A comparison of the labeled magnitude (LAM) scale,an 11-point category scale and the traditional 9-point hedonic scale

Schutz and Cardello [Schutz, H. G. & Cardello, A. V. (2001). A labeled affective magnitude (LAM) scale for assessing food liking/disliking. Journal of Sensory Studies, 16, 117–159] proposed the labeled magnitude (LAM) scale for measuring food acceptance. The LAM is a line scale anchored at its end points with the phrases “greatest imaginable like” and “greatest imaginable dislike” and uses as intermediate anchors the nine phrases of the traditional hedonic scale. In this study, three hedonic scales were compared, including the widely-used 9-point hedonic scale, the LAM scale, and an 11-point category scale using the LAM’s verbal anchors as category labels. Three groups of consumers (N = about 100 each) used one of the three scales to evaluate the acceptability of highly liked foods (orange juices, potato chips, cookies, and ice cream, with four samples of each). Scales were evaluated primarily on their ability to show differences in acceptability, the correspondence of acceptance ratings to preference ranking and the correspondence of stated product usage (e.g., purchase of pulp vs. non-pulp orange juice) to the product scoring highest. All three scales performed equally well, with no one scale showing a consistent superiority over another. All three scales were able to differentiate acceptability of the orange juices, chips and cookies. No scale differentiated among the ice creams, which had equal and high acceptability. All scales showed a strong correspondence between liking and preference rankings and also between the product rated highest and the type of product usually consumed, within each of the product categories.     

Effects of an evoked refreshing consumption context on hedonic responses to apple juice measured using best–worst scaling and the 9-pt hedonic category scale

Awareness of the need to consider a product’s consumption context when measuring consumer hedonic response of a product is increasing among consumer sensory researchers. This study investigated the effects of evoking a consumption context using a written scenario on hedonic response measured using best–worst scaling and the 9-pt hedonic category scale. Hedonic responses for four apple juices with relatively large sensory differences were compared when measured in the evoked context ‘when having something refreshing to drink’ using best–worst hedonic scaling (n = 65) and the 9-pt hedonic scale (n = 48). Best–worst scaling discriminated between the four apple juices when a refreshing context was evoked (p < 0.01), while the juices were equally liked using the 9-point scale (p = 0.41) when the same context was evoked. Consumers perceived best–worst scaling to be more difficult than the 9-pt scale, however there was no difference between the two methods for consumers perceived accuracy of their liking information. The present study highlights that the effect of an evoked context on hedonic response may not be universal for hedonic methods. Further research is needed to understand the effect of evoking context on the liking of products, and to determine whether this measure reflects product liking in an actual consumption context.     

Consumer segmentation based on food neophobia and its application to product development

When evaluating the acceptability of food products, companies often focus on specific demographics for recruiting and screening consumers. However, this information may not necessarily explain the variability in the test results. Other elements, such as consumer psychographic profiles, may help better understand test participants’ responses. The objective of this study was to investigate the effect of food neophobia (reluctance to/avoidance of novel foods) on acceptability of novel food items. Six salad dressings with novel flavor combinations were chosen for evaluation in a central location test. Consumers were screened using the food neophobia scale (Pliner & Hobden, 1992) as well as liking of salad dressings. Each subject evaluated three of six dressings for hedonic and diagnostic attributes. Neophobic subjects rated the salad dressings significantly lower (p < 0.05) than neophilics for all hedonic attributes with the exception of appearance. These results were consistent for all dressings. However, when looking at the hedonic mean scores from both groups, the products were ranked in similar order in that the best liked and least liked dressing for the neophilic group was the same as those for the neophobic group. For diagnostic attributes, while the mean scores were significantly different for neophobics and neophilics, the percentage of “just-about-right” scores did not differ. These results suggest that food neophobia may impact the degree with which a product is liked or disliked by consumers, but it may not affect how products are ranked based on hedonic mean scores. Therefore, while understanding the psychographic composition of a consumer test respondent base may help explain why some products score higher or lower in acceptability, it may not alter the sensory guidance provided to product development regarding the specific flavor and texture attributes that were tested.     

