Creep fatigue of a directionally solidified Ni‐base superalloy – smooth and cylindrically notched specimens

Turbine blade life modelling is complicated by the presence of notches, dwells, high temperatures, thermal cycles and temperature gradients. Furthermore, directionally solidified (DS) Ni‐base superalloys are highly anisotropic. This work seeks to characterize the response of the DS Ni‐base superalloy CM247LC subjected to isothermal low cycle fatigue at either 750 or 950 °C. This study considers the effects of strain rate, dwells at the maximum temperature, and stress concentrations. Experiments were conducted under uniaxial loading on smooth and cylindrically notched round‐bar specimens in both longitudinal and transverse orientations. The location of the creep‐fatigue crack is at the maximum Hill's effective stress in the notched specimens. In addition, the notch behaviour is discussed in light of finite element analysis using an anisotropic elastic‐crystal viscoplastic material model.     

Prediction methods of fatigue critical point for notched components under multiaxial fatigue loading

Two methods based on local stress responses are proposed to locate fatigue critical point of metallic notched components under non‐proportional loading. The points on the notch edge maintain a state of uniaxial stress even when the far‐field fatigue loading is multiaxial. The point bearing the maximum stress amplitude is recognized as fatigue critical point under the condition of non‐mean stress; otherwise, the Goodman's empirical formula is adopted to amend mean stress effect prior to the determination of fatigue critical point. Furthermore, the uniaxial stress state can be treated as a special multiaxial stress state. The Susmel's fatigue damage parameter is employed to evaluate the fatigue damage of these points on the notch edge. Multiaxial fatigue tests on thin‐walled round tube notched specimens made of GH4169 nickel‐base alloy and 2297 aluminium‐lithium alloy are carried out to verify the two methods. The prediction results show that both the stress amplitude method and the Susmel's parameter method can accurately locate the fatigue critical point of metallic notched components under multiaxial fatigue loading.     

Multiaxial fatigue of V‐notched steel specimens: a non‐conventional application of the local energy method

The paper deals with the multi‐axial fatigue strength of notched specimens made of 39NiCrMo3 hardened and tempered steel. Circumferentially V‐notched specimens were subjected to combined tension and torsion loading, both in‐phase and out‐of‐phase, under two nominal load ratios, R=?1 and R= 0, also taking into account the influence of the biaxiality ratio, λ=τ_a/σ_a. The notch geometry of all axi‐symmetric specimens was a notch tip radius of 0.1 mm, a notch depth of 4 mm, an included V‐notch angle of 90° and a net section diameter of 12 mm. The results from multi‐axial tests are discussed together with those obtained under pure tension and pure torsion loading on plain and notched specimens. Furthermore the fracture surfaces are examined and the size of non‐propagating cracks measured from some run‐out specimens at 5 million cycles. Finally, all results are presented in terms of the local strain energy density averaged in a given control volume close to the V‐notch tip. The control volume is found to be dependent on the loading mode.     

Fatigue life evaluation of tension‐compression asymmetric material using local stress–strain method

In this paper, the low‐cycle fatigue characteristics of cold‐drawn steel were investigated under strain‐controlled uniaxial fatigue load. Cyclic softening was observed throughout fatigue life except for the initial relatively short period which exhibited cyclic hardening. Positive mean stress was found under fully reversed strain loading, indicating that there was a significant cyclic asymmetry. A modified local stress–strain method was proposed to estimate fatigue life of notched tension‐compression asymmetric material. In order to verify this method, fatigue experiments on two kinds of notched specimens with different notch radius were carried out under constant and block load spectrum. It was found that the modified local stress–strain method was more accurate than the traditional ones, the maximum relative error between predicted and experimental fatigue life was less than 6%.     

Effect of notch on fatigue behaviour of a directionally solidified superalloy at high temperature

The effect of notch types and stress concentration factors (K_t) on low cycle fatigue life and cracking of the DZ125 directionally solidified superalloy has been experimentally investigated. Single‐edge notched specimens with V and U type geometries were tested at 850 °C with stress ratio R = 0.1. High temperature in situ optical method was used to observe crack initiation and short crack propagation. Scanning electron microscope observation of fracture was used to analyse the failure mechanism. The results reveal that fatigue resistance decreases with K_t increasing from 1.76 to 4.35. The ratcheting is found to be affected by both K_t and the nominal stress from the displacement–force curve. In situ observations indicate that the cracking does not occur at the notch apex but at the location where the max principal stress or Hill's stress is the highest. According to the scanning electron microscope observations, the failure of the notched specimens strongly depends on the anisotropy microstructures.     

