Revealing the quaternary structure of a heterogeneous noncovalent protein complex through surface-induced dissociation

As scientists begin to appreciate the extent to which quaternary structure facilitates protein function, determination of the subunit arrangement within noncovalent protein complexes is increasingly important. While native mass spectrometry shows promise for the study of noncovalent complexes, few developments have been made toward the determination of subunit architecture, and no mass spectrometry activation method yields complete topology information. Here, we illustrate the surface-induced dissociation of a heterohexamer, toyocamycin nitrile hydratase, directly into its constituent trimers. We propose that the single-step nature of this activation in combination with high energy deposition allows for dissociation prior to significant unfolding or other large-scale rearrangement. This method can potentially allow for dissociation of a protein complex into subcomplexes, facilitating the mapping of subunit contacts and thus determination of quaternary structure of protein complexes.     

Surface-induced dissociation of peptides and protein complexes in a quadrupole/time-of-flight mass spectrometer

A novel in-line surface-induced dissociation (SID) device was designed and implemented in a commercial QTOF instrument (Waters/Micromass QTOF II). This new setup allows efficient SID for a broad range of molecules. It also allows direct comparison with conventional collision-induced dissociation (CID) on the same instrument, taking advantage of the characteristics of QTOF instrumentation, including extended mass range, improved sensitivity, and better resolution compared with quadrupole analyzers and ion traps. Various peptides and a noncovalent protein complex have been electrosprayed and analyzed with the new SID setup. Here we present SID of leucine enkephalin, fibrinopeptide A, melittin, insulin chain-B, and a noncovalent protein complex from wheat, heat shock protein 16.9. The SID spectra were also compared to CID spectra. With the SID setup installed, ion transmission proved to be efficient. SID fragmentation patterns of peptides are, in general, similar to CID, with differences in the relative intensities of some peaks such as immonium ions, backbone cleavage b- versus y-type ions, and y- versus y-NH3 ions, suggesting enhanced accessibility to high-energy/secondary fragmentation channels with SID. Furthermore, these results demonstrate that the in-line SID setup is a valid substitute for CID, with potential advantages for activation of singly/multiply charged peptides and larger species such as noncovalent protein complexes.     

Determinants of gas-phase disassembly behavior in homodimeric protein complexes with related yet divergent structures

The overall structure of a protein-protein complex reflects an intricate arrangement of noncovalent interactions. Whereas intramolecular interactions confer secondary and tertiary structure to individual subunits, intermolecular interactions lead to quaternary structure--the ordered aggregation of separate polypeptide chains into multisubunit assemblies. The specific ensemble of noncovalent contacts dictates the stability of subunit folds, enforces protein-protein binding specificity, and determines multimer stability. Consequently, noncovalent architecture is likely to play a role in the gas-phase dissociation of these assemblies during tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS). To further advance the applicability of MS/MS to analytical problems in structural biology, a better understanding of the interplay between the structures and fragmentation behaviors of noncovalent protein complexes is essential. The present work constitutes a systematic study of model protein homodimers (bacteriophage N15 Cro, bacteriophage λ Cro, and bacteriophage P22 Arc) with related but divergent structures, both in terms of subunit folds and protein-protein interfaces. Because each of these dimers has a well-characterized structure (solution and/or crystal structure), specific noncovalent features could be correlated with gas-phase disassembly patterns as studied by collision-induced dissociation, surface-induced dissociation, and ion mobility. Of the several respects in which the dimers differed in structure, the presence or absence of intermolecular electrostatic contacts exerted the most significant influence on the gas-phase dissociation behavior. This is attributed to the well-known enhancement of ionic interactions in the absence of bulk solvent. Because salt bridges are general contributors to both intermolecular and intramolecular stability in protein complexes, these observations are broadly applicable to aid in the interpretation or prediction of dissociation spectra for noncovalent protein assemblies.     

