Physician-received scatter radiation with angiography systems used for interventional radiology: comparison among many X-ray systems

Radiation protection for interventional radiology (IR) physicians is very important. Current IR X-ray systems tend to use flat-panel detectors (FPDs) rather than image intensifiers (IIs). The purpose of this study is to test the hypothesis that there is no difference in physician-received scatter radiation (PRSR) between FPD systems and II systems. This study examined 20 X-ray systems in 15 cardiac catheterisation laboratories (11 used a FPD and 9 used an II). The PRSR with digital cineangiography and fluoroscopy were compared among the 20 X-ray systems using a phantom and a solid-state-detector electronic pocket dosemeter. The maximum PRSR exceeded the minimum PRSR by ~12-fold for cineangiography and ~9-fold for fluoroscopy. For both fluoroscopy and digital cineangiography, the PRSR had a statistically significant positive correlation with the entrance surface dose (fluoroscopy, r = 0.87; cineangiography, r = 0.86). There was no statistically significant difference between the average PRSR of FPDs and IIs during either digital cineangiography or fluoroscopy. There is a wide range of PRSR among the radiography systems evaluated. The PRSR correlated well with the entrance surface dose of the phantom in 20 X-ray units used for IR. Hence, decreasing the dose to the patient will also decrease the dose to staff.     

Comparison of the radiation dose in a cardiac IVR X-ray system

In this study, the entrance surface dose rates received by a phantom during cineangiography and fluoroscopy were compared. The X-ray conditions used in the measurements were those normally used in facilities performing percutaneous coronary intervention. Although, today, the entrance surface doses (cineangiography and fluoroscopy) of X-ray equipment used for cardiac interventional radiology (IVR) tends to be lower than they were previously, some equipment produces a high radiation dose. Therefore, the X-ray equipment used for cardiac IVR procedures must be maintained in good repair and must be carefully calibrated. In addition, periodic measurement of the radiation dose from the X-ray equipment used for both cineangiography and fluoroscopy for cardiac IVR is necessary. If the radiation dose of the X-ray system in use is too high, the IVR staff should determine the reason and make an effort to reduce it. Hence, the IVR staff must be adequately trained in radiation protection.     

Influence of patient thickness and operation modes on occupational and patient radiation doses in interventional cardiology

Patient and staff dose values in an interventional cardiology laboratory for different operational modes and several patient thicknesses (from 16 to 28 cm, simulated using polymethylmethacrylate) are presented. When increasing patient thicknesses and depending on fluoroscopy and cine modes, occupational doses can increase >30 times the baseline level. Scatter dose rates at the cardiologist's position with no radiation protective tools ranged from 1 to 14 mSv h(-1) for fluoroscopy, and from 10 to 47 mSv h(-1) during cine acquisition. Patient entrance surface air kerma rates increased by nearly 3 and staff dose rates by up to 2.6 when fluoroscopy was moved from the low to the high mode, for a typical 20 cm thickness. The respective increase factors were 6 and 4.2 when patient thickness rose from 16 to 28 cm, and by 10 and 8.3, when comparing cine acquisition with the low fluoroscopy mode. The knowledge of typical dose rates for each X-ray system in use in catheterisation laboratories is essential in order to optimise protection of patients and staff.     

Evaluating the maximum patient radiation dose in cardiac interventional procedures

Many of the X-ray systems that are used for cardiac interventional radiology provide no way to evaluate the patient maximum skin dose (MSD). The authors report a new method for evaluating the MSD by using the cumulative patient entrance skin dose (ESD), which includes a back-scatter factor and the number of cineangiography frames during percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI). Four hundred consecutive PCI patients (315 men and 85 women) were studied. The correlation between the cumulative ESD and number of cineangiography frames was investigated. The irradiation and overlapping fields were verified using dose-mapping software. A good correlation was found between the cumulative ESD and the number of cineangiography frames. The MSD could be estimated using the proportion of cineangiography frames used for the main angle of view relative to the total number of cineangiography frames and multiplying this by the cumulative ESD. The average MSD (3.0 ± 1.9 Gy) was lower than the average cumulative ESD (4.6 ± 2.6 Gy). This method is an easy way to estimate the MSD during PCI.     

