Ultrasensitive identification of localization variants of modified peptides using ion mobility spectrometry

Localization of the modification sites on peptides is challenging, particularly when multiple modifications or mixtures of localization isomers (variants) are involved. Such variants commonly coelute in liquid chromatography and may be undistinguishable in tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) for lack of unique fragments. Here, we have resolved the variants of singly and doubly phosphorylated peptides employing drift tube ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) coupled to time-of-flight mass spectrometry. Even with a moderate IMS resolving power of ～80-100, substantial separation was achieved for both 2+ and 3+ ions normally generated by electrospray ionization, including for the variants indistinguishable by MS/MS. Variants often exhibit a distribution of 3-D conformers, which can be adjusted for optimum IMS separation by prior field heating of ions in a funnel trap. The peak assignments were confirmed using MS/MS after IMS separation, but known species could be identified using just the ion mobility "tag". Avoiding the MS/MS step lowers the detection limit of localization variants to <100 amol, an order of magnitude better than that provided by electron transfer dissociation in an Orbitrap MS.     

High-resolution field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry using new planar geometry analyzers

Field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) has emerged as a powerful tool of broad utility for separation and characterization of gas-phase ions, especially in conjunction with mass spectrometry (MS). In FAIMS, ions are filtered by the dependence of mobility on electric field while being carried by gas flow through the analytical gap between two electrodes of either planar (p-) or cylindrical (c-) geometry. Most FAIMS/MS systems employ c-FAIMS because of its ease of coupling to MS, yet the merits of the two geometries have not been compared in detail. Here, a priori simulations reveal that reducing the FAIMS curvature always improves resolution at equal sensitivity. In particular, the resolving power of p-FAIMS exceeds that of c-FAIMS, typically by a factor of 2-4 depending on the ion species and carrier gas. We have constructed a new planar FAIMS incorporating a curtain plate interface for effective operation with an ESI ion source and joined to an MS using an ion funnel interface with a novel slit aperture. The resolution increases up to 4-fold over existing c-FAIMS, even though the analysis is approximately 2 times faster. This allows separation of species not feasible in previous FAIMS studies, e.g., protonated leucine and isoleucine or new bradykinin isomers. The improvement for protein conformers (of ubiquitin) is less significant, possibly because of multiple unresolved geometries.     

Multiplexed ion mobility spectrometry-orthogonal time-of-flight mass spectrometry

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) coupled to orthogonal time-of-flight mass spectrometry (TOF) has shown significant promise for the characterization of complex biological mixtures. The enormous complexity of biological samples (e.g., from proteomics) and the need for both biological and technical analysis replicates imposes major challenges for multidimensional separation platforms with regard to both sensitivity and sample throughput. A major potential attraction of the IMS-TOF MS platform is separation speeds exceeding that of conventional condensed-phase separations by orders of magnitude. Known limitations of the IMS-TOF MS platforms that presently mitigate this attraction include the need for extensive signal averaging due to factors that include significant ion losses in the IMS-TOF interface and an ion utilization efficiency of less than approximately 1% with continuous ion sources (e.g., ESI). We have developed a new multiplexed ESI-IMS-TOF mass spectrometer that enables lossless ion transmission through the IMS-TOF as well as a utilization efficiency of >50% for ions from the ESI source. Initial results with a mixture of peptides show a approximately 10-fold increase in signal-to-noise ratio with the multiplexed approach compared to a signal averaging approach, with no reduction in either IMS or TOF MS resolution.     

Miniaturized ultra high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry combined with mass spectrometry for peptide analysis

Miniaturized ultra high field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (ultra-FAIMS) combined with mass spectrometry (MS) has been applied to the analysis of standard and tryptic peptides, derived from α-1-acid glycoprotein, using electrospray and nanoelectrospray ion sources. Singly and multiply charged peptide ions were separated in the gas phase using ultra-FAIMS and detected by ion trap and time-of-flight MS. The small compensation voltage (CV) window for the transmission of singly charged ions demonstrates the ability of ultra-FAIMS-MS to generate pseudo-peptide mass fingerprints that may be used to simplify spectra and identify proteins by database searching. Multiply charged ions required a higher CV for transmission, and ions with different amino acid sequences may be separated on the basis of their differential ion mobility. A partial separation of conformers was also observed for the doubly charged ion of bradykinin. Selection on the basis of charge state and differential mobility prior to tandem mass spectrometry facilitates peptide and protein identification by allowing precursor ions to be identified with greater selectivity, thus reducing spectral complexity and enhancing MS detection.     