Determination of ligand-protein dissociation constants by electrospray mass spectrometry-based diffusion measurements

A novel approach for the quantification of ligand-protein interactions is presented. Electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) is used to monitor the diffusion behavior of noncovalent ligands in the presence of their protein receptors. These data allow the fraction of free ligand in solution to be determined, such that the corresponding dissociation constants can be calculated. A set of conditions is developed that provides an "allowable range" of concentrations for this type of assay. The method is tested by applying it to two different inhibitor-enzyme systems. The dissociation constants measured for benzamidine-trypsin and for N,N',N' '-triacetylchitotriose-lysozyme are (50 +/- 10) and (6 +/- 1) mM, respectively. Both of these results are in good agreement with previous data from the literature. In contrast to traditional ESI-MS-based methods, the approach used in this work does not rely on the preservation of specific solution-type noncovalent interactions in the gas phase. It is shown that this method allows an accurate determination of dissociation constants, even in cases in which the ion abundance ratio of free to ligand-bound protein in ESI-MS does not reflect the corresponding concentration ratio in solution.     

Electron capture dissociation as structural probe for noncovalent gas-phase protein assemblies

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) of proteins in Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry usually leads to charge reduction and backbone-bond cleavage, thereby mostly retaining labile, intramolecular noncovalent interactions. In this report, we evaluate ECD of the 84-kDa noncovalent heptameric gp31 complex and compare this with sustained off-resonance irradiation collisionally activated dissociation (SORI-CAD) of the same protein. Unexpectedly, the 21+ charge state of the gp31 oligomer exhibits a main ECD pathway resulting in a hexamer and monomer, disrupting labile, intermolecular noncovalent bonds and leaving the backbone intact. Unexpectedly, the charge separation over the two products is highly proportional to molecular weight. This indicates that a major charge redistribution over the subunits of the complex does not take place during ECD, in contrast to the behavior observed when using SORI-CAD. We speculate that the ejected monomer retains more of its original structure in ECD, when compared to SORI-CAD. ECD of lower charge states of gp31 does not lead to dissociation of noncovalent bonds. We hypothesize that the initial gas-phase structure of the 21+ charge state is significantly different from the lower charge states. These structural differences result in the different reaction pathways when using ECD.     

Direct ionization of large proteins and protein complexes by desorption electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry

Desorption electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (DESI-MS) has advantages for rapid sample analysis with little or no sample pretreatment, but performance for large biomolecules has not been demonstrated. In this study, liquid sample DESI, an extended version of DESI used for analysis of liquid samples, was shown to have capabilities for direct ionization of large noncovalent protein complexes (>45 kDa) and proteins (up to 150 kDa). Protein complex ions (e.g., superoxide dismutase, enolase, and hemoglobin) desorbed from solution by liquid sample DESI were measured intact, indicating the capability of DESI for preserving weak noncovalent interactions. Doping the DESI spray solvent with supercharging reagents resulted in protein complex ions having increased multiple charging without complex dissociation. Ion mobility measurements of model protein cytochrome c showed that the supercharging reagent favored the more compact conformation for the lower charged protein ions. Liquid sample DESI of hydrophobic peptide gramicidin D suggests that the ionization mechanism involves a droplet pick-up mixing process. Measurement of liquid samples significantly extends the mass range of DESI-MS, allowing the analysis of high-mass proteins such as 150 kDa immunoglobulin G (IgG) and thus represents the largest protein successfully ionized by DESI to date.     

Mechanism and kinetics of metalloenzyme phosphomannose isomerase: measurement of dissociation constants and effect of zinc binding using ESI-FTICR mass spectrometry

Electrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (ESI-FTICR) mass spectrometry was used to study the noncovalent complexation of a metalloenzyme, phosphomannose isomerase (PMI), which catalyzes the interconversion of mannose 6-phosphate and fructose 6-phosphate. The zinc cofactor binding effect and the noncovalent interactions of the holoenzyme with its two natural substrates and two inhibitors, erythrose 4-phosphate and mannitol 1-phosphate, were investigated. Under nondenaturing conditions, the intact zinc-containing monomeric protein ions were reproducibly observed with no dissociation. Molecular ions corresponding to apo-PMI monomer were obtained by dialyzing the holoenzyme against EDTA. The binding/release of the metal ion did not alter the charge-state distributions of the protein to any significant extent, but changed the binding affinity of the substrates by at least 5-fold. Using ESI-FTICR mass spectrometry, the binding stoichiometry and specificity of the enzyme-substrate and enzyme-inhibitor complexes were directly determined. The first time report of the apparent dissociation constant for the isomeric substrates of PMI was measured to be 88.8 microM. The relative dissociation constant of the two inhibitors derived from gas-phase noncovalent complexation was very similar to the relative inhibition constant derived from solution phase kinetics.     

Conformational and noncovalent complexation changes in proteins during electrospray ionization

Electrospray ion sources efficiently produce gas-phase ions from proteins and their noncovalent complexes. Charge-state distributions of these ions are increasingly used to gauge their conformations in the solution phase. Here we investigate how this correlation is affected by the spraying conditions at the early stage of droplet generation, prior to the ionization process. We followed the folding behavior of model proteins cytochrome c and ubiquitin and the dissociation of the noncovalent holomyoglobin complex. Spray current measurements, fast Taylor cone imaging, and mass analysis of the generated ions indicated that the protein structure experienced conformational or complexation changes upon variations in the spraying mode of the electrospray ionization source. These effects resulted in a departure from the original secondary, tertiary, and quaternary structure of proteins, possibly introducing artifacts in related studies. Therefore, if a particular gas-phase ion conformation is required or correlations with the liquid-phase conformations are studied, it is advantageous to maintain a particular spraying mode. Alternatively, spraying mode-induced changes can be utilized to alter the structure of proteins in, for example, time-resolved experiments for the study of protein folding dynamics.     

Thermochemistry of protein-DNA interaction studied with temperature-controlled nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures

We introduce temperature-controlled nonequilibrium capillary electrophoresis of equilibrium mixtures (NECEEM) and demonstrate its use to study thermochemistry of protein-DNA interactions. Being a homogeneous kinetic method, temperature-controlled NECEEM uniquely allows finding temperature dependencies of equilibrium and kinetic parameters of complex formation without the immobilization of the interacting molecules on the surface of a solid substrate. In this work, we applied temperature-controlled NECEEM to study the thermochemistry of two protein-DNA pairs: (i) Taq DNA polymerase with its DNA aptamer and (ii) E. coli single-stranded DNA binding protein with a 20-base-long single-stranded DNA. We determined temperature dependencies of three parameters: the equilibrium binding constant (Kb), the rate constant of complex dissociation (k(off)), and the rate constant of complex formation (k(on)). The Kb(T) functions for both protein-DNA pairs had phase-transition-like points suggesting temperature-dependent conformational changes in structures of the interacting macromolecules. Temperature dependencies of k(on) and k(off) provided insights into how the conformational changes affected two opposite processes: binding and dissociation. Finally, thermodynamic parameters, DeltaH and DeltaS, for complex formation were found for different conformations. With its unique features and potential applicability to other macromolecular interactions, temperature-controlled NECEEM establishes a valuable addition to the arsenal of analytical methods used to study dynamic molecular complexes.     

Fluorescence polarization studies of affinity interactions in capillary electrophoresis.

Capillary electrophoresis (CE) combined with molecular recognition for ultrasensitive bioanalytical applications often requires the formation of stable complexes between an analyte and its binding partner. Previous studies of binding interactions using CE involve multiple-step titration experiments and are time-consuming. We describe a simple method based on laser-induced fluorescence polarization (LIFP) detection for CE separation, which allows for on-line monitoring of affinity complex formation. Because fluorescence polarization is sensitive to changes in the rotational diffusion arising from molecular association or dissociation, it is capable of providing information on the formation of affinity complexes prior to or during CE separation. Applications of the CE/LIFP method to three binding systems including vancomycin and its antibody, staphylococcal enterotoxin A and its antibody, and trp operator and trp repressor were demonstrated, representing peptide-protein, protein-protein, and DNA-protein interactions. The affinity complexes were readily distinguished from the unbound molecules on the basis of their fluorescence polarization. The relative increase in fluorescence polarization upon complex formation varied with the molecular size of the binding pairs.     