Estimation of radiation doses to patients and surgeons from various fluoroscopically guided orthopaedic surgeries

In this study, a mathematical method was used to estimate the entrance surface dose (ESD) to the patient and the scattered dose (Ds) to the operating surgeon during various fluoroscopically guided surgical orthopaedic procedures. For 204 patients, the procedure type, the fluoroscopy time and the highest tube potential and current values observed during fluoroscopy were recorded. For the most often performed procedures (intramedullary nailing of peritrochanteric fractures, open reduction and internal fixation of malleolar fractures and intramedullary nailing of diaphyseal fractures of the femur), the respective mean fluoroscopy times were 3.2, 1.5 and 6.3 min while the estimated mean ESDs were 183, 21 and 331 mGy, respectively. The estimated Ds rates for the hands, chest, thyroid, eyes, gonads and legs of the operating surgeon were on average to 0.103, 0.023, 0.013, 0.012, 0.066 and 0.045 mGy min(-1), respectively, and compare well with the literature. The mathematical estimation of doses cannot replace actual measurements; however, it can be used for a preliminary assessment of the radiation dose levels during various surgical procedures, so that the operator, the surgeon and the rest of the medical staff involved could be aware of the associated radiation risk and the radiation protection measures required.     

Radiation doses to patients from enteroclysis

The purpose of this study was to determine the patient doses during enteroclysis and compare them with the available bibliographical data. For 14 enteroclysis examinations, the dose-area product (DAP) meter readings, fluoroscopy time, number of radiographs and exposure data were recorded. From these data, the fluoroscopy and radiography contributions to DAP, the entrance surface dose (ESD) and the effective dose (E) for each examination were estimated. The mean DAP was 81 Gy cm(2) and the mean fluoroscopy time was 19.5 min. The fluoroscopy contribution to DAP was 77% and 8.7 films were acquired in each examination on average. The mean ESD and E were estimated to be 428 mGy and 21 mSv, respectively. The mean DAP and fluoroscopy time calculated in this study are quite high when compared with those reported in the literature, suggesting that the examination technique should be reviewed and the ways to reduce patient exposure without compromising the diagnostic quality should be acquired.     

Entrance radiation doses during paediatric cardiac catheterisations performed for diagnosis or the treatment of congenital heart disease

The purpose of this study was to estimate the radiation exposure of children, during cardiac catheterisations for the diagnosis or treatment of congenital heart disease. Radiation doses were estimated for 45 children aged from 1 d to 13 y old. Thermoluminescent dosemeters (TLDs) were used to estimate the posterior entrance dose (DP), the lateral entrance dose (DLAT), the thyroid dose and the gonads dose. A dose-area product (DAP) meter was also attached externally to the tube of the angiographic system and gave a direct value in mGy cm2 for each procedure. Posterior and lateral entrance dose values during cardiac catheterisations ranged from 1 to 197 mGy and from 1.1 to 250.3 mGy, respectively. Radiation exposure to the thyroid and the gonads ranged from 0.3 to 8.4 mGy to 0.1 and 0.7 mGy, respectively. Finally, the DAP meter values ranged between 360 and 33,200 mGy cm2. Radiation doses measured in this study are comparable with those reported to previous studies. Moreover, strong correlation was found between the DAP values and the entrance radiation dose measured with TLDs.     

Radiation doses to patients undergoing enteroclysis

Enteroclysis is a minimally invasive radiographic examination of the small intestine. During the procedure, considerable radiation dose is delivered to the patients. This study intends to: (a) evaluate the radiation dose to the patient using thermoluminescent dosemeters (TLDs, according to the protocol used at Radiology Department, University Hospital of Larissa, Greece; (b) estimate the thyroid surface dose (TSD) and doses to some radiosensitive organs located in the irradiation field. A total of 46 patients was examined. Patients were divided into two groups according to the digital X-ray machine used. The mean entrance surface dose (ESD) was 601.2 ± 96.2 mGy and the mean fluoroscopy time was 8.5 ± 3 min, while the mean TSD was 0.34 ± 0.6 mGy. The ESD for group A was lower by 20 % than group B due to fluoroscopic mode used. The dose values were higher than those in the literature. A local diagnostic reference level was introduced for further patient dose optimisation.     

