Comparative investigation towards machinability improvement in hard turning using coated and uncoated carbide inserts: part I experimental investigation

The investigation of low cost uncoated and coated carbide insert in the hard turning of hardened AISI D2 steel (≥55 HRC) will definitely open up a new arena as an economical alternative suitable to industrial machining sectors. Thus, this paper reports the comparative machinability assessment for the hard turning of AISI D2 steel ((55 ±1) HRC) by coated and uncoated carbide insert in a dry environment. Micro hardness and abrasion tests were carried out to assess resistance capability against wear. The above test results confirmed the greater wear resistance ability of Al₂O₃ coated carbide insert over uncoated carbide. Based on the extensive investigation of comparative machinability, the coated carbide insert (TiN-TiCN-Al₂O₃) outperformed the uncoated carbide insert with regard to surface roughness, flank wear, chip-tool interface temperature, and chip morphology. Abrasion and diffusion were observed as the principal tool wear mechanisms in the investigated range. The uncoated carbide failed completely due to the severe chipping and quick dulling of the cutting edge, which led to its unsuitability for machining hardened steel. The full text can be downloaded at https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s40436-018-0215-z     

Machining of high performance workpiece materials with CBN coated cutting tools

The machining of high performance workpiece materials requires significantly harder cutting materials. In hard machining, the early tool wear occurs due to high process forces and temperatures. The hardest known material is the diamond, but steel materials cannot be machined with diamond tools because of the reactivity of iron with carbon. Cubic boron nitride (cBN) is the second hardest of all known materials. The supply of such PcBN indexable inserts, which are only geometrically simple and available, requires several work procedures and is cost-intensive. The development of a cBN coating for cutting tools, combine the advantages of a thin film system and of cBN. Flexible cemented carbide tools, in respect to the geometry can be coated. The cBN films with a thickness of up to 2 µm on cemented carbide substrates show excellent mechanical and physical properties. This paper describes the results of the machining of various workpiece materials in turning and milling operations regarding the tool life, resultant cutting force components and workpiece surface roughness. In turning tests of Inconel 718 and milling tests of chrome steel the high potential of cBN coatings for dry machining was proven. The results of the experiments were compared with common used tool coatings for the hard machining. Additionally, the wear mechanisms adhesion, abrasion, surface fatigue and tribo-oxidation were researched in model wear experiments.     

Machining performance of low temperature treated P-30 tungsten carbide cutting tool inserts

Machining studies were conducted on C45 workpiece using both untreated and low temperature treated tungsten carbide cutting tool inserts. The machinability of the C45 steel workpiece is evaluated in terms of flank wear of the cutting tool inserts, main cutting force and surface finish of the machined workpieces. The flank wear of low temperature treated carbide tools is lower than that of untreated carbide tools on machining of C45 steel. The cutting forces during machining of C45 steel is lower with the low temperature treated carbide tools when compared with the untreated carbide tools. The surface finish produced on machining the C45 steel workpiece is better with the low temperature treated carbide tools when compared with the untreated carbide tools.     

Effect of a nanoparticle-filled lubricant in turning of AISI 316L stainless steel (SS)

Release of heat and generation of friction associated with machining operation ever posture a problem which not only reduce the tool life but also impair the quality of the product. Nano cutting fluids play a significant role in machining operations and impact tool life and quality of work. In the present work, tool flank wear is analyzed during turning AISI 316L Stainless steel (SS) under a nano cutting environment. Experiments are conducted by turning of AISI 316L SS under wet machining with and without multiwalled carbon nanotube (MWCNT) inclusions in the conventional lubricant. The second order quadratic models were developed to predict tool wear using response surface methodology (RSM) based D-optimal design. Machining parameters such as speed, feed rate, and depth of cut are chosen as numerical factors and the type of lubricant is considered as the categorical factor. The results show that the influence of the feed rate is more significant while machining the AISI 316L SS with a whisker reinforced ceramic insert. The addition of MWCNTs in SAE20W40 enhances the tool performance with their enhanced penetration. After turning experiment, a scanning electron microscope (SEM) with energy dispersive X-ray (EDS) was used to investigate the tool wear.     