Consecutive ion activation for top down mass spectrometry: improved protein sequencing by nozzle-skimmer dissociation

Mass spectra produced by nozzle-skimmer dissociation (NSD) have been little used in the past for structural characterization. NSD cannot be used on mass-separated ions (MS/MS), and for electrosprayed protein ions, previous NSD spectra showed backbone cleavages similar to those from energetic methods such as collisionally activated dissociation (CAD) or infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD). However, our experimental configuration with Fourier transform (FT) MS makes possible three consecutive steps of NSD ion activation: thermal in the entrance capillary and collisional in both the nozzle-skimmer (N-S) region and the region after the skimmer before the quadrupole entrance lens (S-Q). In the high-pressure N-S region of adjustable path length, ions undergo high-frequency, low-energy collisions to rupture weak noncovalent or covalent bonds, with these "denatured" products then subjected to high-energy collisions in the low-pressure S-Q region to cleave strong backbone bonds. These NSD spectra, plus those from variable capillary thermal activation, of 8+ to 11+ ubiquitin ions electrosprayed from denatured solution show backbone cleavages between 74 of 75 amino acid pairs, vs 66 for CAD and 50 for IRMPD in the FTMS cell. Thermal activation by the inlet capillary of the newly desolvated 6+, 7+ ubiquitin ions from electrospraying the native conformer increases the NSD yield from 8% at 56 degrees C to 96% at 76 degrees C, but with little change in product branching ratios; this capillary heating has no effect on CAD or IRMPD of these ions collected in the FTMS cell. Ion desolvation with its concomitant H-bond strengthening appears to produce a transiently stable conformer whose formation can be prevented by capillary heating. The far more complex and stable noncovalent tertiary structures of large protein ions in the gas phase have made MS/MS difficult; initial inhibition of tertiary structure formation with immediate NSD ("prefolding dissociation") appears promising for the top down characterization of a 200-kDa protein.     

Shift reagents for multidimensional ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry analysis of complex peptide mixtures: evaluation of 18-crown-6 ether complexes

18-Crown-6 ether (18C6) is evaluated as a shift reagent for multidimensional ion mobility spectrometry-mass spectrometry (IMS-IMS-MS) analyses of tryptic protein digests. In this approach, 18C6 is spiked into the solution-phase mixture and noncovalent peptide-crown ion complexes are formed by electrospraying the mixture into the gas phase. After an initial mobility separation in the first IMS drift region, complexes of similar mobility are selected and dissociated via collisional activation prior to entering the second drift region. These dissociation products (including smaller complexes, naked peptide ions, charge transfer products, and fragment ions) differ in mobility from their precursor ion complexes and (in favorable cases) from one another, allowing the mixture to resolve further in the second IMS region. We estimate an IMS-IMS peak capacity of ~2400 when shift reagents are employed. The approach is illustrated by examining a tryptic digest of cytochrome c and by identifying a peptide out of a complex mixture obtained by digestion of human plasma proteins. Disadvantages arising from increased complexity of data sets as well as other advantages of this approach are considered.     

Influence of solution and gas phase processes on protein-carbohydrate binding affinities determined by nanoelectrospray Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry

The influence of solution pH, analyte concentration and in-source dissociation on the measurement of the association constant for a single chain variable fragment of a monoclonal antibody (scFv) and its native trisaccharide ligand by nanoelectrospray-Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometery has been systematically investigated. From the results of this study, experimental conditions that preserve the original distribution of bound and unbound protein in solution into the gas phase, such that the nanoES mass spectrum provides a quantitative measure of the solution composition, were identified. These include the use of short spray durations (<10 min) to minimize pH changes, equimolar concentrations of protein and ligand to minimize the formation of nonspecific complexes, and short accumulation times (<2 s) in the hexapole of the ion source to avoid collisional heating and dissociation of the gaseous complex. Application of this methodology to the scFv and a series of carbohydrate ligands yields results that are in agreement with values previously determined by isothermal titration calorimetry. Competitive binding experiments performed on solutions containing the scFv and a mixture of carbohydrate ligands were also found to yield accurate association constants.     

