Behavior of FRP Strengthened Infill Walls under In-Plane Seismic Loading

The present paper investigates the suitability and effectiveness of fiber-reinforced polymers (FRP) in strengthening and/or repairing unreinforced masonry infill walls in reinforced concrete frames which are subjected to in-plane seismic/cyclic loading. For this purpose, a detailed experimental program was conducted. Specimen geometry, test setup, instrumentation, and a loading procedure that simulates earthquake loading are presented in a detailed fashion. Results of experimental observations are discussed in the form of load-displacement hysteretic loops and envelopes; column profiles; strain diagrams, and wall shear distortion. The test results, in general, indicate that the use of glass FRP (GFRP) sheets as strengthening materials provides a degree of enhancement to the infill wall, upgrades its deformation capacity, and makes the wall work as one unit. These results thus show great potential for externally bonded GFRP sheets in upgrading and strengthening the infill walls under in-plane seismic loads.     

Case Study: Seismic Retrofitting of a Medieval Bell Tower with FRP

Seismic retrofitting of monument structures requires compliance with restrictive constraints related to the preservation of original artistic and structural features. Any conceived intervention must achieve structural performance yet still respect the appearance and structural mechanism of the original and be as minimally invasive as possible. Therefore, traditional retrofit strategies may not be suitable for such purposes, and structural engineers need to develop specific techniques. Innovative materials (e.g., composites) may be helpful, as demonstrated by the case study presented in this paper. Fiber-reinforced plastics (FRPs) were used for the design, analysis, and installation of the retrofit for the medieval bell tower in Serra San Quirico (Ancona, Italy). A FRP tie system is applied to the inner walls and anchored at the base by a reinforced concrete slab, independent of the tower’s foundation. The intervention enhances the seismic capacity of the structure and is fully provisional as it may be removed by heating the FRP with a hot air jet. The design process consisted of preliminary finite-element simulation and on-site structural assessment. Effectiveness is evaluated by a comparison of nonlinear static analyses (pushover) of the retrofitted and original structures. Finally, seismic risk reduction is computed by considering probabilistic seismic hazard at the site. Installation issues and the current appearance of the structure are also discussed.     

Static Cyclic Response of Masonry Walls Retrofitted with Fiber-Reinforced Polymers

The behavior of seven one-half scale masonry specimens before and after retrofitting using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) is investigated. Four walls were built using one-half scale hollow clay masonry units and weak mortar to simulate walls built in central Europe in the mid-20th century. Three walls were first tested as unreinforced masonry walls; then, the seismically damaged specimens were retrofitted using FRPs. The fourth wall was directly upgraded after construction using FRP. Each specimen was retrofitted on the entire surface of a single side. All the specimens were tested under constant gravity load and incrementally increasing in-plane loading cycles. The tested specimens had two effective moment/shear ratio, namely, 0.5 and 0.7. The key parameter was the amount of FRP axial rigidity, which is defined as the amount of FRP reinforcement ratio times its E modulus. The single-side retrofitting/upgrading significantly improved the lateral strength, stiffness, and energy dissipation of the test specimens. The increase in the lateral strength was proportional to the amount of FRP axial rigidity. However, using high amount of FRP axial rigidity led to very brittle failure. Finally, simple existing analytical models estimated the ultimate lateral strengths of the test specimens reasonably well.     

Out-of-Plane Strengthening of Unreinforced Masonry Walls with Openings

Collapse of unreinforced masonry (URM) walls is the cause of many casualties during extreme loading events. The objective of this current research was to investigate effective and practical approaches for strengthening URM block walls with openings to resist extreme out-of-plane loads. Five full-scale masonry block walls were constructed. The walls had different opening configurations such as a single center window, one window off center, two windows, a wide window and a door. The walls were tested when subjected to uniformly distributed lateral load up to failure. The walls were then strengthened using carbon fiber-reinforced polymer laminate strips and then retested. The walls were set up in a vertical test frame and were subjected to cyclic out-of-plane distributed pressure using an airbag. Failure of the unstrengthened URM block wall was along the mortar joints. In the strengthened walls, failure occurred in the mortar joints as well as in concrete blocks near the carbon strips. The lateral load carrying capacity of the strengthened walls was found to be significantly higher than that of the unstrengthened walls and had much more ductile performance.     

