Seismic Vulnerability and Mitigation during Construction of Cable-Stayed Bridges

The implications of earthquake loading during balanced cantilever construction of a cable-stayed bridge are examined. Finite-element models of a cable-stayed bridge were developed and multiple ground motion time history records were used to study the seismic response at the base of the towers for six stages of balanced cantilever construction. Probabilistic seismic hazard relationships were used to relate ground motions to bridge responses. The results show that there can be a high probability of having seismic responses (forces/moments) in a partially completed bridge that exceed, often by a substantial margin, the 10%/50-year design level (0.21% per annum) for the full bridge. The maximum probability of exceedance per annum was found to be 20%. This occurs because during balanced-cantilever construction the structure is in a particularly precarious and vulnerable state. The efficacy of a seismic mitigation strategy based on the use of tie-down cables intended for aerodynamic stability during construction was investigated. This strategy was successful in reducing some of the seismic vulnerabilities so that probabilities of exceedance during construction dropped to below 1% per annum. Although applied to only one cable-stayed bridge, the same approach can be used for construction-stage vulnerability analysis of other long-span bridges.     

Theories of Aerodynamic Forces on Decks of Long Span Bridges

Long span bridges are one of the most challenging kinds of structures in civil engineering. Wind loading and wind effects are highly important aspects when designing this typology. The interaction between wind and structure, studied by using aeroelasticity theory, allows us to understand several classes of structural instabilities that may appear. Also, wind tunnel data, obtained by conducting careful testing of reduced models of bridges, produce useful information about prototypes' characteristics. A fundamental aspect of bridge design under aeroelastic constraints is identification of aerodynamic forces; several models for this purpose are presented in this paper. First, a model based on a two-degrees-of-freedom plane plate moving in an incompressible fluid is reviewed; this approach, although useful in airfoil engineering, is not valid any longer in civil engineering, as bridge decks are bluff bodies. Second, a linearized theory, also based on a two-degrees-of-freedom model is analyzed; in this case, obtaining aerodynamic forces requires identification of a set of coefficients, called flutter derivatives, that can be found by carrying out testing of reduced models of a segment of bridge deck. Finally, an extension of that approach, leading to a linearized theory of a three-degrees-of-freedom model is presented.     

大跨度结构非一致地震动作用浅析

大跨度结构一致地震波输入与非一致地震波输入的空间振动效应有着较为明显的差别,本文将对它们间的一些差别进行讨论,并通过对某工程结构的两种输入方式进行分析,对其差异进行具体比较.     

Simulation of Construction of Cable-Stayed Bridges

Construction of cable-stayed bridges involves major changes in configuration of the structure with the addition and removal of structural components to the partially constructed structure. At every stage of construction, it is necessary to have sufficient information about the existing partial structure as-built, to verify the requirements called for in the construction guidelines and to investigate the effects of possible modifications in the construction procedures. The final stresses and deformations in the completed structure are strongly dependent on the sequence of events during the construction and the erection procedure used. Therefore, analysis of the actual construction sequence is an important first step in any analysis of the performance of the bridge under external loads. In this paper a general methodology for construction sequence simulation of cable-stayed bridges is presented, and stage-by-stage construction of an actual bridge is simulated. The objective of the simulation is to evaluate short-term and long-term influences of the construction sequence on the structural integrity of the cable-stayed bridge. Comparisons are presented between results from the present analysis, conventional procedures, and the actual field measurements.     

Stability Analysis of Box-Girder Cable-Stayed Bridges

The objective of this study is to investigate the stability characteristics of box-girder cable-stayed bridges by three-dimensional finite-element methods. Cable-stayed bridges have many design parameters, because they have a lot of redundancies, especially for long-span bridges. Cable-stayed bridges exhibit several nonlinear behaviors concurrently under normal design loads because of large displacements; the interaction among the pylons, the stayed cables, and the bridge deck; the strong axial and lateral forces acting on the bridge deck and pylons; and cable nonlinearity. A typical two-lane, three-span, steel box-girder cable-stayed bridge superstructure was selected for this paper. The numerical results indicate that, if the ratio of the main span length with respect to the total span length, L1∕L, is small, the structure usually has a higher critical load. If the ratio Ip∕Ib increases, the critical load of the bridge decreases, in which Ip is the moment of inertia of the pylon and Ib is the moment of inertia of the bridge deck. When the ratio Ip∕Ib is greater than 10.0, the decrement becomes insignificant. For cable arrangements, bridges supported by a harp-type cable arrangement are the better design than bridges supported by a fan-type cable arrangement on buckling analysis. The numerical results also indicate that use of either A-type or H-type pylons does not significantly affect the critical load of this type of structure. In order to make the numerical results useful, the buckling loads have been nondimensionalized and presented in both tabular and graphical forms.     

