COLLABORATIVE DETERMINATION OF SPECIFIC GRAVITY BY DENSITY METER

A method employing a density meter for the determination of specific gravity (SG) has been tested for the determination of the gravity (G) of beer, aqueous sugar solutions and aqueous ethanol solutions by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing. The term “gravity”, used throughout this report is defined by the equation G = SG × 1000. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values were calculated over the range 994.6 to 1124.2 gravity. For beer, it was judged that precision values were independent of the gravity of the sample. Values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 0.1 and 0.9, respectively, for instruments with a 5 figure display and 0.08 and 0.32, respectively, for instruments with a 6 figure display, over the range 999.1 to 1017.0 gravity. For solutions of ethanol in water, precision was also independent of the gravity of the sample. Values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 0.1 and 0.3, respectively, for instruments with a 5 figure display and 0.05 and 0.19, respectively, for instruments with a 6 figure display, over the range 994.6 to 999.1 gravity. For aqueous sugar solutions the values of r₉₅ and R₉₅ increased with increasing gravity. At 1049.3 gravity, values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 0.1 and 0.8, respectively, for instruments with a 5 figure display and 0.07 and 0.35, respectively, for instruments with a 6 figure display. At 1124.2 gravity values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 0.2 and 1.4, respectively, for instruments with a 5 figure display and 0.16 and 1.35, respectively, for instruments with a 6 figure display.     

DETERMINATION OF REPEATABILITY AND REPRODUCIBILITY OF THE REVISED METHOD FOR GERMINATIVE CAPACITY

The method for the determination of germinative capacity of barley using hydrogen peroxide and peeling technique (EBC 3.5.2) was revised in 1995. The revised procedure has been collaboratively tested by the EBC Analysis Committee. The repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (Rob) values were dependent upon mean values, r₉₅ = (64.23-0.64m) % and R₉₅ = (51.74-0.50 m) % .     

DETERMINATION OF ETHANOL IN BEER BY DIRECT INJECTION GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY: A COMPARISON OF SIX IDENTICAL SYSTEMS

Six identical gas chromatographic (GC) systems from the same manufacturer were evaluated for the determination of ethanol in beers. Each system was assessed for detector linearity and drift using standard ethanol solutions. Repeatability (r₉₅) of each machine, repeatability (r₉₅) of the GC method and reproducibility (R₉₅) of the method over a range of ethanol concentrations (1–11% V/V) was determined using commercial beers. All six instruments were linear over the ethanol range 0–12% V/V and were in good agreement. Drift of the machines was negligible over the period of the analysis. Over the ethanol range 0.95 to 6.32% V/V the repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R95) values were 0.050 and 0.083 respectively. Over the ethanol range 9.48 to 11.15% V/V the repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values were 0.153 and 0.227 respectively. Comparison of the precision values and those obtained in a recent IOB Analysis Committee Collaborative¹ for the determination of ethanol by gas chromatography showed no significant differences between the two methods. The reported method is suitable for determination of ethanol in beers.     

THE DETERMINATION OF SULPHUR DIOXIDE IN BEER—COLLABORATIVE TRIAL OF FOUR METHODS

The Institute of Brewing Analysis Committee has collaboratively tested four methods for the determination of sulphur dioxide in beer over the range 1 to 40 mg/litre. The p-rosaniline method (r₉₅ = 0.51 + 0.10 m. R₉₅ = 0.63 + 0.26 m) was found to have the best precision and is recommended as an alternative to the Monier Williams method (r₉₅ = 0.43 + 0.15 m, R₉₅ = 1.86 + 0.27 m) where high precision at low sulphur dioxide levels is required. The dithiobisnitrobenzoic acid (DTNB) method and the IOB rapid distillation method showed considerably worse precisions.     

DETERMINATION OF THE MOISTURE CONTENT OF BARLEY

The method of the International Organization for Standardization, (ISO 712–1985) for the determination of moisture in cereals and cereal products, has been tested by members of the Analysis Committee of the European Brewery Convention on samples of barley. The method, which relies on loss in mass on drying at 130–133°C for 2 h, is recommended for use as a replacement for the current method, based on loss in mass on drying at 105–107°C for 3 h. It was judged that precision values were independent of concentration over the range 11 to 13% m/m. Repeatability (r₉₅) and Reproducibility R₉₅) values of 0.13 and 0.55 respectively were obtained over this range. At a mean level of 21.7% m/m, the r₉₅ and R₉₅ values were 0.27 and 2.6 respectively. This was probably due to errors associated with the double drying technique which is necessary for samples at this moisture content.     

