Dimerization of protegrin-1 in different environments

The dimerization of the cationic β-hairpin antimicrobial peptide protegrin-1 (PG1) is investigated in three different environments: water, the surface of a lipid bilayer membrane, and the core of the membrane. PG1 is known to kill bacteria by forming oligomeric membrane pores, which permeabilize the cells. PG1 dimers are found in two distinct, parallel and antiparallel, conformations, known as important intermediate structural units of the active pore oligomers. What is not clear is the sequence of events from PG1 monomers in solution to pores inside membranes. The step we focus on in this work is the dimerization of PG1. In particular, we are interested in determining where PG1 dimerization is most favorable. We use extensive molecular dynamics simulations to determine the potential of mean force as a function of distance between two PG1 monomers in the aqueous subphase, the surface of model lipid bilayers and the interior of these bilayers. We investigate the two known distinct modes of dimerization that result in either a parallel or an antiparallel β-sheet orientation. The model bilayer membranes are composed of anionic palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidylglycerol (POPG) and palmitoyl-oleoyl-phosphatidylethanolamine (POPE) in a 1:3 ratio (POPG:POPE). We find the parallel PG1 dimer association to be more favorable than the antiparallel one in water and inside the membrane. However, we observe that the antiparallel PG1 β-sheet dimer conformation is somewhat more stable than the parallel dimer association at the surface of the membrane. We explore the role of hydrogen bonds and ionic bridges in peptide dimerization in the three environments. Detailed knowledge of how networks of ionic bridges and hydrogen bonds contribute to peptide stability is essential for the purpose of understanding the mechanism of action for membrane-active peptides as well as for designing peptides which can modulate membrane properties. The findings are suggestive of the dominant pathways leading from individual PG1 molecules in solution to functional pores in bacterial membranes.     

Solid-state NMR studies of the structure, dynamics, and assembly of beta-sheet membrane peptides and alpha-helical membrane proteins with antibiotic activities

beta-Sheet antimicrobial peptides and alpha-helical channel-forming colicins are bactericidal molecules that target the lipid membranes of sensitive cells. Understanding the mechanisms of action of these proteins requires knowledge of their three-dimensional structure in the lipid bilayer. Solid-state NMR has been used to determine the conformation, orientation, depth of insertion, oligomerization, mobility, and lipid interaction of these membrane peptides and proteins. We review the NMR methods developed and applied to study the structure and dynamics of these antibiotic membrane proteins. These studies shed light on how these peptides disrupt lipid membranes and provide fundamental insights into the folding of beta-sheet and alpha-helical membrane proteins.     

Membrane Interactions of Latarcins: Antimicrobial Peptides from Spider Venom

A group of seven peptides from spider venom with diverse sequences constitute the latarcin family. They have been described as membrane-active antibiotics, but their lipid interactions have not yet been addressed. Using circular dichroism and solid-state ¹⁵N-NMR, we systematically characterized and compared the conformation and helix alignment of all seven peptides in their membrane-bound state. These structural results could be correlated with activity assays (antimicrobial, hemolysis, fluorescence vesicle leakage). Functional synergy was not observed amongst any of the latarcins. In the presence of lipids, all peptides fold into amphiphilic α-helices as expected, the helices being either surface-bound or tilted in the bilayer. The most tilted peptide, Ltc2a, possesses a novel kind of amphiphilic profile with a coiled-coil-like hydrophobic strip and is the most aggressive of all. It indiscriminately permeabilizes natural membranes (antimicrobial, hemolysis) as well as artificial lipid bilayers through the segregation of anionic lipids and possibly enhanced motional averaging. Ltc1, Ltc3a, Ltc4a, and Ltc5a are efficient and selective in killing bacteria but without causing significant bilayer disturbance. They act rather slowly or may even translocate towards intracellular targets, suggesting more subtle lipid interactions. Ltc6a and Ltc7, finally, do not show much antimicrobial action but can nonetheless perturb model bilayers.     