Development of probiotic beads similar to fish eggs

Probiotic foods are mainly restricted to dairy and soy products. This study aimed to develop a new probiotic beads similar to fish eggs, commonly used in oriental cuisine. Beads were produced by the extrusion encapsulation technique with calcium alginate, added to one of the following cultures: Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG ATCC 53103 and Bifidobacterium animalis DN-173 010 and stored for 30 days at 4 °C. The beads were characterized by the size, weight, morphology and viability of the probiotic strains in different storage temperatures and in simulated gastric juice adjusted to different pH values. The beads were also evaluated by a sensorial affective hedonic scale. The beads present a 2.8 mm diameter and a weight of 0.01 g (p > 0.05). Free and encapsulated cells were tolerant to pH 3.0. At pH 2.5 only of the encapsulated cells presented counts above 6 Log colony-forming units per gram (CFU/g). Beads containing L. rhamnosus showed higher viability 10⁷ CFU/g in storage for 30 days under refrigeration. The beads may be stored at abusive temperature for 5 h without loss of viability cells. The probiotic product developed showed an 82.2% acceptability index of overall characteristics and good market potential as a new probiotic product.     

Sensory and Nutritional Quality of Dehydrated Potato Flakes in Long-Term Storage

ABSTRACT:  The sensory and nutritional quality of dehydrated potato flakes packaged in nr 10 cans held at ambient temperatures up to 30 y was studied. Thirteen samples of dehydrated potato flakes were obtained from donors. A consumer panel evaluated reconstituted product for appearance, aroma, texture, flavor, and overall acceptability using a 9-point hedonic scale. Overall acceptability hedonic scores ranged from 3.7 to 6.6 and declined significantly over time. Sensory shelf-life, based on a cutoff of 80% of initial overall acceptability, was 16 y. Vitamin C levels remained constant over storage time. Headspace hexanal concentrations ranged from 0 to 2.09 μg/g. There was no significant correlation between headspace hexanal of dry flakes and hedonic scores of reconstituted product. Dehydrated potato flakes appear to retain sufficient quality over time to warrant consideration for long-term storage purposes.     

Development of peanut milk–based fermented curd

Fermented milk product (Indian curd) was developed by using peanut milk. The level of incubation period (IP), skimmed milk powder (SMP), carboxymethyl cellulose (CMC) was optimised using response surface methodology (RSM). Central composite rotatable design was used with three independent variables i.e. IP (16–20 h), SMP (3–5%) and CMC (0.1–0.3%). SMP had significant (P ≤ 0.05) positive effect on overall acceptability (OAA) of curd because of increase in the total solids that ultimately increased firmness of the curd. CMC was found effective in reducing the synersis of curd samples. The developed curd samples had moisture 84.8 ± 0.28%, protein 3.2 ± 0.12%, fat 3.5 ± 0.10%, ash 0.5 ± 0.05%, carbohydrate 8.0% (wb), peak viscosity 291.4 ± 3.52 cP, firmness 1.3 ± 0.15 N, synersis 32.1 ± 0.2 mL 100 g^?1 and acidity (as % lactic acid) 0.58 ± 0.02. It had OAA score of 7.8 ± 0.2 on nine‐point hedonic scale. Based on compromise optimisation, the conditions recommended were IP as 18 h, SMP, 4.24% and CMC, 0.19% for making peanut milk–based fermented curd with 83.4% desirability.     

Comparative performance of the nine-point hedonic,hybrid and self-adjusting scales in the generation of internal preference maps

This study evaluated the performance of the nine-point hedonic, hybrid and self-adjusting scales in the segmentation of samples and consumers using MDPREF methodology. Overall acceptability of eight Cabernet Sauvignon red wines was evaluated by 112 consumers using the three scales mentioned above. Both the scale’s and the sample’s presentation order were balanced among the consumers. The data were analyzed by ANOVA, REGWQ test, MDPREF and permutation tests. Scales’ performance was judged using the following criteria: number of significant dimensions (p = 5%) in the MDPREF, number of significantly fitted consumers (p = 5%) and segmentation of the products and consumers. The MDPREF generated by the hybrid scale data produced the greatest number of significant dimensions (p = 5%), yielding 79.5% of significantly fitted consumers (p = 5%), while the MDPREFs of the self-adjusting and the nine-point scales fitted 54.5% and 51.8% of the consumers, respectively. Overall, the results indicated superiority of the hybrid scale over the traditional hedonic and self-adjusting scales.     