DETERMINATION OF THE VOLATILE COMPONENTS OF BEER

A method relying on headspace sampling and gas chromatography for the determination of the lower boiling point volatile compounds (fusel oils) in beer, has been approved by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing (IOB), for inclusion in Recommended Methods of Analysis. In view of the large values obtained for precision in terms of repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) and the differences in gas chromatographic equipment used by individual brewing laboratories, the method is considered not to be ideal, but is given as a guideline only. The IOB Analysis Committee has recommended a method relying on gas chromatography and flame photometric detection for the determination of dimethyl sulphide in beer. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values of 3.3 μg/litre and 3.66+0.168 m μg/litre (where m is concentration), respectively, were obtained over the range 20–50 μg/litre. Methods currently used in brewing laboratories, for the measurement of vicinal diketones, are being surveyed with a view to obtaining a suitable method for collaborative testing by the Analysis Committee.     

DETERMINATION OF NITRATE IN BEER BY ION CHROMATOGRAPHY

¹A method, relying on ion chromatography, for the determination of nitrate in beer, has been collaboratively tested by members of the European Brewery Convention (EBC) and the Brewery Convention of Japan (BCOJ). Precision values were judged to be acceptable. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values were 1.5, 0.96, 5.1, and 9.3, 10.4, 13.5 respectively for corresponding mean levels of 6.5, 26.2 and 52.8 mg/litre. However, r₉₅ and R₉₅ values of 1.5 and 2.3 respectively were obtained for an aqueous solution of nitrate ions at a mean level of 20.7 mg/litre. The determination of nitrate is recommended for use and inclusion in Analytica-EBC, as an additional analyte in the International Method which relies on ion chromatography for estimating chloride, sulphate and phosphate.     

ESTIMATION OF ENDO BETA-GLUCANASE ACTIVITY IN MALT USING A VISCOMETRIC METHOD

A viscometric method for estimation of endo beta-glucanase activity in malt has been collaboratively tested by the Institute of Brewing Analysis Committee. Ten participating laboratories analysed five pairs of malt samples in the range 176 to 1238 IRV units. The repeatability (r₉₅) values ranged from 22 to 122 IRV units and the reproducibility (R₉₅) values from 93 to 650 IRV units. The results indicated that R₉₅, but not r₉₅, was dependent on endo beta-glucanase activity. Overall precision values were 76.8 for r₉₅ and 0.506Mean + 4.786 for R₉₅. It was decided that the method would be included in IOB Methods of Analysis but that attention would be drawn to the poor precision values obtained in this and previous collaborative trials.     

DETERMINATION OF REPEATABILITY AND REPRODUCIBILITY OF A NEW RAPID ENZYME METHOD FOR THE DETERMINATION OF GLYCOSIDE NITRILE IN MALTED BARLEY

A new rapid method for the determination of malt glycosidic nitrile, using an enzymatic incubation with beta-glucosidase, was tested in an inter-laboratory collaborative trial. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values are reported. A limited comparison is made with the existing determination of malt combined nitrile using methods involving laboratory fermentations.     

DETERMINATION OF VICINAL DIKETONES IN BEER BY GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY (HEADSPACE TECHNIQUE)—COLLABORATIVE TRIAL

Two methods for the determination of vicinal diketones in beer have been collaboratively tested by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing and are recommended for use. Both methods employ gas chromatography and are essentially the same, except that one relies on the use of a packed column and the other on a capillary column. For diacetyl it was judged that repeatability (r₉₅) values were independent of concentration over the range 0.04 to 0.19 mg/litre. Over this range, r₉₅ values for diacetyl of 0.028, 0.020 and 0.026 mg/litre were obtained for capillary, packed columns and combined results respectively. Values for reproducibility (R₉₅) were judged to be dependent on the mean level (m). R₉₅ values were 0.032 + 0.68 m, 0.01 + 0.47 m and 0.005 + 0.67 m were obtained for capillary, packed columns and combined results respectively. For both methods the r₉₅ and R₉₅ values for 2,3-pentanedione were judged to be independent of concentration over the range 0.02 to 0.07 mg/litre. For capillary columns, packed columns and combined results respectively, r₉₅ values were 0.009, 0.009, 0.010 mg/litre and R₉₅ values were 0.037, 0.042 and 0.038 mg/litre.     

