Interaction of willow (Salix) clones grown in polyclonal stands in short rotation coppice

Stool survival of Salix spp. clones is reduced when growing in polyclonal stands as compared to monoclonal stands. Stools growing in polyclonal stands show increased vigour with compensation of weak or dead stools from adjacent stools. In monoclonal stands the stools tend to be less vigorous but there is also less variation between stools. When a clone, which has become highly susceptible to rust infection, is included in the mixture, e.g. Salix burjatica Korso, it will die out completely within two years.     

The influence of soil and coppice cycle on the rooting habit of short rotation poplar and willow coppice

The increased demand for renewable energy sources has led to large areas of former agricultural land being proposed for short rotation coppice (SRC) establishment. Concerns expressed over the potential impacts of tree roots on buried archaeological evidence led to a study into the rooting habit of SRC. Roots were exposed in trenches dug within a variety of willow and poplar clonal stands grown on brown earth, pelosol, ground-water gley and surface-water gley soils. Root depths and diameters were recorded in each of the 33 trenches. In total, over 18,000 roots were measured on 264 coppice stools. The rotation length, species and stool location within a block were all found to influence the maximum size of root produced. Soil type had some influence on the root number and depth, but the pattern of root distribution down the soil profile was similar for both species.     

The influence of canopy density on willow leaf rust (Melampsora epitea) severity in willow short rotation coppice

Willow short rotation coppice is used as a renewable energy source and also as a vegetation filter for purifying wastewater. Wastewater irrigation might change microclimatic conditions and increase the canopy density in plantations, which might decrease production due to leaf rust (Melampsora epitea). The aim of this study was to estimate the impact of the canopy density on rust abundance on willows. For that, we counted rust pustules on leaves of five different willow clones from dense and sparse areas in both the wastewater irrigated and control part of the plantation. The results demonstrated clear differences between clones; clone ‘81090’ was very susceptible, ‘78183’ susceptible, ‘78021’ fairly tolerant and ‘Tora’ rust resistant. Clone ‘Gudrun’, which was previously reported resistant, had severe rust damages in Estonia. In the case of clones ‘78183’ and ‘78021’ there were significantly more rust pustules per leaf unit area at areas with denser canopy, which confirmed that higher plant density could result in biomass losses caused by leaf rust. No differences, however, were detected between dense and sparse areas of hybrid clone ‘Gudrun’, most probably because in this particular case leaves from upper canopy layer were used. There was a tendency detected that clones with a higher number of shoots per plant had more rust damages on their leaves, however, the correlation was not statistically confirmed. In conclusion, the impact of canopy density on rust abundance is clone-specific and significant in the case of clones on which infection starts from the lower part of the canopy.     

Life cycle assessment of biomass chains: Wood pellet from short rotation coppice using data measured on a real plant

This paper presents a LCA study about household heat from Short Rotation Coppice wood pellets combustion. The overall process, from field growth to ash disposal, was considered; environmental analysis was carried out using a LCA software programme (Simapro 7.0) and adopting the EcoIndicator 99 model for the evaluation of the global burden; analysis with EPS 2000 and EDIP methodologies were also carried out, in order to compare the different approaches. For the pellet production process, mass and energy flows were measured on an existing Italian plant, while other data were obtained from the Literature; a comparison between results obtained using only data from Literature and using data from the existing plant was made, showing for the pelleting phase a value of about 23% lower if measured data are used. The LCA study showed that agricultural operations account for most of the environmental impact if evaluated both with EcoIndicator 99 and EPS 2000; EDIP gave results that were not very reliable for this chain, due to the high weight given to the infra-structures and machinery construction. The comparison between data obtained considering and not considering the infra-structures contribution in the LCA analysis with EcoIndicator 99 showed a modest contribution of infra-structures on the final score (about 2%). The overall impact evaluated with EcoIndicator 99 is considerably less than the one caused by natural gas heating. The Energy Return Ratio was finally calculated; a value of 3.25 was found, good if compared to the one for the methane combustion, equal to 6.     

