Fracture toughness properties of HIC susceptible carbon steels in sour service conditions

Hydrogen Induced Cracking (HIC) in carbon steels is a well-studied mechanism, where diffusing hydrogen atoms accumulates at the steel imperfections/laminations to create gaseous hydrogen with very high pressure, leading to initiation and growth of internal cavities, so-called HIC. Measurements of relevant fracture toughness properties of non-HIC resistant steels in hydrogen environment is critical to predict and assess the initiation and growth of HIC. The present work attempts to quantify the effect of hydrogen on the fracture toughness properties (K_Q and CTOD) of an API X42 pipeline steel under simulated H₂S in-service conditions. The fracture toughness properties are measured in TL and SL directions: perpendicular and parallel to the pipeline wall thickness, respectively, following ASTM E1820, standard. Since the X42 is a non-HIC resistant steel, the measurement of the fracture toughness properties in the SL direction is more relevant in terms of HIC initiation and growth than fracture toughness properties in the TL direction. Indeed, parallel to the thickness of the pipeline wall, X42 steel shows microstructural features prone to HIC formation and growth. Steady state H₂S in-service conditions were simulated by charging the specimen for 48 h using a special electrolytic solution and then tested (ex-situ) to evaluate the fracture toughness properties. The steady state H₂S environment was obtained by measuring the Hydrogen Concentration (CH) in the bulk of the specimen, using Thermal desorption Spectroscopy at three levels of CH. It was observed that the K_Q was not affected in the SL direction, while it was reduced in the TL direction for 1.5 ppmw of CH. The CTOD showed mixed results in the TL direction while it was significantly reduced in the SL direction reaching a saturation at 1 ppmw of CH. Besides, microstructural analyses showed that the presence of inclusions coalescence in form of dimples promote the early failure, which is more pronounced in the hydrogen environment especially at higher levels of CH.     

Hydrogen effect on a low carbon ferritic-bainitic pipeline steel

Hydrogen effect on an API 5L X65 low carbon ferritic-bainitic steel is investigated, by evaluating the fracture toughness parameters in air and in hydrogen environment. The hydrogen environment is manifested by in situ hydrogen charging of the X65 steel, using the electrolytic solution NS4, which simulates the electrolyte trapped between the pipeline steel and the coating in a buried pipeline. The fracture toughness results of the X65 are compared to two other pipeline steels with different microstructures, namely an X52 and an X70, possessing a banded ferritic-pearlitic and banded ferritic-mixed bainitic-pearlitic microstructure, respectively. The X65 steel exhibits significant reduction of fracture toughness parameter J₀ integral due to hydrogen charging and insignificant variation of fracture toughness parameter K_Q. Comparing the three steels, the lowest reduction of J₀ integral due to hydrogen charging, is met on the X52 and the highest in the X65.     

Hydrogen embrittlement of super duplex stainless steel in acid solution

Super duplex stainless steel (SDSS) is a good choice of material when resistance to harsh environments is needed. Despite the material’s excellent corrosion resistance and high strength, a number of in-service failures have been recorded. The root cause of these failures was environmentally induced cracking initiated at manufacturing and in-service metallurgical defects. In this study the hydrogen embrittlement of pre-strained super duplex stainless steel specimens was investigated after 48 h cathodic charging in 0.1 M H₂SO₄. The metallurgical changes that resulted from four levels of cold work (4, 8, 12, and 16% plastic strain) were considered and their effect on the embrittlement of the SDSS alloy was investigated. After hydrogen charging, the specimens were pulled immediately to failure and the mechanical properties evaluated. The obtaining fracture morphology was investigated using low and high magnification microscopy. Experimental results indicated that charging the super duplex stainless steel alloy with hydrogen caused varying degrees of embrittlement depending on cold work level. Increasing cold work resulted in a reduction of the elongation to failure. Microscopic investigation confirmed the significant effect of cold work on the hydrogen embrittlement susceptibility of the super duplex stainless steel alloy investigated.     

Effect of low partial hydrogen in a mixture with methane on the mechanical properties of X70 pipeline steel

In this study, the effect of a low partial hydrogen in a mixture with natural gas on the tensile, notched tensile properties, and fracture toughness of pipeline steel X70 is investigated. An artificial HE aging is simulated by exposing the tested sample to the mixture gas condition for 720 h. In addition, a series of tests is conducted in ambient air and 10 MPa of 100% He and H₂. Overall, 10 MPa of 100% H₂ significantly degrades the mechanical properties of an X70 pipeline steel. However, it is observed that the 10 MPa gas mixture with 1% H₂ does not affect the mechanical properties when tested with a smooth tensile specimen. In the notched tensile test, a significant reduction in loss in the area is observed when tested with a notched specimen with a notch radius of 0.083 mm. It is also confirmed that a 10-MPa gas mixture with 1% H₂ causes a remarkable reduction in the toughness. The influence of the exposure time to 1% hydrogen in a mixture with natural gas was found to be minor.     

