Adhesion: Comparison Between Physico-chemical Expected and Measured Adhesion of Oxygen-plasma-treated Carbon Fibers and Polycarbonate

The adhesive interaction between oxygen-plasma-treated, polyacrylonitrile-based, high-tensile-strength carbon fibers and a polycarbonate matrix has been studied. Several models have been used to predict the impact of the plasma treatment process on the strength of adhesion between both jointing partners. These approaches have been the thermodynamic work of adhesion which was calculated from the solid surface tensions, based on the results of contact angle measurements versus test liquids, the contact angle which was directly obtained via polycarbonate melt droplets on single carbon fibers and the zeta (?)-potential data provided by streaming potential measurements. The results have been compared with the interfacial shear strength determined from the single-fiber fragmentation test. Additionally, the single-fiber tensile strength of the oxygen-plasma-treated carbon fibers was determined.

We confirmed that any physico-chemical method on its own fails to describe exactly the measured adhesion. However, for the investigated system, the conscientious interpretation of the data obtained from wetting measurements, in conjunction with the thermodynamic approach, is sufficient to predict the success of a modification technique which has been applied to one component in order to improve adhesion.     

Adhesion characteristics of oxygen plasma-treated rayon fibers

The effect of oxygen plasma treatment of fiber on the adhesion between regenerated cellulose fiber and polyethylene (PE) was investigated using the single-fiber fragmentation test. In addition to allowing the determination of the interfacial shear strength, the fragmentation test provided a great deal of useful information on shear stress transfer and failure mechanisms in the systems. It was found that oxygen plasma treatment considerably enhanced the interfacial adhesion, as established by both the shear strength values that were measured and the birefringence patterns observed. The influence of the duration of treatment on adhesion was studied and found to be a very important parameter. The roles of surface chemistry, surface energetics, and surface topography of fiber in the interaction balance were investigated using electron spectroscopy for chemical analysis (ESCA), contact angle measurements, and scanning electron microscopy (SEM). It was seen that neither the plasma-induced changes in the surface energetics nor those in the surface topography could have exerted a positive effect on adhesion. Instead, the improved adhesion was ascribed to covalent bonds formed between the fiber and the matrix, as hydroperoxides, which were created on the fiber surface by the plasma treatment, decomposed during the fabrication of single-fiber specimens.     

Measurement of Adhesion Between Carbon Fibers and Bismaleimide Resins

The adhesion between carbon fibers and bismaleimide resins was evaluated using the microbond single fiber pull-out test. A commercially-available, methylene dianiline-based bismaleimide resin and a novel phosphorus-containing bismaleimide were tested with as-received and plasma-treated polyacrylonitrile-based carbon fibers. The surface chemical composition, topography, tensile strength, and surface free energy of the carbon fibers were studied using x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, single fiber tensile tests, and dynamic contact angle analysis. The carbon fiber-bismaleimide adhesion improved when the carbon fiber received an oxidative commercial surface treatment or was exposed to an air or ammonia plasma prior to bonding.     

Measurement of Adhesion Between Carbon Fibers and Bismaleimide Resins

The adhesion between carbon fibers and bismaleimide resins was evaluated using the microbond single fiber pull-out test. A commercially-available, methylene dianiline-based bismaleimide resin and a novel phosphorus-containing bismaleimide were tested with as-received and plasma-treated polyacrylonitrile-based carbon fibers. The surface chemical composition, topography, tensile strength, and surface free energy of the carbon fibers were studied using x-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, scanning electron microscopy, single fiber tensile tests, and dynamic contact angle analysis. The carbon fiber-bismaleimide adhesion improved when the carbon fiber received an oxidative commercial surface treatment or was exposed to an air or ammonia plasma prior to bonding.     