High-sensitivity ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry using electrodynamic ion funnel interfaces

The utility of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) for separation of mixtures and structural characterization of ions has been demonstrated extensively, including in biological and nanoscience contexts. A major attraction of IMS is its speed, several orders of magnitude greater than that of condensed-phase separations. Nonetheless, IMS combined with mass spectrometry (MS) has remained a niche technique, substantially because of limited sensitivity resulting from ion losses at the IMS-MS junction. We have developed a new electrospray ionization (ESI)-IMS-QTOF MS instrument that incorporates electrodynamic ion funnels at both front ESI-IMS and rear IMS-QTOF interfaces. The front funnel is of the novel "hourglass" design that efficiently accumulates ions and pulses them into the IMS drift tube. Even for drift tubes of 2-m length, ion transmission through IMS and on to QTOF is essentially lossless across the range of ion masses relevant to most applications. The rf ion focusing at the IMS terminus does not degrade IMS resolving power, which exceeds 100 (for singly charged ions) and is close to the theoretical limit. The overall sensitivity of the present ESI-IMS-MS system is comparable to that of commercial ESI-MS, which should make IMS-MS suitable for analyses of complex mixtures with ultrahigh sensitivity and exceptional throughput.     

Gas-phase proton-transfer chemistry coupled with TOF mass spectrometry and ion mobility-MS for the facile analysis of poly(ethylene glycols) and PEGylated polypeptide conjugates

Gas-phase ion/molecule chemistry has been combined with ion mobility separation and time-of-flight mass spectrometry to enable the characterization of large poly(ethylene glycol)s (PEGs) and PEGylated molecules (>40 kDa). A facile method is presented in which gas-phase superbases are reacted in the high-pressure source region of commercial TOF mass spectrometers to manipulate the charge states of large ions generated by electrospray ionization (ESI). Charge stripping decreases the spectral congestion typically observed in ESI mass spectra of high molecular weight polydisperse PEGylated molecules. From these data, accurate average molecular weights and molecular weight distributions for synthetic polymers and PEGylated proteins are determined. The average MW measured for PEGylated Granulocyte colony-stimulating factor (rh-GCSF, 40 726.2 Da) is in good agreement with the theoretical value, and a 16 Da mass shift is easily observed in the spectrum of an oxidized form of the heterogeneous PEGylated protein. Ion mobility separations can fractionate PEGs of different chain length; when coupled with charge stripping ion/molecule reactions, ion mobility mass spectrometry (IMMS) offers several analytical advantages over mass spectrometry alone for the characterization of large PEGylated molecules including enhanced dynamic range, increased sensitivity, and specificity. Low abundance free PEG in a PEGylated peptide preparation, which is not directly detectable by mass spectrometry, can be easily observed and accurately quantified with gas-phase ion/molecule chemistry combined with ion mobility mass spectrometry.     

IMS-IMS and IMS-IMS-IMS/MS for separating peptide and protein fragment ions

Multidimensional ion mobility spectrometry (IMS-IMS and IMS-IMS-IMS) techniques have been combined with mass spectrometry (MS) and investigated as a means of generating and separating peptide and protein fragment ions. When fragments are generated inside a drift tube and then dispersed by IMS prior to MS analysis, it is possible to observe many features that are not apparent from MS analysis alone. The approach is demonstrated by examining fragmentation patterns arising from electrospray ion distributions of insulin chain B and ubiquitin. The multidimensional IMS approach makes it possible to select individual components for collisional activation and to disperse fragments based on differences in mobility prior to MS analysis. Such an approach makes it possible to observe many features not apparent by MS analysis alone.     

FTMS structure elucidation of natural products: application to muraymycin antibiotics using ESI multi-CHEF SORI-CID FTMS(n), the top-down/bottom-up approach,and HPLC ESI capillary-skimmer CID FTMS

The molecular formulas for the structures and substructures of muraymycin antibiotics A1 (C52H90N14O19, MW 1214) and B1 (C49H83N11O18, MW 1113) were determined using electrospray ionization (ESI) Fourier transform mass spectrometry (FTMS). The muraymycin A1 and B1 structures were elucidated by utilizing capillary-skimmer fragmentation with up to five stages of mass spectrometry (MS5). Multi-CHEF, a multiple ion isolation method, was used at each stage of MS(n) to isolate a parent ion and up to four reference ions, for exact-mass calibration. The parent ions were fragmented by SORI-CID and the product ions internally calibrated with average absolute mass errors less than 1 ppm at each stage in the fragmentation processes. Using the top-down/bottom-up approach, the molecular formulas for the antibiotics were determined by summing the elemental formulas of the neutral losses, obtained by measuring the mass differences (<500 Da) between the genetically related sequential parent ion masses in the MS(n) spectra, with the unique elemental formula of the lowest parent ion mass (<500 Da). The structures of 12 additional compounds in the muraymycin complex were elucidated using HPLC ESI capillary-skimmer CID FTMS by correlating their fragmentation patterns with those of muraymycins A1 and B1. Sequential neutral losses of an aminosugar, a valine, a uridine, and an ester fatty acid from the muraymycin parent ions provided diagnostic fragments for characterization.     