The Central PXXP Motif Is Crucial for PMAP-23 Translocation across the Lipid Bilayer

PMAP-23, a cathelicidin-derived host defense peptide, does not cause severe membrane permeabilization, but exerts strong and broad-spectrum bactericidal activity. We have previously shown that it forms an amphipathic α-helical structure with a central hinge induced by the PXXP motif, which is implicated in the interaction of PMAP-23 with negatively charged bacterial membranes. Here, we studied the potential roles of the PXXP motif in PMAP-23 translocation across the lipid bilayer by replacing Pro residues with either α-helix former Ala (PMAP-PA) or α-helix breaker Gly (PMAP-PG). Although both PMAP-PA and PMAP-PG led to effective membrane depolarization and permeabilization, they showed less antimicrobial activity than wild-type PMAP-23. Interestingly, we observed that PMAP-23 crossed lipid bilayers much more efficiently than its Pro-substituted derivatives. The fact that the Gly-induced hinge was unable to replace the PXXP motif in PMAP-23 translocation suggests that the PXXP motif has unique structural properties other than the central hinge. Surface plasmon resonance sensorgrams showed that the running buffer almost entirely dissociated PMAP-23 from the membrane surface, while its Pro-substituted derivatives remained significantly bound to the membrane. In addition, kinetic analysis of the sensorgrams revealed that the central PXXP motif allows PMAP-23 to rapidly translocate at the interface between the hydrophilic and hydrophobic phases. Taken together, we propose that the structural and kinetic understanding of the PXXP motif in peptide translocation could greatly aid the development of novel antimicrobial peptides with intracellular targets by promoting peptide entry into bacterial cells.     

Arginine dynamics in a membrane-bound cationic beta-hairpin peptide from solid-state NMR

The site-specific motion of Arg residues in a membrane-bound disulfide-linked antimicrobial peptide, protegrin-1 (PG-1), was investigated by using magic-angle-spinning solid-state NMR spectroscopy to better understand the membrane insertion and lipid interaction of this cationic membrane-disruptive peptide. The C-H and N-H dipolar couplings and 13C chemical shift anisotropies were measured in the anionic POPE/POPG membrane, and were found to be reduced from the rigid-limit values by varying extents; this indicates the presence of segmental motion. An Arg residue at the beta-turn region of the peptide showed much weaker spin interactions, which indicates larger amplitudes of motion than an Arg residue in the beta-strand region of the peptide. This is consistent with the exposure of the beta turn to the membrane surface and the immersion of the beta strand in the hydrophobic middle of the membrane, and supports the previously proposed oligomerization of the peptide into beta barrels in the anionic membrane. The 13C T2 and 1H T(1rho) relaxation times indicate that the beta-turn backbone undergoes large-amplitude intermediate-timescale motion in the fluid phase of the membrane; this causes significant line broadening and loss of spectral intensity. This study illustrates the strong correlation between the dynamics and structure of membrane proteins, and the capability of solid-state NMR spectroscopy to provide detailed information on site-specific dynamics in complex membrane-protein assemblies.     

Membrane-Associated Nucleobase-Functionalized β-Peptides (β-PNAs) Affecting Membrane Support and Lipid Composition

Protein-membrane interactions are essential to maintain membrane integrity and control membrane morphology and composition. Cytoskeletal proteins in particular are known to interact to a high degree with lipid bilayers and to line the cytoplasmic side of the plasma membrane with an extensive network structure. In order to gain a better mechanistical understanding of the protein–membrane interplay and possible membrane signaling, we started to develop a model system based on β-peptide nucleic acids (β-PNAs). These β-peptides are known to form stable hydrogen-bonded aggregates due to their helical secondary structure, which serve to pre-organize the attached nucleobases. After optimization of the β-PNA solid-phase peptide synthesis and validation of helix formation, the ability of the novel β-PNAs to dimerize and interact with lipid bilayers was investigated by both fluorescence and circular dichroism spectroscopy. It was shown that duplex formation occurs rapidly and with high specificity and could also be detected on the surfaces of the lipid bilayers. Hereby, the potential of a β-PNA-based peptide system to mimic membrane-associated protein networks could be demonstrated.     