Economics of electricity and heat production by gasification or flash pyrolysis of short rotation coppice in Flanders (Belgium)

Short rotation coppice (SRC) seems attractive as an energy crop on degraded land. Gasification and flash pyrolysis are promising technologies for the conversion of SRC into energy or chemicals. A model has been developed to calculate the net present value (NPV) of the cash flows generated by an investment in gasification or flash pyrolysis of SRC for the production of electricity or for combined heat and power production. The NPV has been calculated and compared for (combined heat and) power stations with an electrical capacity (P_e) between 5 MW and 20 MW. Furthermore the minimal amount of heat that has to be sold to make combined heat and power production more profitable than pure electricity production has been determined. By performing Monte Carlo simulations, key variables that influence the NPV have been identified.In the case of small scale SRC conversion, i.e. at an electrical capacity of 5 MW-10 MW, flash pyrolysis is more profitable than gasification. At the smallest scale of 5 MW it is necessary to invest in combined heat and power production, as the sole production of electricity is not profitable at this low scale. At an electrical capacity of 10 MW flash pyrolysis for the sole production of electricity becomes profitable, but gasification for electricity production is still not viable. At this capacity however, the extra investments required in the case of combined heat and power production are already paid back if only 25% of the produced heat can be sold. At a higher capacity of 20 MW, the technology choice becomes unclear taking into account the most uncertain variables, i.e. investment cost parameters and energetic efficiencies.     

The effects of policy incentives in the adoption of willow short rotation coppice for bioenergy in Sweden

The effect of policy incentives in the development of short rotation willow plantations for bioenergy is studied by using an aggregate adoption model based on sigmoidal curves for the Swedish municipalities. A total of 56 municipalities were studied, with 891 farmers that planted willow during the period 1986–1996. The model included variables related to the subsidies applied, the taxation on fossil fuels, the development of the wood-fuel consumption by the district heating systems, and the geographical and socio-economic characteristics of the municipality. Results of the simulations using the model show an increment of almost 70% of farmers planting willow during the period studied when the subsidy and tax incentives and the increments of the wood-fuel capacity by the district heating system took place. This study gives tools for future policy implementations in order to achieve the goals of the energy strategies.     

An economic assessment of the use of short-rotation coppice woody biomass to heat greenhouses in southern Canada

This study explores the economic feasibility of fossil fuel substitution with biomass from short-rotation willow plantations as an option for greenhouse heating in southern Ontario, Canada. We assess the net displacement value of fossil fuel biomass combustion systems with an integrated purpose-grown biomass production enterprise. Key project parameters include greenhouse size, heating requirements, boiler capital costs and biomass establishment and management costs. Several metrics have been used to examine feasibility including net present value, internal rate of return, payback period, and the minimum or break-even prices for natural gas and heating oil for which the biomass substitution operations become financially attractive. Depending on certain key assumptions, internal rates of return ranged from 11-14% for displacing heating oil to 0-4% for displacing natural gas with woody biomass. The biomass heating projects have payback periods of 10 to >22 years for substituting heating oil and 18 to >22 years for replacing a natural gas. Sensitivity analyses indicate that fossil fuel price and efficiency of the boiler heating system are critical elements in the analyses and research on methods to improve growth and yield and reduce silviculture costs could have a large beneficial impact on the feasibility of this type of bioenergy enterprise.     

Comparison of the productivity of Populus nigra L. with an interspecific hybrid in a short rotation coppice in marginal areas

Populus nigra as an autochthonous European woody species is irreplaceable in regions where it is not legal to plant allochthonous species. Twelve clones of P. nigra ssp. nigra and one clone NE-42 (Populus maximowiczii×Populus trichocarpa) were tested in two localities at altitudes of 515–600 m with annual temperatures 5.7–6.8 °C. Different cultural practices and nutrition were used in these localities. Rooted plants were set out (2222 plants ha⁻¹). The second harvest was carried out after 4 years in a 7-year crop. The yield of the best clones of P. nigra (7.6–7.9 t ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹) approached the yield of hybrid clone (9.4 t ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹) in a fertilised locality, with pH=6.7 and lower rainfall amounts in the growing season. In a locality with pH=5, without fertilisation and with high groundwater level the yield of clones of P. nigra was 4.6–2.2 t ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹, in clone NE-42 it was 9.8 t ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹. The most productive clones of P. nigra had a significantly higher number of shoots (16.8–14.2) than the clone NE-42 (9.3) and the mortality of their shoots was lower (14–31.4%) than in NE-42 (32.1%). Shoots 20–53 mm in diameter accounted for 50% of the volume index of shoots in almost 70% of P. nigra clones. In high-yielding clones of P. nigra the dry weight of lateral shoots in total weight ranged between 66% and 75% while in NE-42 it was 55%. Resistance to Melampsora larici-populina Kleb. was higher in the interspecific hybrid but the best clone of P. nigra had a similar level of resistance.     