Parallel detection of intrinsic fluorescence from peptides and proteins for quantification during mass spectrometric analysis

Direct mass spectrometric quantification of peptides and proteins is compromised by the wide variabilities in ionization efficiency which are hallmarks of both the MALDI and ESI ionization techniques. We describe here the implementation of a fluorescence detection system for measurement of the UV-excited intrinsic fluorescence (UV-IF) from peptides and proteins just prior to their exit and electrospray ionization from an ESI capillary. The fluorescence signal provides a quantifiable measure of the amount of protein or peptide present, while direct or tandem mass spectrometric analysis (MS/MS) on the ESI-generated ions provides information on identity. We fabricated an inexpensive, modular fluorescence excitation and detection device utilizing an ultraviolet light-emitting diode for excitation in a ～300 nL fluorescence detection cell integrated into the fused-silica separation column. The fluorescence signal is linear over 3 orders of magnitude with on-column limits of detection in the low femtomole range. Chromatographically separated intact proteins analyzed using UV-IF prior to top-down mass spectrometry demonstrated sensitive detection of proteins as large as 77 kDa.     

Separation and characterization of metallosupramolecular libraries by ion mobility mass spectrometry

The self-assembly of Zn(II) ions and bis(terpyridine) (tpy) ligands carrying 120° or 180° angles between their metal binding sites was utilized to prepare metallosupramolecular libraries with the connectivity. These combinatorial libraries were separated and characterized by ion mobility mass spectrometry (IM MS) and tandem mass spectrometry (MS(2)). The 180°-angle building blocks generate exclusively linear complexes, which were used as standards to determine the architectures of the assemblies resulting from the 120°-angle ligands. The latter ligand geometry promotes the formation of macrocyclic hexamers, but other n-mers with smaller (n = 5) or larger ring sizes (n = 7-9) were identified as minor products, indicating that the angles in the bis(terpyridine) ligand and within the coordinative tpy-Zn(II)-tpy bonds are not as rigid, as previously believed. Macrocyclic and linear isomers were detected in penta- and heptameric assemblies; in the larger octa- and nonameric assemblies, ring-opened conformers with compact and folded geometries were observed in addition to linear extended and cyclic architectures. IM MS(2) experiments provided strong evidence that the macrocycles present in the libraries were already formed in solution, during the self-assembly process, not by dissociation of larger complexes in the gas phase. The IM MS/MS(2) methods provide a means to analyze, based on size and shape (architecture), supramolecular libraries that are not amenable to liquid chromatography, LC-MS, NMR, and/or X-ray techniques.     

Mass analysis of mobility-selected ion populations using dual gate, ion mobility, quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometry

An electrospray ionization, dual gate, ion mobility, quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer (ESI-DG-IM-QIT-MS) was constructed and evaluated for its ability to select mobility-filtered ions prior to mass analysis. While modification of the common signal-averaged ion mobility experiment was required, no modifications to the QIT were necessary. The dual gate scanning mode of operation was used to acquire mobility spectra, whereas the single mobility monitoring experiment selectively filtered ions for concentration and subsequent fragmentation within the QIT. Ion mobility separation of positively charged peptides and negatively charged carbohydrates, followed by MS fragmentation, was demonstrated. For a 1-min acquisition time, it was possible to obtain complete de novo sequence information for the examined peptides. Fragmentation of the negative carbohydrate chlorine adducts yielded ions characteristic of cross-ring and glycosidic bond cleavage. Previous unions of atmospheric pressure ion mobility and mass spectrometry have been limited in their ability to reproducibly obtain MSn data for mobility separation ions. The union of high-pressure ion mobility with quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometry presents the unique opportunity to obtain more detailed information regarding the chemistries of gas-phase ions.     