Influence of the fiber surface properties on the mechanical strength of unidirectional fiber composites

The influence of the thermodynamic adhesion between fibers and matrix on the mechanical properties of a continuous fiber reinforced composite is studied for two systems: carbon fiber reinforced poly(ether ether ketone) and glass fiber reinforced poly(ether imide). The fibers are modified chemically and characterized by measuring the contact angle formed by molten resin on the fibers. Various fiber treatments yield a wide range of contact angles, which are determined optically. Unidirectional fiber reinforced laminates are manufactured and transverse flexural strength is measured with the values reported as a function of the specific work of adhesion. It is shown that adhesion at the fiber-resin interface correlates with both the composite strength and the void morphology within the laminate after consolidation.     

Adhesion of poly(m-, p-phenylene isophtalamide) coatings to metal substrates

The adhesive properties of wear-resistant poly(m-, p-phenylene isophtalamide) coatings to substrates of ferrous and non-ferrous metal materials which are the most common in mechanical engineering were investigated experimentally. The results of measurements of adhesive characteristics taken with the help of such methods as a cross cutting test, a quantitative peel test, a lap shear strength test, a contact angle test and a spreading radius test are discussed in terms of the three most common mechanisms of adhesion: mechanical coupling, molecular bonding, and thermodynamic adhesion. It was established that the adhesive properties of poly(m-, p-phenylene isophtalamide) coatings depend on the content of a ferrite component in the structure of carbon steel substrates.     

Adhesion of flame-treated polyolefins to styrene butadiene rubber

Samples of polyethylene and polypropylene have been submitted to repeated short duration (75 ms) flame treatments, at optimum flaming conditions. Surface energies of untreated and flamed specimens were determined by liquid contact angle measurements. It appears that the surface energy of polyethylene increases much more than that of polypropylene after flame treatment. The flamed polymer surfaces were further examined by electron spectroscopy, Fourier Transform IR spectroscopy and secondary ions mass spectrometry. The adhesion properties of modified polymer surfaces were studied by testing in peel the bonded Styrene Butadiene Rubber/polyolefins assemblies. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and water contact angle measurements have been used to observe the locus of failure. Good correlations were obtained between surface energy and adhesion strength, the increase in adhesion strength being particularly important for flamed PE/SBR assemblies. In addition, the peeling in a liquid medium allowed the determination of the respective contribution to adhesion of chemical and physical interactions. It is shown that a major part of the adhesion strength increase is of chemical origin, particularly for the bonded flamed PE/SBR assemblies.     

Adhesion of Polypropylene Fiber to Cement Matrix

Abstract

In this research, the adhesion of polypropylene (PP) fibers to cementitious matrix has been investigated and the chemical bonding and mechanical interlocking between PP fiber and hardened cement paste has been studied. Furthermore, thermodynamic work of adhesion and loss-function (dissipation energy) has been calculated in the PP-cement matrix model system. To investigate the work of adhesion, the pull-out test has been used. Also, the surface free energy and contact angle of the PP monofilaments and cement matrix have been measured using a tensiometer and the fiber–cement interfacial interactions and thermodynamic work of adhesion and loss-function were calculated. Scanning electron microscopy (SEM) analysis was used to study the fiber–cement matrix interfacial transition zone (ITZ). The results showed that the application of theories of polymer–polymer adhesion in fiber–cement matrix systems was feasible. To verify the accuracy of the method, the adhesion of two other fibers (nylon 6,6 and acrylic polymer) was studied.     

Surface Modification of Polycarbonate by Ultraviolet Radiation and Ozone

The effect of ultraviolet (UV) radiation in the presence of ozone as a surface treatment for polycarbonate is examined in regards to changes in the wettability, adhesion, and surface mechanical properties. Standalone, 175-µm-thick films of a commercially available polycarbonate were exposed to UV radiation from sources of different power with various treatment times in the presence of supplemental ozone. Significant decreases in the water contact angle were observed after exposure to UV radiation in the presence of ozone. After several variations in the experimental setup, it was determined that the change in water contact angle is a function of the UV irradiance and the work of adhesion follows a master curve versus UV irradiance. Nanoindentation experiments revealed that the modulus of the top 500 nm of the surface is increased following UV exposure, attributable to surface cross-linking. Adhesion tests to the surface (conducted by a pneumatic adhesion tensile test instrument) showed little change as a function of UV exposure. Analysis of adhesion test failure surfaces with X-ray Photoelectron Spectroscopy (XPS) showed the locus of bond failure lay within the bulk polycarbonate and the measured bond strength is limited by the bulk properties of the polycarbonate and/or the creation of a weak boundary layer within the polymer.     

