Improving the efficiency of IMS-IMS by a combing technique

A simple method for increasing the efficiency of multidimensional ion mobility spectrometry (IMS-IMS) measurements (as defined by the number of two-dimensional data sets necessary to sample all of the ions in a complex mixture) is illustrated. In this approach, components from a packet containing a mixture of ions are introduced into the first IMS drift region where they are separated based on differences in mobility. At the exit of this region, narrow distributions of ions having identical mobilities are selected, subjected to gentle activation conditions that are intended to induce conformational changes, and transmitted into a second IMS drift region where the new conformations are separated. Here, we describe a simple timing sequence associated with selection and activation of multiple distributions at the entrance of the second drift region in a systematic fashion that improves the efficiency of two-dimensional IMS-IMS by a factor of approximately 8. The method is illustrated by examination of a mixture of tryptic peptides from human hemoglobin.     

Assessing the peak capacity of IMS-IMS separations of tryptic peptide ions in He at 300 K

Two-dimensional ion mobility spectrometry (IMS-IMS) coupled with mass spectrometry is examined as a means of separating mixtures of tryptic peptides (from myoglobin and hemoglobin). In this study, we utilize two distinct drift regions that are identical in that each contains He buffer gas at 300 K. The two-dimensional advantage is realized by changing the structures of the ions. As ions arrive at the end of the first drift region, those of a specified mobility are selected, exposed to energizing collisions, and then introduced into a second drift region. Upon collisional activation, some ions undergo structural transitions, leading to substantial changes in their mobilities; others undergo only slight (or no) mobility changes. Examination of peak positions and shapes for peptides that are separated in the first IMS dimension indicates experimental peak capacities ranging from approximately 60 to 80; the peak shapes and range of changes in mobility that are observed in the second drift region (after activation) indicate a capacity enhancement ranging from a factor of approximately 7 to 17. Thus, experimental (and theoretical) evaluation of the peak capacity of IMS-IMS operated in this fashion indicates that capacities of approximately 480 to 1360 are accessible for peptides. Molecular modeling techniques are used to simulate the range of structural changes that would be expected for tryptic peptide ions and are consistent with the experimental shifts that are observed.     

An IMS-IMS analogue of MS-MS

The development of a new ion mobility/mass spectrometry instrument that incorporates a multifield drift tube/ion funnel design is described. In this instrument, individual components from a mixture of ions can be resolved and selected on the basis of mobility differences prior to collisional activation inside the drift tube. The fragment ions that are produced can be dispersed again in a second ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) region prior to additional collisional activation and MS analysis. The result is an IMS-IMS analogue of MS-MS. Here, we describe the preliminary instrumental design and experimental approach. We illustrate the approach by examining the highly characterized bradykinin and ubiquitin systems. Mobility-resolved fragment ions of bradykinin show that b-type ions are readily discernible fragments, because they exist as two easily resolvable structural types. Current limitations and future directions are briefly discussed.     

Coupling ion mobility separations, collisional activation techniques, and multiple stages of MS for analysis of complex peptide mixtures

An ion trap/ion mobility/quadrupole/collision cell/time-of-flight mass spectrometer that incorporates a differentially pumped orifice-skimmer cone region at the back of the drift tube has been developed for the analysis of peptide mixtures. The combined approach allows a variety of strategies to be employed for collisionally activating ions, and fragments can be monitored by subsequent stages of mass spectrometry in a parallel fashion, as described previously (Anal. Chem. 2000, 72, 2737). Here, we describe the overall experimental approach in detail. Applications involving different aspects of the initial mobility separation and various collisional activation and parallel sequencing strategies are illustrated by examining several simple peptide mixtures and a mixture of tryptic peptides from beta-casein. Detection limits associated with various experimental configurations and the utility for analysis of complex systems are discussed.     

Ion trap/ion mobility/quadrupole/time-of-flight mass spectrometry for peptide mixture analysis

An ion trap/ion mobility/quadrupole/time-of-flight mass spectrometer has been developed for the analysis of peptide mixtures. In this approach, a mixture of peptides is electrosprayed into the gas phase. The mixture of ions that is created is accumulated in an ion trap and periodically injected into a drift tube where ions separate according to differences in gas-phase ion mobilities. Upon exiting the drift tube, ions enter a quadrupole mass filter where a specific mass-to-charge (m/z) ratio can be selected prior to collisional activation in an octopole collision cell. Parent and fragment ions that exit the collision cell are analyzed using a reflectron geometry time-of-flight mass spectrometer. The overall configuration allows different species to be selected according to their mobilities and m/z ratios prior to collision-induced dissociation and final MS analysis. A key parameter in these studies is the pressure of the target gas in the collision cell. Above a critical pressure, the well-defined mobility separation degrades. The approach is demonstrated by examining a mixture of tryptic digest peptides of ubiquitin.     