Effect of experimental parameters on the ESI FT-ICR mass spectrum of fulvic acid

Fulvic acid (FA) is a heterogeneous mixture of organic macromolecules found in the waters, soils, and sediments of the earth's surface. The ability of electrospray ionization (ESI) to effectively transfer large ions from the solution phase to the gas phase and the coupling of ESI to the high-mass-resolution capabilities of Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (FT-ICR MS) provide a potential method for the mass spectrometric analysis of FA. Positive- and negative-ion ESI FT-ICR MS analyses of four reference International Humic Substances Society FAs were performed. The spray solution composition was found to have a dramatic effect on the ion distributions, with high-mass aggregates (m/z approximately 2000-4000) being formed in less polar spray solutions. Positive-ion spectra for each FA obtained under optimum conditions resulted in number-average molecular weights ranging from 1700 to 1900. The mass spectra were extremely complex, with ion distributions on the order of m/z approximately 500-3000. The presence of more than one ion at each nominal mass was routinely observed. Negative-ion ESI analysis of the FA samples resulted in the observation of multiply charged ions whose distributions could be affected by the acidification of the spray solution. Solution parameters which have been reported to affect molecular weight distributions of FA such as pH, ionic strength, and concentration of multivalent cations were found to have little or no effect on the observed m/z distributions.     

Characterization of naphthenic acids by electrospray ionization high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry mass spectrometry

Electrospray ionization (ESI) high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) was combined with quadrupole, time-of-flight, and tandem mass spectrometry to characterize commercial and naturally occurring naphthenic acids (NA) mixtures. This new method provides quantitatively reliable mass and isomer distributions of NA components in approximately 3 min without extensive sample preparation. ESI-FAIMS-MS seems to be especially useful for characterization of fragile ions that cannot be detected by other methods. A unique part of this technique is separation of structural isomers that proved to be critical in determination of elemental composition and in structure elucidation. Tandem mass spectrometry of NA ions separated by FAIMS provides more information about the structure of NA than other methods in the field of NA analysis.     

Efficient electrophoretic method to remove neutral additives from protein solutions followed by mass spectrometry analysis

A mass spectrometry (MS)-compatible, isoelectric point-based separation method for removal of neutral additives from protein solutions is described. The separation is performed by electrophoretic migration and trapping using a device referred to as membrane separated wells for isoelectric focusing and trapping (MSWIFT). Electrophoretic separation in the MSWIFT device is fast; the entire process can be carried out in a matter of minutes, and it does not require further sample cleanup prior to MS analysis. Proof-of-concept experiments in which neutral additives (e.g., Triton X-100, Tween 20, poly(ethylene glycol)) are removed from protein solutions using the MSWIFT device followed by MS analysis are described. Coupling the MSWIFT separation with ion mobility MS provides additional separation via the gas phase and assists in achieving higher quality ESI mass spectra when small amounts of additives remain in solution.     

In-spray supercharging of peptides and proteins in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry

Enhanced charging, or supercharging, of analytes in electrospray ionization mass spectrometry (ESI MS) facilitates high resolution MS by reducing an ion mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio, increasing tandem mass spectrometry (MS/MS) efficiency. ESI MS supercharging is usually achieved by adding a supercharging reagent to the electrospray solution. Addition of these supercharging reagents to the mobile phase in liquid chromatography (LC)-MS/MS increases the average charge of enzymatically derived peptides and improves peptide and protein identification in large-scale bottom-up proteomics applications but disrupts chromatographic separation. Here, we demonstrate the average charge state of selected peptides and proteins increases by introducing the supercharging reagents directly into the ESI Taylor cone (in-spray supercharging) using a dual-sprayer ESI microchip. The results are comparable to those obtained by the addition of supercharging reagents directly into the analyte solution or LC mobile phase. Therefore, supercharging reaction can be accomplished on a time-scale of ion liberation from a droplet in the ESI ion source.     

Identification of intact proteins in mixtures by alternated capillary liquid chromatography electrospray ionization and LC ESI infrared multiphoton dissociation Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry.

Here we propose a novel method for rapidly identifying proteins in complex mixtures. A list of candidate proteins (including provision for posttranslational modifications) is obtained by database searching, within a specified mass range about the accurately measured mass (e.g., +/- 0.1 Da at 10 kDa) of the intact protein, by capillary liquid chromatography electrospray ionization Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry (LC ESI FT-ICR MS). On alternate scans, LC ESI infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD) FT-ICR MS yields mostly b and y fragment ions for each protein, from which the correct candidate is identified as the one with the highest "hit" score (i.e., most b and y fragments matching the candidate database protein amino acid sequence masses) and sequence "tag" score (based on a series of fragment sequences differing in mass by 1 or 2 amino acids). The method succeeds in uniquely identifying each of a mixture of five proteins treated as unknowns (melittin, ubiquitin, GroES, myoglobin, carbonic anhydrase II), from more than 1000 possible database candidates within a +/- 500 Da mass window. We are also able to identify posttranslational modifications of two of the proteins (mellitin and GroES). The method is simple, rapid, and definitive and is extendable to a mixture of affinity-selected proteins, to identify proteins with a common biological function.     

