHP) were analysed for the location of the mean instantaneous centre of rotation (ICR). Forty-six healthy young adults (30 women and 16 men) with sound dentitions, free from cranio-cervical disorders, performed habitual movements that were automatically detected and measured by an infrared three-dimensional motion analyser. ICR and curvature radius were calculated for each movement and subject. In both extension and flexion, ICR position changed during the motion. The movement was symmetrical in all subjects. No gender or flexion/extension differences were found for both ICR position and relevant curvature radius. On average, ICR relative to NHP soft-tissue nasion was located at about 150% of the soft-tissue nasion-right tragus distance, with an angle of about 220 degrees relative to the true horizontal. Results suggest that head flexion or extension is always performed with a combination of rotation (atlanto-occipital joint) and translation (cervical spine) even in the first degrees of motion. Moreover, NHP at rest seems to be some degree more flexed and anterior than head position during movements. These relative positions and their muscular determinants could also influence mandibular posture at rest and during functional movements.     

In vivo kinematics of the cervical spine. Part I: Development of a roentgen stereophotogrammetric technique using metallic markers and assessment of its accuracy

A technique for simultaneous roentgen stereophotogrammetry (RS) was developed, and its accuracy was assessed. In vitro models fabricated from dried cadaveric C4 and C5 vertebrae were used to simulate the motion behavior of the cervical spine. Metallic markers made of Vitallium beads (diameter < 0.3 mm) were implanted into the posterior and anterior surfaces of each vertebra at surgically accessible locations to simulate the bead placement for both posterior and anterior surgical approaches to the cervical spine. A series of roentgen stereo pairs were obtained to systematically assess the accuracy (validity) of displacement measurements in anteroposterior (AP) translation, axial rotation, and flexion/extension. In addition, the effects of soft tissue density on the accuracy of the system were investigated by obtaining a series of roentgen stereo pairs with the experimental model immersed in a water bath. The coordinates of the metallic markers on the radiographs were then digitized by two raters who were not informed of the actual motion (i.e., blind study). The results indicated a high accuracy throughout the study. Overall root mean square errors were 0.07 mm for AP translation, 0.08 degrees for axial rotation, and 0.14 degrees for flexion/extension. The corresponding accuracy estimates (R2 values by linear regression analysis) were very high (0.992, 0.998, and 0.995) when the measurement results were compared with the actual displacements. The water bath did not affect measurement accuracy, indicating that soft tissue density should have little effect on the accuracy of the technique for in vivo applications. This system appears to be an accurate and reliable method for assessment of simulated in vivo cervical spine motion, regardless of the rater. The technique has been further used in in vivo assessment of cervical spine kinematics in one patient to confirm the efficacy of the developed technique.     

Ideal thickness of Smith-Robinson graft for anterior cervical fusion. A cadaveric study with computed tomographic correlation

To establish the optimal thickness for Smith-Robinson anterior cervical fusion grafts, anterior C4-5 discectomy and fusions were performed on six fresh, frozen cadavers. Plain radiographs and computed tomographic scans then were employed to correlate graft placement with changes in disc space height, foraminal height, and foraminal areas after 3-, 5-, 7-, and 9-mm interbody fusions. The ideal graft thickness appeared to be directly related to the preoperative baseline disc height. For a preoperative disc height of 3.5-6.0 mm, an interbody graft of 2 mm above baseline thickness was most appropriate. A thicker graft was required when the baseline disc height was smaller (2.0 mm) and a thinner graft when the disc height was larger (7.4 mm). No significant correlation was noted between disc space distraction at C4-5 and disc height, foraminal height, or foraminal area at adjacent levels.     

The developmental segmental sagittal diameter of the cervical spinal canal in patients with cervical spondylosis

The role of the narrow cervical spinal canal in the expression of clinical syndromes in the cervical spine was investigated in a retrospective review of 63 patients with symptomatic cervical spondylosis refractory to conservative therapy. The measurement of the developmental segmental sagittal diameter, determined at the level of the pedicle, and of the spondylotic segmental sagittal diameter, determined at the level of the disc, were applied. When divided into groups based on anatomic variance around an average size midcervical diameter of 17 mm, 40 patients were found to have less than the average size of midcervical canal. A spondylosis index was computed for the narrow canal group at 2.08 mm per segment and for the wide canal group at 3.29. Canal dimensions are determinants of symptom production and neurologic compromise.     