Structural Behavior of Short Span Precast Channel Beam Bridges without Shear Reinforcement

This paper presents findings of a research study conducted by the writers for the Arkansas State Highway and Transportation Department. The study investigated precast nonprestressed concrete channel beam sections cast without shear reinforcement used in short, multispan bridges. The original objective of the study was to establish a correlation for inspection purposes between the beam’s visual deteriorated state and its corresponding approximate structural capacity. However, during four-point load testing of 33 beams, it was found that beam strength was more a function of a beam’s concrete compression strength rather than deterioration state. A national survey of state transportation departments within the contiguous states was conducted by the authors and found that 13 states currently use precast channel beam bridges. The particular section considered in this paper is a 5.79?m (19?ft) precast channel beam section used to cross small streams and depressions; however constructed without shear reinforcing steel. Bridges using these sections were constructed in the 1950s through to the early 1970s and were designed for H15 loading. Thirty-three formally in-service beams, in various states of deterioration, were load tested. The writers found that the majority of the beams exhibited load capacity greater than the initially required H15 design strength. Second, member strength was a function of concrete compressive strength. Of the 33 beams load tested, 28 beams showed ductile behavior; conversely, the other five beams failed without exhibiting a yield plateau.     

Dynamic Behavior of Steel Deck Tension-Tied Arch Bridges to Seismic Excitation

The dynamic responses of steel deck, tension-tied, arch bridges subjected to earthquake excitations were investigated. The 620 ft (189 m) Birmingham Bridge, located in Pittsburgh, was selected as an analytical model for the study. The bridge has a single deck tension-tied arch span and is supported by two bridge piers, which in turn are supported by the pile foundations. Due to the complex configuration of the deck system, two analytical models were considered to represent the bridge deck system. Using the normal mode method, seismic responses were calculated for two bridge models and the results were compared with each other. Three orthogonal records of the El Centro 1940 earthquake were used as input for the seismic response analysis. The modal contributions were also checked in order to obtain a reasonable representation of the response and to minimize computational cost. Displacements and stresses at the panel points of the bridge are calculated and presented in graphical form.     

Optimization of Cable Tensioning in Cable-Stayed Bridges

During the structural analysis of cable-stayed bridges, some specific problems arise that are not common in other types of bridges. One of these problem is the derivation of an optimal sequence for the tensioning of the stay cables. This paper describes a novel solution to this problem, the unit force method. The method takes into account all relevant effects for the design of cable-stayed bridges, including construction sequence, second-order theory, large displacements, cable sag and time-dependent effects, such as creep and shrinkage or relaxation of prestressing tendons. Information about the implementation of this method into a computer program is given, and an example of a practical application of this method concludes this paper. The method is not restricted to the design of cable-stayed bridges and may well be used for other structural applications in the future.     

Role of Shear Keys in Seismic Behavior of Bridges Crossing Fault-Rupture Zones

This paper examines the role of shear keys at bridge abutments in the seismic behavior of “ordinary” bridges. The seismic responses of bridges subjected to spatially uniform and spatially varying ground motions for three shear-key conditions—nonlinear shear keys that break off and cease to provide transverse restraint if deformed beyond a certain limit; elastic shear keys that do not break off and continue to provide transverse restraint throughout the ground shaking; and no shear keys—are examined. Results show that seismic demands for a bridge with nonlinear shear keys can generally be bounded by the demands of a bridge with elastic shear keys and a bridge with no shear keys for both types of ground motions. While ignoring shear keys provides conservative estimates of seismic demands in bridges subjected to spatially uniform ground motion, such a practice may lead to underestimation of some seismic demands in bridges in fault-rupture zones that are subjected to spatially varying ground motion. Therefore, estimating the upper bounds of seismic demands in bridges crossing fault-rupture zones requires analysis for two shear-key conditions: no shear keys and elastic shear keys.     

