Influence of solid lubricants and fibre reinforcement on wear behaviour of polyethersulphone

Polyethersulphone (PES), is an amorphous, brittle and high temperature engineering thermoplastic. Two composites of PES containing short glass fibres (GF) and solid lubricants viz. PTFE and MoS₂; and two composites containing short carbon fibre (CF) [30% and 40%] were selected for the present studies. Compositional analysis of selected materials was done with various techniques such as gravimetry, solvent extraction and thermal analysis viz. thermal gravimetric analysis (TGA) and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). These materials were studied for adhesive and abrasive wear performance by sliding against a mild steel disc and silicon carbide abrasive paper respectively, under different loads. It was observed that GF reinforcement along with incorporation of solid lubricants (PTFE and MoS₂) enhanced the wear performance of PES by an order of two. In the case of solid lubricants, PTFE proved to be more beneficial than MoS₂. CF reinforcement, however, proved to be the most effective in enhancing wear performance of PES. PES reinforced with 40% CF exhibited a specific wear rate in the order of 10⁻¹⁶m³/Nm which is considered to be very good for the thermoplastic composite. In the case of abrasive wear behaviour, however, incorporation of fibres or solid lubricants deteriorated the performance of the neat matrix. SEM was employed to investigate the wear mechanisms.     

The effect of lubricant additives on friction and wear studies of polyphenylene sulphide

Polyphenylene sulphide is a polymer with good thermal stability and high crystallinity. This paper summarizes the results of friction and wear studies of polyphenylene sulphide and its composites made with conventional solid lubricants to ascertain the suitability of the material as a matrix for solid lubricant additives. The polymer itself has a high coefficient of friction. Wear rate increases with load and speed. Addition of solid lubricant additives helps in improving the friction and wear of the polymer. Composites with MoS₂-Sb₂O₃ and PTFE gave better results than composites made by the addition of graphite and MoS₂ graphite. Wear rate of these composites increased with load and speed; but load and speed had little effect on friction.     

Preliminary studies of the influence of cryo‐treatment on the mechanical and tribological properties of ptfe and composites

Cryogenic treatment of polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) has proved beneficial in improving the abrasive wear resistance of several polymers, and it was thus assessed in an adhesive wear mode, as well. Preliminary investigations on the effect of cryogenic treatment on the tribological properties, in adhesive wear mode, and mechanical properties of neat PTFE and it composites filled with bronze or short glass fibres (GF) were carried out. It was found that, although the improvement in the wear and friction performance of neat PTFE and a GF + PTFE composite was significant, no such positive effect was observed for the bronze + PTFE composite. On the contrary, this composite showed a deterioration in performance. The reason behind the improvement in the tribological behaviour of neat PTFE and the GF + PTFE composite could not be clearly understood. However, it was confirmed that, if the treatment adversely affected the mechanical properties, then the tribological performance also deteriorated. An examination of the worn surface of the material and the counterface disc using a scanning electron microscope revealed changes in the microstructure due to the treatment. It was also confirmed from these SEM studies that the compatibility of bronze and PTFE was very poor, which led to poor performance of the composite both in the untreated and the cryo‐treated form. Further detailed investigation and analysis of various materials and composites, however, are necessary to establish the utility of this technique.     

Theoretical investigation of transient elastohydrodynamic lubrication with newtonian solid‐liquid lubricants

This paper reports a theoretical investigation of transient elastohydrodynamic lubrication of a line contact. A time‐dependent Reynolds equation and elasticity equations for compressible solid‐liquid lubricants were solved using finite volume and multigrid techniques. The lubricants used were mineral oils mixed with very small solid particles, MoS₂ and PTFE, which can be treated as Newtonian fluids. The two surfaces were initially at rest and in contact. The transient oil film pressure and oil film thickness were calculated numerically. This simulation showed the significant effects of solid particles on the lubrication characteristics.     

