The arterivirus nsp4 protease is the prototype of a novel group of chymotrypsin-like enzymes, the 3C-like serine proteases

The replicase of equine arteritis virus, an arterivirus, is processed by at least three viral proteases. Comparative sequence analysis suggested that nonstructural protein 4 (Nsp4) is a serine protease (SP) that shares properties with chymotrypsin-like enzymes belonging to two different groups. The SP was predicted to utilize the canonical His-Asp-Ser catalytic triad found in classical chymotrypsin-like proteases. On the other hand, its putative substrate-binding region contains Thr and His residues, which are conserved in viral 3C-like cysteine proteases and determine their specificity for (Gln/Glu) downward arrow(Gly/Ala/Ser) cleavage sites. The replacement of the members of the predicted catalytic triad (His-1103, Asp-1129, and Ser-1184) confirmed their indispensability. The putative role of Thr-1179 and His-1199 in substrate recognition was also supported by the results of mutagenesis. A set of conserved candidate cleavage sites, strikingly similar to junctions cleaved by 3C-like cysteine proteases, was identified. These were tested by mutagenesis and expression of truncated replicase proteins. The results support a replicase processing model in which the SP cleaves multiple Glu downward arrow(Gly/Ser/Ala) sites. Collectively, our data characterize the arterivirus SP as a representative of a novel group of chymotrypsin-like enzymes, the 3C-like serine proteases.     

Structure of the human cytomegalovirus protease catalytic domain reveals a novel serine protease fold and catalytic triad

Proteolytic processing of capsid assembly protein precursors by herpesvirus proteases is essential for virion maturation. A 2.5 A crystal structure of the human cytomegalovirus protease catalytic domain has been determined by X-ray diffraction. The structure defines a new class of serine protease with respect to global-fold topology and has a catalytic triad consisting of Ser-132, His-63, and His-157 in contrast with the Ser-His-Asp triads found in other serine proteases. However, catalytic machinery for activating the serine nucleophile and stabilizing a tetrahedral transition state is oriented similarly to that for members of the trypsin-like and subtilisin-like serine protease families. Formation of the active dimer is mediated primarily by burying a helix of one protomer into a deep cleft in the protein surface of the other.     

Cold-active serine alkaline protease from the psychrotrophic bacterium Shewanella strain ac10: gene cloning and enzyme purification and characterization

The gene encoding serine alkaline protease (SapSh) of the psychrotrophic bacterium Shewanella strain Ac10 was cloned in Escherichia coli. The amino acid sequence deduced from the 2,442-bp nucleotide sequence revealed that the protein was 814 amino acids long and had an estimated molecular weight of 85,113. SapSh exhibited sequence similarities with members of the subtilisin family of proteases, and there was a high level of conservation in the regions around a putative catalytic triad consisting of Asp-30, His-65, and Ser-369. The amino acid sequence contained the following regions which were assigned on the basis of homology to previously described sequences: a signal peptide (26 residues), a propeptide (117 residues), and an extension up to the C terminus (about 250 residues). Another feature of SapSh is the fact that the space between His-65 and Ser-369 is approximately 150 residues longer than the corresponding spaces in other proteases belonging to the subtilisin family. SapSh was purified to homogeneity from the culture supernatant of E. coli recombinant cells by affinity chromatography with a bacitracin-Sepharose column. The recombinant SapSh (rSapSh) was found to have a molecular weight of about 44,000 and to be highly active in the alkaline region (optimum pH, around 9.0) when azocasein and synthetic peptides were used as substrates. rSapSh was characterized by its high levels of activity at low temperatures; it was five times more active than subtilisin Carlsberg at temperatures ranging from 5 to 15 degreesC. The activation energy for hydrolysis of azocasein by rSapSh was much lower than the activation energy for hydrolysis of azocasein by the subtilisin. However, rSapSh was far less stable than the subtilisin.     