Vulnerability Assessment of Cable-Stayed Bridges in Probabilistic Domain

Vulnerability of a structure under terrorist attack can be regarded as the study of its behavior against blast-induced loads. A structure is vulnerable if a small damage can trigger a disproportionately large consequence and lead to a cascade of failure events or even collapse. The performance of structural vulnerability depends upon factors such as external loading condition and structural properties. As many of these factors are random in nature, it is necessary to develop a vulnerability assessment technique in the probabilistic domain. In this study, one such assessment framework is proposed for cable-stayed bridges. The framework consists of two stages of analysis: determining the probability of direct damage due to blast loads and assessing the subsequent probability of collapse due to component damage. In the first stage assessment, damage of the bridge component is defined as the exceedance of a predefined limit state such as displacement or yielding. The damage probability is obtained through a stochastic finite-element analysis and the first-order second-moment reliability method. The second stage assessment further calculates the probability of collapse due to direct damage of some component via an event tree approach. The proposed assessment methods are illustrated on a hypothetical single-tower cable-stayed bridge. It is seen that the proposed methods provide a quantitative tool for analyzing the vulnerability performance of cable-stayed bridges under terrorist attack.     

Feasibility of a 1,400 m Span Steel Cable-Stayed Bridge

This paper describes the feasibility of 1,400 m steel cable-stayed bridges from both structural and economic viewpoints. Because the weight of a steel girder strongly affects the total cost of the bridge, the writers present a procedure to obtain a minimum weight for a girder that ensures safety against static and dynamic instabilities. For static instability, elastoplastic, finite-displacement analysis under in-plane load and elastic, finite-displacement analysis under displacement-dependent wind load are conducted; for dynamic instability, multimodal flutter analysis is carried out. It is shown that static critical wind velocity of lateral torsional buckling governs the dimension of the girder. Finally, the writers briefly compare a cable-stayed bridge with suspension bridge alternatives.     

Seismic Response of Multiple Span Steel Bridges in Central and Southeastern United States. II: Retrofitted

Part I of this two-part paper evaluated the seismic response of typical multispan simply supported (MSSS) and multispan continuous steel girder bridges in the central and southeastern United States. The results showed that the bridges were vulnerable to damage resulting from impact between decks, and large ductility demands on nonductile columns. Furthermore, fixed and expansion bearings were likely to fail during strong ground motion. In this paper, several retrofit measures to improve the seismic performance of typical multispan simply supported and multispan continuous steel girder bridges are evaluated, including the use of elastomeric bearings, lead-rubber bearings, and restrainer cables. It is determined that lead-rubber bearings are the most effective retrofit measure for reducing the seismic vulnerability of typical bridges. While isolation provided by elastomeric bearings limits the forces into the columns, the added flexibility results in pounding between decks in the MSSS steel girder bridges. Restrainer cables, which are becoming a common retrofit measure, are effective in reducing the hinge opening in MSSS bridges with steel bearings. However, when used with elastomeric bearings, the restrainer cables negate the isolation effect of the bearings.     

Seismic Response of Isolated Bridges

The seismic response of bridges seismically isolated by lead-rubber bearings (L-RB) to bidirectional earthquake excitation (i.e., two horizontal components) is presented in this paper. The force-deformation behavior of L-RB is considered as bilinear, and the interaction between the restoring forces in two orthogonal horizontal directions is duly considered in the response analysis. The specific purpose of the study is to assess the effects of seismic isolation on the peak response of the bridges, and to investigate the effects of the bidirectional interaction of restoring forces of isolation bearings. The seismic response of the lumped mass model of continuous span isolated bridges is obtained by solving the governing equations of motion in the incremental form using an iterative step-by-step method. To study the effectiveness of L-RB, the seismic response of isolated bridges is compared with the response of corresponding nonisolated bridges (i.e., bridges without isolation devices). A comparison of the response of the isolated bridges obtained by considering and ignoring the bidirectional interaction of bearing forces is made under important parametric variation. The important parameters included are the flexibility of the bridge piers and the stiffness and yield strength of the L-RB. The results show that the bidirectional interaction of the restoring forces of the L-RB has considerable effects on the seismic response of the isolated bridges. If these interaction effects are ignored, then the peak bearing displacements are underestimated, which can be crucial from the design point of view.     

Seismic Response of Multiple Span Steel Bridges in Central and Southeastern United States. I: As Built

The seismic response of typical multispan simply supported (MSSS) and multispan continuous steel girder bridges in the central and southeastern United States is evaluated. Nonlinear time history analyses are conducted using synthetic ground motion for three cities for 475 and 2,475-year return period earthquakes (10 and 2% probability of exceedance in 50 years). The results indicate that the seismic response for the 475-year return period earthquake would lead to an essentially linear response in typical bridges. However, the seismic response for a 2,475-year return period earthquake resulted in significant demands on nonductile columns, fixed and expansion bearings, and abutments. In particular, pounding between decks in the MSSS bridge would result in significant damage to steel bearings and would lead to the toppling of rocker bearings, which may result in unseating of the bridge deck.     