Hydrogen effect on fracture toughness of pipeline steel welds, with in situ hydrogen charging

The API 5L X70 and X52 pipeline steel weld fracture toughness parameters are measured in a hydrogen environment and compared to the ones in air. The hydrogen environment is created by in situ hydrogen charging, using as an electrolyte a simulated soil solution, with three current densities, namely 1, 5 and 10 mA/cm². A specially designed electrolytic cell mounted onto a three-point bending arrangement is used and hydrogen charging is performed during the monotonic loading of the specimens. Ductility is measured in terms of the J₀ integral. In all cases a slight change in toughness was measured in terms of K_Q. Reduction of ductility in the base metal is observed, which increases with increasing current density. A more complex phenomenon is observed in the heat affected zone metal, where a small reduction in ductility is observed for the two current densities (1 and 5 mA/cm²) and a larger reduction for the third case (10 mA/cm²). Regarding microstructure of tested X70 and X52 base and HAZ metal, it is observed that the hydrogen degradation effect is enhanced in banded ferrite-pearlite formations. The aforementioned procedure is used for calculating the fracture toughness parameters of a through-thickness pipeline crack.     

Hydrogen induced blister cracking and mechanical failure in X65 pipeline steels

The present work aims to investigate the role of hydrogen induced blisters cracking on degradation of tensile and fatigue properties of X65 pipeline steel. Both tensile and fatigue specimens were electrochemically charged with hydrogen at 20 mA/cm² for a period of 4 h. Hydrogen charging resulted in hydrogen induced cracking (HIC) and blister formation throughout the specimen surface. Nearly all the blisters formed during hydrogen charging showed blister wall cracking (BWC). Inclusions mixed in Al-Si-O were found to be the potential sites for HIC and BWC. Slow strain rate tensile (SSRT) test followed by fractographic analysis confirmed significant hydrogen embrittlement (HE) susceptibility of X65 steel. Short fatigue crack growth framework, on the other hand, specifically highlighted the role of BWC on accelerated crack growth in the investigated material. Coalescence of propagating short fatigue crack with BWC resulted in rapid increase in the crack length and reduced the number of cycles for crack propagation to the equivalent crack length.     

Comprehensive study on hydrogen induced cracking of electrical resistance welded API X52 pipeline steel

Different heat treatment cycles were designed in order to investigate the effect of microstructural changes on hydrogen induced cracking resistance (HIC) and mechanical properties of the electric resistance welded steel. The heat treating of the as-welded specimen improved the ductility and impact toughness. After heat treatment, the uniform hardness profile was obtained for the welded specimens. The removal of local hard zones reduced the risk of HIC. The chemical composition and clustering of inclusions have a deleterious effect on cracking resistance in the H₂S environment. Aluminosilicate compounds and MnS inclusions were favorite sites for HIC. The most promising post weld heat treatment for improving mechanical properties and the resistance to HIC was the application of two-cycle quenching followed by tempering.     

Effects of hydrogen-charging on the susceptibility of X100 pipeline steel to hydrogen-induced cracking

In this work, the hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) behavior of X100 pipeline steel was investigated by a combination of tensile test, electrochemical hydrogen permeation measurement and surface characterization techniques. The effect of inclusions in the steel on the crack initiation was analyzed. Results demonstrated that the amount of hydrogen-charging into the X100 steel specimen increases with the charging time and charging current density. Hydrogen-charging will enhance the susceptibility of the steel to HIC. The cracks initiate primarily at inclusions, such as aluminum oxides, titanium oxides and ferric carbides, in the steel. The diffusivity of hydrogen at room temperature in X100 steel is determined to be 1.04 × 10⁻⁸ cm²/s.     