Trichogin GA IV Alignment and Oligomerization in Phospholipid Bilayers

Trichogin GA IV is a short peptaibol with antimicrobial activity. This uncharged, but amphipathic, sequence is aligned at the membrane interface and undergoes a transition to an aggregated state that inserts more deeply into the membrane, an assembly that predominates at a peptide-to-lipid ratio (P/L) of 1:20. In this work, the natural trichogin sequence was prepared and reconstituted into oriented lipid bilayers. The ¹⁵N NMR chemical shift is indicative of a well-defined alignment of the peptide parallel to the membrane surface at P/Ls of 1:120 and 1:20. When the P/L is increased to 1:8, an additional peptide topology is observed that is indicative of a heterogeneous orientation, with helix alignments ranging from around the magic angle to perfectly in-plane. The topological preference of the trichogin helix for an orientation parallel to the membrane surface was confirmed by attenuated total reflection FTIR spectroscopy. Furthermore, ¹⁹F CODEX experiments were performed on a trichogin sequence with ¹⁹F-Phe at position 10. The CODEX decay is in agreement with a tetrameric complex, in which the ¹⁹F sites are about 9–9.5 Å apart. Thus, a model emerges in which the monomeric peptide aligns along the membrane surface. When the peptide concentration increases, first dimeric and then tetrameric assemblies form, made up from helices oriented predominantly parallel to the membrane surface. The formation of these aggregates correlates with the release of vesicle contents including relatively large molecules.     

Molecular Basis of Selectivity and Activity for the Antimicrobial Peptide Lynronne-1 Informs Rational Design of Peptide with Improved Activity

Antibiotic resistance is a significant threat to human health, with natural products remaining the best source for new antimicrobial compounds. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are natural products with great potential for clinical use as they are small, amenable to customization, and show broad-spectrum activities. Lynronne-1 is a promising AMP identified in the rumen microbiome that shows broad-spectrum activity against pathogens such as methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus and Acinetobacter baumannii. Here we investigated the structure of Lynronne-1 using solution NMR spectroscopy and identified a 13-residue amphipathic helix containing all six cationic residues. We used biophysical approaches to observe folding, membrane partitioning and membrane lysis selective to the presence of anionic lipids. We translated our understanding of Lynronne-1 structure to design peptides which varied in the size of their hydrophobic helical face. These peptides displayed the predicted continuum of membrane-lysis activities in vitro and in vivo, and yielded a new AMP with 4-fold improved activity against A. baumannii and 32-fold improved activity against S. aureus.     

Identification of Bacterial Membrane Selectivity of Romo1-Derived Antimicrobial Peptide AMPR-22 via Molecular Dynamics

The abuse or misuse of antibiotics has caused the emergence of extensively drug-resistant (XDR) bacteria, rendering most antibiotics ineffective and increasing the mortality rate of patients with bacteremia or sepsis. Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) are proposed to overcome this problem; however, many AMPs have attenuated antimicrobial activities with hemolytic toxicity in blood. Recently, AMPR-11 and its optimized derivative, AMPR-22, were reported to be potential candidates for the treatment of sepsis with a broad spectrum of antimicrobial activity and low hemolytic toxicity. Here, we performed molecular dynamics (MD) simulations to clarify the mechanism of lower hemolytic toxicity and higher efficacy of AMPR-22 at an atomic level. We found four polar residues in AMPR-11 bound to a model mimicking the bacterial inner/outer membranes preferentially over eukaryotic plasma membrane. AMPR-22 whose polar residues were replaced by lysine showed a 2-fold enhanced binding affinity to the bacterial membrane by interacting with bacterial specific lipids (lipid A or cardiolipin) via hydrogen bonds. The MD simulations were confirmed experimentally in models that partially mimic bacteremia conditions in vitro and ex vivo. The present study demonstrates why AMPR-22 showed low hemolytic toxicity and this approach using an MD simulation would be helpful in the development of AMPs.     