Extremely thermostable serine-type protease from Aquifex pyrophilus. Molecular cloning, expression, and characterization

A gene encoding a serine-type protease has been cloned from Aquifex pyrophilus using a sequence tag containing the consensus sequence of proteases as a probe. Sequence analysis of the cloned gene reveals an open reading frame of 619 residues that has three canonical residues (Asp-140, His-184, and Ser-502) that form the catalytic site of serine-type proteases. The size of the mature form (43 kDa) and its localization in the cell wall fraction indicate that both the NH2- and COOH-terminal sequences of the protein are processed during maturation. When the cloned gene is expressed in Escherichia coli, it is weakly expressed as active and processed forms. The pH optimum of this protease is very broad, and its activity is completely inactivated by phenylmethylsulfonyl fluoride. The half-life of the protein is 6 h at 105 degreesC, suggesting that it is one of the most heat-stable proteases. The cysteine residues in the mature form may form disulfide bonds that are responsible for the strong stability of this protease, because the thermostability of the protein is significantly reduced in the presence of reducing reagent.     

A Ni2+ binding motif is the basis of high affinity transport of the Alcaligenes eutrophus nickel permease

Amino acid exchanges in the Alcaligenes eutrophus nickel permease (HoxN) were constructed by site-directed mutagenesis, and their effects on nickel ion uptake were investigated. Mutant hoxN alleles were expressed in Escherichia coli, and activity of the altered permeases was examined via a recently described physiological assay (Wolfram, L., Friedrich, B., and Eitinger, T. (1995) J. Bacteriol. 177, 1840-1843). Replacement of Cys-37, Cys-256, or Cys-318 by alanine did not severely affect nickel ion uptake. This activity of a C331A mutant was diminished by 60%, and a similar phenotype was obtained with a cysteine-less mutant harboring four Cys to Ala exchanges. Alterations in a histidine-containing sequence motif (His-62, Asp-67, His-68), which is conserved in microbial nickel transport proteins, strongly affected or completely abolished transport activity in the E. coli system. The analysis of HoxN alkaline phosphatase fusion proteins implied that His-62, Asp-67, and His-68 exchanges did not interfere with overall membrane topology or stability of the nickel permease. These mutations were reintroduced into the A. eutrophus wild-type strain. Analyses of the resulting HoxN mutants indicated that exchanges in the histidine motif led to a clearly decreased affinity of the permease for nickel ion.     

Characterization and functional analysis of the cis-autoproteolysis active center of glycosylasparaginase

Glycosylasparaginase is an N-terminal nucleophile hydrolase and is activated by intramolecular autoproteolytic processing. This cis-autoproteolysis possesses unique kinetics characterized by a reversible N-O acyl rearrangement step in the processing. Arg-180 and Asp-183, involved in binding of the substrate in the mature enzyme, are also involved in binding of free amino acids in the partially formed substrate pocket on certain mutant precursors. This binding site is sequestered in the wild-type precursor. Binding of free amino acids on mutant precursors can either inhibit or accelerate their processing, depending on the individual mutants and amino acids. The polypeptide sequence at the processing site, which is highly conserved, adopts a special conformation. Asp-151 is essential for maintaining this conformation, possibly by anchoring its side chain into the partially formed substrate pocket through interaction with Arg-180. The reactive nucleophile Thr-152 is activated not only by deprotonation by His-150 but also by interaction with Thr-170, suggesting a His-Thr-Thr active triad for the autoproteolysis.     

Unique fold and active site in cytomegalovirus protease

Human herpesviruses are responsible for a variety of diseases. They are divided into three subfamilies: alpha includes herpes simplex viruses (HSV-1 and HSV-2) and varicella-zoster virus (VZV); beta includes cytomegalovirus (CMV) and human herpesvirus-6 (HHV-6); and gamma includes Epstein-Barr virus (EBV). Each virus encodes a serine protease that is essential for its replication and is a potential target for therapeutic intervention. Human CMV is a ubiquitous opportunistic pathogen that can result in life-threatening infections in congenitally infected infants, immunocompromised individuals and immunosuppressed cancer or transplant patients. Here we report the crystal structure of human CMV protease at 2.5 angstroms resolution. The structure reveals a fold that has not been reported for any other serine protease, and an active site consisting of a novel catalytic triad in which the third member is a histidine instead of an aspartic acid, or possibly a catalytic tetrad consisting of a serine, two histidines and an aspartic acid. An unusual dimer interface that is important to the protease activity has also been identified.     