A tandem ion trap/ion mobility spectrometer

A tandem quadrupole ion trap/ion mobility spectrometer (QIT/IMS) has been constructed for structural analysis based on the gas-phase mobilities of mass-selected ions. The instrument combines the ion accumulation, manipulation, and mass-selection capabilities of a modified ion trap mass spectrometer with gas-phase electrophoretic separation in a custom-built ion mobility drift cell. The quadrupole ion trap may be operated as a conventional mass spectrometer, with ion detection using an off-axis dynode/multiplier arrangement, or as an ion source for the IMS drift cell. In the latter case, pulses of ions are ejected from the trap and transferred to the drift cell where mobility in the presence of helium buffer gas is determined by the collision cross section of the ion. Ions traversing the drift cell are detected by an in-line electron multiplier and the data processed with a multichannel scaler. Preliminary data are presented on instrumental performance characteristics and the application of QIT/ IMS to structural and conformational studies of aromatic ions and protonated amine/crown ether noncovalent complexes generated via ion/molecule reactions in the ion trap.     

IMS-IMS and IMS-IMS-IMS/MS for separating peptide and protein fragment ions

Multidimensional ion mobility spectrometry (IMS-IMS and IMS-IMS-IMS) techniques have been combined with mass spectrometry (MS) and investigated as a means of generating and separating peptide and protein fragment ions. When fragments are generated inside a drift tube and then dispersed by IMS prior to MS analysis, it is possible to observe many features that are not apparent from MS analysis alone. The approach is demonstrated by examining fragmentation patterns arising from electrospray ion distributions of insulin chain B and ubiquitin. The multidimensional IMS approach makes it possible to select individual components for collisional activation and to disperse fragments based on differences in mobility prior to MS analysis. Such an approach makes it possible to observe many features not apparent by MS analysis alone.     

Exploring crown ethers as shift reagents for ion mobility spectrometry

A series of crown ethers, 12-crown-4, 15-crown-5, 18-crown-6, and dibenzo-30-crown-10, are examined as a possible means of shifting the mobilities of peptide ions. In this approach, a crown ether is added to a solution containing a mixture of peptides and is electrosprayed into the gas phase in order to create distributions of peptide-crown complexes. The ion complexes have different mobilities than the naked peptide ions, and the crown ether molecules appear to interact specifically with basic sites in the peptides thus providing some sequence selectivity. After the peptide-crown complexes are separated by ion mobility spectrometry, the ions can be collisionally activated to dissociate the complex (forming the naked peptide ions) prior to m/z analysis. The overall effect is that complex formation shifts peptide ions to different regions of the mobility spectrum, extending the ability to resolve components. The approach is illustrated by examining isobaric dipeptides as well as a combinatorial library containing 27 tripeptides. Cross sections for the series of crown ether ions and complexes that are observed are reported.     

Fundamentals of traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry

Traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry (TW IMS) is a new IMS method implemented in the Synapt IMS/mass spectrometry system (Waters). Despite its wide adoption, the foundations of TW IMS were only qualitatively understood and factors governing the ion transit time (the separation parameter) and resolution remained murky. Here we develop the theory of TW IMS using derivations and ion dynamics simulations. The key parameter is the ratio (c) of ion drift velocity at the steepest wave slope to wave speed. At low c, the ion transit velocity is proportional to the squares of mobility (K) and electric field intensity (E), as opposed to linear scaling in drift tube (DT) IMS and differential mobility analyzers. At higher c, the scaling deviates from quadratic in a way controlled by the waveform profile, becoming more gradual with the ideal triangular profile but first steeper and then more gradual for realistic profiles with variable E. At highest c, the transit velocity asymptotically approaches the wave speed. Unlike with DT IMS, the resolving power of TW IMS depends on mobility, scaling as K(1/2) in the low-c limit and less at higher c. A nonlinear dependence of the transit time on mobility means that the true resolving power of TW IMS differs from that indicated by the spectrum. A near-optimum resolution is achievable over an approximately 300-400% range of mobilities. The major predicted trends are in agreement with TW IMS measurements for peptide ions as a function of mobility, wave amplitude, and gas pressure. The issues of proper TW IMS calibration and ion distortion by field heating are also discussed. The new quantitative understanding of TW IMS separations allows rational optimization of instrument design and operation and improved spectral calibration.     

Gas-phase separations of electrosprayed peptide libraries.