Comparison of radiation dose to patient and staff for two interventional cardiology units: a phantom study

The purpose of this investigation was to measure the patient and staff dose during routine interventional cardiology procedures for an image intensifier-based and a flat detector system using a water phantom. The Integris BH3000 image intensifier-based (Philips) and the Axiom Artis flat detector-based (Siemens) angiography units were used in this study. The accuracy of tubes potential and irradiation timers and also internal dosimeters were verified and confirmed. A water phantom with a thickness of 18 cm was used for patient and staff dose measurements. For the Philips system, phantom entrance dose rates were 2.77 and 38.97 microGym(2) s(-1) during fluoroscopy and cineangiography. The respective dose rates for the Siemens were 1.98 and 13.46 microGym(2) s(-1). Phantom entrance dose rate was 28.5 and 65% higher for the Philips system during fluoroscopy and cineangiography, respectively. Comparing the scattered dose rates at the operator location showed that the flat detector-based Siemens system delivers five times lower dose to the operator in comparison with the image intensifier-based Philips unit. The results suggest that the decrease in received dose of the patient and staff is achievable using the flat detector system. In addition, application of lead curtain and glass is recommended to lower the cardiologist dose especially for the image intensifier-based Philips system.     

Patient dose in interventional radiology: a European survey

Patient doses for a few common fluoroscopy-guided procedures in interventional radiology (IR) (excluding cardiology) were collected from a few radiological departments in 13 European countries. The major aim was to evaluate patient doses for the basis of the reference levels. In total, data for 20 procedures for about 1300 patients were collected. There were many-fold variations in the number of IR equipment and procedures per population, in the entrance dose rates, and in the patient dose data (total dose area product or DAP, fluoroscopy time and number of frames). There was no clear correlation between the total DAP and entrance dose rate, or between the total DAP and fluoroscopy time, indicating that a number of parameters affect the differences. Because of the limited number of patients, preliminary reference levels were proposed only for a few procedures. There is a need to improve the optimisation of IR procedures and their definitions and grouping, in order to account for their different complexities.     

A study on the radiation dose of the orthopaedic surgeon and staff from a mini C-arm fluoroscopy unit

In this study, radiation exposure to the surgeon and supporting staff from a mini C-arm unit during fluoroscopically guided orthopaedic surgeries was studied. A Diadose dosemeter and Gamma-Scout meter were used for air-kerma measurements for primary and scattered radiations. The entrance dose of hands, eyes and thyroid of the surgeon was measured during direct observation. Scattered air-kerma rate was measured to quantify the received entrance dose of the supporting staff. During direct observation, the skin-entrance exposure rates of the surgeon's hand, eye and thyroid gland were 8036, 0.85 and 0.9 microGy min(-1), respectively. The scattered exposure rate was precipitously dropped beyond the path of the primary radiation beam, and reached 0.51 microGy min(-1) at a distance of 40 cm from the beam's central axis. This study showed that the surgeon's hand was the most dose-limiting organ for fluoroscopically guided orthopaedic surgery procedures when it was exposed to primary radiation. The exposure of supporting staff at a working distance of >20 cm from the beam was minimal during fluoroscopy by mini C-arm unit.     

First results on patient dose measurements from conventional diagnostic radiology procedures in Serbia and Montenegro

The objective of this work is to assess patient doses for the most frequent X-ray examinations for the first time in Serbia and Montenegro. A total of 510 procedures for 11 different examination categories in 3 general hospitals were analysed. Mean and median entrance surface air kerma (ESAK) and kerma area product (KAP) values followed by mean effective doses were reported. Using X-ray tube output data, ESAK for each radiographic examination was calculated, as well as the effective dose for each patient. Except for chest PA examination, all estimated doses are less than stated European and International Atomic Energy Agency (IAEA) reference levels for simple radiographic examinations. For complex examinations involving fluoroscopy and radiography total KAP was measured and contributions from fluoroscopy and radiography were assessed. The study of KAP confirms that the dose level for complex fluoroscopy investigations is closely related to the technique and individual patient variation in terms of fluoroscopy time and number of radiography exposures. The obtained values are comparable to those reported in the UK. Survey data are aimed aid development of a national quality control and radiation protection programme for medical exposures.     