Improving the performance of a quadrupole time-of-flight instrument for macromolecular mass spectrometry

We modified and optimized a first generation quadrupole time-of-flight (Q-TOF) 1 to perform tandem mass spectrometry on macromolecular protein complexes. The modified instrument allows isolation and subsequent dissociation of high-mass protein complexes through collisions with argon molecules. The modifications of the Q-TOF 1 include the introduction of (1) a flow-restricting sleeve around the first hexapole ion bridge, (2) a low-frequency ion-selecting quadrupole, (3) a high-pressure hexapole collision cell, (4) high-transmission grids in the multicomponent ion lenses, and (5) a low repetition rate pusher. Using these modifications, we demonstrate the experimental isolation of ions up to 12 800 mass-to-charge units and detection of product ions up to 38 150 Da, enabling the investigation of the gas-phase stability, protein complex topology, and quaternary structure of protein complexes. Some of the data reveal a so-far unprecedented new mechanism in gas-phase dissociation of protein oligomers whereby a tetramer complex dissociates into two dimers. These data add to the current debate whether gas-phase structures of protein complexes do retain some of the structural features of the corresponding species in solution. The presented low-cost modifications on a Q-TOF 1 instrument are of interest to everyone working in the fields of macromolecular mass spectrometry and more generic structural biology.     

Direct monitoring of heat-stressed biopolymers with temperature-controlled electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The ability to monitor protein aggregation at the molecular level is critical for progress in many areas of life sciences ranging from understanding mechanisms of amyloidosis and etiology of conformational diseases to development of safe and efficient biopharmaceutical products. Despite the spectacular progress in understanding the mechanisms of protein aggregation in recent years, many aspects of the aggregating proteins behavior remain unclear because of the extreme difficulty in tracking evolution of these notoriously complex and heterogeneous systems. Here, we introduce a mass spectrometry-based methodology that allows the early stages of heat-induced aggregation to be studied by monitoring both conformational changes and formation of oligomers as a function of temperature. The new approach allows biopolymer behavior (both reversible and irreversible processes) to be monitored in a wide temperature range. Validation of the methodology is carried out by comparing temperature profiles of model proteins and nucleic acids deduced from mass spectrometry measurements and differential scanning calorimetry. Application of the methodology to study heat-induced aggregation of human glucocerebrosidase unequivocally links loss of conformational fidelity to formation of soluble oligomers, which serve as precursors to aggregation.     

Dynamic titration: determination of dissociation constants for noncovalent complexes in multiplexed format using HPLC-ESI-MS

With recent growth in fields such as life sciences and supramolecular chemistry, there has been an ever increasing need for high-throughput methods that would permit determination of binding affinities for noncovalent complexes of various host-guest systems. These are traditionally measured by titration experiments where concentration-dependent signals of species participating in solution-based binding equilibria are monitored by methods such as UV-vis spectrophotometry, calorimetry, or nuclear magnetic resonance spectrometry. Here we present a new titration technique that unifies and allows chromatographic separation of guests with determination of dissociation constants by electrospray mass spectrometry in a multiplexed format. A theoretical model has been derived that describes the complex formation for the guests eluted from a chromatographic column when hosts are admixed postcolumn. The model takes possible competition equilibria into account; i.e., it can deal with unresolved peaks of guests with the possible addition of multiple hosts in one experiment. This on-line workflow makes determination of binding affinities for large libraries of compounds possible. The potential of the method is demonstrated on the determination of dissociation constants for complexes of beta- and gamma-cyclodextrins with nonsteroidal antiinflammatory drugs ibuprofen, naproxen, and flurbiprofen.     