The role of anteromedial foraminotomy and the uncovertebral joints in the stability of the cervical spine. A biomechanical study

STUDY DESIGN: The biomechanical role of the cervical uncovertebral joint was investigated using human cadaveric spines. Sequential resection of cervical uncovertebral joints, including clinical anteromedial foraminotomy, was conducted, followed by biomechanical testing after each stage of resection. OBJECTIVES: To clarify the biomechanical role of uncovertebral joints and clinical anteromedial foraminotomy in the cervical spine and their effects on interbody bone graft stability. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Although the biomechanical role of the cervical uncovertebral joints has been considered to be that of a guiding mechanism in flexion and extension and a limiting mechanism in posterior translation and lateral bending, there have been no studies quantifying this role. According to results in quantitative anatomic studies, anatomic variations exist in uncovertebral joints, depending on the vertebral level, articular angulation, and relative height of the joints. METHODS: Fourteen human functional spinal units at C3-C4 and C6-C7 underwent sequential uncovertebral joint resection, with each stage of resection followed by biomechanical testing. The uncovertebral joint was divided anatomically into three parts on each side: the posterior foraminal part, the posterior half, and the anterior half. The loading modes included torsion, flexion, extension, and lateral bending. A simulated anterior bone graft construct was also tested after each uncovertebral joint resection procedure. RESULTS: Significant changes in stability were observed after sequential uncovertebral joint resection in all loading modes (P < 0.05). The biomechanical contribution of uncovertebral joints decreased in the following order: the posterior foraminal part, the posterior half, and the anterior half. Unilateral and bilateral foraminotomy most affected the stability of the functional spinal unit during extension, causing a 30% and 36% decrease in stiffness of the functional spinal unit, respectively. The effect was less in torsion and lateral bending. After sequential resection, there was a statistically significant difference between decreases in torsional stiffness at C3-C4 and C6-C7 (P < 0.05). The stiffness of the simulated bone graft construct decreased progressively during flexion and lateral bending after each foraminotomy (P < 0.05). Increased bone graft height of 79% returned stability to the preforaminotomy level. CONCLUSIONS: This is the first study to quantitate the biomechanical role of uncovertebral joints in cervical segmental stability and the effect at each intervertebral level. The effect differs because of anatomic variations in uncovertebral joints. The major biomechanical function of uncovertebral joints includes the regulation of extension and lateral bending motion, followed by torsion, which is mainly provided by the posterior uncovertebral joints. This study highlights the clinical assessment of additional segmental instability attributed to destruction of the uncovertebral joints during surgical procedures or by neoplastic lesions.     

Indication and clinical results of laminoplasty for cervical myelopathy caused by disc herniation with developmental canal stenosis

STUDY DESIGN: The outcome of a herniated disc in patients with cervical myelopathy treated by laminoplasty without discectomy and in those treated conservatively was studied by magnetic resonance imaging. OBJECTIVES: To compare the surgical results of laminoplasty with those of anterior spinal fusion in patients with myelopathy caused by to cervical disc herniation and to make a treatment strategy for cervical disc herniation depending on these results. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Anterior discectomy and spinal fusion have had acceptable surgical results, but many complications have been reported, especially adjacent segment degeneration and bone graft complications. METHODS: Forty-seven patients with cervical disc herniation were examined in this study. Of them, 32 patients (mean age, 56 years) underwent laminoplasty without resection of the herniated disc. Seven patients with mild cervical myelopathy and 8 patients with radiculopathy (mean age, 53 years) were treated conservatively. As a control group, 44 patients (mean age, 50.3 years) who underwent anterior spinal fusion were examined. All patients in the laminoplasty group also had congenital spinal canal stenosis in which the ventrodorsal canal diameter was less than 13 mm. The association between the outcome of a herniated disc and clinical features was investigated. The severity of myelopathy was evaluated according to the Japanese Orthopaedic Association's scoring system. Surgical outcomes were evaluated by the system of Hirabayashi for determining recovery rate. RESULTS: The recovery rate averaged 67.9% in laminoplasty and 68.8% in anterior spinal fusion. There were no significant differences between the groups. No patients underwent anterior spinal fusion after laminoplasty. Follow-up magnetic resonance imaging showed regression of the size of the herniated disc in 15 of the 20 patients in the laminoplasty group and in 12 of 15 patients treated conservatively. In the MRI studies of the natural course of disc herniation, the size of the herniated disc decreased to almost half in 1 to 2 months and almost disappeared within 3 months after surgery. CONCLUSIONS: The size of the herniated disc in cervical lesions regressed as it does in the lumbar lesions. Laminoplasty for patients with narrowed spinal canals showed favorable surgical results. Therefore, the therapeutic method for cervical disc herniation should be chosen after taking the natural history of the disc herniation into consideration.