Specimen thickness effect on the property of hydrogen embrittlement in single edge notch tension testing of high strength pipeline steel

In the study, hydrogen effects on the fracture toughness of an API X90 pipeline steel are investigated considering specimen thickness effects. It is found that the embrittlement of fracture increases with thickness for the hydrogenated specimens. The fracture toughness of hydrogen-free specimens are about 2.9, 5.2 and 11.6 times larger than the hydrogenated ones for B/W = 0.5, 1 and 2, respectively. Digital image correlation (DIC) measurement indicates that as the specimen thickness increases, hydrogen deteriorates drastically the plasticity in the vicinity of the crack tip. A remarkably low dislocation density is observed, indicating hydrogen atom has great influence on the cohesive energy, rather than the dislocation pile-ups. Finally, it is concluded that hydrogen enhanced decohesion (HEDE) mechanism is responsible for the high hydrogen sensitivity to the specimen thickness.     

Hydrogen effects on X80 pipeline steel in high-pressure natural gas/hydrogen mixtures

Blending hydrogen into existing natural gas pipelines has been proposed as a means of increasing the output of renewable energy systems such as large wind farms. X80 pipeline steel is commonly used for transporting natural gas and such steel is subjected to concurrent hydrogen invasion with mechanical loading while being exposed to hydrogen containing environments directly, resulting in hydrogen embrittlement (HE). In accordance with American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM) standards, the mechanical properties of X80 pipeline steel have been tested in natural gas/hydrogen mixtures with 0, 5.0, 10.0, 20.0 and 50.0vol% hydrogen at the pressure of 12 MPa. Results indicate that X80 pipeline steel is susceptible to hydrogen-induced embrittlement in natural gas/hydrogen mixtures and the HE susceptibility increases with the hydrogen partial pressure. Additionally, the HE susceptibility depends on the textured microstructure caused by hot rolling, especially for the notch specimen. The design calculation by the measured fatigue data reveals that the fatigue life of the X80 steel pipeline is dramatically degraded by the added hydrogen.     

Effects of CH4 and CO on hydrogen embrittlement susceptibility of X80 pipeline steel in hydrogen blended natural gas

The slow strain rate tensile experiments are carried out to investigate the tensile properties of X80 pipeline steel in hydrogen blended natural gas environments with different H₂/CH₄/CO contents. Mechanical properties and fracture morphologies are further analyzed. The results show that the hydrogen embrittlement susceptibility of X80 steel can be inhibited by the presence of CH₄/CO, and the inhibition mechanisms are discussed. When the CH₄ contents increase above 20 vol%, the inhibition on hydrogen embrittlement of X80 steel is stabilized. By comparison, the inhibitory effect of CO is more significant.     

Hydrogen related degradation in pipeline steel: A review

To support our increasing energy demand, steel pipelines are deployed in transporting oil and natural gas resources for long distances. However, numerous steel structures experience catastrophic failures due to the evolution of hydrogen from their service environments initiated by corrosion reactions and/or cathodic protection. This process results in deleterious effect on the mechanical strength of these ferrous steel structures and their principal components. The major sources of hydrogen in offshore/subsea pipeline installations are moisture as well as molecular water reduction resulting from cathodic protection. Hydrogen induced cracking comes into effect as a synergy of hydrogen concentration and stress level on susceptible steel materials, leading to severe hydrogen embrittlement (HE) scenarios. This usually manifests in the form of induced-crack episodes, e.g., hydrogen induced cracking (HIC), stress-oriented hydrogen induced cracking (SOHIC) and sulfide stress corrosion cracking (SSCC). In this work, we have outlined sources of hydrogen attack as well as their induced failure mechanisms. Several past and recent studies supporting them have also been highlighted in line with understanding of the effect of hydrogen on pipeline steel failure. Different experimental techniques such as Devanathan–Stachurski method, thermal desorption spectrometry, hydrogen microprint technique, electrochemical impedance spectroscopy and electrochemical noise have proven to be useful in investigating hydrogen damage in pipeline steels. This has also necessitated our coverage of relatively comprehensive assessments of the effect of hydrogen on contemporary high-strength pipeline steel processed by thermomechanical controlled rolling. The effect of HE on cleavage planes and/or grain boundaries has prompted in depth crystallographic texture analysis within this work as a very important parameter influencing the corrosion behavior of pipeline steels. More information regarding microstructure and grain boundary interaction effects have been presented as well as the mechanisms of crack interaction with microstructure. Since hydrogen degradation is accompanied by other corrosion-related causes, this review also addresses key corrosion causes affecting offshore pipeline structures fabricated from steel. We have enlisted and extensively discussed several recent corrosion mitigation trials and performance tests in various media at different thermal and pressure conditions.     