Separation and detection of intact noncovalent protein complexes from mixtures by on-line capillary isoelectric focusing-mass spectrometry

Separation and mass spectrometric analysis of intact noncovalent protein-protein complexes from mixtures is described. Protein complexes were separated using isoelectric focusing in a capillary under native conditions. During the mobilization, molecular masses of the intact complexes were measured on-line (as they emerged from the capillary) using Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance (FTICR) mass spectrometry. An FTICR "in-trap" ion cleanup procedure was necessary for some complexes to reduce high levels of adduction and to obtain accurate molecular mass measurements. Optimization of the conditions for analysis of different intact complexes is discussed. We have shown that either the intact noncovalent complexes or their constituent protein subunits can be detected by variation of sheath liquid (i.e., NH4OAc vs HOAc) added at the electrospray-mass spectrometer interface. Thus, two successive experiments permit a fast and efficient characterization of intact complex stoichiometry, the individual complex subunits and the possible presence of metal or other adducted species.     

Stabilization of gas-phase noncovalent macromolecular complexes in electrospray mass spectrometry using aqueous triethylammonium bicarbonate buffer

The use of triethylammonium bicarbonate (TEAB) solution in electrospray mass spectrometry proved to be a very efficient way for studying proteins or noncovalent protein complexes under "nondenaturing" conditions. The low charge states observed in the mass spectra improve the separation of ions arising from macromolecular species of close masses. Moreover, the multiply charged ions generated in a TEAB solution are significantly more stable than those formed under more conventional conditions (for example, with ammonium bicarbonate or acetate solution). The analytical interest of TEAB for the analysis of macromolecular species that can easily dissociate in the gas phase, such as hemoglobin or other macromolecular noncovalent complexes, is demonstrated.     

Quantifying protein-protein interactions within noncovalent complexes using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Several electrospray-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS)-based methods are available for determining the constant of association (K(a)) between a protein and a small ligand, but current MS-based strategies are not fully adequate for measuring K(a) of protein-protein interactions accurately. We expanded the application of ESI-MS-based titration to determine the strength of noncovalent interactions between proteins, forming a complex. Taking into account relative response factors (probability of being ionized, transmitted, and detected), we determined K(a) values of an equilibrium between dimers and tetramers at three different pH values (6.8, 3.4, and 8.4). We investigated the association of the lectin concanavalin A, whose dimer-tetramer ratio in the gas phase is affected by solution concentration and by pH. To calculate the constants of association in solution, we also utilized isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) for a comparison with MS-based titration. At pH 6.8 and pH 8.4, the K(a) values measured by MS and by ITC were in agreement. ITC results allowed us to restrain the response factor to a value close to 4. At pH 3.4, we were able to measure the K(a) only by MS, but not by ITC because of limited sensitivity of calorimetry. Our investigation illustrates the great potential MS for calculating the binding strength of protein-protein interactions within noncovalent complexes. The main advantages of MS over ITC are its sensitivity (i.e., the required amount of sample is >100 times less than the one necessary for ITC), and the possibility to obtain precise information on composition of protein complexes, their stoichiometry, their subunit interactions, and their assembly pathway. Compared to previous investigations, our study shows the strong influence of response factors on determining accurate protein-protein association constants by MS.     

The flight of macromolecular complexes in a mass spectrometer

The discovery that conditions can be found such that non-covalent macromolecular complexes can survive the transition from solution to gas phase and remain intact during their flight in a mass spectrometer is an intriguing observation. While the nature of the interaction between the components, either ionic, hydrophobic or van der Waals, undoubtedly has an effect on the stability of these gas phase species, the role of small molecules in conferring additional stability is often overlooked. Here we review historical aspects of the development of mass spectrometry for macromolecular complexes with particular focus on the role of small molecules in stabilizing gas-phase complexes. Moreover, we demonstrate how the dissociation of small molecules from subunits within a macromolecular complex can be used to probe the topological arrangement. Overall, therefore, we show that mass spectrometry used in this way is capable of addressing features of the energy landscape not readily accessed by traditional structural biology approaches.