Characterizing electrospray ionization using atmospheric pressure ion mobility spectrometry

Reduced flow rate electrospray ionization has been proven to provide improved sensitivity, less background noise, and improved limits of detections for ESI-MS analysis. Miniaturizing the ESI source from conventional electrospray to microelectrospray and further down to nanoelectrospray has resulted in higher and higher sensitivity; however, when effects of flow rate were investigated for atmospheric pressure ESI-IMS using a nanospray emitter, a striking opposite result was observed. The general tendency we observed in ESI-IMS was that higher flow rate offered higher ion signal intensity throughout a variety of conditions investigated. Thus, further efforts were undertaken to rationalize these contradictory results. It is well accepted that decreased flow rate increases both ionization efficiency and transmission efficiency, thus improving ion signal in ESI-MS. However, our study revealed that decreased flow rate results in decreased ion signal because ion transfer is constant, no matter how flow rate changes in ESI-IMS. Since ion transfer is constant in atmospheric pressure ESI-IMS, ionization efficiency can be studied independently, which otherwise is not possible in ESI-MS in which both ionization efficiency and transmission efficiency vary as conditions alter. In this article, we present a systematic study of signal intensity and ionization efficiency at various experimental conditions using ESI-IMS and demonstrate the ionization efficiency as a function of flow rate, analyte concentration, and solvent composition.     

Separation of isomeric peptides using electrospray ionization/high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry

In this paper, the first examples of baseline separation of isomeric macromolecules by electrospray ionization/ion mobility spectrometry (ESI/IMS) at atmospheric pressure are presented. The behavior of a number of different isomeric peptides in the IMS was investigated using nitrogen as a drift gas. The IMS was coupled to a quadrupole mass spectrometer, which was used for identification and selective detection of the electrosprayed ions. The mobility data were used to determine their average collision cross sections. The gas-phase ions of isomeric peptides were found to have different collision cross sections. In all cases, doubly charged ions exhibited significantly (8-20%) larger collision cross sections than the respective singly charged species. The analysis of mixtures of the isomeric peptides clearly demonstrated the capability of IMS to separate gas-phase peptide ions due to small differences in their conformational structures, which cannot be determined by mass spectrometry. An actual resolving power of 80 was achieved for two doubly charged reversed sequenced pentapeptides. Baseline separation was provided for ions differing by only 2.5% in their measured collision cross sections; partial separation was shown for isomeric ions exhibiting differences as small as 1.1%.     

Probing ligand binding to duplex DNA using KMnO4 reactions and electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry

An electrospray ionization tandem mass spectrometry (ESI-MS/MS) strategy employing the thymine-selective KMnO4 oxidation reaction to detect conformational changes and ligand binding sites in noncovalent DNA/drug complexes is reported. ESI-MS/MS is used to detect specific mass shifts of the DNA ions that are associated with the oxidation of thymines. This KMnO4 oxidation/ESI-MS/MS approach is an alternative to conventional gel-based oxidation methods and affords excellent sensitivity while eliminating the reliance on radiolabeled DNA. Comparison of single-strand versus duplex DNA indicates that the duplexes exhibit a significant resistance to the reaction, thus confirming that the oxidation process is favored for unwound or single-strand regions of DNA. DNA complexes containing different drugs including echinomycin, actinomycin-D, ethidium bromide, Hoechst 33342, and cis-C1 were subjected to the oxidation reaction. Echinomycin, a ligand with a bisintercalative binding mode, was found to induce the greatest KMnO4 reactivity, while Hoechst 33342, a minor groove binder, caused no increase in the oxidation of DNA. The oxidation of echinomycin/DNA complexes containing duplexes with different sequences and lengths was also assessed. Duplexes with thymines closer to the terminal ends of the duplex demonstrated a greater increase in the degree of oxidation than those with thymines in the middle of the sequence. Collisional activated dissociation (CAD) and infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) experiments were used to determine the site of oxidation based on oligonucleotide fragmentation patterns.     

Secondary electrospray ionization ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry of illicit drugs

A secondary electrospray ionization (SESI) method was developed as a nonradioactive ionization source for ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). This SESI method relied on the gas-phase interaction between charged particles created by electrospray ionization (ESI) and neutral gaseous sample molecules. Mass spectrometry (MS) was used as the detection method after ion mobility separation for ion identification. Preliminary investigations focussed on understanding the ionization process of SESI. The performance of ESI-IMS and SESI-IMS for illicit drug detection was evaluated by determining the analytical figures of merit. In general, SESI had a higher ionization efficiency for small volatile molecules compared with the electrospray method. The potential of developing a universal interface for both GC- and LC-MS with an addition stage of mobility separation was demonstrated.     