Slow expansion and low yields of willow short rotation coppice in Sweden; implications for future strategies

About 16 000 ha of commercial willow Short Rotation Coppice (SRC) fields for production of biomass for energy were planted in the early 1990s in Sweden. The cultivated with SRC area has remained almost stable and was slightly decreased during the last years despite the incentives and predictions for drastic increases. Similar incentives and predictions in other countries have been lately launched. The bioenergy produced in the planted SRC areas in Sweden has been lower than anticipated, partly due to the lower than expected biomass yields and the termination of some willow SRC plantations. Explanations for the low yields are depicted based on analyzing the results of a survey where 175 willow SRC growers participated. Lower biomass yields are attributed to: (i) the low input in management activities; (ii) the choice of land for the willow SRC plantation; (iii) and the level of personal involvement of the farmer. Understanding the reasons to earlier years’ performance of willow SRC is important for development of better performing systems in the future, in Sweden as well as in other countries.     

Quantity and quality of harvestable biomass from Populus short rotation coppice for solid fuel use—a review of the physiological basis and management influences

Woody biomass from poplar and aspen (Populus sp.) short rotation coppice (SRC) has good combustion properties compared to non wood solid bio fuels and fossil solid fuels. This review compiles and discusses relevant literature on fuel quality and yield for Central European conditions. The most problematic quality parameter of woody biomass from Populus SRC is its high water content at harvest time (55–60%). Storing unchipped material on the field during summer is an efficient tool to lower it. In order to control other quality parameters—mainly nitrogen (N), potassium (K) and heavy metal contents but also yield—one has to take into account the physiological background of SRC. Important features are species/clone, age of sprouts, growth pattern, site and nutrient cycling. Maximum mean annual increment (MAI) occurs later than in willows. Therefore rotations should be longer than in willow: at least 6–7 years for poplars and,—due to differences in growth pattern,—10 to 12 years for aspen. Both results in MAIs of 10–12 o.d.t.ha⁻¹ yr⁻¹ and reduced nutrient concentrations due to a lower share of branches and twigs in the harvested biomass. However, with elongated rotations costs rise because yet no automated (and thus cheap) harvest methods for large stem diameters were developed. Although sometimes ignored poplars are demanding concerning site characteristics. Basic requirements are good water (minimum 350 mm rainfall during growing season) and nutrient supplies, deep soils and favourable climatic conditions (average air temperature between June and September at least 14°C). Only aspen are partly suited for poorer conditions. For Populus-SRC in general weed control during establishing phase is essential.     

Rapid biomass estimation using optical stem density of willow (Salix spp.) grown in short rotation

Quick and accurate biomass estimation of willow (Salix spp.) grown under short rotation intensive culture (SRIC) is essential for carbon accounting and management decisions. Currently, most estimates of tree biomass, including willow, rely on measurement of stem diameter. This is a suitable approach for single-stem species but for measurements of multi-stem species such as willow, there is an increase in the time and effort required as well as the need to include site, clone and age specific information. Therefore, we developed a new method which calculates optical stem density from digital photographs taken at predetermined locations and angles within a plantation during the fall or winter when the willow is without leaves. We then calibrated a mathematical model using destructive sampling to convert the measurements of optical stem density into estimates of biomass. The method produced very strong relationships (adjusted r² = 0.97) between the predicted and actual harvested biomass for the plots studied. Being new, the method still requires further testing and possibly adjustments for different planting designs and clones.     