Comparative assessment of coated and uncoated ceramic tools on cutting force components and tool wear in hard turning of AISI H11 steel using Taguchi plan and RMS

This study investigated the cutting performance of coated CC6050 and uncoated CC650 mixed ceramics in hard turning of hardened steel. The cutting performance was mainly evaluated by cutting force components and tool wear. The planning of experiments was based on Taguchi’s L₃₆ orthogonal array. The response surface methodology and analysis of variance were used to check the validity of multiple linear regression models and to determine the significant parameter affecting the cutting force components. Tool wear progressions and, hence, tool life, different tool wear forms and wear mechanisms observed for tools coated with TiN and uncoated mixed ceramics are presented along with the images captured by digital and electron microscope. Experimental observations indicate higher tool life with uncoated ceramic tools, which shows encouraging potential of these tools to hard turning of AISI H11 (50 HRC). Finally, tool performance indices are based on units which characterise machined cutting force components and wear when hard turning.     

On Applicability of Multilayer Coated Tool in Dry Machining of Aerospace Grade Stainless Steel

The present research work has been undertaken with a view to investigate the influence of CVD multilayer coated (TiN/TiCN/Al₂O₃/ZrCN) and cutting speed on various machining characteristics such as chip morphology, tool wear, cutting temperature, and machined surface roughness during dry turning of 17-4 PH stainless steel. In order to understand the effectiveness of CVD multilayer coated tool a comparison has been carried out with that of uncoated carbide insert. The surface roughness and cutting temperature obtained during machining with chemical vapor deposition (CVD) multilayer coated tool was higher than that of uncoated carbide insert at all cutting velocity. However, the results clearly indicated that CVD multilayer coated tool played a significant role in restricting various modes of tool failure and reducing chip deformation compared to its uncoated counterpart. Adhesion and abrasion were found to be dominating wear mechanism with flank wear, plastic deformation, and catastrophic failure being major tool wear modes.     

Analysis of hard turning process:thermal aspects

In manufacturing sector,hard turning has emerged as a vital machining process for cutting hardened steels.Besides many advantages of hard turning operations,one has to implement to achieve close tolerances in terms of surface finish,high product quality,reduced machining time,low operating cost and environmental friendly characteristics.In the study,three dimensional(3D) computer aided engineering(CAE) based simulation of hard turning by using commercial software DEFORM 3D has been compared to the experimental results of stresses,temperatures and tool forces in machining of AISI D3 and AISI H13 steel using mixed ceramic inserts(CC6050).In the following analysis,orthogonal cutting models are proposed,considering several processing parameters such as cutting speed,feed and depth of cut.An exhaustive friction modelling at the tool-work interface is carried out.Work material flow around the cutting edge is carefully modelled with adaptive re-meshing simulation capability of DEFORM 3D.The process simulations are performed at constant feed rate(0.075 mm/r) and cutting speed(155 m/min),and analysis is focused on stresses,forces and temperatures generated during the process of machining.Close agreement is observed between the CAE simulation and experimental values.     

Drehen und Fräsen pulvermetallurgischer Hartlegierungen für warmgehende Werkzeuge

Turning and Milling of Powder Metallurgical Hard Alloys for Tools in Hot Working Applications Hard metals are high wear resistant materials. The microstructure of these composites consists of hard phases which are embedded in a metal matrix. The high hardness and the high content of the hard phases lead to a difficult machining of these materials. The present study investigates the turning and milling of D3 cold work steel (X210 Cr 12) and the powder metallurgical Fe‐based alloys ASP60 and ASP23 + WC/W₂C. The cutting tool materials were polycrystalline cubic boron nitrides (CBN) and ceramic inserts. The machining process could be judged by means of tool wear and machining quality (surface roughness and changes in the surface near zone). The investigations illustrate that the machinability of the different hard metals depends on the cutting speed and the cutting tool material.     