Characterization of gas-phase molecular interactions on differential mobility ion behavior utilizing an electrospray ionization-differential mobility-mass spectrometer system

Differential mobility spectrometry (DMS) is a rapidly advancing technology for gas-phase ion separation. The interfacing of DMS with mass spectrometry (MS) offers potential advantages over the use of mass spectrometry alone. Such advantages include improvements to mass spectral signal/noise ratios, orthogonal/complementary ion separation to mass spectrometry, enhanced ion and complexation structural analysis, and potential for rapid analyte quantitation. The introduction of a new ESI-DMS-MS system and its utilization to aid in the understanding of DMS separation theory is described. A current contribution to DMS separation theory is one of an association/dissociation process between ions/molecules in the gas phase during the differential mobility separation. A model study was designed to investigate the molecular dynamics and chemical factors influencing the theorized association/dissociation process, and the mechanisms by which these gas-phase interactions affect an ion's DM behavior. Five piperidine analogues were selected as model analytes, and three alcohol drift gas dopants/modifiers were used to interrogate the analyte ions in the gas phase. Two proposed DMS separation mechanisms, introduced as Core and Fa?ade, corresponding to strong and weak attractions between ions/molecules in the gas phase, are detailed. The proposed mechanisms provide explanation for the observed changes in analyte separation by the various drift gas modifiers. Molecular modeling of the proposed mechanisms provides supportive data and demonstrates the potential for predictive optimization of analyte separation based on drift gas modifier effects.     

Molecular resolution and fragmentation of fulvic acid by electrospray ionization/multistage tandem mass spectrometry

Molecular weight distributions of fulvic acid from the Suwannee River, Georgia, were investigated by electrospray ionization/quadrupole mass spectrometry (ESI/ QMS), and fragmentation pathways of specific fulvic acid masses were investigated by electrospray ionization/ion trap multistage tandem mass spectrometry (ESI/MST/ MS). ESI/QMS studies of the free acid form of low molecular weight poly(carboxylic acid) standards in 75% methanol/25% water mobile phase found that negative ion detection gave the optimum generation of parent ions that can be used for molecular weight determinations. However, experiments with poly(acrylic acid) mixtures and specific high molecular weight standards found multiply charged negative ions that gave a low bias to molecular mass distributions. The number of negative charges on a molecule is dependent on the distance between charges. ESI/MST/MS of model compounds found characteristic water loss from alcohol dehydration and anhydride formation, as well as CO2 loss from decarboxylation, and CO loss from ester structures. Application of these fragmentation pathways to specific masses of fulvic acid isolated and fragmented by ESI/MST/MS is indicative of specific structures that can serve as a basis for future structural confirmation after these hypothesized structures are synthesized.     

Separation of cisplatin and its hydrolysis products using electrospray ionization high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry coupled with ion trap mass spectrometry

Cisplatin and its mono- and dihydrated complexes have been separated using a high-field asymmetric waveform ion mobility spectrometry (FAIMS) analyzer interfaced with electrospray ionization (ESI) and ion trap mass spectrometry (ITMS). The addition of helium to the nitrogen curtain/carrier gas in the FAIMS device improved both the sensitivity and selectivity of the electrospray analysis. Introduction of a three-component mixture as curtain/carrier gas, nitrogen, helium, and carbon dioxide, resulted in further improvements to sensitivity. Compared with conventional ESI-MS, the background chemical noise in the ESI-FAIMS-ITMS spectrum was dramatically reduced, resulting in over 30-fold improvement in the signal-to-noise ratio for cisplatin. Analytical results were linear over the concentration range 10-200 ng/mL for intact cisplatin with a corresponding detection limit determined of 0.7 ng/mL with no derivatization or chromatographic separation prior to analysis.     

Secondary electrospray ionization ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry of illicit drugs

A secondary electrospray ionization (SESI) method was developed as a nonradioactive ionization source for ion mobility spectrometry (IMS). This SESI method relied on the gas-phase interaction between charged particles created by electrospray ionization (ESI) and neutral gaseous sample molecules. Mass spectrometry (MS) was used as the detection method after ion mobility separation for ion identification. Preliminary investigations focussed on understanding the ionization process of SESI. The performance of ESI-IMS and SESI-IMS for illicit drug detection was evaluated by determining the analytical figures of merit. In general, SESI had a higher ionization efficiency for small volatile molecules compared with the electrospray method. The potential of developing a universal interface for both GC- and LC-MS with an addition stage of mobility separation was demonstrated.