Productivity model and reference diagram for short rotation biomass crops of poplar grown in Mediterranean environments

A Reference Diagram (RD) was constructed for first rotations of the Euroamerican poplar ‘I-214’ grown as short rotation coppice (SRC). Data from 144 plots, established in eleven sites in Mediterranean environments, were used to develop the model. The density at establishment of the plantations ranged between 6666 and 33,333 stools ha⁻¹, covering the usual densities ranges used in short rotation forestry (SRF). The RD was based on a density-independent mortality model that relates the density of living stools to the average height of dominant shoot and the initial plantation density, and it includes a system of two simultaneously fitted equations relating a) quadratic mean basal diameter of dominant shoots to the average height of dominant shoot and the final density, and b) total above-ground woody dry biomass to quadratic mean basal diameter and final density. The isolines in the RD represented mortality, quadratic mean basal diameter of dominant shoots and total above-ground woody dry biomass at the end of a first rotation of three years. The final yield in terms of biomass ranged from 1 to 85 Mg dm ha⁻¹. The RD enables rapid and straightforward comparison of different situations, both at planting and at harvesting, and is a useful tool, based on a wide range of empirical data, for management and decision making regarding short rotation poplar crops.     

Growth and production of a short rotation coppice culture of poplar. II. Clonal and year-to-year differences in leaf and petiole characteristics and stand leaf area index

Twelve different poplar (Populus) clones, belonging to different species and interspecific hybrids were studied during the first and second growing seasons of the second rotation of a high density coppice culture. Leaf size, leaf area, leaf nitrogen and specific leaf area (SLA) were examined at two different canopy levels, together with petiole length and petiole diameter. Leaves in the upper canopy layer were larger, heavier and had a lower SLA. They also had longer and thicker petioles, as well as a higher nitrogen concentration per unit dry weight than lower canopy leaves. Significant clonal variation was observed in leaf and petiole characteristics in both growing seasons. Leaf area index (LAI), scaled-up from allometric relationships, showed significant clonal variation in the two growing seasons, and increased for all clones in the second growing season. LAI increment was related to a significantly increased diameter of all shoots. Our study demonstrates (i) that light significantly affects leaf and petiolar characteristics, and nitrogen concentrations of foliage elements, and (ii) that year-to-year differences in foliar characteristics are related to stand aging rather than to increased shading due to larger LAI.     

Influence of the agricultural management practices on the yield and quality of poplar biomass (a 9-year study)

The aim of this work is to study the effect of different agricultural management on the yield and quality of two poplar biomass clones (AF2 and I-214 clones) in short rotation coppices (SRC), which were harvested using different alternatives (with and without cutting and sprouting after the first year), with two fertilisation doses and through three different 3-year rotation cycles. The plantation was established in 2006 in a marginal land at 1100 m above sea level in central-northern Spain. Yields were evaluated and biomass samples were analysed to determine the quality of the biomass for energy purposes. Biomass quality was estimated taking into account calorific value, volatile matter, ash content, carbon, nitrogen, sulphur and chlorine contents, as well as the chemical composition and melting behaviour of their ashes.The highest yields, around 9 dry tons per hectare and year, were obtained in this marginal land during the first and second rotation cycles when plots received a supplementary fertilisation. Both clones (AF2 and I-214) provided similar yield and biomass quality. Plots where poplar was not harvested the first year (without cutting and sprouting after the first year) provided higher accumulated yields. Poplar biomass from SRC can be considered a suitable solid biofuel due to its appropriate ash melting behaviour and its low content of nitrogen (0.44 wt-%), sulphur (0.03 wt-%) and chlorine (around 0.01 wt-%). No important significance effect on the poplar quality can be found depending on the additional fertilisation. Poplar quality varied as a function of root/stem age.     