Effects of Lubricant Condition and Tool Wear in Hard Turning of Novel-Abrasion-Resistance (N-AR) Cast Iron

Advanced materials, such as high abrasion resistant cast iron, have great applications for abrasive and erosive environments. Since the amount and the hardness of the microstructural carbides constituents in this material is extremely high, the abrasion-resistance cast iron is generally difficult to be machined with traditional cemented carbide tool. The hard and abrasive particles in this material can remarkably shorten the cutting tool life through abrasion of tool face and deterioration of cutting edge. In this article, Cubic Boron Nitride (CBN) cutting tool has been used to machine a novel-abrasion-resistance (N-AR) cast iron. The performances of CBN tool under different lubrication conditions were evaluated in view of tool wear, cutting force, and surface roughness (Rz). Further more, the wear rate of CBN tool under different machining condition and the mechanism of the CBN tool in machining of this type of work materials has also been investigated.     

An Investigation on Turning Hardened Steel Using Different Tool Inserts

Turning of hard materials usually presents poor machinability. However, for high productivity, it is desirable to employ turning of hard materials rather than grinding. In this work, turning of hardened 16MnCrS5 steel with hardness of 43 HRC was explored to judge machining performance with plain and wide-groove-type chip-breaking TiC-coated carbide inserts under dry and wet environmental conditions, different cutting velocity, and feed. Tool wear tests were also done in dry and wet conditions. Satisfactory tool performance was observed under wet condition using TiC-coated plain and wide-groove carbide inserts even at 268 m/min cutting velocity, when dry machining could not be done effectively.     

Development of ANFIS model and machinability study on dry turning of cryo-treated PH stainless steel with various inserts

This present investigation deals about the machinability comparison of cryogenically treated 15-5 PH stainless steel with various cutting tools such as uncoated tungsten carbide, cryogenic-treated tungsten carbide and wiper geometry inserts. Cryo-treated PH stainless steel is considered as the work material in this investigation and experimental trials were performed under dry turning condition. The machinability aspects considered for evaluation are cutting force (F_z), surface roughness (R_a) and tool wear. The outcomes of experimentation reveal that the tungsten carbide inserts which are cryogenically treated provide improved performance in machining while comparing with conventional and wiper geometry inserts at all machining conditions. The measured cutting force and the observed flank wear were less for the cryo-treated inserts. However, wiper tool produces a better surface finish during machining. An artificial intelligence decision-making tool named Adaptive Neuro Fuzzy Inference System has been evolved to determine the relation among the considered input machining variables and output measures, namely cutting force and surface roughness of the machined surface. An analysis has been performed to compare the results obtained from developed models and experimental results.     

Vibration-Assisted Precision Machining of Steel with PCD Tools

This article presents experimental results of precision machining of steel alloys with polycrystalline diamond tools. Ultrasonic vibration-assisted cutting was tried out for expanding the application of diamond tools for high-precision and high-quality machining of ferrous materials. The experimental results show that compared with conventional turning, the cutting performance, in terms of cutting force, surface finish, and tool life, was improved by applying ultrasonic vibration to the cutting tool. The cutting forces and tool wear measured in vibration cutting are much lower than those in conventional cutting. The tool wear mechanism was discussed on the basis of the observation of wear zone.     

Study of deformation zone effects of low,conventional, high and very high speed machining

The paper deals with cutting speed in range 3 m?min^‐1 up to 2200 m?min^‐1 and its complex impact mainly on chip macroscopic shape, chip microstructure, chip compression, tool wear, tool life and machined surface quality and interprets and compares the effects regarding low, conventional, high and very high speed machining based on the dry turning of carbon steel by sintered carbide coated by titanium nitride and ceramic cutting inserts. The deformation zone response for different cutting speeds at the tool‐chip‐workpiece interfaces and their effect on tool wear were studied. The extensive (so called complete) experiments within wide range of values and large number of measurements were carried out. The formation of secondary chip occurring in high speed turning is reported. Moreover, the paper analyses the total machining time involving tool replacement time in terms of high speed machining regarding the obtained experimental results.     