FRP-Retrofitted URM Walls under In-Plane Shear: Review and Assessment of Available Models

In the last two decades, several seismic retrofitting techniques for masonry structures have been developed and practiced and fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) material has been increasingly used owing to its high strength/stiffness to mass ratio and easy application. Although much research has been carried out on FRP strengthening of unreinforced masonry (URM) structures, most of it has been experimental studies to investigate the effectiveness of retrofitting techniques rather than the development of a rational design model. In addition, more research has been conducted on FRP-retrofitted URM walls under out-of-plane loads where flexural behavior dominates, the research on the shear strength of FRP-retrofitted URM walls has been limited. This paper presents a review of research in this area. Existing retrofitting techniques are overviewed, followed by a detailed discussion of experimental results of failure modes as they are directly related to the design model. The available design models are then assessed based on a test database collected from the available literature. Limitations of each model are addressed.     

Strengthening of Infill Masonry Walls with FRP Materials

This paper evaluates the effectiveness of different externally bonded glass fiber–reinforced polymer (GFRP) systems for increasing the out-of-plane resistance of infill masonry walls to loading. The research included a comprehensive experimental program comprising 14 full-scale specimens, including four unstrengthened (control) specimens and 10 strengthened specimens. To simulate the boundary conditions of infill walls, all specimens consisted of a reinforced concrete (RC) frame, simulating the supporting RC elements of a building superstructure, which was infilled with solid concrete brick masonry. The specimens were loaded out-of-plane using uniformly distributed pressure to simulate the differential (suction) pressure induced by a tornado. Parameters investigated in the experimental program included aspect ratio, FRP coverage ratio, number of masonry wythes, and type of FRP anchorage. Test results indicated that the type of FRP anchorage had a significant effect on the failure mode. Research findings concluded that GFRP strengthening of infill masonry walls is effective in increasing the out-of-plane load-carrying capacity when proper anchorage of the FRP laminate is provided.     

Seismic Response of Interior RC Beam-Column Joints Upgraded with FRP Sheets. I: Experimental Study

In this paper, efficiency and effectiveness of carbon fiber-reinforced polymers (CFRP) in upgrading the shear strength and ductility of seismically deficient beam-column joints have been studied. For this purpose, four reinforced concrete interior beam-column sub-assemblages were constructed with nonoptimal design parameters (inadequate joint shear strength with no transverse reinforcement) representing preseismic code design construction practice of joints and encompassing the vast majority of existing beam-column connections. Out of these four, two specimens were used as baseline specimens (control specimens) and the other two were strengthened with CFRP sheets under two different schemes (strengthened specimens). In the first scheme, CFRP sheets were epoxy bonded to the joint, beams, and part of the column regions. In the second scheme, however, sheets were epoxy bonded to the joint region only but they were effectively prevented against any possible debonding through mechanical anchorages. All four subassemblages were subjected to cyclic lateral load histories so as to provide the equivalent of severe earthquake damage. Further, the damaged control specimens were repaired after filling the cracks through epoxy and wrapping them with CFRP sheets under the same two above-mentioned schemes. These repaired specimens were subjected to the similar cyclic lateral load history and their response histories were obtained. Hence, a total of six specimens were tested: two control; two strengthened; and two repaired. Response histories of control, repaired, and strengthened specimens were then compared. The results were compared through hysteretic loops, load-displacement envelopes, column profiles (maximum horizontal displacements of column along its height), joint shear distortion, ductility, and stiffness degradation. The comparison shows that CFRP sheets improve the shear resistance of the joint and increase its ductility. Results of two chosen schemes of strengthening were also compared and the importance of beam upgrading was highlighted.     