Notched-tensile properties under high-pressure gaseous hydrogen: Comparison of pipeline steel X70 and austenitic stainless type 304L, 316L steels

The effect of high-pressure gaseous H₂ on the fracture behavior of pipeline steel X70 and austenitic stainless steel type 304L and 316L was investigated by means of notched-tensile tests at 10 MPa H₂ gas and various test speed. The notch tensile strength of pipeline X70 steel and austenitic stainless steels were degraded by gaseous H₂, and the deterioration was accompanied by noticeable changes in fracture morphology. The loss of notch tensile strength of type 316L and X70 steels was comparable, but type 304L was more susceptible to hydrogen embrittlement than the others. In the X70 steel, hydrogen embrittlement increased as test speed decreased until the test speed reached 1.2 × 10^?3 mm/s, but the effect of test speed was not significant in 304L and 316L steels.     

Microstructure and properties of intercritically reheated coarse-grained heat affected zone in pipeline steel after secondary thermal cycle

As a kind of high strength microalloyed steel, pipeline steel has high strength and toughness. However, the formation of the intercritically reheated coarse-grained heat affected zone (ICCGHAZ) during the welding process is an important limitation affecting its performance. Herein, microstructural transformation in the ICCGHAZ of X100 pipeline steel after a secondary thermal cycle and hydrogen sulfide stress corrosion cracking (SSCC) resistance of the transformed microstructure are investigated. The microstructure of X100 pipeline steel after the secondary thermal cycle is similar to that after the primary thermal cycle, comprising lath bainite and granular bainite. With an increase in t_8/5 (time required for the material to cool from 800 °C to 500 °C), the M-A constituents that continuously precipitate along the prior austenite grain boundaries in the second thermal cycle are coarsened and form a necklace-type structure. A variation in t_8/5 does not significantly affect the crystallographic characteristics of the ICCGHAZ. The stress corrosion test shows that the resistance to SSCC decreases and cleavage fracture characteristics become more noticeable with an increase in t_8/5.     

Strengthening mechanism and hydrogen-induced crack resistance of AISI 316L stainless steel subjected to laser peening at different power densities

Microstructural response of AISI 316L stainless steel to laser peening (LP) was examined by means of optical microscopy (OM) and transmission electron microscopy (TEM) in order to analyze the effects of LP on hydrogen-induced cracking (HIC) resistance. Depth profiles of near-surface microhardness and surface compressive residual stress (CRS) of LP treated specimens were presented respectively. Slow strain rate tensile tests were performed on the hydrogen-charged samples and their corresponding stress-strain curves as well as fracture morphologies were finally investigated in detail. The results demonstrated that LP induced a grain refinement effect on the treated surface while a maximum refining rate of 56.18% was achieved at the laser power density of 10 GW/cm². The near-surface microhardness also exhibited an attenuation trend with the increasing depth. The surface CRS positively correlated with power density before it reached a threshold value. A special U-shaped dislocation tangle band was observed in the LP treated specimen which served as hydrogen trapping sites. The LP treated samples exhibited better toughness after hydrogen charging from both macro mechanical properties and micro fracture morphologies. LP-induced grain refinement and CRS are believed to be the main contributing factors towards inhibiting the diffusion of hydrogen atoms which ultimately leads to the reduction of the hydrogen embrittlement sensitivity of AISI 316L stainless steel.     

Influence of hydrogen on the microstructure and fracture toughness of friction stir welded plates of API 5L X80 pipeline steel

In this work, the influence of hydrogen on the microstructure and fracture toughness of API 5L X80 high strength pipeline steel welded by friction stir welding was assessed. Samples were hydrogenated at room temperature for a duration of 10 h in a solution of 0.1 M H₂SO₄ + 10 mg L⁻¹ As₂O₃, with an intensity current of 20 mA cm⁻². Fracture toughness tests were performed at 0 °C in single-edged notched bending samples, using the Critical Crack Tip Opening Displacement (CTOD) parameter. Notches were positioned in different regions within the joint, such as the stir zone, hard zone, and base material. Hydrogen induces internal stress between bainite packets and ferrite plates within bainite packets. Besides, hydrogen acted as a reducer of the strain capacity of the three zones. The base metal had a moderate capacity to resist stable crack growth, displaying a ductile fracture mechanism. While the hard zone showed a brittle behavior with CTOD values below the acceptance limits for pipeline design (0.1–0.2 mm). The fracture toughness of the stir zone is higher than that of the base metal. Nevertheless, the stir zone displayed higher data dispersion due to its high inhomogeneity. Hence, it can also show a brittle behavior with critical CTOD values.     