Improving the drying kinetics and microstructure of vacuum-fried ripened durian chips

This research evaluated the effects of process conditions on the physiochemical properties of vacuum-fried durian chips. Ripened durians were sliced and fried at 90, 100, 110 and 120°C under 8-kPa absolute pressure. From this study, microwave heating (MWH) during vacuum frying (VF) significantly reduced the frying time by 20% compared to VF (P < 0.05) with the effective moisture diffusivity for VF, pre-treatment before vacuum frying (P+VF) and VF+MWH at 110°C determined to be 3.63 × 10⁻⁰⁹, 4.30 × 10⁻⁰⁹ and 4.84 × 10⁻⁰⁹ m² s⁻¹, respectively. VF+MWH produced chips with significantly lower shrinkage, more yellowness (P < 0.05) and higher crispiness (consistent with the microstructure from scanning electron microscopy (SEM)). In addition, VF+MWH drastically decreased oil absorption by 10%, while P+VF yielded the lowest specific energy consumption (SEC). From sensory evaluation, the overall acceptability of VF+MWH chips rose from 5.83 to 6.07 (seven-point hedonic scale), thus making the product fall into the ‘Good’ to ‘Very Good’ range.     

Effect of gum tragacanth on rheological and physical properties of a flavored milk drink made with date syrup

Date syrup as a nutritional additive and safe alternative to added sugar is one of the best choices for milk flavoring. In this study, a flavored milk beverage was formulated using date syrup for flavoring the product and gum tragacanth to obtain an acceptable mouth feel. Steady shear and dynamic oscillatory rheological properties of the samples contained 3 concentrations (0, 0.1, 0.2, and 0.3%, wt/wt) of 2 types of gum tragacanth (Astragalus gossypinus and Astragalus rahensis) which at 3°C, were studied. Particle size distribution and colorimetric assays were determined by laser diffractometry and using reflection spectrometer, respectively. Sensory analysis was performed with 25 semitrained panelists, using a 5-point hedonic scale. The results showed that viscoelastic properties, flow behavior parameters, particle size, and color parameters (L^*, a^*, and b^*, where L^* represents lightness, a^* represents the redness/greenness quality of the color, and b^* represents the yellowness and blueness quality of the colors) were significantly affected by the concentration of the gum tragacanth and the severity of this effect was influenced by the type of gum. The use of appropriate type and concentration of gum tragacanth in date milk formulation can improve the texture and mouth feel by affecting on particle size and the flow behavior of this product.     

Survival Analysis Applied to Sensory Shelf Life of Yogurts–II: Spanish Formulations

Sensory shelf lives of commercial Spanish yogurts stored at 10 °C were studied. Yogurts were strawberry flavored and differed in fat content (free and whole‐fat) and consistency (stirred and set‐style). Yogurts were tested between 0 and 90 d of storage by consumers who expressed acceptance or rejection of each sample and measured overall and attribute acceptability on a 9‐point hedonic scale. Survival analysis statistics were used to estimate sensory shelf lives. Considering 25% of consumers rejecting the product, shelf lives varied from 38 to 69 d, depending on the composition, so if useful life were to be established using sensory criteria, a single shelf life for yogurt would not appear to be very appropriate. A log‐linear model and a direct quantile comparison formula were introduced to analyze the effect of formulation on rejection time distributions and shelf life values, respectively. Fat‐free yogurts had shorter shelf lives than whole‐fat yogurts. Acceptability of yogurts measured on a 9‐point hedonic scale varied less than percentage rejection over the storage times.     