Two methods for predicting the multiaxial fatigue limits of sharp notches

In this paper the problem of the multiaxial fatigue limit estimation of sharply notched components has been addressed using two different methods: a critical distance method and a method involving modified Wöhler curves. These two methods had been previously developed by the authors, but required modification for use in conjunction with finite element stress analysis of sharply notched specimens subjected to multiaxial loadings. Initially, it was demonstrated mathematically that these methods are equivalent in terms of multiaxial stresses near the notch tip. Subsequently, by employing some well‐known uniaxial notch fatigue concepts, some assumptions have been made in order to extend the use of these methods to in‐phase multiaxial notch fatigue situations. Experimental data were obtained from tests conducted on V‐notched specimens subjected to in‐phase mixed Mode I and Mode II loadings. Both methods were successful in giving fatigue limit predictions with an error usually less than 15%. This is interesting because the two methods make quite different assumptions about the nature of fatigue crack growth in the vicinity of the notch.     

Analysis on the fatigue damage evolution of notched specimens with consideration of cyclic plasticity

This paper presents a damage mechanics method applied successfully to assess fatigue life of notched specimens with plastic deformation at the notch tip. A damage‐coupled elasto‐plastic constitutive model is employed in which nonlinear kinematic hardening is considered. The accumulated damage is described by a stress‐based damage model and a plastic strain‐based damage model, which depend on the cyclic stress and accumulated plastic strain, respectively. A three‐dimensional finite element implementation of these models is developed to predict the crack initiation life of notched specimens. Two cases, a notched plate under tension‐compression loadings and an SAE notched shaft under bending‐torsion loadings including non‐proportional loadings, are studied and the predicted results are compared with experimental data.     

A notch critical plane approach of multiaxial fatigue life prediction for metallic notched specimens

An approach based on the local stress response is proposed to locate the fatigue critical point for metallic blunt notched specimens under multiaxial fatigue loading. According to the stress analysis, both stress gradient and gradient of loading nonproportionality exist at notch root. The plane in the vicinity of the notch that passes through the fatigue critical point and experiences the maximum shear stress amplitude is defined as the critical plane for notch specimens (CPN). Furthermore, the Susmel's fatigue damage parameter is modified to assess fatigue life of notched components by combining CPN and the theory of critical distance (TCD). The multiaxial fatigue test of the thin‐walled round tube specimens made of Ni‐base alloy GH4169 is carried out to verify the above approaches. In addition, test data of two kinds of materials are collected. The results show that the maximum absolute error of the fatigue critical point is 9.6° and the majority of the predicted life falls within the three‐time scatter band.     

Creep–fatigue crack growth behaviour based on EBSD observations for notched specimen made of directionally solidified Ni-base superalloy

Abstract

In order to characterise the creep–fatigue crack growth behaviour of a directionally solidified Ni-base superalloy, an investigation into damage behaviour based on the electron backscattered diffraction (EBSD) method using notched specimens has been carried out. The average misorientation in the vicinity of notches increases linearly up to the initiation of cracks with the increasing creep strains under creep or creep–fatigue conditions, whereas under fatigue conditions fatigue cracks grew without an increase in misorientation. The stress holding time clearly influenced the growth behaviour of creep–fatigue cracks and the appearance of misorientation development. However, it was shown that the relationship between the average misorientation and the relative notch opening displacement was independent of test conditions such as temperatures, stresses and stress wave forms.

It is concluded that the misorientation analysis of damaged samples based on the EBSD method allows the prediction of the initiation of creep–fatigue cracks and their growth behaviours.     

Notch fatigue life prediction considering nonproportionality of local loading path under multiaxial cyclic loading

An innovative numerical methodology is presented for fatigue lifetime estimation of notched bodies experiencing multiaxial cyclic loadings. In the presented methodology, an evaluation approach of the local nonproportionality factor F for notched specimens, which defines F as the ratio of the pseudoshear strain range at 45° to the maximum shear plane and the maximum shear strain range, is proposed and discussed deeply. The proposed evaluation method is incorporated into the material cyclic stress‐strain equation for purpose of describing the nonproportional hardening behavior for some material. The comparison between multiaxial elastic‐plastic finite element analysis (FEA) and experimentally measured strains for S460N steel notched specimens shows that the proposed nonproportionality factor estimation method is effective. Subsequently, the notch stresses and strains calculated utilizing multiaxial elastic‐plastic FEA are used as input data to the critical plane‐based fatigue life prediction methodology. The prediction results are satisfactory for the 7050‐T7451 aluminum alloy and GH4169 superalloy notched specimens under multiaxial cyclic loading.     