Crack propagation analysis of hydrogen embrittlement based on peridynamics

We introduced a coupled peridynamic hydrogen diffusion and fracture model to solve the hydrogen embrittlement fracture of low alloy steel AISI 4340. In this model, the influence of temperature on hydrogen diffusion coefficient is considered, and a new peridynamic constitutive analysis method is used to simulate the crack propagation of hydrogen embrittlement. We verified the model in 3D using the experimental test of the hydrogen embrittlement cracking process of AISI 4340 steel in 0.1 N H₂SO₄ solution from the literature. Considering different ambient temperatures, it is found that the crack propagation is highly similar to the experimental results. Based on the numerical analysis of peridynamics, the model can numerically simulate the hydrogen embrittlement fracture of AISI 4340 steel, and obtain a visual demonstration of the entire process of hydrogen atom diffusion and crack growth.     

Experimental study and numerical simulation on the SSCC in FV520B stainless steel exposed to H2S+Cl− Environment

Constant displacement loading tests using wedge opening loading specimens were carried out in aqueous hydrogen sulfide solution containing sodium chloride to investigate the susceptibility of stress corrosion cracking (SCC) of FV520B precipitation hardening martensitic stainless steel. Results of the SCC tests indicated that the stress corrosion critical stress intensity factor (K_ISCC) dramatically decreased in the corrosion medium investigated and decreased with the increasing of H₂S concentration. Microstructures of fracture surfaces were analyzed using a scanning electron microscope (SEM) with an energy dispersive X-ray spectroscopy (EDS). The fracture surface was typical of sulfide stress corrosion fracture. In addition, large amount of intermittent arc-crack on the side surfaces around the tip of main crack formed even no main crack propagated.A sequentially coupling finite element analysis (FEA) program was utilized to simulate the stress field and calculate the diffused hydrogen concentration distribution of specimen exposed to the corrosion medium investigated. The FEA results indicated that corrosion pit affected the stress and diffusion hydrogen distribution around the corrosion pit where large stress gradients formed. Side surface cracks initiated from those corrosion pits and propagated under the synergy of stress and hydrogen. The effect of the corrosion pit on hydrostatic stress distribution was limited in superficial zone near the side surface, thus side surface cracks propagated along the hoop direction rather than along the direction of specimen thickness. Based on the morphology observation and FEA results, it can be concluded that the SCC mechanism of FV520B steel was hydrogen embrittlement mainly and combination of anodic dissolution. Simultaneously, corrosion pitting was the precondition of side surface crack formation while the stress induced hydrogen diffusion was the dominant factor.     

Effect of ball-burnishing on hydrogen-assisted cracking of a martensitic stainless steel

Slow strain rate tensile tests under hydrogen cathodic charging are conducted on 17-4 PH steel with two surface conditions: mirror polished and ball-burnished. In both cases, significant subcritical cracking initiating at the surface is observed leading to considerable reduction in elongation to fracture. However, ball-burnished specimens show better elongation and much less secondary cracking than the polished ones. Ball-burnishing introduces high compressive residual stresses in the specimen sub-surface. However, EBSD showed a very limited impact of ball-burnishing on the microstructure, so little effect on hydrogen trapping is expected. The beneficial effect of ball-burnishing on the resistance of the hydrogen assisted cracking is mainly explained by the high compressive longitudinal stress at the specimen surface, which makes crack initiation more difficult and hence delays specimen failure. In addition, it is estimated that the amount of hydrogen introduced at the specimen surface is decreased by approximately 30% due to the high compressive hydrostatic stress.     

Nondestructive determination of tensile properties and fracture toughness of cold worked A36 steel

Tensile and fracture properties of ASTM grade A36 steel have been studied using nondestructive Stress–Strain Microprobe™ system (SSM), which is developed on the basis of automated ball indentation (ABI) technique. Tests have been carried out on as-received, and cold worked (4, 8 and 12%) materials at several temperatures in the range −150°C–+200°C at a constant strain rate. Tensile properties determined from ABI tests agreed well with the results from conventional tensile tests. The elastic–plastic fracture toughness parameter K_JC was estimated from the ABI data. As expected, cold working resulted in increase in strength, decrease in fracture toughness and increase in ductile to brittle transition temperature. ABI is a reliable nondestructive technique for determining tensile and fracture properties of materials and has potential applications in the nuclear industry particularly to determine toughness degradation due to aging in service.