Advances in solid lubrication with MoS2 multilayered coatings

The general classification of solid lubricant types is reviewed, along with the reasons for choosing and methods of depositing solid lubricants, in particular MoS₂. The best‐performing and most flexible technique for making MoS₂ films is by physical vapour deposition (PVD), and the variants of that technology are considered. The intrinsically‐lubricating, lamellar structure of pure MoS₂ is described, along with a brief summary of the wear and failure modes. Present applications for lubrication by MoS₂ in spacecraft and dry machining are described. Anti‐adhesion uses in extruding and moulding are also mentioned. The current modification of MoS₂ films is by addition of dopants (co‐sputtering), by multilayering as a series of films each fulfilling a specific task, or by stacking repeating nanometre‐scale films. Composite films of MoS₂ islands in a hard film matrix are also being developed.     

Experimental Study on the Tribological Properties of Powder Lubrication under Plane Contact

Powder lubrication has been studied using a plane contact tribometer. Four kinds of powders—polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), graphite, MoS₂, and ball-like copper—were used during the experiments. The results show that powder can be introduced into frictional clearance without any special treatment. The powder's physical properties significantly influence the tribological characteristics in the powder lubrication. The friction coefficient and wear are obviously decreased when the powders are PTFE, graphite, and MoS₂, which are excellent solid lubricants. At lower load capacity, powder lubrication using ball-like copper had certain antifriction effects, but it rapidly became worse with increasing load capacity. Observation with optical microscopy showed that the lubricant film is dynamically formed on the rubbing surfaces in most experiments.     

On the rheological behaviour of synthetic fluids thickened by solid additives

A variety of fluid space lubricants, i.e., synthetic oils thickened by solid additives (particles of PTFE and MoS₂), has been developed. These lubricants present a solid-like behaviour under yield stress, and a strong non-Newtonian effect during flow. Measurement of the yield stresses revealed an unexpectedly strong interaction between a synthetic hydrocarbon oil and one type of PTFE particle. Furthermore, the substitution of 1 vol.% PTFE particles by MoS₂ particles introduced a significant change in the yield stress values. This effect is also apparent in viscosity measurements. These lubricants display, through their rheological behaviour, good ability to replenish contacts over a wide range of temperatures, as shown by measurements taken at −20°C and −60°C.     

Modern solid lubrication: Recent developments and applications of MoS2

An important and growing field of lubrication lies in the use of solid films, although they are in general more expensive than oils or greases, and require specialist attention both in mechanical design and in coating application techniques. In this paper, the general classification of solid lubricant types is reviewed, along with the reasons for choosing, and methods of depositing, solid lubricants, in particular MoS₂. The best‐performing and most flexible technique for making MoS₂ films is by physical vapour deposition (PVD), and the variants of that technology are considered. The intrinsically lubricating, lamellar structure of pure MoS₂ is described, along with a brief summary of its wear and failure modes. Present applications for lubrication by MoS₂ in spacecraft and dry machining are outlined, as are anti‐adhesive uses in extruding and moulding. The current state of the art of modification of MoS₂ films consists in the addition of dopants (co‐sputtering), in multilayering as a series of films, each fulfilling a specific task, or in stacking repeating nano‐metre‐scale films. Composite films of MoS₂ islands in a hard film matrix are also being developed.     

Wear and friction behavior of alloyed gray cast iron with solid lubricants under boundary lubrication

Friction and wear behavior of MoS₂, boric acid, graphite and TiO₂ has been compared under extreme boundary lubrication condition. Boundary lubrication was simulated for the study. Results show that MoS₂ and graphite were 30-50% more effective than other two lubricants. Friction coefficient shows a decreasing trend with increase in sliding speed due to increasing temperature and higher shear force. High friction coefficient values were recorded for all the lubricants (0.2-0.5). This is due to predominating solid interactions during boundary lubrication condition. Boric acid and TiO₂ were not much effective in lubrication.     