Number of Cable Effects on Buckling Analysis of Cable-Stayed Bridges

Cables instead of interval piers support cable-stayed bridges, and the bridge deck is subjected to strong axial forces due to the horizontal components of cable reactions. The structural behavior of a bridge deck becomes nonlinear because of the axial forces, large deflection, and nonlinear behavior of the cables and the large deformation of the pylons as well as their interactions. The locations and amplitude of axial forces acting on the bridge deck may depend on the number of cables. Agrawal indicated that the maximum cable tension decreases rapidly with the increase in the number of cables. This paper investigates the stability analysis of cable-stayed bridges and considers cable-stayed bridges with geometry similar to those proposed in Agrawal's paper. A digital computer and numerical analysis are used to examine 2D finite element models of these bridges. The eigen buckling analysis has been applied to find the minimum critical loads of the cable-stayed bridges. The numerical results indicate that the total cumulative axial forces acting on the bridge girder increase as the number of cables increases, yet because the bridge deck is subjected to strong axial forces, the critical load of the bridges decreases. Increasing the number of cables may not increase the critical load on buckling analysis of this type of bridge. The fundamental critical loads increase if the ratio of Ip∕Ib increases until the ratio reaches the optimum ratio. If the ratio of Ip∕Ib is greater than the optimum ratio, depending on the geometry of an individual bridge, the fundamental critical load decreases for all the types of bridges considered in this paper. In order to make the results useful, they have been normalized and represented in graphical form.     

Design and Experimental Study of a Harp-Shaped Single Span Cable-Stayed Bridge

This paper presents issues in the design concept, analysis, and test results of a harp-shaped single span cable-stayed bridge, Hongshan Bridge, located in Changsha, Hunan Province, China. The bridge has a 206 m span, with a pylon inclined at 58° from the horizontal and 13 pairs of parallel cable stays without a back?stay. This paper discusses the design approach for the main components of the bridge. Emphasis will be put on the following three aspects. First, the weight of the pylon and all dead loads of the main girder in addition to part of the live loads must be in a balanced condition. Second, the main girder should be an orthotropic steel-concrete composite box girder because of the superior safety and weight reduction of this type of structure. Third, the cable?stays should be anchored at the neutral axis of the pylon to prevent the development of high secondary moments caused by other anchor approaches. Furthermore, based on results from tests carried out on three models, namely, scaled full model tests in a scale of 1:30, scaled section model tests in a scale of 1:6, and wind tunnel tests, the following four key issues were studied: (1) the local stability of orthotropic steel-concrete composite box girder subjected to combined bending and axial loads; (2) the characteristics under loads of 13-m-long cantilever beams; (3) the safety of the bridge under some other dangerous conditions; and (4) the characteristics of wind resistance and wind tunnel testing.     

Performance Evaluation of Short Span Reinforced Concrete Arch Bridges

In this paper, the static and seismic performance of some short span reinforced concrete arch bridges, before and after strengthening interventions, are evaluated. To verify whether retrofit strategies for the considered arch bridges, which were designed for resisting under permanent and service actions, were adequate for earthquake resistance, seismic analyses of the as-built model of the structures have been undertaken. To account for multiple input effects on arches, induced by out-of-phase motions at foundation levels as well as different boundary conditions at structural supports, the seismic response of the structures under correlated horizontal and vertical multiple excitations is calculated. The effects on arch bridges of conventionally used uniform input and partially correlated multiple inputs with phase shifts are compared. In all cases, the results are discussed with particular reference to the influence of structural configuration, secondary systems, cross-section thickness of the arch, and retrofit interventions.     

Erection of Cable-Stayed Bridges Having Composite Decks with Precast Concrete Slabs

For the construction of composite steel-concrete decks of cable-stayed bridges, methods of erection and analysis have to be applied that, upon completion of the deck, accurately yield the prescribed dead load configuration of the deck regarding geometry and forces. During deck erection, no unwanted bending moments should be locked into the composite sections when the concrete slab is connected to the steel substructure. Such locked-in moments would bend the deck, cause concrete creep that is difficult to predict, and introduce the risk of deviations from the desired deck alignment and the corresponding distribution of forces. This paper presents a simple and practical method of erection and erection analysis for composite decks with precast concrete slabs. A two-step tensioning procedure of the stay cables is proposed that minimizes the effects of unwanted locked-in moments, making it easy to predict the geometry of the erection stages and to yield the desired dead load configuration of the deck. The method was successfully applied for the erection of the Ting Kau bridge in Hong Kong, a cable-stayed bridge of 1,200 m in length having a composite deck with a precast deck slab.