Assessment of Design Formulas for In-Plane FRP Strengthening of Masonry Walls

Masonry structures have demonstrated their seismic vulnerability during recent world seismic events. This paper investigates in-plane seismic performance of unreinforced masonry (URM) walls before and after they are retrofit using fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) materials. An assessment of available design formulas for evaluating both the in-plane performance of URM walls and the contribution of FRP strengthening systems was performed. Walls with two configurations of the FRP reinforcement have been analyzed: one based on FRP strips installed parallel to the mortar joints, the other characterized by FRP strips arranged along the diagonals of the wall. Based on shear–compression tests carried out on FRP-strengthened masonry walls available in the literature, a comparison between theoretical and experimental data is performed. A discussion about the FRP strains at failure of the walls is provided and values of effective FRP strains to be used for design purposes are proposed.     

Seismic Response of Interior RC Beam-Column Joints Upgraded with FRP Sheets. II: Analysis and Parametric Study

In this paper a procedure for analytical prediction of joint shear strength of interior beam-column joints, strengthened with externally bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) sheets, has been presented. The procedure is based on the formulation available in the literature. To implement the available formulation for shear capacity prediction a computer program has been developed. Using this program shear capacity of the joint and joint shear stress variation at various stages of loading have been predicted and compared with experimental observations; presented in Part I of this study. Predictions show good agreement with experimental test results. The formulation is further extended to predict diagonal tensile stresses in the joint. The effectiveness of FRP quantity on joint shear strength and on various strains has been studied on parametric basis. It is observed that even a low quantity of FRP can enhance shear capacity of the joint significantly and its effectiveness can be further increased if debonding is suppressed (e.g., through mechanical anchorages). Effect of column axial load on shear strength of the joint has also been studied. It is observed that axial load increases the confinement of the joint core, which in turn increases the shear capacity of the joint.     

In-Plane Lateral Response of a Full-Scale Masonry Subassemblage with and without an Inorganic Matrix-Grid Strengthening System

A full-scale unreinforced masonry (URM) wall with an opening was tested under in-plane lateral loading. The wall was first subjected to monotonically increasing displacements until a moderate damage level was reached. The damaged specimen was then cyclically tested up to almost the same maximum drift attained during the monotonic test to investigate the effects of previous damage on its nonlinear response. Finally, the masonry wall was repaired with inorganic matrix-grid (IMG) composites and subjected to a cyclic displacement-controlled test up to a near-collapse state. Most of the observed damage developed in the spandrel panel affecting both lateral resistance and strength degradation. Rocking of piers governed lateral stiffness and hysteretic response, which was characterized by low residual displacements and recentering behavior. The comparison between the experimental force-displacement curves demonstrated that the IMG strengthening system was able to provide energy dissipation capacity to the spandrel panel, restoring load-bearing capacity of the as-built wall, and delaying strength degradation that was indeed observed at larger displacements. Bilinear idealizations of force-displacement curves allowed the identification of displacement ductility, global overstrength, and strength reduction factor of the tested wall systems.     

Seismic Response Modification Factors for Reinforced Masonry Structural Walls

The current North American design standards provide seismic force modification factors for the rectangular masonry structural walls category only; no similar provisions for flanged and end-confined masonry structural walls exist. This study demonstrates that seismic force reduction factor (R) values calculated for rectangular walls was close to 5.0, which is consistent with the value stipulated by the ASCE 7, and was 36 and 90% higher for the corresponding flanged and end-confined walls. The deflection amplification factor (Cd) values calculated for rectangular walls were higher than specified in the ASCE 7 for the special reinforced masonry wall category. Values of the ductility-related force modification factor (Rd) for flanged and end-confined walls were, respectively, at least 30 and 100% higher than those of rectangular walls specified in the National Building Code of Canada (NBCC). Quantification of the seismic response parameters within this study is expected to facilitate adoption of the flanged and end-confined wall categories in North American masonry codes as a cost-effective technique to enhance the seismic performance of masonry construction.     

Lateral Out-of-Plane Strengthening of Masonry Walls with Composite Materials

The structural behavior of masonry walls laterally strengthened with externally bonded composite materials to resist out-of-plane loads is theoretically and experimentally studied. Hollow concrete block masonry walls and solid autoclaved aerated concrete (AAC) block masonry walls are examined. A theoretical model that accounts for the cracking and the physical nonlinear behavior, the debonding of the composite layers, the arching effect, the interfacial stresses, and the unique modeling aspects of the laterally strengthened wall is presented. The experimental study includes loading to failure of 4 laterally strengthened masonry walls and 2 control walls. The experimental and analytical results point at the unique aspects of the lateral strengthening of masonry walls with composite materials. In particular, they reveal and explain the premature shear failure in laterally strengthened hollow concrete blocks walls and, on the other hand, demonstrate the potential of lateral fiber-reinforced polymer strengthening of AAC masonry walls. The laterally strengthened AAC masonry walls reveal improved strength, deformability, and integrity at failure characteristics.     