Variation in radiation doses in paediatric cardiac catheterisation procedures

Paediatric cardiac catheterisation involves diagnostic and therapeutic procedures that range from simple to complex and can subject paediatric patients to varying radiation doses. The study aims to determine the variation in entrance doses in patients in terms of dose-area product (DAP) values and to investigate the methods for optimising radiation protection. A total of 190 paediatric patients belonging to age groups 0, 1, 5 and 10 y who underwent diagnostic and six selected therapeutic procedures at King Faisal Specialist Hospital and Research Centre, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia were included in the study. Therapeutic procedures include coarctation (COA), patent ductus arteriosus (PDA), radiofrequency ablation, pulmonary, embolisation and septostomy. Fluoroscopy and cine radiography were used in all procedures. Patient demography (weight, age, gender and height), radiographic technique factors, fluoroscopy and cine time, frame rate, and DAP values were taken from patients records. Effective doses for each procedure were estimated from the DAP values. The mean DAP per procedure were analysed for correlation with patient equivalent cylindrical diameter, weight, fluoroscopy time and number of frames. Factors influencing the variation in doses were investigated. Initial results show that PDA occlusion has the highest mean DAP value of 23.21 Gy-cm(2), while the diagnostic and septostomy procedures have the lowest value of 7.77 and 6.95 Gy-cm(2), respectively.     

Population dose from medical diagnostic exposure in Taiwan

Medical exposure showed a continuous increasing trend. This trend was due to the growth of diagnostic procedures such as computed tomography (CT) and interventional fluoroscopy (IVF). In the present work, results of a recent study on medical exposure in Taiwan are reported. This study analysed data from the National Health Insurance Research Database. Surveyed data on the dose indices, including the entrance surface dose in radiography, dose area product in fluoroscopy, CT dose index in CT and mean glandular dose in mammography, were applied. Using programmes and databases, dose indices were converted to the effective dose. For the year 2008, individual effective doses in Taiwan were estimated as 0.16, 0.37, 0.12 and 0.12 mSv for conventional radiography and fluoroscopy, CT, IVF and nuclear medicine, respectively. The total collective effective dose and the effective dose per individual for medical exposure were 17 788 person-Sv and 0.77 mSv, respectively.     

Assessment of performance of a new digital image intensifier fluoroscopy system

The aim of this study is to assess the physical properties of a recently installed digital fluoroscopy unit, Axiom Iconos R200 unit (Siemens, Germany), including image quality and patient dose. Image quality parameters and patient doses were measured at various fields of view (FOV) and frame rates. The entrance surface dose rate (ESDR) was measured using standard 30 x 30 cm(2) polymethylmethacrylate (PMMA) phantom with different thicknesses. The ESDR was measured using a 20 cm PMMA and largest FOV ranged from 1.1 to 8.2 mGy min(-1) for different frame rates available. The low-contrast sensitivity varied from 1.8 to 6.6%, as the limiting spatial resolution changes from 1.25 to 2.24 ln mm(-1) for the different magnifications, frame rates and phantom thicknesses. This study shows the weak points of the standard quality control protocols. The additional image quality and dose assessments revealed the existing potential for optimisation of the system.     

Dose performance evaluation of a charge coupled device and a flat-panel digital fluoroscopy system recently installed in an interventional cardiology laboratory

The purpose of the study was to evaluate the dose performance of a flat-panel (FP) and an image intensifier (II) charge coupled device (CCD) digital fluoroscopy X-ray systems newly installed in an Interventional Cardiology (IC) department. Filter entrance dose rate, detector dose rate (during fluoroscopy) and filter entrance dose per image were measured at 70 cm from the focus using 2 mm copper sheets to mimic normal size patient. Image quality was also evaluated. The patient dose survey included 277 patients, which had either a Coronary Angiography (CA) or a Percutaneous Transluminal Coronary Angioplasty (PTCA). Dose area product (DAP), fluoroscopy time (T) and total number of frames (F) values were also collected. The results showed that both systems performed within international recommendations with the exception of higher cine radiation doses, stressing the fact that neither specific protocols of measurement nor reference values for digital equipment were provided by the official bodies.     