Quantitative dynamics of site-specific protein phosphorylation determined using liquid chromatography electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

We have developed and validated a method that uses liquid chromatography/electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry to quantify site-specific protein phosphorylation. The method uses selected ion monitoring to determine the chromatographic peak areas of specific tryptic peptides from the protein of interest. The extent of phosphorylation is determined from the ratio of the phosphopeptide peak area to the peak area of an unmodified reference peptide that acts as internal standard, correcting for variations in protein amounts and peptide recovery in the digest preparation procedure. As a result, we refer to this protocol as the native reference peptide method. Mole of phosphate at the selected site per mole of protein is obtained from this ratio, using calibration curves of synthetic peptides to determine relative responses. Our method begins with protein separation by SDS-PAGE and is carried out on amounts of peptide produced by an in-gel digestion of single Coomassie blue-stained bands. To illustrate the utility of the method and provide validation, we used cardiac troponin I as analyte and monitored the time course of a protein kinase C betaII reaction. Those analyses appropriately demonstrate the time-dependent increase of phosphorylation at a PKC-preferred site, Ser44 in the peptide 41ISASPR45 and the concomitant consumption of the nonphosphorylated peptide. We believe that this method provides a novel tool to directly measure specific phosphorylation sites in proteins in different physiological states and expect that the method will be adaptable not only to a variety of samples types (i.e., culture cells, tissues, etc.) but to a variety of posttranslation modifications as well.     

Identifying specific small-molecule interactions using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

A simple method for establishing whether complexes composed of small molecules detected by electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ES-MS) originate from specific interactions in solution or nonspecific binding during the ES process is described. The technique, referred to as the nonspecific probe method, exploits the tendency of small molecules to bind nonspecifically to macromolecules during the ES process to establish the presence of specific noncovalent interactions. To implement the method, a macromolecule probe (P(NS)), which does not bind specifically to any of the components present in solution, is added prior to ES-MS analysis. The existence of specific small-molecule complexes is determined from an analysis of the measured distributions of the small molecules bound nonspecifically to P(NS). The principal assumption on which this methodology is based is that nonspecific binding of small molecules and their complexes to P(NS) during ES is a statistical (random) process. A mathematical framework for establishing the presence of specific heterocomplexes is presented. The reliability of the method for distinguishing specific from nonspecific small-molecule interactions is illustrated for peptide-antibiotic and metal ion-ligand interactions in water.     

Tissue imaging using nanospray desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Ambient ionization imaging mass spectrometry is uniquely suited for detailed spatially resolved chemical characterization of biological samples in their native environment. However, the spatial resolution attainable using existing approaches is limited by the ion transfer efficiency from the ionization region into the mass spectrometer. Here, we present a first study of ambient imaging of biological samples using nanospray desorption ionization (nano-DESI). Nano-DESI is a new ambient pressure ionization technique that uses minute amounts of solvent confined between two capillaries comprising the nano-DESI probe and the solid analyte for controlled desorption of molecules present on the substrate followed by ionization through self-aspirating nanospray. We demonstrate highly sensitive spatially resolved analysis of tissue samples without sample preparation. Our first proof-of-principle experiments indicate the potential of nano-DESI for ambient imaging with a spatial resolution of better than 12 μm. The significant improvement of the spatial resolution offered by nano-DESI imaging combined with high detection efficiency will enable new imaging mass spectrometry applications in clinical diagnostics, drug discovery, molecular biology, and biochemistry.     

Development of submillisecond time-resolved mass spectrometry using desorption electrospray ionization

Reaction kinetics studied by mass spectrometry (MS) has previously been limited to millisecond time resolution. This paper presents the development of a submillisecond time-resolved mass spectrometric method for fast reaction kinetic study, based on the capability of desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) for direct and fast ionization of a high-speed liquid jet stream. The principle underlying this methodology is that two reactant solutions undergo rapid mixing to produce a free liquid jet which is ionized by DESI at different positions corresponding to different reaction times. Due to the high velocity of the liquid jet, high time resolution can be achieved. In this study, the fast reduction reaction of 2, 6-dichlorophenolindophenol (DCIP) and L-ascorbic acid (L-AA) was chosen as an example to demonstrate this concept, and the reaction rate constant was successfully measured with an unprecedented time resolution of 300 μs. The good agreement of the measured value of (116 ± 3) s(-1) with that measured by the stopped-flow optical method (105 ± 2) s(-1) validates the feasibility of such a DESI-MS approach. Unlike classical spectroscopic techniques that require either chromophoric substrates or labeling, MS is a general detector with high chemical specificity. Therefore, this time-resolved DESI-MS method should find wide applications in fast (bio)chemical reaction investigations.     