Effect of Reference Foods in Repeated Acceptability Tests: Testing Familiar and Novel Foods Using 2 Acceptability Scales

ABSTRACT:  Hedonic tests are routinely used to assess the acceptance of food products. However, these single tests may not be the best approach for predicting long-term use. The objectives of this study were, first, to check whether a difference from reference score is more sensitive to changes in hedonic scores, second, to assess whether the labeled affective scale (LAM) is more sensitive to differences than the 9-point scale, and third, to assess the effect of repeated exposure on the hedonic scores of neophilic and neophobic panelists for familiar and novel foods. Two groups of 41 panelists were tested with either the 9-point hedonic scale or LAM scale. Panelists received a food neophobia questionnaire and were subsequently classified to neophobic, neophilic, or neutral. Ten foods, including 5 novel and 5 familiar, were used. In each session, 5 to 6 foods were served twice/week for 4 wk. Serving frequency ranged between 1 and 8 times (1, 2, 4, 6, 8). Data analyses were performed 3 times, using either absolute acceptability scores or relative scores, that is, the difference between absolute scores and scores for either the reference (cracker, RELFAM) or a novel food (pickled-ginger, RELNOV) served in every session. The 3 analyses (absolute, RELFAM, and RELNOV) generated similar results with respect to the number of significant differences between foods. There was no major drift in acceptability scores with sessions. A significant food effect was obtained ( P < 0.05) and a significant food × neophobia ( P < 0.05) was noted for 2 novel foods, pickled ginger, and lychee, whereby neophobic panelists were less accepting of them. Both scales were equally sensitive with some advantages for LAM over the 9-point hedonic scale.     

Effect of varying salt and fat levels on the sensory and physiochemical quality of frankfurters

The sensory and physiochemical properties of frankfurters with varying fat and salt levels were investigated. Twenty frankfurter formulations were produced with varying concentrations of fat (10%, 15%, 20%, 25% w/w) and salt (1%, 1.5%, 2%, 2.5%, 3% w/w). Frankfurters were assessed instrumentally for colour, moisture, fat, cooking loss and texture profile analysis. Consumers (n = 25) evaluated each product in duplicate for colour, coarseness, tenderness, juiciness, salt taste, meat flavour, off-flavour and overall acceptability using a hedonic scale. Salt levels below 1.5% were shown to have a negative effect on consumer acceptability, with 2.5% salt concentration being the most accepted (P < 0.001) by consumers. However, frankfurters containing the lower fat levels 10% and 15% fat with higher salt levels (2.5–3%) were significantly the most acceptable variants to consumers. Samples containing less fat and salt were found to be tougher, less juicy and had greater cooking losses. Thus salt perception is very important for consumer acceptability, but fat levels can be potentially reduced without significantly affecting overall acceptability.     

Optimisation of the formulation for barley–milk composite‐based fermented drink

The effect of barley flour concentration, Lactobacillus plantarum NCDC344 (Lp344) and co‐culture (Streptococcus thermophilus 20) inoculum levels on the sensory quality, Lp344 count, β‐glucan content and viscosity of barley–milk composite‐based fermented drink was investigated. A central composite rotatable design of response surface methodology was used for optimisation of the formulation. Of the three formulation variables, barley flour concentration was found to be the most critical as it significantly affected overall acceptability, Lp344 count and β‐glucan content (P < 0.01). The optimised drink rated 7.80 on a 9‐point hedonic scale, and contained 8.59 log cfu/mL of Lp344 cells and 0.144 g/100 g of β‐glucan.     

Effect of varying salt and fat levels on the sensory and physiochemical quality of frankfurters

The sensory and physiochemical properties of frankfurters with varying fat and salt levels were investigated. Twenty frankfurter formulations were produced with varying concentrations of fat (10%, 15%, 20%, 25% w/w) and salt (1%, 1.5%, 2%, 2.5%, 3% w/w). Frankfurters were assessed instrumentally for colour, moisture, fat, cooking loss and texture profile analysis. Consumers (n=25) evaluated each product in duplicate for colour, coarseness, tenderness, juiciness, salt taste, meat flavour, off-flavour and overall acceptability using a hedonic scale. Salt levels below 1.5% were shown to have a negative effect on consumer acceptability, with 2.5% salt concentration being the most accepted (P<0.001) by consumers. However, frankfurters containing the lower fat levels 10% and 15% fat with higher salt levels (2.5-3%) were significantly the most acceptable variants to consumers. Samples containing less fat and salt were found to be tougher, less juicy and had greater cooking losses. Thus salt perception is very important for consumer acceptability, but fat levels can be potentially reduced without significantly affecting overall acceptability.     