Binding of different divalent cations to the active site of avian sarcoma virus integrase and their effects on enzymatic activity

Retroviral integrases (INs) contain two known metal binding domains. The N-terminal domain includes a zinc finger motif and has been shown to bind Zn2+, whereas the central catalytic core domain includes a triad of acidic amino acids that bind Mn2+ or Mg2+, the metal cofactors required for enzymatic activity. The integration reaction occurs in two distinct steps; the first is a specific endonucleolytic cleavage step called "processing," and the second is a polynucleotide transfer or "joining" step. Our previous results showed that the metal preference for in vitro activity of avian sarcoma virus IN is Mn2+ > Mg2+ and that a single cation of either metal is coordinated by two of the three critical active site residues (Asp-64 and Asp-121) in crystals of the isolated catalytic domain. Here, we report that Ca2+, Zn2+, and Cd2+ can also bind in the active site of the catalytic domain. Furthermore, two zinc and cadmium cations are bound at the active site, with all three residues of the active site triad (Asp-64, Asp-121, and Glu-157) contributing to their coordination. These results are consistent with a two-metal mechanism for catalysis by retroviral integrases. We also show that Zn2+ can serve as a cofactor for the endonucleolytic reactions catalyzed by either the full-length protein, a derivative lacking the N-terminal domain, or the isolated catalytic domain of avian sarcoma virus IN. However, polynucleotidyl transferase activities are severely impaired or undetectable in the presence of Zn2+. Thus, although the processing and joining steps of integrase employ a similar mechanism and the same active site triad, they can be clearly distinguished by their metal preferences.     

Mutagenesis of the NS3 protease of dengue virus type 2

The flavivirus protease is composed of two viral proteins, NS2B and NS3. The amino-terminal portion of NS3 contains sequence and structural motifs characteristic of bacterial and cellular trypsin-like proteases. We have undertaken a mutational analysis of the region of NS3 which contains the catalytic serine, five putative substrate binding residues, and several residues that are highly conserved among flavivirus proteases and among all serine proteases. In all, 46 single-amino-acid substitutions were created in a cloned NS2B-NS3 cDNA fragment of dengue virus type 2, and the effect of each mutation on the extent of self-cleavage of the NS2B-NS3 precursor at the NS2B-NS3 junction was assayed in vivo. Twelve mutations almost completely or completely inhibited protease activity, 9 significantly reduced it, 14 decreased cleavage, and 11 yielded wild-type levels of activity. Substitution of alanine at ultraconserved residues abolished NS3 protease activity. Cleavage was also inhibited by substituting some residues that are conserved among flavivirus NS3 proteins. Two (Y150 and G153) of the five putative substrate binding residues could not be replaced by alanine, and only Y150 and N152 could be replaced by a conservative change. The two other putative substrate binding residues, D129 and F130, were more freely substitutable. By analogy with the trypsin model, it was proposed that D129 is located at the bottom of the substrate binding pocket so as to directly interact with the basic amino acid at the substrate cleavage site. Interestingly, we found that significant cleavage activity was displayed by mutants in which D129 was replaced by E, S, or A and that low but detectable protease activity was exhibited by mutants in which D129 was replaced by K, R, or L. Contrary to the proposed model, these results indicate that D129 is not a major determinant of substrate binding and that its interaction with the substrate, if it occurs at all, is not essential. This mutagenesis study provided us with an array of mutations that alter the cleavage efficiency of the dengue virus protease. Mutations that decrease protease activity without abolishing it are candidates for introduction into the dengue virus infectious full-length cDNA clone with the aim of creating potentially attenuated virus stocks.     

An intact conformation at the tip of elongation factor G domain IV is functionally important

Three variants of Thermus thermophilus EF-G with mutations in the loop at the distal end of its domain IV were obtained. The replacement of His-573 by Ala and double mutation H573A/D576A did not influence the functional activity of EF-G. On the other hand, the insertion of six amino acids into the loop between residues Asp-576 and Ser-577 reduced the translocational activity of EF-G markedly, while its GTPase activity was not affected. It is concluded that the native conformation of the loop is important for the factor-promoted translocation in the ribosome. The functional importance of the entire EF-G domain IV is discussed.     