Medical radiation usage and exposures from medical X ray diagnosis in Shandong province of China

Shandong province is situated in the eastern part of China with a population of 88 million. A collaborative survey was conducted in 1999 to investigate the medical radiation usage and the patients' exposures from medical X ray diagnosis in this province. There were three stages in this survey: general survey, sampling survey and dose survey. Patients' entrance surface doses (ESD) were measured using thermoluminescence dosemeters (TLDs) attached to the patient's skin. All the hospitals in this province and 2153 patients were included in this survey. The frequencies of tele- and brachytherapy were 1.450 and 1.685 per 1000 population in 1996 and 1998 respectively. The frequency of diagnostic nuclear medicine was 0.325 and 0.412 per 1000 population in 1996 and 1998 respectively; for therapeutic nuclear medicine, it was 0.015 and 0.021. The total annual frequencies of every type of X ray examination and interventional radiology (IVR) in 1996 and 1998 were 179.8 and 200.0 per 1000 population respectively. The main type of X ray examination was chest fluoroscopy, which made up about 39% of the total. The average entrance surface doses were comparatively high for the examinations of CT, gastrointestinal tract, lumbarspine, urography, angiography, hip and cerebral angiography.     

Survey on performance assessment of cardiac angiography systems

Advances in imaging technology have facilitated the development of increasingly complex interventional cardiac equipment. Consequently, there is a need for definitive equipment requirements. The aim of the study is to assess the performances of different cardiac angiographic systems. A questionnaire was sent to centres participating in SENTINEL Project to collect dosimetry data (typical entrance dose rate in fluoroscopy and imaging mode), image quality evaluations (low and high contrast resolutions) and KAP calibration factors. Results from this survey could contribute to the explanation of patient dose variability in angiographic cardiac procedures and to derive reference levels for cardiac angiographic equipment performance parameters.     

Comparison of operator radiation exposure between C-arm and O-arm fluoroscopy for orthopaedic surgery

The O-arm system has recently been introduced and has the capability of combined two-dimensional (2-D) fluoroscopy imaging and three-dimensional computed tomography imaging. In this study, an orthopaedic surgical procedure using C-arm and O-arm systems in their 2-D fluoroscopy modes was simulated and the radiation doses to susceptible organs to which operators can be exposed were investigated. The experiments were performed in four configurations of the location of the X-ray source and detector. Shielding effects on the thyroid surface and the direct exposure delivered to the surgeon's hands were also compared. The results obtained show that the O-arm delivered higher doses to the sensitive organs of the operator in all configurations. The thyroid shield cut-off 89 % of the dose in the posteroanterior configuration of both imaging systems. Thus, the operators need to pay more attention to managing radiation exposure, especially when using the O-arm system.     

Entrance surface, organ and effective doses for some of the patients undergoing different types of X ray procedures in Bangladesh

Entrance surface doses (ESDs) were measured for the most common types of X ray procedures, such as chest PA, lumber spine AP, lumber spine lateral, skull AP, skull lateral and pelvis AP in four major hospitals of Dhaka, the capital city of Bangladesh. Organ/tissue doses for 29 organs/tissues and effective doses for the patients were also calculated using the entrance surface dose as the input quantity. Organ/tissue doses and effective doses were calculated by using XDOSE software based on the Monte Carlo computation method. It was observed that the fluctuation of the entrance surface dose was too large. The ratio of maximum and minimum ESD values ranged from 4.8 to 35.9. Consequently, variation of organ doses was large even in the same type of X ray examination and in the same facility. Mean effective doses for the above mentioned X ray procedures were also determined and compared with the effective doses of some other countries. In most cases effective doses measured for the different types of X ray procedures were found to be lower than the effective doses of some other countries.