A study of the influence of steam treatment on the tribological behaviour of steel specimens

The influence of steam treatment (ST) on the tribological behaviour of steel was assessed by Falex, Schwingungsreibverschleiss (SRV) and Amsler tests performed either under dry conditions or using solid MoS₂, graphite, polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE) or grease lubricants. ST produced a thin layer of magnetite containing small quantities of haematite. MoS₂ was found to be the best lubricant in Falex tests with normal test pieces. Only greaselubricated Amsler couples withstood the full testing cycle. The SRV tests were inconclusive because the endurance time was too short, only a few seconds with MoS₂ lubrication.The influence of ST varied in the Falex tests. No improvement was found with grease-lubricated journals and the load-carrying capacity of MoS₂-lubricated test pieces was decreased. However, it was beneficial for PTFE lubrication. In the Amsler tests the grease-lubricated disks were crazed and magnetite splinters were removed. The performance of the graphite lubricant was lowered by ST and the median lives of MoS₂- or PTFE-lubricated couples were increased although their reliability was impaired. In SRV tests, ST improved the performance of grease and MoS₂-lubricated test pieces. The test results do not confirm the reported improved behaviour of ST components, particularly cutting tools, in workshop practice.     

The effect of space irradiation on the lubricating performance of perfluoropolyether greases in simulated space environment

In this paper, 2 kinds of commercial perfluoropolyether (PFPE) greases were coated on the polyimide (PI) blocks, which were placed within simulated space environment including atomic oxygen (AO), proton (Pr), ultraviolet (UV), and electron (El) irradiations, and then the tribological performance has been investigated with a ball‐on‐disc tribometer. Results indicated that the MoS₂‐grease showed better lubrication performance than the PTFE‐grease. The changes in infrared spectroscopy induced by Pr and El irradiations were more obvious than that by AO and UV irradiations. Results of energy dispersive X‐ray spectroscopy indicated that Pr and El irradiations caused carbonation of greases, and AO and UV irradiations induced oxidation of greases. Referred to the tribological properties of PI coated with PFPE oil, PI coated with PFPE greases showed minor changes in friction coefficient and wear rate, and the MoS₂ additives could significantly improve the lubrication properties of PFPE greases in simulated space environment.     

An investigation of friction and wear performances of bonded molybdenum disulfide solid film lubricants in fretting conditions

The friction and wear performances of bonded MoS₂ solid film lubricants with the counterpart steel ball rubbing were investigated in fretting wear conditions in order to inquire into the load-carrying capacity and wear mechanisms of bonded MoS₂ solid film lubricants under dry friction conditions. Experimental results show that the bonded MoS₂ solid film lubricants have excellent anti-friction and wear-resistance performances within a wide load range between 20 N and 800 N and within a wide oscillatory frequency range between 5 Hz and 30 Hz. It is found through analyses of the transfer films formed in the surface of the counterpart steel ball investigated by SEM, XPS and AES, that the thickness of the transfer film formed is about 38 nm and the oxidation of MoS₂ in the transfer films does not occur during dry friction process. The high load and frequency promote the formation of a compact transfer films. The compact transfer films are believed to be the predominant mechanism giving rise to high load-carrying capacity, and excellent wear-resistance performances of the bonded MoS₂ solid film lubricants.     

Tribological properties of epoxy nanocomposites: III. Characteristics of transfer films

The multiple parts of this study are intended to experimentally and analytically elaborate the tribological properties of epoxy nanocomposites, reinforced by short carbon fibres (SCF), nano-TiO₂ particles, polytetrafluorethylen (PTFE) powders and graphite flakes, in order to understand the role of fillers in modifying the wear behaviour of the materials. In this part, the influences of two solid lubricants, PTFE and graphite, were studied and compared. The transfer films established with two lubricants in sliding wear of epoxy nanocomposites against metallic counterparts were characterised under different sliding conditions. The morphology of transfer films was examined using scanning electronic microscopy (SEM), while their mechanical properties were investigated using micro-hardness tests. A method was proposed to determine the thickness of transfer films based on micro-indentation. The role of transfer films in dissipation of frictional heating was also studied. Epoxy nanocomposites containing both PTFE powders and graphite flakes showed a synergised effect in wear performance, especially under very severe wear conditions.     