THE DETERMINATION OF ALCOHOL IN BEER USING THE SCABA AUTOMATED METHOD (COLLABORATIVE TRIAL)

The Institute of Brewing Analysis Committee has organised two collaborative trials for the analysis of alcohol using the ServoChem Automatic Beer Analyser (SCABA). The mean repeatability (r₉₅) values for the two trials were 0.051% and 0.034% V/V respectively. The value for the second trial could however be judged to be dependent on concentration (m) at 0.008m% V/V. The Reproducibility (R₉₅) values of both trials were judged to be dependent on concentration at 0.027m% V/V and 0.025m% V/V respectively. The combined data for the two trials gave r₉₅ = 0.044% V/V and R₉₅ = 0.026m% V/V.     

COLLABORATIVE DETERMINATION OF THE PH OF BEER AND WORT

A method for the determination of pH in wort and beer has been tested for precision by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing . Over the pH range 3.94 to 5.04 it was judged that precision values were independent of the pH value of the sample. Values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 0.025 and 0.129 respectively .     

ESTIMATION OF ISO-ALPHA-ACIDS IN BEER BY HPLC-COLLABORATIVE TRIAL

A procedure relying on high performance liquid chromatography for the estimation of iso-alpha-acids in beer has been collaboratively tested by the IOB Analysis Committee. In addition the trial samples were analysed by the IOB Recommended Method for the measurement of bitterness (BU). It was judged that the results obtained by the HPLC method were not sufficiently precise to permit adoption as a Recommended Method. However, since the method has the advantage of measuring bitterness in terms of iso-alpha-acids, it is suggested as an alternative to that of the Recommended Method. The iso-alpha-acids are absorbed from beer on to a C₁₈ Bond Elut column and then selectively desorbed prior to isocratic analysis by HPLC using an eluting solvent of methanol/water/phosphoric acid/tetrabutylammonium hydroxide and a C₁₈ radialpak cartridge. For both methods the repeatability values (r₉₅) were not dependent upon mean concentration (m) whereas the reproducibility values (R₉₅) were dependent upon concentration. The values of (r₅₃) and (R₉₅) obtained were 2.11 and (1.38 + 0.134 m) over the concentration range 13.8 to 34.0 mg/litre for the HPLC procedure and 1.20 and (0.76 + 0.122 m) over the concentration range 15.4 to 38.6 BU for the Recommended Method.     

DETERMINATION OF DIMETHYL SUPLHIDE IN BEER BY GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY — COLLABORATIVE TRIAL

The Analysis Committee has collaboratively tested both routine headspace gas chromatographic methods and a standardised method for the determination of dimethyl sulphide in beer using the flame photometric and flame ionisation detectors available in the participating laboratories. The mean repeatability value (r₉₅) was 7.8 μg/litre for the concentration range 12–65 μg/litre, and the reproducibility value (R₉₅) showed the relationship R₉₅ = 18.1 + 0.452m μg/litre to the concentration (m). No differences in precision were attributed either to the methods or the types of detectors used.     

COLLABORATIVE DETERMINATION OF BEER FOAM STABILITY BY RUDIN AND NIBEM

Two methods, the “Rudin” method and the “Nibem” method have been tested for the determination of foam stability of beer by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing . For the Rudin method, over the range 90 to 102 seconds, it was judged that precision values were independent of the foam stability of the sample. Values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 6 and 22 seconds, respectively . For the Nibem method, precision was also independent of the foam stability of the sample over the range 213 to 246 seconds. Values for r₉₅ and R₉₅ were 22 and 70 seconds, respectively . The two methods ranked the foam stability of the three beers tested differently. This is to be expected, bearing in mind the different principles of the two procedures .     