Plasma Treatment of Polyacetal-Copolymer, Polycarbonate, Polybutylene terephthalate and Nylon 6, 6 Surfaces to Improve the Adhesion of Ink

Polyacetal-copolymer (POMB), polycarbonate (PC), polybutylene terephthalate (PBT), and nylon 6, 6 (PA6, 6) have been treated in an electron cyclotron resonance (ECR) plasma chamber to improve their adhesion properties towards ink. The chemical composition, the surface free energy, and the macroscopic adhesion have been studied by X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS), contact angle measurements, cross-cut tests, and the Scotch Tape test. Their dependence on the neutral gas, the treatment time, the pressure, and the ageing in air have been investigated. The XPS results reveal that the plasma treatment allows one to clean the surface and, if reactive gases are used, to incorporate new chemical species. The static and dynamic contact angles decrease with the plasma treatment and continue to decrease after contact with air. Very slow hydrophobic recovery is visible in the advancing contact angle, whereas the receding contact angle remains non-measurable even after more than a week of air exposure. Lower pressures and longer treatment times (120 s) lead to better macroscopic adhesion and reproducibility. For optimal treatment conditions (0.5 Pa, 120s N₂ plasma treatment time), the improvement of the adhesion remains excellent after seven days exposure of the sample in air.     

A Comparison of the Work of Adhesion Obtained from Wetting and Vapor Adsorption Measurements

Some of the limitations to determining experimental values of the work of adhesion are discussed. Wetting measurements appear to provide the most direct means of assessing the work of adhesion for a solid-liquid system, but they require the formation of a finite contact angle by the liquid against the solid of interest, and the need for independent knowledge of the equilibrium spreading pressure of the liquid's vapor on the solid further limits their applicability. Vapor adsorption measurement using the technique of inverse gas chromatoraphy (IGC) provides a promising alternative means of determining the work of adhesion not subject to these limitations. The measurements are, furthermore, amenable to solids which are difficult to use with wetting measurements, e.g., those which are porous or granular. An attempt is made here to compare values of the work of adhesion determined using both wetting and vapor adsorption measurements. Good agreement is attained between the two methods for diiodomethane in contact with poly (vinyl chloride), poly (methyl methacrylate), and chemi-thermo-mechanical wood pulp fibers, suggesting that the technique of IGC is particularly well-suited for rapid determination of the work of adhesion.     

Regeneration of Interfacial Adhesion in Fiber Reinforced Composites

Our studies of the regeneration of interfacial adhesion in micro-composites have shown that fiber/thermoplastic (aramid/polycarbonate) bonds can be completely regenerated, the degree of regeneration depending on both time and temperature of heating. Complete regeneration requires high temperatures, suggesting that mechanical interlocking resulting from flow of heat-softened resin into fiber surface crevices may be the primary mechanism of bond strength regeneration. Only partial regeneration of fiber/thermosetting resin (epoxy with aramid and carbon fibers) bond strength has been achieved, and this appears to be independent of fiber and reheating time. Apparently, the viscoelastic behavior of the resin is a critical factor in bond strength regeneration.     

Viscoelastic and Processing Effects on the Fiber-Matrix Interphase Strength. Part III. The Effects of Postcure

A novel method for tailoring the interphase of carbon fiber-polymer composites by resistive electric heating is presented. The single-fiber fragmentation test is used to investigate the adhesion and fracture properties of the interphase. Electric resistive heating is shown to increase adhesion and toughness at the interphase region. In analyzing the results, the strength and fracture energy of the interphase are related to the thermal postcure conditions created by resistive electric heating. For this purpose, a difference analysis method is used to obtain a numerical solution for the heat conduction problem in the single-fiber test specimen and the temperature distributions are determined. Improvements obtained by using resistive electric heating of the carbon fiber are compared with those obtained by postcuring of the whole sample via convective thermal postcuring. The results obtained using these two different postcure methods seem to be similar.     