Etched-pocket, dry-bearing materials

Novel, dry-bearing materials have been fabricated by photo-etching an array of very small, blind holes in metal surfaces and filling them with solid lubricant formulations. Friction and wear were assessed against a tool-steel counterface in reciprocating line-contact conditions. Preliminary experiments demonstrated feasibility with a range of substrates (bronze, steel, cobalt alloy) and lubricants (PTFE + Pb, MoS₂ + polyimide). Detailed studies were made with different copper alloys to examine the effects of substrate hardness and the distribution, size, spacing and depth of the etched pockets. Be---Cu containing PTFE + Pb exhibits wear lives over a range of stresses (Hertzian) to 375 MPa which are appreciably longer than those of a porous bronze composite containing the same lubricant. Wear rates of etched Be----Cu are also much lower than those of a typical, woven PTFE fibre-type of dry-bearing composite. Wear life is not, in general, limited by the depth of the etched pockets and several failure mechanisms have been identified.     

Cryogenic Friction Behavior of PTFE based Solid Lubricant Composites

Solid lubricants used in aerospace applications must provide low friction and a predictable operation life over an extreme range of temperatures, environments and contact conditions. PTFE and PTFE composites have shown favorable tribological performance as solid lubricants. This study evaluates the effect of temperature on the friction coefficient of neat PTFE, a PTFE/PEEK composite and an expanded PTFE (ePTFE)/epoxy coating. These experiments evaluate friction coefficient over a temperature span which, to the investigators’ knowledge, has not been previously examined. Results show a monotonic increase in friction coefficient as sample surface temperature was decreased from 317 to 173 K for all three samples. The frictional performance of these and other published solid lubricant polymers was modeled using an adjusted Arrhenius equation, which correlates the coefficient of friction of the polymer materials to their viscoelastic behavior. A model fit of all the polymer data from 173 to 450 K gives an activation energy of 3.7 kJ/mol. This value suggests that breaking of van der Waals bonds is the likely mechanism responsible for the frictional behavior over this temperature range.     

Tribological Properties of Self-Lubricating Polymer–Steel Laminated Composites

Self-lubricating polymer–steel laminated composites (SLC) consisting of matrix zones and filled zones were fabricated by a laminating–bonding process. The matrix zones were silicon steel sheets and the filled zones were polymer matrix filled with MoS₂ and graphite, respectively. The control specimen was prepared by spraying a polymer composite coating on a GCr15 disc. The tribological properties of SLC were investigated using a ball-on-disc tribometer under different loads and frequencies. Compared to the control specimen, the friction coefficient and wear rate of SLC was reduced by 57% and threefold at 4 N and 6 Hz, respectively. In addition, the friction coefficient of SLC was low and stable under low reciprocating frequency, and it was high and fluctuating under high reciprocating frequency. In addition, the wear rate increased with increasing applied load and reciprocating frequency. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) images show that the lubricating mechanism of SLC was that solid lubricants embedded in filled zones expanded and smeared a layer of transfer film on the sliding path to lubricate the surface. The thermal expansion of solid lubricants was simulated using ANSYS software with thermal-stress coupling. The simulation results showed the maximum temperature of the filled zones was 130°C, and the maximum normal displacement of solid lubricants was approximately 10 μm. This confirmed that the solid lubricants expanded effectively by the aid of frictional heat.     

Evaluation of Ion-Sputtered Molybdenum Disulfide Bearings for Spacecraft Gimbals

High-density, sputtered molybdenum disulfide films (MoS₂) were investigated as lubricants for the next generation of spacecraft gimbal bearings where low torque signatures and long life are required. Low friction in a vacuum environment, virtually no out-gassing, insensitivity to low temperature, and radiation resistance of these lubricant films are valued in such applications. One hundred and twenty five thousand hours of accumulated bearing lest time were obtained on 24 pairs of flight-quality bearings ion-sputtered with three types of advanced MoS₂ films. Life tests were conducted in a vacuum over a simulated duty cycle for a space pay bad gimbal. Optimum retainer and ball material composition were investigated. Comparisons were made with test bearings lubricated with liquid space lubricants.