Low‐cycle fatigue/high‐cycle fatigue interactions in notched Ti‐6Al‐4V*

Combined low‐cycle fatigue/high‐cycle fatigue (LCF/HCF) loadings were investigated for smooth and circumferentially V‐notched cylindrical Ti–6Al–4V fatigue specimens. Smooth specimens were first cycled under LCF loading conditions for a fraction of the previously established fatigue life. The HCF 10⁷ cycle fatigue limit stress after LCF cycling was established using a step loading technique. Specimens with two notch sizes, both having elastic stress concentration factors of K_t = 2.7, were cycled under LCF loading conditions at a nominal stress ratio of R = 0.1. The subsequent 10⁶ cycle HCF fatigue limit stress at both R = 0.1 and 0.8 was determined. The combined loading LCF/HCF fatigue limit stresses for all specimens were compared to the baseline HCF fatigue limit stresses. After LCF cycling and prior to HCF cycling, the notched specimens were heat tinted, and final fracture surfaces examined for cracks formed during the initial LCF loading. Fatigue test results indicate that the LCF loading, applied for 75% of total LCF life for the smooth specimens and 25% for the notched specimens, resulted in only small reductions in the subsequent HCF fatigue limit stress. Under certain loading conditions, plasticity‐induced stress redistribution at the notch root during LCF cycling appears responsible for an observed increase in HCF fatigue limit stress, in terms of net section stress.     

Notched fatigue behavior including load sequence effects under axial and torsional loadings

Notch effects on axial and torsion fatigue behaviors of low carbon steel were investigated. Fully-reversed tests were conducted on thin-walled tubular specimens with or without a transverse circular hole. A shear failure mechanism was observed for both smooth and notched specimens and under both axial and torsion loadings. The notch effect was more pronounced under axial loading, in spite of higher stress concentration factor in torsion. The commonly used nominal S–N approach with fatigue notch factor in conjunction with von Mises effective stress resulted in overly conservative life predictions of both smooth and notched torsion fatigue lives. Neuber’s rule yielded notch root stress and strain amplitudes close to the FEA results for both axial and torsion loadings. The local strain approach based on effective strain obtained from Neuber’s rule or FEA resulted in poor correlation of the fatigue life data of smooth and notched specimens. The Fatemi–Socie critical plane parameter represented the observed failure mechanism and resulted in very good correlations of smooth and notched specimens fatigue data under both axial and torsion loadings. In block loading tests with equal number of alternating axial and torsion cycles at the same stress level, beneficial effect of axial loading was observed. Possible potential reasons for this unexpected behavior are discussed.     

State‐of‐the‐art review on the local strain energy density concept and its relation to the J‐integral and peak stress method

The local average strain energy density (SED) approach has been proposed and elaborated by Lazzarin for strength assessments in respect of brittle fracture and high‐cycle fatigue. Pointed and rounded (blunt) V‐notches subjected to tensile loading (mode 1) are primarily considered. The method is systematically extended to multiaxial conditions (mode 3, mixed modes 1 and 2). The application to brittle fracture is documented for PMMA flat bar specimens with pointed or rounded V‐notches inclusive of U‐notches. Results for other brittle materials (ceramics, PVC, duraluminum and graphite) are also recorded. The application to high‐cycle fatigue comprises fillet‐welded joints, weld‐like shaped and V‐notched base material specimens as well as round bar specimens with a V‐notch. The relation of the local SED concept to comparable other concepts is investigated, among them the Kitagawa, Taylor and Atzori–Lazzarin diagrams, the Neuber concept of fictitious notch rounding applied to welded joints and also the J‐integral approach. Alternative details of the local SED concept such as a semicircular control volume, microrounded notches and slit‐parallel loading are also mentioned. Coarse FE meshes at pointed or rounded notch tips are proven to be acceptable for accurate local SED evaluations. The peak stress method proposed by Meneghetti, which is based on a notch stress intensity factor consideration combined with a globally even coarse FE mesh and is used for the assessment of the fatigue strength of welded joints, is also presented.     

The linear‐elastic Theory of Critical Distances to estimate high‐cycle fatigue strength of notched metallic materials at elevated temperatures

This paper investigates the accuracy of the linear‐elastic Theory of Critical Distances (TCD) in estimating high‐cycle fatigue strength of notched metallic materials experiencing elevated temperatures during in‐service operations. The TCD postulates that the fatigue damage extent can be estimated by directly post‐processing the entire linear‐elastic stress field acting on the material in the vicinity of the crack initiation locations. The key feature of this theory is that the high‐cycle fatigue assessment is based on a scale length parameter that is assumed to be a material property. The accuracy of this design method was checked against a number of experimental results generated, under axial loading, by testing, at 250 °C, notched specimens of carbon steel C45. To further investigate the reliability of the TCD, its accuracy was also checked via several data taken from the literature, these experimental results being generated by testing notched samples of Inconel 718 at 500 °C as well as notched specimens of directionally solidified superalloy DZ125 at 850 °C. This validation exercise allowed us to prove that the linear‐elastic TCD is successful in estimating high‐cycle fatigue strength of notched metallic materials exposed to elevated temperature, resulting in estimates falling within an error interval of ±20%. Such a high level of accuracy suggests that, in situations of practical interest, reliable high‐cycle fatigue assessment can be performed without the need for taking into account those non‐linearities characterising the mechanical behaviour of metallic materials at high temperature, the used critical distance being still a material property whose value does not depend on the sharpness of the notch being designed.     