Surface-Chemical Criteria for Optimum Adhesion

According to Bikerman, who attributes failure in adhints to a weak boundary layer, it is almost impossible and meaningless to correlate adhesive strength to surface-chemical properties of adhints. Though his assertion seems to be confirmed by the recent studies of Schonhorn and his coworkers on the methods of CASING and TCR, not a few results have yet been accumulated, which show a close relation between them. In this paper surface-chemical criteria for the optimum adhesion are investigated and the minimum interfacial tension or the maximum wetting pressure is deduced from the published data and our own as a first approximation. It is emphasized that, when critical surface tension γ_c would be used as a measure of surface-chemical properties of solid, its variability according to liquid series (nonpolar, polar and hydrogen bonding liquids) should be carefully taken into consideration. The importance is shown for polyethylene and its fluorine substituted polymers, using newly measured contact angle data and Zisman's data. Results of Levine et al. and Schonhorn et al. on adhesive shear strength with epoxy adhesives are replotted against available values of γ_c obtained by the use of hydrogen bonding liquid (γ_c^c), which are thought to reflect wetting behaviors of epoxy adhesives quite well. Each curve shows a maximum around γ_c^c = 40 dyne/cm with few points falling off the curves.     

Plasma etching and plasma polymerization coating of carbon fibers. Part 2. Characterization of plasma polymer coated carbon fibers

Unsized AS-4 carbon fibers were subjected to RF plasma etching and/or plasma polymerization coating in order to enhance their adhesion to vinyl ester resin. Ar, N₂ and O₂ were utilized for plasma etching, and acetylene, butadiene and acrylonitrile were used for plasma polymerization coating. Etching and coating conditions were optimized in terms of plasma power, treatment time, and gas (or monomer) pressure by measuring the interfacial adhesion strength. Interfacial adhesion was evaluated using micro-droplet specimens prepared with vinyl ester resin and plasma etched and/or plasma polymer coated carbon fibers. Surface modified fibers were characterized by SEM, XPS, FT-IR, α-Step, dynamic contact angle analyzer (DCA) and tensile strength measurements. Interfacial adhesion between plasma etched and/or plasma polymer coated carbon fibers and vinyl ester resin was reported previously (Part 1), and characterization results are discussed is this paper (Part 2). Gas plasma etching resulted in preferential etching of the fiber surface along the draw direction and decreased the tensile strength, while plasma polymer coatings altered neither the surface topography of fibers nor the tensile strength. Water contact angle decreased with plasma etching, as well as with acrylonitrile and acetylene plasma polymer coatings, but did not change with butadiene plasma polymer coating. FT-IR and XPS analyses revealed the presence of functional groups in plasma polymer coatings.     

Wettability and Adhesion Characteristics of Plasma-Treated Carbon Fibers

The surface free energy (γ_s) of modified carbon fibers was determined by tensiometry and effects of CF₄-O₂ plasma treatment were evaluated. The treatment with the gas mixture in which oxygen was above 40% accelerated preferentially the oxidation of fiber surfaces and the nondispersive component of the surface free energy, γ^P_S, increased to about three times that of the untreated fiber. On the other hand, the treatment with the gas containing CF₄ above 80% induced fluorination and surface species such as - CF, - CF₂, or - CF₃ were formed. The γ^P_S values decreased to almost zero and the dispersive component became about 18 mJ/m². The calculated work of adhesion between various fibers and the epoxy resin was well correlated with the interfacial shear strength of the composites formed with these materials.     