Bacteriolytic activity and specificity of Achromobacter beta-lytic protease

Achromobacter beta-lytic protease (blp), one of the bacteriolytic proteases secreted by Achromobacter lyticus, exhibited both peptidase and bacteriolytic activities at alkaline pH. The protease was strongly inhibited by 1,10-phenanthroline, and one zinc atom was detected in the molecule by ion-spray mass spectrometry. The zinc-protease specifically cleaved Gly-X bonds in peptides and possibly possessed subsites S2, S1, S1', and S2' for binding substrate [Schecter, I. and Berger, A. (1967) Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 27, 157-162]. Blp lysed Staphylococcus aureus and Micrococcus luteus cells more efficiently than Achromobacter alpha-lytic protease (alp) and lysozyme, thus being responsible for the high bacteriolytic activity of A. lyticus. In the lysis of bacterial cell walls, blp hydrolyzed both the D-Ala-Gly/Ala bond at the linkage between the peptide subunit and the interpeptide and the Gly-Gly bond in the interpeptide bridge. These results indicate that blp is a highly active bacteriolytic enzyme with a broad bacteriolytic spectrum, which acts primarily by splitting the linkage between the peptide subunit and the interpeptide in the peptidoglycan.     

Three-dimensional stereotactic posterior ischiorectal space computerized tomography guided brachytherapy of prostate cancer: a preliminary report

We reported recently that protein D2 (OprD) porin of Pseudomonas aeruginosa bears protease activity (FEBS Letters 394, 179-182, 1996). To identify the catalytic residues of OprD, we introduced the site-directed mutations replacing the putative catalytic triad His156, Asp208, and Ser296 with glutamine, asparagine, and alanine, respectively. The OprD proteins purified from the chromosomal oprD-deficient mutants harboring the plasmids encoding the site-directed mutations showed protease activity less than 0.1% of that of the wild-type OprD. These site-directed mutageneses caused undetectable changes in the pore-forming activity of OprD as measured by single-channel conductance by the planar lipid bilayer. The minimum inhibitory concentration of imipenem in mutants having the replaced catalytic triads was identical with that in the wild-type strain. On the other hand, introduction of the mutation at His367 replacing with glutamine, the site that is supposed to be unrelated to the catalytic sites, showed the unchanged protease activity. These results unequivocally demonstrate that OprD is the protease bearing porin and catalyzes the reaction at His156, Asp208, and Ser296 residues.     

The 0.78 A structure of a serine protease: Bacillus lentus subtilisin

Ultrahigh-resolution X-ray diffraction data from cryo-cooled, B. lentus subtilisin crystals has been collected to a resolution of 0.78 A. The refined model coordinates have a rms deviation of 0.22 A relative to the same structure determined at room temperature and 2.0 A resolution. Several regions of main-chain and side-chain disorder have been identified for 21 out of 269 residues in one polypeptide chain. Hydrogen atoms appear as significant peaks in the Fo - Fc difference electron density map, and carbon, nitrogen, and oxygen atoms can be differentiated. The estimated standard deviation (ESD) for all main-chain non-hydrogen bond lengths is 0.009 A and 0.5 degrees for bond angles based on an unrestrained full-matrix least-squares refinement. Hydrogen bonds are resolved in the serine protease catalytic triad (Ser-His-Asp). Electron density is observed for an unusual, short hydrogen bond between aspartic acid and histidine in the catalytic triad. The hydrogen atom, identified by NMR in numerous serine proteases, appears to be shared by the heteroatoms in the bond. This represents the first reported correlation between detailed chemical features identified by NMR and those in a cryo-cooled crystallographic structure determination at ultrahigh resolution. The short hydrogen bond, designated "catalytic hydrogen bond", occurs as part of an elaborate hydrogen bond network, involving Asp of the catalytic triad. While unusual, these features appear to have conserved analogues in other serine protease families although specific details differ from family to family.     

The motor unit potential distribution over the skin surface and its use in estimating the motor unit location

Dextransucrase (DSRS) from Leuconostoc mesenteroides NRRL B-512F is a glucosyltransferase that catalyzes the synthesis of soluble dextran from sucrose or oligosaccharides when acceptor molecules, like maltose, are present. The L. mesenteroides NRRL B-512F dextransucrase-encoding gene (dsrS) was amplified by the polymerase chain reaction and cloned in an overexpression plasmid. The characteristics of DSRS were found to be similar to the characteristics of the extracellular dextransucrase produced by L. mesenteroides NRRL B-512F. The enzyme also exhibited a high homology with other glucosyltransferases. In order to identify critical amino acid residues, the DSRS sequence was aligned with glucosyltransferase sequences and four amino acid residues were selected for site-directed mutagenesis experiments: aspartic acid 511, aspartic acid 513, aspartic acid 551 and histidine 661. Asp-511, Asp-513 and Asp-551 were independently replaced with asparagine and His-661 with arginine. Mutation at Asp-511 and Asp-551 completely suppressed dextran and oligosaccharide synthesis activities, showing that at least two carboxyl groups (Asp-511 and Asp-551) are essential for the catalysis process. However, glucan-binding properties were retained, showing that DSRS has a two-domain structure like other glucosyltransferases. Mutations at Asp-513 and His-661 resulted in greatly reduced dextransucrase activity. According to amino acid sequence alignments of glucosyltransferases, alpha-amylases or cyclodextrin glucanotransferases, His-661 may have a hydrogen-bonding function.     