Probing the unfolding and refolding processes of carbonic anhydrase 2 using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry combined with pH jump

A novel method for proving the time course of the unfolding and refolding processes of metalloprotein bovine carbonic anhydrase 2 (CA2) is demonstrated using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS) combined with pH jumps between 3.6 and 4.4. The shift in mass accompanied by the release or coordination of a zinc ion and the change in the charge state distribution were measured to evaluate the folding process. The time course of the ESI mass spectra revealed the existence of four types of ions in the experimental system, i.e., lower charged apo-CA2 and holo-CA2 ions and higher charged apo-CA2 and holo-CA2 ions. The deconvolution spectrum of the ion peak ensemble for each type of ion was processed and time course plots of the relative intensities of the four ions were prepared in order to analyze the folding processes. These analyses revealed the coexistence of two folding states of the lower and higher charged apo-CA2 under the condition of pH 3.6. The lower and higher charged apoproteins spontaneously refolded to the lower charged holoprotein by a pH jump from 3.6 to 4.4 without the addition of an extra zinc ion. The higher charged holoprotein observed during both the unfolding and refolding processes was considered to be an intermediate of the change in folding. The present study indicates that ESI MS combined with pH jump would be a powerful method to probe the unfolding and refolding of proteins. This method simultaneously measures mass spectra and analyzes the folding processes as a function of time using deconvolution spectra constructed by selecting a suitable m/z range for the analysis from the peaks of charge state distributions.     

Interfacing capillary-based separations to mass spectrometry using desorption electrospray ionization

The powerful hybrid analysis method of capillary-based separations followed by mass spectrometric analysis gives substantial chemical identity and structural information. It is usually carried out using electrospray ionization. However, the salts and detergents used in the mobile phase for electrokinetic separations suppress ionization efficiencies and contaminate the inlet of the mass spectrometer. This report describes a new method that uses desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) to overcome these limitations. Effluent from capillary columns is deposited on a rotating Teflon disk that is covered with paper. As the surface rotates, the temporal separation of the eluting analytes (i.e., the electropherogram) is spatially encoded on the surface. Then, using DESI, surface-deposited analytes are preferentially ionized, reducing the effects of ion suppression and inlet contamination on signal. With the use of this novel approach, two capillary-based separations were performed: a mixture of the rhodamine dyes at milligram/milliliter levels in a 10 mM sodium borate solution was separated by capillary electrophoresis, and a mixture of three cardiac drugs at milligram/milliliter levels in a 12.5 mM sodium borate and 12.5 mM sodium dodecyl sulfate solution was separated by micellar electrokinetic chromatography. In both experiments, the negative effects of detergents and salts on the MS analyses were minimized.     

Thin-layer chromatography and mass spectrometry coupled using desorption electrospray ionization

Desorption electrospray ionization (DESI) was demonstrated as a means to couple thin-layer chromatography (TLC) with mass spectrometry. The experimental setup and its optimization are described. Development lanes were scanned by moving the TLC plate under computer control while directing the stationary DESI emitter charged droplet plume at the TLC plate surface. Mass spectral data were recorded in either selected reaction monitoring mode or in full scan ion trap mode using a hybrid triple quadrupole linear ion trap mass spectrometer. Fundamentals and practical applications of the technique were demonstrated in positive ion mode using selected reaction monitoring detection of rhodamine dyes separated on hydrophobic reversed-phase C8 plates and reversed-phase C2 plates, in negative ion full scan mode using a selection of FD&C dyes separated on a wettable reversed-phase C18 plate, and in positive ion full scan mode using a mixture of aspirin, acetaminophen, and caffeine from an over-the-counter pain medication separated on a normal-phase silica gel plate.     