Free Out-of-Plane Vibrations of Masonry Walls Strengthened with Composite Materials

The natural frequencies and the out-of-plane vibration modes of one-way masonry walls strengthened with composite materials are studied. Due to the inherent nonlinear behavior of the masonry wall, the dynamic characteristics depend on the level of out-of-plane load (mechanical load or forced out-of-plane deflections) and the resulting cracking, nonlinear behavior of the mortar material, and debonding of the composite system. In order to account for the nonlinearity and the accumulation of damage, a general nonlinear dynamic model of the strengthened wall is developed. The model is mathematically decomposed into a nonlinear static analysis phase, in which the static response and the corresponding residual mechanical properties are determined, and a free vibration analysis phase, in which the dynamic characteristics are determined. The governing nonlinear differential equations of the first phase, the linear differential eigenvalue problem corresponding to the second phase, and the solution strategies are derived. Two numerical examples that examine the capabilities of the model and study the dynamic properties of the strengthened wall are presented. The model is supported and verified through comparison with a step-by-step time integration analysis, and comparison with experimental results of a full-scale strengthened wall under impulse loading. The results show that the strengthening system significantly affects the natural frequencies of the wall, modifies its modes of vibration, and restrains the deterioration of the dynamic properties with the increase of load. The quantification of these effects contributes to the understanding of the performance of damaged strengthened walls under dynamic and seismic loads.     

Use of Composite Reinforcement to Strengthen Concrete and Air-Entrained Concrete Masonry Walls against Air Blast

Two concrete structures and three air-entrained concrete (AEC) masonry walls were subjected to two, high explosive detonations. The concrete structures were placed at a stand-off distance such that medium damage was expected. The stand-off distance of the AEC-masonry walls was reduced on each successive detonation until breaching occurred. The two concrete structures retrofitted with composite materials were subjected to air-blast loading at a stand-off distance of approximately 14.6 m. The structures were constructed such that each long side of the structure contained a wall retrofitted with a composite material and a wall left bare as a control. Both concrete structures exhibited less residual displacement on the walls strengthened with composite materials than the bare control walls.     

Experimental Response of Externally Retrofitted Masonry Walls Subjected to Shear Loading

Recent earthquakes have produced extensive damage in a large number of existing masonry buildings, demonstrating the need for retrofitting masonry structures. Externally bonded carbon fiber is a retrofitting technique that has been used to increase the strength of reinforced concrete elements. Sixteen full-scale shear dominant clay brick masonry walls, six with wire-steel shear reinforcement, were retrofitted with two configurations of externally bonded carbon fiber strips and subjected to shear loading. The results of the experimental program showed that the strength of the walls could be increased 13–84%, whereas, their displacement capacity increased 51–146%. This paper presents an analysis of the experimental results and simple equations to estimate the cracking load and the maximum shear strength of clay brick masonry walls, retrofitted with carbon fiber.     

Response of Bonded Membrane Retrofit Concrete Masonry Walls to Dynamic Pressure

This paper describes the development of analytical models used to predict the response of bonded membrane retrofit concrete masonry walls subjected to out-of-plane impulse pressure loads. Full scale tests have shown significant improvement in the resistance of unreinforced concrete masonry walls retrofitted by membrane materials. The majority of the membrane retrofit concrete masonry walls survived compared to their unretrofitted counterparts that collapsed. Polymer membrane retrofit materials may be sprayed on, trowled on, or attached with adhesives to the tension face of the wall. Other membrane materials such as thin steel or aluminum sheets may be attached to the tension face of the wall using expansion screws or other structurally sound methods. Resistance functions previously presented by the writers for membrane retrofit concrete masonry walls are used in the development of the response. Single-degree-of-freedom equations are developed to predict the response of these walls to impulse pressure and the results of the analysis are compared with available full-scale tests.     