Contribution of the Tyr-1 in Plantaricin149a to Disrupt Phospholipid Model Membranes

Plantaricin149a (Pln149a) is a cationic antimicrobial peptide, which was suggested to cause membrane destabilization via the carpet mechanism. The mode of action proposed to this antimicrobial peptide describes the induction of an amphipathic α-helix from Ala7 to Lys20, while the N-terminus residues remain in a coil conformation after binding. To better investigate this assumption, the purpose of this study was to determine the contributions of the Tyr1 in Pln149a in the binding to model membranes to promote its destabilization. The Tyr to Ser substitution increased the dissociation constant (K_D) of the antimicrobial peptide from the liposomes (approximately three-fold higher), and decreased the enthalpy of binding to anionic vesicles from −17.2 kcal/mol to −10.2 kcal/mol. The peptide adsorption/incorporation into the negatively charged lipid vesicles was less effective with the Tyr1 substitution and peptide Pln149a perturbed the liposome integrity more than the analog, Pln149S. Taken together, the peptide-lipid interactions that govern the Pln149a antimicrobial activity are found not only in the amphipathic helix, but also in the N-terminus residues, which take part in enthalpic contributions due to the allocation at a lipid-aqueous interface.     

Conformational Changes of Anoplin,W-MreB1–9, and (KFF)3K Peptides near the Membranes

Many peptides interact with biological membranes, but elucidating these interactions is challenging because cellular membranes are complex and peptides are structurally flexible. To contribute to understanding how the membrane-active peptides behave near the membranes, we investigated peptide structural changes in different lipid surroundings. We focused on two antimicrobial peptides, anoplin and W-MreB_1–9, and one cell-penetrating peptide, (KFF)₃K. Firstly, by using circular dichroism spectroscopy, we determined the secondary structures of these peptides when interacting with micelles, liposomes, E. coli lipopolysaccharides, and live E. coli bacteria. The peptides were disordered in the buffer, but anoplin and W-MreB_1–9 displayed lipid-induced helicity. Yet, structural changes of the peptide depended on the composition and concentration of the membranes. Secondly, we quantified the destructive activity of peptides against liposomes by monitoring the release of a fluorescent dye (calcein) from the liposomes treated with peptides. We observed that only for anoplin and W-MreB_1–9 calcein leakage from liposomes depended on the peptide concentration. Thirdly, bacterial growth inhibition assays showed that peptide conformational changes, evoked by the lipid environments, do not directly correlate with the antimicrobial activity of the peptides. However, understanding the relation between peptide structural properties, mechanisms of membrane disruption, and their biological activities can guide the design of membrane-active peptides.     

Probing and Manipulating the Lateral Pressure Profile in Lipid Bilayers Using Membrane-Active Peptides—A Solid-State 19F NMR Study

The lateral pressure profile constitutes an important physical property of lipid bilayers, influencing the binding, insertion, and function of membrane-active peptides, such as antimicrobial peptides. In this study, we demonstrate that the lateral pressure profile can be manipulated using the peptides residing in different regions of the bilayer. A ¹⁹F-labeled analogue of the amphiphilic peptide PGLa was used to probe the lateral pressure at different depths in the membrane. To evaluate the lateral pressure profile, we measured the orientation of this helical peptide with respect to the membrane using solid-state ¹⁹F-NMR, which is indicative of its degree of insertion into the bilayer. Using this experimental approach, we observed that the depth of insertion of the probe peptide changed in the presence of additional peptides and, furthermore, correlated with their location in the membrane. In this way, we obtained a tool to manipulate, as well as to probe, the lateral pressure profile in membranes.     

Break on through to the other side-biophysics and cell biology shed light on cell-penetrating peptides

Cell-penetrating peptides (CPPs) have become widely used vectors for the cellular import of molecules in basic and applied biomedical research. Despite the broad acceptance of these molecules as molecular carriers, the details of the mode of cellular internalization and membrane permeation remain elusive. Within the last two years endocytosis has been demonstrated to be a route of uptake shared by several CPPs. These findings had a significant impact on CPP research. State-of-the-art cell biology is now required to advance the understanding of the intracellular fate of the CPP and cargo molecules. Owing to their presumed ability to cross lipid bilayers, CPPs also represent highly interesting objects of biophysical research. Numerous studies have investigated structure-activity relationships of CPPs with respect to their ability to bind to a lipid bilayer or to cross this barrier. Endocytosis route only relocates the membrane permeation from the cell surface to endocytic compartments. Therefore, biophysical experiments are key to a mechanistic molecular understanding of the cellular uptake of CPPs. However, biophysical investigations have to consider the molecular environment encountered by a peptide inside and outside a cell. In this contribution we will review biophysical and cell-biology data obtained for several prominent CPPs. Furthermore, we will summarize recent findings on the cell-penetrating characteristics of antimicrobial peptides and the antimicrobial properties of CPPs. Peptides of both groups have overlapping characteristics. Therefore, both fields may greatly benefit from each other. The review will conclude with a perspective of how biophysics and cell biology may synergize even more efficiently in the future.     