Miniature differential mobility spectrometry using atmospheric pressure photoionization

Positive and negative ion spectra have been obtained with a miniature differential mobility spectrometer equipped with a photoionization source operating at atmospheric pressure. With benzene as a dopant, providing C6H6+ as reactant ion, protonated molecular ions and proton-bound dimer ions were obtained with dimethyl methylphosphonate and butanone. The spectra obtained from gas chromatographic injections of aromatic hydrocarbons, benzene, toluene, and the xylenes, produced the molecular ions when the moisture level was very low, but at a high level the hydrated proton was also present. Possible mechanisms for the formation of protonated products are discussed. Negative ions were produced from electron capture by sulfur hexafluoride using benzene or acetone as dopant. Photoionization of nitrogen dioxide led to the formation of the nitrate ion whose yield was a nonlinear function of concentration. The use of a suitable dopant enhanced ion formation by up to 2 orders of magnitude, and limits of detection in both the positive and negative modes were all at the sub ppm(v) level. The study makes a strong case for the use of a photoionization source as an alternative to the radioactive 63Ni source.     

Separation of cisplatin and its hydrolysis products using electrospray ionization high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry coupled with ion trap mass spectrometry

Cisplatin and its mono- and dihydrated complexes have been separated using a high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) analyzer interfaced with electrospray ionization (ESI) and ion trap mass spectrometry (ITMS). The addition of helium to the nitrogen curtain/carrier gas in the FAIMS device improved both the sensitivity and selectivity of the electrospray analysis. Introduction of a three-component mixture as curtain/carrier gas, nitrogen, helium, and carbon dioxide, resulted in further improvements to sensitivity. Compared with conventional ESI-MS, the background chemical noise in the ESI-FAIMS-ITMS spectrum was dramatically reduced, resulting in over 30-fold improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio for cisplatin. Analytical results were linear over the concentration range 10-200 ng/mL for intact cisplatin with a corresponding detection limit determined of 0.7 ng/mL with no derivatization or chromatographic separation prior to analysis.     

Study of electrochemical reactions using nanospray desorption electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The combination of electrochemistry (EC) and mass spectrometry (MS) is a powerful analytical tool for studying mechanisms of redox reactions, identification of products and intermediates, and online derivatization/recognition of analytes. This work reports a new coupling interface for EC/MS by employing nanospray desorption electrospray ionization, a recently developed ambient ionization method. We demonstrate online coupling of nanospray desorption electrospray ionization MS with a traditional electrochemical flow cell, in which the electrolyzed solution emanating from the cell is ionized by nanospray desorption electrospray ionization for MS analysis. Furthermore, we show first coupling of nanospray desorption electrospray ionization MS with an interdigitated array (IDA) electrode enabling chemical analysis of electrolyzed samples directly from electrode surfaces. Because of its inherent sensitivity, nanospray desorption electrospray ionization enables chemical analysis of small volumes and concentrations of sample solution. Specifically, good-quality signal of dopamine and its oxidized form, dopamine o-quinone, was obtained using 10 μL of 1 μM solution of dopamine on the IDA. Oxidation of dopamine, reduction of benzodiazepines, and electrochemical derivatization of thiol groups were used to demonstrate the performance of the technique. Our results show the potential of nanospray desorption electrospray ionization as a novel interface for electrochemical mass spectrometry research.     

Quantifying protein-protein interactions within noncovalent complexes using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Several electrospray-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS)-based methods are available for determining the constant of association (K(a)) between a protein and a small ligand, but current MS-based strategies are not fully adequate for measuring K(a) of protein-protein interactions accurately. We expanded the application of ESI-MS-based titration to determine the strength of noncovalent interactions between proteins, forming a complex. Taking into account relative response factors (probability of being ionized, transmitted, and detected), we determined K(a) values of an equilibrium between dimers and tetramers at three different pH values (6.8, 3.4, and 8.4). We investigated the association of the lectin concanavalin A, whose dimer-tetramer ratio in the gas phase is affected by solution concentration and by pH. To calculate the constants of association in solution, we also utilized isothermal titration calorimetry (ITC) for a comparison with MS-based titration. At pH 6.8 and pH 8.4, the K(a) values measured by MS and by ITC were in agreement. ITC results allowed us to restrain the response factor to a value close to 4. At pH 3.4, we were able to measure the K(a) only by MS, but not by ITC because of limited sensitivity of calorimetry. Our investigation illustrates the great potential MS for calculating the binding strength of protein-protein interactions within noncovalent complexes. The main advantages of MS over ITC are its sensitivity (i.e., the required amount of sample is >100 times less than the one necessary for ITC), and the possibility to obtain precise information on composition of protein complexes, their stoichiometry, their subunit interactions, and their assembly pathway. Compared to previous investigations, our study shows the strong influence of response factors on determining accurate protein-protein association constants by MS.     