Consumer Acceptability of Muffins with Flaxseed (Linum usitatissimum)

Flaxseed has recently gained attention as a functional food. The effect of adding flaxseed (7.3%, 11.6%, and 15.5%) to muffins on consumer acceptability was evaluated by a focus group, hedonic scoring, and food action rating scale (FACT). The majority of consumers (82.6%, P < 0.001) rated the control muffin (0 % flaxseed) higher than the flax muffin for appearance, color, flavor, texture, overall acceptability, and food acceptance. Flaxseed muffin (11.6%) was “neither liked nor disliked” to “liked slightly” in overall acceptability. This may have been accounted for by the observation that many persons aged 18 to 25 y did not think they needed to consume “health foods”. This “indifferent” and in some cases “negative” attitude toward the flax muffins, which they considered a “health food”, may have influenced the ratings the flax muffins received. Texture and flavor were strongly and positively correlated (P < 0.01) to overall acceptability. A flaxseed muffin provided at least 16% fiber of the daily recommended value.     

Discriminability and appropriateness of category scaling versus ranking methods to study sensory preferences in elderly

Two methods: the nine-point hedonic scale and hedonic ranking, have been compared for their discrimination power and appropriateness when studying hedonic responses in elderly. A group of 35 elderly subjects (aged 60–88) and a control group of 35 young adults (aged 20–25) participated in the comparison. Five samples of each of two commercial fruit juices (apple and orange) differing in sensory profiles served as test material. Generally hedonic discriminability in elderly was lower than in young subjects for both methods. Ranking appeared to be more discriminating for apple juice samples, where hedonic differences among samples were smaller (F sample_apple=8.80); for orange juice samples, of more pronounced hedonic differences (F sample_orange=17.24) both methods revealed equal discriminability. From simplicity of the task and “user friendliness” of the tasting procedure, hedonic ranking seems to have some advantages over nine-point hedonic scaling. Results obtained by both methods for both juices were significantly correlated for elderly as well as for young subjects. However, the strength of correlation (Spearman R value) in elderly was much lower (R_apple=0.2217; R_orange=0.2213) than in young (R_apple=0.4766; R_orange=0.4844). Repeatability of hedonic assessment of orange juice samples performed by elderly (n=27) 2 weeks after first evaluation for both methods was very good and did not show any advantage of one method over another.     

Sensory and Quality Evaluation of Traditional Compared with Power Ultrasound Processed Corn (Zea Mays) Tortilla Chips

Power ultrasound reduces the traditional corn steeping time from 18 to 1.5 h during tortilla chips dough (masa) processing. This study sought to examine consumer (n = 99) acceptability and quality of tortilla chips made from the masa by traditional compared with ultrasonic methods. Overall appearance, flavor, and texture acceptability scores were evaluated using a 9‐point hedonic scale. The baked chips (process intermediate) before and after frying (finished product) were analyzed using a texture analyzer and machine vision. The texture values were determined using the 3‐point bend test using breaking force gradient (BFG), peak breaking force (PBF), and breaking distance (BD). The fracturing properties determined by the crisp fracture support rig using fracture force gradient (FFG), peak fracture force (PFF), and fracture distance (FD). The machine vision evaluated the total surface area, lightness (L), color difference (ΔE), Hue (°h), and Chroma (C*). The results were evaluated by analysis of variance and means were separated using Tukey's test. Machine vision values of L, °h, were higher (P < 0.05) and ΔE was lower (P < 0.05) for fried and L, °h were significantly (P < 0.05) higher for baked chips produced from ultra‐sonication as compare to traditional. Baked chips texture for ultra‐sonication was significantly higher (P < 0.05) on BFG, BPD, PFF, and FD. Fried tortilla chips texture were higher significantly (P < 0.05) in BFG and PFF for ultra‐sonication than traditional processing. However, the instrumental differences were not detected in sensory analysis, concluding possibility of power ultrasound as potential tortilla chips processing aid.