Variants of tissue-type plasminogen activator which display substantially enhanced stimulation by fibrin

Unlike most proteases, tissue-type plasminogen activator (t-PA) is secreted from cells as an active, single chain "proenzyme" whose catalytic efficiency is comparable with that of the corresponding mature, two-chain enzyme. We have previously suggested that the absence of the "zymogen triad" (Asp194-His40-Ser32; chymotrypsin numbering) contributes to this unusually high enzymatic activity of single chain t-PA. Consistent with this prediction, the single chain form of a variant of t-PA containing the zymogen triad displayed dramatically reduced activity toward synthetic substrates. Activation cleavage of this variant, however, resulted in a mature, two-chain enzyme with full catalytic activity. To further examine the functional significance of the zymogen triad, we used site-specific mutagenesis to construct a variant of t-PA, t-PA/R275E,A292S,F305H, that contained this triad but could not be converted into its two-chain form by plasmin. Characterization of this variant demonstrated that the presence of the zymogen triad specifically suppressed plasminogen activation by single chain t-PA in the absence of fibrin. In addition, these studies indicated that, like wild type t-PA, zymogen activation of this variant could be accomplished by binding to the co-factor fibrin. The combination of full activity in the presence of fibrin and reduced activity in its absence resulted in novel variants of t-PA that displayed dramatically enhanced stimulation by fibrin. While the presence of fibrin increased the catalytic efficiency of t-PA toward plasminogen by a factor of approximately 520, this stimulation factor increased to 130,000 for t-PA/R275E,A292S,F305H. Plasmin-resistant, zymogen-like variants of t-PA, therefore, may represent thrombolytic enzymes with enhanced "clot selectivity."     

Dimerization and activation of the herpes simplex virus type 1 protease

The quaternary state of the herpes simplex virus type 1 (HSV-1) protease has been analyzed in relation to its catalytic activity. The dependence of specific activity upon enzyme concentration indicated that association of the 27-kDa subunits strongly increased activity. Size-exclusion chromatography identified the association as a monomer-dimer equilibrium. Isolation of monomeric and dimeric species from a size-exclusion column followed by immediate assay identified the dimer as the active form of the enzyme. Activation of the protease by antichaotropic cosolvents correlated with changes in the monomer-dimer equilibrium. Thus, dimerization of the enzyme was enhanced in solvents containing glycerol or the anions citrate or phosphate. These are substances previously identified as activators of HSV-1 protease (Hall, D. L., and Darke, P. L. (1995) J. Biol. Chem. 270, 22697-22700). The relative potencies of these cosolvents as enzyme activators correlated with their efficiency in promoting dimerization. Under all solvent conditions examined, the dependence of specific activity upon enzyme concentration was consistent with a kinetic model in which only the dimer is active. Dissociation constants for the HSV-1 protease dimer determined with this model at 15 degrees C, pH 7.5, were 964 and 225 nM in 20% glycerol with 0.2 and 0.5 M citrate present, respectively. The activation of the HSV-1 protease by antichaotropic cosolvents was hereby shown to be similar in nature to the activation of the other well characterized herpesvirus protease, that from human cytomegalovirus.     