Rehabilitation of Masonry Walls Using Unobtrusive FRP Techniques for Enhanced Out-of-Plane Seismic Resistance

Earthquake damage to unreinforced masonry buildings has shown the vulnerability of perimeter walls to out-of-plane failure. This paper describes a study that was carried out to develop and test innovative fiber reinforced polymer (FRP) rehabilitation techniques that meet the stringent requirements for strengthening historical buildings and to be cost-effective alternatives applicable to other existing masonry structures. Unobtrusive FRP rehabilitation techniques that utilize flexible carbon fiber composite cables, mounted near the surface of the fa?ade walls in epoxy-filled grooves in the bed and head joints, were developed. Ten full size walls were constructed of clay bricks and retrofitted using the developed FRP rehabilitation techniques. The test results demonstrated the high efficiency of the rehabilitation techniques under both monotonic and quasistatic cyclic loadings. Significant increases in ultimate capacities, energy absorption, and deformability were achieved for various reinforcing schemes compared to the behavior of the unreinforced walls.     

Nonlinear Analyses of Tuff Masonry Walls Strengthened with Cementitious Matrix-Grid Composites

Previous experimental studies, conducted by some of the authors, on in-plane response of tuff masonry walls strengthened with an innovative cementitious matrix composite grid (CMG) system confirmed that the CMG system could satisfy basic design requirements such as compatibility with the tuff masonry support (i.e., in terms of good bond properties), reversibility of the intervention and strengthening effectiveness. However, very large scatter was found in the experimental outcomes. Micromodeling and some parametric analyses were adopted to understand the contribution of basic material (mortar, tuff blocks and CMG strengthening) and the effect of the workmanship defects on the structural behavior of a natural stone wall. In order to conduct the analyses, finite-element method models of the elements have been compared to experimental data and they were found to be in good agreement with the test data. Significant improvements of strength and in the postpeak response were achieved installing different layouts of the CMG system. However the strengthening intervention had a negligible influence on the initial stiffness of the walls and this means that it has a reduced impact on the behavior of the existing structure.     

Experimental In-Plane Behavior of Tuff Masonry Strengthened with Cementitious Matrix–Grid Composites

Tuff buildings are a significant part of the Mediterranean area and are to be preserved from a structural viewpoint especially in seismic areas. Over the past few decades, the interest in strengthening of historical tuff masonry structures has led to developing specific and noninvasive architectural and engineering strategies. In the present paper, a comprehensive experimental program on tuff masonry panels is presented; the results are intended as a contribution to the knowledge of in-plane behavior of tuff masonry strengthened with composite materials. Particularly, a cement based matrix-coated alkali resistant glass grid system (CMG) was used to strengthen tuff masonry walls; different CMG layouts were selected, and overall performances were compared with those of as-built ones. The characterization of base materials was carried out first, followed by uniaxial tests of masonry and shear tests on triplets. Finally, tuff masonry panels were subjected to diagonal compression loading under displacement control in order to measure their in-plane deformation and strength properties, including the postpeak softening regime in view of seismic applications.     

Investigation of Seismic Behavior and Infill Wall Effects for Prefabricated Industrial Buildings in Turkey

Recently, Turkey has been hit by several moderate to large earthquakes that resulted in significant loss of life and property. The 1998 Adana and 1999 Marmara earthquakes caused severe damage not only in residential buildings but also in industrial buildings. Most of the industrial buildings in Turkey are constructed as prefabricated structures. Prefabricated structures are preferred because of their economic and rapid production. In the present study, the earthquake behavior and infill wall effects for single story hinged industrial prefabricated buildings were investigated. Nonlinear pushover, performance-based, time history, and fragility analyses were carried out for a sample prefabricated industrial building. Infill wall effect was investigated by adopting a diagonal strut model. The structural behavior and load-deformation relationship of prefabricated industrial buildings both with and without infilled walls were evaluated and compared. Results of the study show that masonry infill walls can affect the lateral load-carrying capacity and modify the earthquake response of prefabricated industrial buildings.