New developments in biochemical mass spectrometry: electrospray ionization

The principles, development, and recent application of electrospray ionization-mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) to biological compounds are reviewed. ESI-MS methods now allow determination of accurate molecular weights for proteins extending to over 50,000, and in some cases well over 100,000. Similar capabilities are being developed for oligonucleotides. The instrumentation used for ESI-MS is briefly described and it is shown that, although ionization efficiency appears to be uniformly high, detector sensitivity may be directly correlated with molecular weight. The use of tandem mass spectrometry (e.g., MS/MS) for extending collision-induced dissociation (CID) methods to the structural studies of large molecules is described. For example, effective CID of various albumin species (molecular weight approximately 66,000) can be obtained, far larger than obtainable for singly charged molecular ions. The combination of capillary electrophoresis, in both free solution zone electrophoresis and isotachophoresis formats, as well as microcolumn liquid chromatography with ESI-MS, provides the capability for on-line separation and analysis of subpicomole quantities of proteins. These and other new developments related to ESI-MS are illustrated by a range of examples. Fundamental considerations suggest even more impressive developments may be anticipated related to detection sensitivity and methods for obtaining structural information.     

Ultrahigh-resolution differential ion mobility spectrometry using extended separation times

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS), and particularly differential IMS or field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS), is emerging as a versatile tool for separation and identification of gas-phase ions, especially in conjunction with mass spectrometry. For over two decades since its inception, the utility of FAIMS was constrained by resolving power (R) of less than ～20. Stronger electric fields and optimized gas mixtures have recently raised achievable R to ～200, but further progress with such approaches is impeded by electrical breakdown. However, the resolving power of planar FAIMS devices using any gas and field intensity scales as the square root of separation time (t). Here, we extended t from the previous maximum of 0.2 s up to 4-fold by reducing the carrier gas flow and increased the resolving power by up to 2-fold as predicted, to >300 for multiply charged peptides. The resulting resolution gain has enabled separation of previously "co-eluting" peptide isomers, including folding conformers and localization variants of modified peptides. More broadly, a peak capacity of ～200 has been reached in tryptic digest separations.     

Quantifying ligand binding to large protein complexes using electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

An electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI-MS) method for quantifying protein-ligand complexes that cannot be directly detected by ESI-MS is described. The proxy protein ESI-MS method combines direct ESI-MS binding measurements with competitive protein-ligand binding. To implement the method, a proxy protein (P(proxy)), which interacts specifically with the ligand of interest with known affinity and can be detected directly by ESI-MS, is used to quantitatively monitor the extent of ligand binding to the protein of interest. A mathematical framework for establishing the association constant (K(a)) for protein-ligand binding by the proxy protein ESI-MS method, implemented with a P(proxy) containing a single ligand binding site, is given. A modified form of the proxy protein ESI-MS method, which accounts for real-time changes in ligand concentration, is also described. The reliability of these methods is demonstrated for the interactions between the 180 kDa wildtype homotrimeric tailspike protein of the bacteriophage P22 and its endorhamnosidase point mutant (D392N) with its ligands comprising two and three O-antigen repeats from Salmonella enterica serovar Typhimurium: octasaccharide ([α-Gal-(1→2)-[α-Abe-(1→3)]-α-Man-(1→4)-α-Rha](2)) and dodecasaccharide ([α-Gal-(1→2)-[α-Abe-(1→3)]-α-Man-(1→4)-α-Rha](3)). A 27 kDa single chain antibody, which binds to both ligands, served as P(proxy). The results of binding measurements performed at 10 and 25 °C are in excellent agreement with K(a) values measured previously using a fluorescence quenching assay.     

Study of the ribonuclease-S-protein-peptide complex using a radical probe and electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

The interaction between ribonuclease (RNase) S-protein and S-peptide is examined by studying their limited oxidation within the RNase-S complex and free forms using radicals. The limited oxidation of the RNase-S complex and each component is effected through their reaction with a high flux of oxygen-based radicals generated by an electrical discharge within an electrospray ion source. Their exposure to radicals occurs on short millisecond time scales and has been consistently found not to cause any measurable structural damage or conformational change to proteins in a number of published reports. Consistent with these studies, S-peptide is preferentially protected from reactions with radicals under conditions in which it is bound to S-protein. Conversely, a region of S-protein comprising residues 96-100 constitutes the S-peptide binding domain based on its diminished reactivity with radicals within the RNase-S complex over the free S-protein. The results, for the first time, demonstrate the use of radicals generated by an electrical discharge to study protein complexes.