Lysine 58 and histidine 66 at the C-terminal alpha-helix of monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 are essential for glycosaminoglycan binding

Monocytes rolling on the endothelial cell layer interact with monocyte chemoattractant protein-1 (MCP-1) that is tethered to the proteoglycans on the luminal side of the endothelial cells and consequently initiate adhesion of monocytes in the early phase of immune response. The amino acid residues in MCP-1 involved in tethering to the proteoglycans have not been elucidated. MCP-1 showed binding to [3H]heparin with a KD of 1.5 microM. We substituted lysine or histidine residues at the C-terminal end of MCP-1 with alanine residues and tested these mutants for their ability to bind heparin, heparan sulfate, hyaluronic acid, and chondroitin sulfate-C. Substitution of Lys-58 or His-66 drastically reduced glycosaminoglycan binding. Substitution of Lys-56 or deletion of the five amino acid residues at the C terminus, including Lys-75, did not alter the heparin binding ability, suggesting that the other lysine residues at the C terminus are not involved in glycosaminoglycan binding. MCP-1 and its mutants did not bind hyaluronic acid as strongly as the other subunits of the GAGs. Substitution of Lys-58 or His-66 by alanine that prevented glycosaminoglycan binding did not affect Ca2+ influx, receptor binding, or chemotactic activity elicited by the chemokine on monocytic THP-1 cells. Therefore, we conclude that the Lys-58 and His-66 residues in the C-terminal alpha-helix of MCP-1 are essential for glycosaminoglycan binding and probably for the binding to the endothelial surface proteoglycans.     

Mechanism of phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C: a unified view of the mechanism of catalysis

The mechanism of phosphatidylinositol-specific phospholipase C (PI-PLC) has been suggested to resemble that of ribonuclease A. The goal of this work is to rigorously evaluate the mechanism of PI-PLC from Bacillus thuringiensis by examining the functional and structural roles of His-32 and His-82, along with the two nearby residues Asp-274 and Asp-33 (which form a hydrogen bond with His-32 and His-82, respectively), using site-directed mutagenesis. In all, twelve mutants were constructed, which, except D274E, showed little structural perturbation on the basis of 1D NMR and 2D NOESY analyses. The H32A, H32N, H32Q, H82A, H82N, H82Q, H82D, and D274A mutants showed a 10(4)-10(5)-fold decrease in specific activity toward phosphatidylinositol; the D274N, D33A, and D33N mutants retained 0. 1-1% activity, whereas the D274E mutant retained 13% activity. Steady-state kinetic analysis of mutants using (2R)-1, 2-dipalmitoyloxypropane-3-(thiophospho-1d-myo-inositol) (DPsPI) as a substrate generally agreed well with the specific activity toward phosphatidylinositol. The results suggest a mechanism in which His-32 functions as a general base to abstract the proton from 2-OH and facilitates the attack of the deprotonated 2-oxygen on the phosphorus atom. This general base function is augmented by the carboxylate group of Asp-274 which forms a diad with His-32. The H82A and D33A mutants showed an unusually high activity with substrates featuring low pKa leaving groups, such as DPsPI and p-nitrophenyl inositol phosphate (NPIPs). These results suggest that His-82 functions as the general acid with assistance from Asp-33, facilitating the departure of the leaving group by protonation of the glycerol O3 oxygen. The Bronsted coefficients obtained for the WT and the D33N mutant indicate a high degree of proton transfer to the leaving group and further underscore the "helper" function of Asp-33. The complete mechanism also includes activation of the phosphate group toward nucleophilic attack by a hydrogen bond between Arg-69 and a nonbridging oxygen atom. The overall mechanism can be described as "complex" general acid-general base since three elements are required for efficient catalysis.     

Mechanism of action of serine proteases: tetrahedral intermediate and concerted proton transfer

Stopped-flow spectrophotometry and proton inventory experiments have been used to define the reaction pathway for hydrolysis of a specific peptide substrate, Ac-L-Ala-L-Pro-L-Ala p-nitroanilide, by the serine proteases elastase and alpha-lytic protease. The stopped-flow studies reveal the existence and buildup of a tetrahedral adduct between the active site serine hydroxyl group and the sensitive carbonyl group of the substrate. The decomposition of this tetrahedral intermediate to the acyl enzyme and p-nitroaniline is the rate-limiting step for the hydrolytic reaction. The proton inventory data suggest the simultaneous transfer of two protons (presumably from the catalytic carboxyl of Asp-102 to N pi of the catalytic imidazole of His-57 and from N pi of the imidazole to the anilide NH) in the transition state leading to breakdown of the tetrahedral complex. That these proton transfers occur in a concerted, rather than stepwise, process attests to the ability of enzymes to lower the enthalpy of activation most effectively when the precise alignment of a highly specific substrate and catalytic groups minimizes the entropy of activation.