High-resolution ion mobility spectrometry has been combined with time-of-flight mass spectrometry for analysis of a combinatorial peptide library that is expected to contain 676 components. In this approach, the components of a mixture of three residue peptides, having the general form (D)Phe-Xxx-Xxx-CONH2 (where Xxx is randomized over 26 residues including 10 naturally occurring amino acids and 16 synthetic forms) were ionized by electrospray ionization. Ion mobility/time-of-flight distributions have been recorded for all ions using a nested drift(flight) time technique. The improvement in resolving power [(t/delta t) = 100-150 for singly charged ions] was illustrated by analysis of a mixture of tryptic digest peptides using high- and low-resolution instruments. The approach allows many components of the library (e.g., structural, sequence, and stereo isomers) that cannot be distinguished by mass spectrometry alone to be resolved. Impurities due to side reactions appear to be minimal, comprising < 10% of the total ion signal. Direct evidence for approximately 60-70% of the expected peptides is found. Variation in ion abundance for different components indicates that there are differences in solution concentrations or ionization efficiencies for the components.     

Two-dimensional gas-phase separations coupled to mass spectrometry for analysis of complex mixtures

Ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) has been explored for decades, and its versatility in separation and identification of gas-phase ions is well established. Recently, field asymmetric waveform IMS (FAIMS) has been gaining acceptance in similar applications. Coupled to mass spectrometry (MS), both IMS and FAIMS have shown the potential for broad utility in proteomics and other biological analyses. A major attraction of these separations is extremely high speed, exceeding that of condensed-phase alternatives by orders of magnitude. However, modest separation peak capacities have limited the utility of FAIMS and IMS for analyses of complex mixtures. We report 2-D gas-phase separations that join FAIMS to IMS, in conjunction with high-resolution and accuracy time-of-flight (TOF) MS. Implementation of FAIMS/IMS and IMS/MS interfaces using electrodynamic ion funnels greatly improves sensitivity. Evaluation of FAIMS/IMS/TOF performance for a protein mixture tryptic digest reveals high orthogonality between FAIMS and IMS dimensions and, hence, the benefit of FAIMS filtering prior to IMS/MS. The effective peak capacities in analyses of tryptic peptides are approximately 500 for FAIMS/IMS separations and approximately 10(6) for 3-D FAIMS/IMS/MS, providing a potential platform for ultrahigh-throughput analyses of complex mixtures.     

Coupling high-pressure MALDI with ion mobility/orthogonal time-of-flight mass spectrometry

A new ion mobility/time-of-flight mass spectrometer employing a high-pressure MALDI source has been designed and tested. The prototype instrument operates at a source/drift cell pressure of 1-10 Torr helium, resulting in a mobility resolution of approximately 25. A small time-of-flight mass spectrometer (20 cm) with a mass resolution of up to 200 has been attached to the drift cell to identify (in terms of mass-to-charge ratio) the separated ions. A simple tripeptide mixture has been separated in the drift tube and mass identified as singly protonated species. The ability to separate peptide mixtures, e.g., tryptic digest of a protein, is illustrated and compared to results obtained on a high-vacuum time-of-flight instrument.     

Ion mobility spectrometry of halothane, enflurane, and isoflurane anesthetics in air and respired gases

Three common gaseous anesthetics, halothane, enflurane, and isoflurane, were characterized by using ion mobility spectrometry (IMS)/mass spectrometry, and the dependence of product ion distributions on temperature and concentration was evaluated. At 40 degrees C and 500 ppb, negative ion mobility spectra in air largely consisted of monomer or dimer adducts with Br- or Cl- formed through dissociative electron capture of molecular neutrals. With increased temperature or decreased vapor concentrations, declustering and dissociation of product ions became pronounced. Ion-molecule reactions in the drift region of the IMS were evident as distortions in peak shape in the mass-resolved mobility spectra and in variable reduced mobilities for the same ions. A portable hand-held IMS was used for convenient, real-time detection of enflurane in respired gases following a controlled inhalation episode.     

Separation of isomeric peptides using electrospray ionization/high-resolution ion mobility spectrometry

In this paper, the first examples of baseline separation of isomeric macromolecules by electrospray ionization/ion mobility spectrometry (ESI/IMS) at atmospheric pressure are presented. The behavior of a number of different isomeric peptides in the IMS was investigated using nitrogen as a drift gas. The IMS was coupled to a quadrupole mass spectrometer, which was used for identification and selective detection of the electrosprayed ions. The mobility data were used to determine their average collision cross sections. The gas-phase ions of isomeric peptides were found to have different collision cross sections. In all cases, doubly charged ions exhibited significantly (8-20%) larger collision cross sections than the respective singly charged species. The analysis of mixtures of the isomeric peptides clearly demonstrated the capability of IMS to separate gas-phase peptide ions due to small differences in their conformational structures, which cannot be determined by mass spectrometry. An actual resolving power of 80 was achieved for two doubly charged reversed sequenced pentapeptides. Baseline separation was provided for ions differing by only 2.5% in their measured collision cross sections; partial separation was shown for isomeric ions exhibiting differences as small as 1.1%.     