Manipulating Active Structure and Function of Cationic Antimicrobial Peptide CM15 with the Polysulfonated Drug Suramin: A Step Closer to in Vivo Complexity

Antimicrobial peptides (AMPs) kill bacteria by targeting their membranes through various mechanisms involving peptide assembly, often coupled with disorder-to-order structural transition. However, for several AMPs, similar conformational changes in cases in which small organic compounds of both endogenous and exogenous origin have induced folded peptide conformations have recently been reported. Thus, the function of AMPs and of natural host defence peptides can be significantly affected by the local complex molecular environment in vivo; nonetheless, this area is hardly explored. To address the relevance of such interactions with regard to structure and function, we have tested the effects of the therapeutic drug suramin on the membrane activity and antibacterial efficiency of CM15, a potent hybrid AMP. The results provided insight into a dynamic system in which peptide interaction with lipid bilayers is interfered with by the competitive binding of CM15 to suramin, resulting in an equilibrium dependent on peptide-to-drug ratio and vesicle surface charge. In vitro bacterial tests showed that when CM15 ⋅ suramin complex formation dominates over membrane binding, antimicrobial activity is abolished. On the basis of this case study, it is proposed that small-molecule secondary structure regulators can modify AMP function and that this should be considered and could potentially be exploited in future development of AMP-based antimicrobial agents.     

Structure of the antimicrobial, cationic hexapeptide cyclo(RRWWRF) and its analogues in solution and bound to detergent micelles

Antimicrobial, cationic peptides are abundant throughout nature as part of many organisms' defence against microorganisms. They exhibit a large variety of sequences and structural motifs and are thought to act by rupturing the bacterial membrane. Several models based on biophysical experiments have been proposed for their mechanism of action. Here we present the NMR-determined structure of the cyclic, cationic antimicrobial peptide cyclo(RRWWRF) both free in aqueous solution and bound to detergent micelles. The peptide has a rather flexible but ordered structure in water. A distinct structure is formed when the peptide is bound to a detergent micelle. The structures in neutral and negatively charged micelles are nearly identical but differ from that in aqueous solution. The orientation of the amino acid side chains creates an amphipathic molecule with the peptide backbone forming the hydrophilic part. The orientation of the peptide in the micelle was determined by using NOEs and paramagnetic agents. The peptide is oriented mainly parallel to the micelle surface in both detergents. Substitution of the arginine and tryptophan residues is known to influence the antimicrobial activity. Therefore the structure of the micelle-bound analogues cyclo(RRYYRF), cyclo(KKWWKF) and cyclo(RRNalNalRF) were also determined. They exhibit remarkable similarities in backbone conformation and side-chain orientation. The structure of these peptides allows the side-chain properties to be correlated to biological activity.     

Endowment of pH Responsivity to Anticancer Peptides by Introducing 2,3-Diaminopropionic Acid Residues

Endowment of pH responsivity to anticancer peptides is a promising approach to achieve better selectivity to cancer tissues. In this research, a template peptide was designed based on magainin 2, an antimicrobial peptide with anticancer activity, and a series of peptides were designed by replacing different numbers of lysine with the unnatural amino acid, 2,3diaminopropionic acid (Dap), which has a positive charge at weakly acidic pH in cancer tissues, but is neutral at physiological pH 7.4. These Dap-containing peptides are expected to interact more strongly with tumor cells than with normal cells because 1) weakly acidic conditions form in tumors, and 2) the membrane of tumor cells is more anionic than that of normal cells. Although all examined peptides showed potent cytotoxicities to multidrug-resistant cancer cells at a weakly acidic pH (ED₅₀≈5 μm ), the toxicity decreased with an increase in the number of Dap at pH 7.4 (8 Dap residues resulted in ED₅₀≈60 μm ). Furthermore, the introduction of Dap reduced cytotoxicity against normal cells. Thus, Dap led to significantly improved cancer targeting due to a pH-dependent charge shift. Fluorescence imaging and model membrane experiments supported this charge-shift model.     