Molecular dynamics simulation model for the quantitative assessment of tool wear during single point diamond turning of cubic silicon carbide

Silicon carbide (SiC) is a material of great technological interest for engineering applications concerning hostile environments where silicon-based components cannot work (beyond 623 K). Single point diamond turning (SPDT) has remained a superior and viable method to harness process efficiency and freeform shapes on this harder material. However, it is extremely difficult to machine this ceramic consistently in the ductile regime due to sudden and rapid tool wear. It thus becomes non trivial to develop an accurate understanding of tool wear mechanism during SPDT of SiC in order to identify measures to suppress wear to minimize operational cost.In this paper, molecular dynamics (MD) simulation has been deployed with a realistic analytical bond order potential (ABOP) formalism based potential energy function to understand tool wear mechanism during single point diamond turning of SiC. The most significant result was obtained using the radial distribution function which suggests graphitization of diamond tool during the machining process. This phenomenon occurs due to the abrasive processes between these two ultra hard materials. The abrasive action results in locally high temperature which compounds with the massive cutting forces leading to sp³-sp² order-disorder transition of diamond tool. This represents the root cause of tool wear during SPDT operation of cubic SiC. Further testing led to the development of a novel method for quantitative assessment of the progression of diamond tool wear from MD simulations.     

Dry machining characteristics of coated inserts and multi response optimization through DEAR-Taguchi method

The primary intent of the proposed research work is to investigate the effectiveness of the titanium aluminium nitride/tungsten carbide-carbide coated insert during dry turning structural stainless steel. The aim of the study is to simultaneously optimise machining variables like spindle speed, depth of cut and feed for several responses like flank wear, material removal rate and surface roughness. Titanium aluminium nitride/tungsten carbide-carbide is coated on the surface of carbide tool by cathodic arc evaporation method. The characterization studies have been conducted to ensure the existence of coating material. Micro hardness of coated and pure inserts was tested, which confirms that titanium aluminium nitride/tungsten carbide-carbide coated insert possesses 17.43 % augmented hardness over pure inserts. The machining was performed by adopting Taguchi experimental design. A multi-response optimization approach was applied in this study that included ranking methodology based on data development analysis and Taguchi's design. The performance index for multiple responses was measured and mathematically analysed for their effect on processing parameters. The combination of parameter such as spindle speed: 2000 min⁻¹; cutting depth: 0.45 mm and feed rate: 0.16 mm rev⁻¹ was experimental as optimal machining parameters.     

Experimental investigations on cryogenic cooling by liquid nitrogen in the end milling of hardened steel

Milling of hardened steel generates excessive heat during the chip formation process, which increases the temperature of cutting tool and accelerates tool wear. Application of conventional cutting fluid in milling process may not effectively control the heat generation also it has inherent health and environmental problems. To minimize health hazard and environmental problems caused by using conventional cutting fluid, a cryogenic cooling set up is developed to cool tool–chip interface using liquid nitrogen (LN₂). This paper presents results on the effect of LN₂ as a coolant on machinability of hardened AISI H13 tool steel for varying cutting speed in the range of 75–125 m/min during end milling with PVD TiAlN coated carbide inserts at a constant feed rate. The results show that machining with LN₂ lowers cutting temperature, tool flank wear, surface roughness and cutting forces as compared with dry and wet machining. With LN₂ cooling, it has been found that the cutting temperature was reduced by 57–60% and 37–42%; the tool flank wear was reduced by 29–34% and 10–12%; the surface roughness was decreased by 33–40% and 25–29% compared to dry and wet machining. The cutting forces also decreased moderately compared to dry and wet machining. This can be attributed to the fact that LN₂ machining provides better cooling and lubrication through substantial reduction in the cutting zone temperature.     