Development of high-sensitivity ion trap ion mobility spectrometry time-of-flight techniques: a high-throughput nano-LC-IMS-TOF separation of peptides arising from a Drosophila protein extract

A linear octopole trap interface for an ion mobility time-of-flight mass spectrometer has been developed for focusing and accumulating continuous beams of ions produced by electrospray ionization. The interface improves experimental efficiencies by factors of approximately 50-200 compared with an analogous configuration that utilizes a three-dimensional Paul geometry trap (Hoaglund-Hyzer, C. S.; Lee, Y. J.; Counterman, A. E.; Clemmer, D. E. Anal. Chem. 2002, 74, 992-1006). With these improvements, it is possible to record nested drift (flight) time distributions for complex mixtures in fractions of a second. We demonstrate the approach for several well-defined peptide mixtures and an assessment of the detection limits is given. Additionally, we demonstrate the utility of the approach in the field of proteomics by an on-line, three-dimensional nano-LC-ion mobility-TOF separation of tryptic peptides from the Drosophila proteome.     

Effective temperature of ions in traveling wave ion mobility spectrometry

Traveling wave ion mobility spectrometers (TW IMS) operate at significantly higher fields than drift tube ion mobility spectrometers. Here we measured the fragmentation of the fragile p-methoxybenzylpyridinium ion inside the TW ion mobility cell of the first-generation SYNAPT HDMS spectrometer. The ion's vibrational internal energy was quantified by a vibrational effective temperature T(eff,vib), which is the mean temperature of the ions inside the cell that would result in the same fragmentation yield as observed experimentally. Significant fragmentation of the probe ion inside the TW IMS cell was detected, indicating that field heating of the ions takes place in TW IMS. For typical small molecule IMS conditions, T(eff,vib) = 555 ± 2 K. The variations of the effective temperature were studied as a function of the IMS parameters, and we found that T(eff,vib) decreases when the wave height decreases, when the pressure increases, or when the wave speed increases. The energy transfer efficiency of argon is higher than for He, N(2), or CO(2). With T(eff,vib) being directly related to the ion speed inside the TW IMS, our results also provide new insight on the ion movement in TW IMS. We also discuss the influence of field heating of ions for calibration and structural studies in TW IMS.     

Separation of a set of peptide sequence isomers using differential ion mobility spectrometry

Protein identification in bottom-up proteomics requires disentangling isomers of proteolytic peptides, a major class of which are sequence inversions. Their separation using ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) has been limited to isomeric pairs. Here we demonstrate baseline separation of all seven 8-mer tryptic peptide isomers using differential IMS. Evaluation of peak capacity implies that even larger libraries should be resolved for heavier peptides with higher charge states.     

Pulsed-ionization miniature ion mobility spectrometer

We have demonstrated a miniature ion mobility spectrometer (IMS) that employs single pulses of corona discharge ionization. IMS spectra of both positive and negative ions generated from ambient air were measured as a function of drift field under various ionization conditions. Ion mobility spectra were studied with various pulse widths for both positive and negative ions, giving insights into mechanisms and kinetics of corona discharge ionization used in the miniature IMS. A combination of a pulsed potential with a steady dc bias was used to generate ions in the miniature IMS. There was a threshold dc potential for ion generation for a given pulse height. The dc ionization threshold was found to decrease linearly with increasing pulse height.     

High-sensitivity ion mobility spectrometry/mass spectrometry using electrodynamic ion funnel interfaces

The utility of ion mobility spectrometry (IMS) for separation of mixtures and structural characterization of ions has been demonstrated extensively, including in biological and nanoscience contexts. A major attraction of IMS is its speed, several orders of magnitude greater than that of condensed-phase separations. Nonetheless, IMS combined with mass spectrometry (MS) has remained a niche technique, substantially because of limited sensitivity resulting from ion losses at the IMS-MS junction. We have developed a new electrospray ionization (ESI)-IMS-QTOF MS instrument that incorporates electrodynamic ion funnels at both front ESI-IMS and rear IMS-QTOF interfaces. The front funnel is of the novel "hourglass" design that efficiently accumulates ions and pulses them into the IMS drift tube. Even for drift tubes of 2-m length, ion transmission through IMS and on to QTOF is essentially lossless across the range of ion masses relevant to most applications. The rf ion focusing at the IMS terminus does not degrade IMS resolving power, which exceeds 100 (for singly charged ions) and is close to the theoretical limit. The overall sensitivity of the present ESI-IMS-MS system is comparable to that of commercial ESI-MS, which should make IMS-MS suitable for analyses of complex mixtures with ultrahigh sensitivity and exceptional throughput.