Self-lubricating PTFE retainers were required for long life, i.e., > 40 million gimbal cycles. Bearings with polyimide retainers, silicon nitride ceramic balls, or steel balls sputtered with MoS₂ film suffered early torque failure, irrespective of the type of race-sputtered MoS₂ film. Failure generally resulted from excess film or retainer debris deposited in the ball track which tended to jam the bearing. Both grease lubricated and the better MoS₂ film lubricated bearings produced long lives, although the torque with liquid lubricants was lower and less irregular.     

Lubrication at 750°C in a vacuum by a transfer film from self‐lubricating composites for roll/slide contact of Si3N4

Roll/slide friction tests were carried out at a temperature of 750°C in a vacuum. Disc specimens were made of Si₃N₄ with or without a sputtered MoS₂ film. A pin specimen was rubbed against one disc to supply a lubricating transfer film. With a pin made of an MoS₂‐based composite, the friction coefficient was around 0.3 and almost no wear of the discs was observed after 24 h of operation at a load of 50 N, a rotating speed of 0.5 m/s, and a slip ratio of 10%. Transferred patchy MoS₂ films were observed on the friction track. With a pin made of Ni‐based composite containing BN and graphite, the friction coefficient increased from 0.2 to 0.7 over a test time of about 8 h and severe disc wear was found. In an additional test using Si₃N₄ discs with a sputtered MoS₂ film without a pin, the friction coefficient was about 0.3, and no wear of the discs was found after 24 h of operation. The appearance of the friction track was similar to that in the test using the MoS₂‐based composite pin. It seems that the sputtered MoS₂ film wore, but wear particles reattached on the friction path to develop an effective lubricating film. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of transfer film lubrication for long‐term operation in a high‐temperature vacuum, and the superior ability of MoS₂ to develop an effective transfer film.     

The effect of the transfer film on the friction and wear of dry bearing materials for a power plant application

Friction and wear tests have been carried out for a number of commercial dry bearing materials containing polytetrafluoroethylene (PTFE), MoS₂ or graphite for a specific turbogenerator application. The effect of operating temperatures up to 300 °C has been investigated. The performance of the materials was strongly related to the formation and stability of a transferred film. PTFE-containing materials offered the most favourable performance over a wide temperature range; the wear rate obeyed a modified form of Archard's adhesive wear law. A simple model for the running-in behaviour of these materials is proposed.     

A comparison of oxidation and oxygen substitution in MoS2 solid film lubricants

Significant advancements in the production of low friction, long wear life, sputter-deposited MoS₂ lubricant coatings have been made in the last decade. The introduction of multi-layered coatings, the establishment of careful controls on doping during DC and magnetron sputter deposition, and the implementation of ion assisted deposition have resulted in lubricants with substantially longer wear lives (up to a factor of ten greater than in the early 1980s) and lower sliding friction coefficients. A major research effort, designed to improve the performance of solid lubricants, involved a number of laboratories during this time period, resulting in these major breakthroughs. However, even with this concentrated effort, the typical investigation involved making an educated guess, based on previous experience, of the deposition conditions, target compositions, or post treatments that might be expected to provide improved performance of resulting coatings. One notable discovery during this time period was that typical MoS₂ films contain large quantities (up to 20 atom %) of oxygen substituted for sulfur in individual crystal lattices. In this paper we will compare the effects of this oxygen substitution with the effects of oxidation which involves a change in the oxidation number of the central molybdenum atoms within the crystals. A discussion of the relationship(s) between chemistry and coating structure and tribological performance will be presented with emphasis on defect chemistry and multiple phase interactions. Speculations on the role of coating chemistry in determining coating performance in applications such as in ball bearings will be presented.