全层TiAl合金裂纹扩展阻力的研究

本文通过对直缺口两个层团厚度拉伸试样的扫描电镜原位拉伸实验、相应的断裂表面观察以及有限元计算研究了全层铸状TiAl基合金组织的裂纹扩展机理.研究表明:为了扩展主裂纹,外加载荷需要增加.外加载荷的增加一方面归功于试样表面观察到的主裂纹并没有穿透整个试样厚度,另一方面因为应力场由缺口控制,只有随着外加载荷的增加,扩展的裂纹尖端才保持一定的应力.当两个层团的位向使裂纹从沿层扩展过渡到穿层扩展时,裂纹扩展阻力才提高.     

Multiaxial notch fatigue life prediction based on pseudo stress correction and finite element analysis under variable amplitude loading

A new computational methodology is proposed for fatigue life prediction of notched components subjected to variable amplitude multiaxial loading. In the proposed methodology, an estimation method of non‐proportionality factor (F) proposed by authors in the case of constant amplitude multiaxial loading is extended and applied to variable amplitude multiaxial loading by using Wang‐Brown's reversal counting approach. The pseudo stress correction method integrated with linear elastic finite element analysis is utilized to calculate the local elastic‐plastic stress and strain responses at the notch root. For whole local strain history, the plane with weight‐averaged maximum shear strain range is defined as the critical plane in this study. Based on the defined critical plane, a multiaxial fatigue damage model combined with Miner's linear cumulative damage law is used to predict fatigue life. The experimentally obtained fatigue data for 7050‐T7451 aluminium alloy notched shaft specimens under constant and variable amplitude multiaxial loadings are used to verify the proposed methodology and equivalent strain‐based methodology. The results show that the proposed methodology is superior to equivalent strain‐based methodology.     

Experimental investigation on low cycle fatigue and fracture behaviour of a notched Ni‐based superalloy at elevated temperature

In order to investigate the effects of stress concentration on low cycle fatigue properties and fracture behaviour of a nickel‐based powder metallurgy superalloy, FGH97, at elevated temperature, the low cycle fatigue tests have been conducted with semi‐circular and semi‐elliptical single‐edge notched plate specimens at 550 and 700 °C. The results show that the fatigue life of the notched specimen decreases with the increase of stress concentration factor and the fatigue crack initiation life evidently decreases because of the defect located in the stress concentration zone. Moreover, the plastic deformation induced by notch stress concentration affects the initial crack occurrence zone. The angle α of the crack occurrence zone is within ±10° of notch bisector for semi‐circular notched specimens and ±20° for semi‐elliptical notched specimens. The crack propagation rate decreases to a minimum at a certain length, D, and then increases with the growth of the crack. The crack propagation rate of the semi‐elliptical notched specimen decelerates at a faster rate than that of the semi‐circular notched specimen because of the increase of the notch plasticity gradient. The crack length, D, is affected by both the applied load and the notch plasticity gradient. In addition, the fracture mechanism is shown to transition from transgranular to intergranular as temperature increases from 550 to 700 °C, which would accelerate crack propagation and reduce the fatigue life.     

Creep properties of a U‐type notch plate in Ni‐based superalloy

In the present investigation, the effect of notch on creep rupture behavior and creep rupture life of a Ni‐based superalloy has been assessed by performing creep tests on smooth and U‐notched plate specimen under 0°C. The finite element analysis coupled with continuum damage mechanics are carried out to understand the stress distribution across the notch throat and the creep damage evolution under multi‐axial stress state. The creep rupture life of U‐notched specimen is much larger than that of plane plate specimen under the same stress condition, indicating that there is a strengthening effect on notch specimen. Creep rupture life increases with increasing the notch radius, the smaller notch radius can induce the creep rupture easier. The effect of notch on the creep damage is also studied. It is found that the location of the maximum creep damage and the maximum equivalent creep strain initiates first at the notch root and gradually moves to the inside as the notch radius increases.     

Fatigue strength analysis of notched aluminium specimens using the highly stressed volume method

This paper describes a methodology to analyse the fatigue strength of notched aluminium 7075 T7531 specimens using the highly stressed volume method. A straightforward test setup was developed to load test samples with different stress concentrations in repeated bending at high frequency. The highly stressed volumes are precisely determined using static finite element analysis in combination with Matlab for post‐processing. Mean values of the local endurable stress amplitudes are calculated by means of the staircase method. The results indicate that the highly stressed volume can be used as an accurate and efficient design parameter to take the notch‐effect in aluminium components into account.