Physico-Chemical Criteria for Maximum Adhesion. Part II: A New Comprehensive Thermodynamic Analysis

In this paper, two parameters defined as the relative work of adhesion [W_A/γ_L] and the relative interfacial energy [γ_SL/γ_L] have been examined for their assumed usefulness in correlating the thermodynamic properties of the components of the system substrate/ adhesive with its practical performance (strength). It is shown that the minimum value of [γ_SL/γ_L] relevant to conditions for the maximum adhesion becomes zero only for those systems (relatively rare) for which interaction factor Φ₀ is equal to 1.0.

Several transition points were identified for boundary conditions acquired at θ = 0° and θ = 90° which can be used to predict the properties and performance of an adhesive joint. These transition points are: a_MIN—energy modulus of the system (E. M. S.), relevant to the minimum interfacial energy; a_S—E. M. S. where self-spreading of adhesive occurs; a_CRIT—E. M. S. relevant to conditions under which the thermodynamic work of adhesion becomes negative and the system exhibits a tendency for self-delaminating or has “zero-strength”; a_CF—E. M. S. beyond which the geometry of the interface at any interfacial void or boundary of the joint may be regarded as a crack tip.

It is shown that only in those systems for which Φ₀ = 1.0 can a minimum contact angle of 0° indicate a condition for the maximum strength. If Φ₀ is known, the optimum contact angle can be estimated and hence the optimum surface energy of the substrate (adjusted by surface treatment, etc.) for the maximum adhesion.     

Studies on adhesion of polyethylene. Part I. Influence of functionality and phase transfer catalyst

Low-density polyethylene (LDPE) has been oxidized using phase transferred permanganate as an oxidant. The resulting surface modifications have been characterized by different methods and the consequent adhesion promotion has been characterized in terms of contact angle and peel strength measurements. From contact angle measurements using water and formamide liquid drops, reversible work of adhesion, and thence γ^p _s and γ-^d _s, the contributions of polar and dispersion components, respectively, have been calculated. The polar contributions increased in each oxidized LDPE relative to untreated LDPE and the surface energies also increased appreciably. The adhesion strengths between aluminium and untreated LDPE, as well as those between aluminium and oxidized LDPEs, have been examined by peel strength measurements. We found that the adhesion strength increased about 8-28 times in the case of oxidized LDPEs. Maximum strength was observed when benzyl triphenyl phosphonium permanganate was the oxidant. Both the peel force and the thermodynamic work of adhesion increase sharply with an increase in the carboxyl content, the total number of oxo groups, and the combined CO and COOH content. The dependence of these quantities on carbonyl content is either weak or even follows a reverse trend. It is proposed that the adhesion proceeds primarily through hydrogen bonds involving carboxyl group and/or coordinative bond formation between aluminium and epoxy and/or hydroperoxo groups.     

Viscoelastic and Processing Effects on the Fiber-Matrix Interphase Strength. Part III. The Effects of Postcure

A novel method for tailoring the interphase of carbon fiber-polymer composites by resistive electric heating is presented. The single-fiber fragmentation test is used to investigate the adhesion and fracture properties of the interphase. Electric resistive heating is shown to increase adhesion and toughness at the interphase region. In analyzing the results, the strength and fracture energy of the interphase are related to the thermal postcure conditions created by resistive electric heating. For this purpose, a difference analysis method is used to obtain a numerical solution for the heat conduction problem in the single-fiber test specimen and the temperature distributions are determined. Improvements obtained by using resistive electric heating of the carbon fiber are compared with those obtained by postcuring of the whole sample via convective thermal postcuring. The results obtained using these two different postcure methods seem to be similar.     

The properties of dry-spun carbon nanotube fibers and their interfacial shear strength in an epoxy composite

Continuous fibers composed of carbon nanotubes have been adopted as reinforcements for polymeric composites. This paper presents several fundamental studies relevant to the mechanical behavior of CNT fibers, including fiber tensile behavior; in situ SEM observation of fiber deformation mechanisms; and fiber modulus, ultimate strength and fracture strain measurements. A modified Weibull strength distribution model that takes into account the flaw density variation with fiber diameter has been adopted for the statistical strength analysis. The interfacial shear strength between the carbon nanotube fiber and the epoxy matrix has been measured using fragmentation tests of single-fiber composites.