A GIS-based analysis on the relationship between the annual available amount and the procurement cost of forest biomass in a mountainous region in Japan

The feasibility of utilization of forest biomass for energy in a mountainous region in Japan is discussed based on analyses with a geographic information system (GIS). In this study, ‘forest biomass’ denotes logging residues, thinned trees, and trees from broad-leaved forests. First, using the GIS, the distribution map of biomass resources was completed, and the topographical information of each sub-compartment was prepared. Second, harvesting and transportation systems were classified into six types by fraction of tree for energy (two types) and by topographical conditions (three types). Equations for cost calculation were developed and included the variables slope, skidding/yarding distance, and transportation distance. Finally, the relationship between the mass and the procurement cost of forest biomass in the region was analyzed. The results show that logging residues (the available amount was 4.035 Gg y⁻¹ on a dry-mass basis) were the least costly followed by broad-leaved forests (20.317 Gg y⁻¹) while thinned trees (27.854 Gg y⁻¹) were the most costly. The analysis may support operational planning, especially the decision of selecting sub-compartments to be felled. For instance, the amount of biomass needed to supply a power-plant covering 24.8% of the regional household need was calculated to 30.106 Gg y⁻¹. This amount of forest biomass could optimally be harvested from sub-compartments whose procurement costs were lower than 108.6 US$ Mg⁻¹.     

Energetic recovery of biomass in the region of Rabat,Morocco

Morocco has a potential of considerable biomass with a forest estate around nine million of hectares, and a herd around seven million units of large cattle. In particular, in the Rabat region, the amount of waste is about 714 350 Kg in 2014, who is equivalent to 0.96 Kg/inhabitant/day. In this document, we present, in the case of the Rabat, the Current situation of the electricity production from waste incineration. The data will be processed by statistical methods (Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) model and Solid Waste Association of North America (SWANA) model). The objective behind using these models is to introduce data for future years' estimates. We will show that the amount of electricity generated by incineration of waste in Rabat is in the order of more hundreds of Giga-watt-hours. This alternative allows a reduction in tonnage of accumulated waste and avoids its negative impact on the environment. It also provides energy independence. This involves, necessarily, construction of landfills and integration of neighbourhoods' population.     

Above-ground biomass production and allometric relations of Eucalyptus globulus Labill. coppice plantations along a chronosequence in the central highlands of Ethiopia

Eucalyptus plantations are extensively managed for wood production in the central highlands of Ethiopia. Nevertheless, little is known about their biomass (dry matter) production, partitioning and dynamics over time. Data from 10 different Eucalyptus globulus stands, with a plantation age ranging from 11 to 60 years and with a coppice-shoot age ranging from 1 to 9 years were collected and analyzed. Above-ground tree biomass of 7–10 sampled trees per stand was determined destructively. Dry weights of tree components (W_c; leaves, twigs, branches, stembark, and stemwood) and total above-ground biomass (W_a) were estimated as a function of diameter above stump (D), tree height (H) and a combination of these. The best fits were obtained, using combinations of D and H. When only one explanatory variable was used, D performed better than H. Total above-ground biomass was linearly related to coppice-shoot age. In contrast a negative relation was observed between the above-ground biomass production and total plantation age (number of cutting cycles). Total above-ground biomass increased from 11 t ha^?1 at a stand age of 1 year to 153 t ha^?1 at 9 years. The highest dry weight was allocated to stemwood and decreased in the following order: stemwood > leaves > stembark > twigs > branches. The equations developed in this study to estimate biomass components can be applied to other Eucalyptus plantations under the assumption that the populations being studied are similar with regard to density and tree size to those for which the relationships were developed.     

Hydrogen production by supercritical water gasification of biomass: Explore the way to maximum hydrogen yield and high carbon gasification efficiency

Supercritical water gasification (SCWG) is a promising technology for wet biomass utilization. In this paper, orthogonal experimental design method, which can minimize the number of experiments compared with the full factorial experiments, was used to optimize the operation parameters of SCWG with a tubular reactor system. Using this method, the influences of the main parameters including pressure, temperature, residence time and solution concentration on biomass gasification were also investigated. Simultaneously, in order to further improve the gasification efficiency of biomass, acid hydrolysis pretreatment of feedstock, oxidizers addition and increasing reaction temperature were employed. Results from the experiments show that in the range of experimental parameters, the order of the effects of the factors on H₂ yield of corn cob gasification in SCW is temperature > pressure > feedstock concentration > residence time. Temperature and pressure have a significant and complicated effect on biomass gasification. Hydrogen yield increases by the acid hydrolysis pretreatment of feedstock, and oxidizer addition reduces the hydrogen yield but it promotes the increase in carbon gasification efficiency. Biomass feedstock with high concentration was gasified successfully at high reaction temperature.