Cryogenic turning of the Ti–6Al–4V alloy with modified cutting tool inserts

Productivity in the machining of titanium alloys is adversely affected by rapid tool wear as a consequence of high cutting zone temperature. Conventional cutting fluids are ineffective in controlling the cutting temperature in the cutting zone. In this research work, an attempt has been made to investigate the effect of liquid nitrogen when it is applied to the rake surface, and the main and auxiliary flank surfaces through holes made in the cutting tool insert during the turning of the Ti–6Al–4V alloy. The cryogenic results of the cutting temperature, cutting forces, surface roughness and tool wear of the modified cutting tool insert have been compared with those of wet machining. It has been observed that in the cryogenic cooling method, the cutting temperature was reduced by 61–66% and the surface roughness was reduced to a maximum of 36% over wet machining. The cutting force was decreased by 35–42% and the flank wear was reduced by 27–39% in cryogenic cooling over that of wet machining. Cryogenic cooling enabled a substantial reduction in the geometry of tool wear through the control of the tool wear mechanisms. The application of liquid nitrogen to the heat generation zones through holes made in the cutting tool insert was considered to be more effective over conventional machining.     

Application of response surface methodology for determining cutting force model in turning hardened AISI H11 hot work tool steel

This experimental study is conducted to determine statistical models of cutting forces in hard turning of AISI H11 hot work tool steel (∼ 50 HRC). This steel is free from tungsten on Cr–Mo–V basis, insensitive to temperature changes and having a high wear resistance. It is employed for the manufacture of highly stressed diecasting moulds and inserts with high tool life expectancy, plastic moulds subject to high stress, helicopter rotor blades and forging dies.     

Process Optimization of Finish Turning of Hardened Steels

Process planning and optimization is crucial to help establish the economic and quality viability of hard turning processes with the presence of a wide spectrum of tooling and process parameters. A systematic methodology is discussed in this paper to design the optimal tool geometry and cutting conditions for hard turning, incorporating the consideration of part finish, tool wear, and material removal rate. Experimental demonstration of the optimization scheme is presented at two levels: the first level is to validate the process prediction results and the second is to validate the optimization results. Hardened AISI 1053 steel was selected as the workpiece material in this study and its material property related parameters, including the Johnson-Cook constants and wear coefficients, were determined based on the machining tests. It is seen that the cutting force and tool wear progression agrees well with the predictions from 3-D oblique cutting model, and the machined surface roughness can be predicted with a surface kinematic model incorporating the plowing effect. The experimental results also showed that the process configuration as derived from the analytical optimization procedure lends itself to superior results in comparison to other experimental results under non-optimal configurations.     

Experimental studies on the cryogenic machining of biodegradable ZK60 Mg alloy using micro-textured tools

Reducing the contact area between the cutting tool rake surface and chip promotes the machining performance of the work material and increases the tool life. Magnesium alloys are ductile-lightweight materials that form continuous chips during machining. The present investigation discusses the orthogonal turning of ZK60 magnesium alloy with linearly textured cutting inserts under both dry and liquid nitrogen (LN₂) cooling conditions. Linear grooves that are parallel and perpendicular to chip flow direction were created using Nd-YAG laser on the tungsten carbide cutting inserts. The effect of texturing combined with the application of LN₂ cooling is studied by evaluating the machining temperature and forces, microhardness, surface roughness and tool wear. Textured tools considerably minimize the liaison area of the chip with the rake plane compared to non-textured tools, which resulted in favorable effects in machinability. In case of cryogenic machining, textured tools substantially minimize the friction by the coupled effect of micro-pool lubrication and the formation of thin-film lubrication between the tool–chip/tool–work interfaces. Parallel-textured tools aided with cryogenic cooling exhibit superior performance during machining among the different types of tools employed in the present investigation.