DETERMINATION OF ETHANOL IN BEER BY GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY (DIRECT INJECTION)—COLLABORATIVE TRIAL

A method employing gas chromatography for the determination of ethanol in beer has been collaboratively tested by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing. It was judged that precision values were independent of concentration over the range 0.93 to 6.05% V/V ethanol. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values of 0.061 and 0.136 respectively, were obtained over this range. At a mean level of 9.17% V/V, the r₉₅ and R₉₅ values were 0.154 and 0.284 respectively. This was probably due to dilution errors as the sample had to be diluted to bring it within the linear range of the method. A comparison of the precision values given by the gas chromatographic method, with those obtained in 1991/1992 by 8 laboratories in a major brewing company using 12 sample pairs, for the IOB Recommended Distillation Method, revealed that there is no significant difference between the precision data for the two methods.     

DETERMINATION OF LOWER BOILING POINT VOLATILE COMPOUNDS IN BEER BY HEADSPACE GAS CHROMATOGRAPHY — COLLABORATIVE TRIAL

The Analysis Committee has collaboratively tested local routine headspace gas chromatographic methods for the determination of the lower boiling point volatile compounds in beer. The repeatability values (r₉₅) were dependent upon mean concentration (m) for acetaldehyde and alcohols but not for esters, whilst reproducibility values (R₉₅) were dependent upon concentration in all cases. The range of values of m and the estimates of r₉₅ and R₉₅ (mg/litre) for each compound were, respectively: acetaldehyde (5–8, 0.21m, 0.60m); propanol (9–23, 0.25m, 2.5+0.57m); isobutanol (5–22, 0.56+0.085m, 1.7+0.15m); methylbutanols (45–105, 0.14m, 0.22m); ethyl acetate (10–54, 3.1, 2.1+0.29m); isoamyl acetate (0.8–4.7, 0.36, 0.20+0.58m); and ethyl hexanoate (0.13–0.36, 0.073, 0.10+0.91m). No advantage was gained by diluting beer samples containing 9% V/V ethanol to 4% ethanol (used for the calibration mixtures) prior to analysis, but use of a standard method of sample preparation decreased most of the R₉₅ values. No recommendation is made in this interim report.     

DETERMINATION OF REPEATABILITY AND REPRODUCIBILITY OF EBC ACCEPTED METHODS. III—BARLEY ANALYSIS

Methods for barley analysis published in Analytics EBC, 4th ed. have been collaboratively tested by the European Brewery Convention Analysis Committee and other European laboratories involved in Barley analysis. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₆) values are presented. The answers to a questionnaire sent to all participating laboratories are discussed.     

DETERMINATION OF HOT WATER EXTRACT

The Analysis Committee of the European Brewery Convention has recommended that the Hot Water Extract procedure for malt, which relies on a coarse grind and single temperature mash (65°C), is included in Analytica-EBC, as an additional method to that of the EBC Extract procedure. The Committee accepted the precision values obtained by the Institute of Brewing on the 1984 Check Malt. Repeatability (r₉₅) and reproducibility (R₉₅) values in litre degrees/kg were 2.14 and 3.48 respectively, for mean value of 295.3 at a Miag 0.7 mm setting, and 1.93 and 2.90 respectively, for a mean value of 298.2 at a Miag 0.2 mm setting.     

EXTRACT AND COLOUR DETERMINATION OF TORREFIED PRODUCTS (WHEAT,BARLEY AND RYE)—COLLABORATIVE TRIAL

A procedure for preparing torrefied products for analysis has been examined and the effects of this procedure on the determination of laboratory extract and colour have been collaboratively tested by the Analysis Committee of the Institute of Brewing. White malts of DP levels 50° and 100° IOB were used as the sources of enzymes in the mixed mash procedure. With these malts r₉₅ and R₉₅ values for extract of the torrefied products ranged from 1.7 to 10.2 and 12.4 to 21.9 resp. on mean extracts ranging from 244 to 270 litre °/kg. The r₉₅ and R₉₅ values for colour ranged from 1.6 to 2.3 and 2.2 to 3.8 resp. on mean colours ranging from 2.7 to 3.5 EBC units.