SAHBNET,an Accessible Surface-Based Elastic Network: An Application to Membrane Protein

Molecular Dynamics is a method of choice for membrane simulations and the rising of coarse-grained forcefields has opened the way to longer simulations with reduced calculations times. Here, we present an elastic network, SAHBNET (Surface Accessibility Hydrogen-Bonds elastic NETwork), that will maintain the structure of soluble or membrane proteins based on the hydrogen bonds present in the atomistic structure and the proximity between buried residues. This network is applied on the coarse-grained beads defined by the MARTINI model, and was designed to be more physics-based than a simple elastic network. The SAHBNET model is evaluated against atomistic simulations, and compared with ELNEDYN models. The SAHBNET is then used to simulate two membrane proteins inserted in complex lipid bilayers. These bilayers are formed by self-assembly and the use of a modified version of the GROMACS tool genbox (which is accessible through the gcgs.gembloux.ulg.ac.be website). The results show that SAHBNET keeps the structure close to the atomistic one and is successfully used for the simulation of membrane proteins.     

Molecular modeling of the Abeta1-42 peptide from Alzheimer's disease

The three-dimensional structure of the Alzheimer's disease Abeta1-42 peptide was predicted by sequence homology, threading approaches and by experimental observations. The Abeta molecule displayed a Greek key motif with four antiparallel beta-strands. To shield thermodynamically unfavorable domains, two Abeta molecules interact with each other to generate a beta-barrel structure with a hydrophilic surface and a hydrophobic core. The N-terminal domains of the dimer form crevices into which the non-polar C-termini are accommodated to yield a globular structure 27x32 A in diameter. Alternatively, the C-terminal domains of two opposing dimers could be extended to form an antiparallel beta- sheet. The stacking of these building blocks generates a helical protofilament. To create a thermodynamically more favorable structure, three protofilaments associate into a right-handed triple helix with a hydrophobic beta-sheet completely surrounded by the hydrophilic beta- barrels made of residues 1-28. Two triple helical strands can further associate into a right-handed amyloid filament. Although our model did not meet all the expected criteria, it nevertheless exhibited a series of naturally disposed structural features, revealed by other biophysical studies utilizing synthetic Abeta peptides. These characteristics are of functional significance in terms of Abeta- topology, fibril formation and cytotoxicity. The model also suggests that Abeta may not exist in a thermodynamically stable conformation, but rather as an ensemble of metastable dimeric structures some of which are capable of generating an extended C-terminal antiparallel beta-sheet essential in the promotion of fibrillogenesis.      

Key Residues in Octyl‐Tridecaptin A1 Analogues Linked to Stable Secondary Structures in the Membrane

Tridecaptin A₁ is a linear antimicrobial lipopeptide comprised of 13 amino acids, including three diaminobutyric acid (Dab) residues. It displays potent activity against Gram‐negative bacteria, including multidrug‐resistant strains. Using solid‐phase peptide synthesis, we performed an alanine scan of a fully active analogue, octyl‐tridecaptin A₁, to determine key residues responsible for activity. The synthetic analogues were tested against ten organisms, both Gram‐positive and Gram‐negative bacteria. Modification of D ‐Dab8 abolished activity, and marked decreases were observed with substitution of D ‐allo‐Ile12 and D ‐Trp5. Circular dichroism showed that octyl‐tridecaptin A₁ adopts a secondary structure in the presence of model phospholipid membranes, which was weakened by D ‐Dab8‐D ‐Ala, D ‐allo‐Ile12‐D ‐Ala, and D ‐Trp5‐D ‐Ala substitutions. The antimicrobial activity of the analogues is directly correlated to their ability to adopt a stable secondary structure in a membrane environment.