Effects of nonionic surfactant on the rheological property of associative polymers in complex formulations

The rheological properties of hydrophobically modified ethoxylated urethane (HEUR) were investigated in the presence of a nonionic surfactant, polyoxyethylene stearyl ether (C₁₈(EO)₂₀). The presence of nonionic surfactants played an important role in tuning the rheological properties of HEUR aqueous solutions. Observing both plateau modulus and viscoelastic relaxation time of HEUR aqueous solutions with varying the concentration of C₁₈(EO)₂₀ allowed us to demonstrate that C₁₈(EO)₂₀ readily interacts with the hydrophobic segments of HEUR polymers, which eventually formed a strong micellar network. Moreover, the micellar network formed at a critical concentration of C₁₈(EO)₂₀, ∼0.6% w/v, was indeed stable against both ionic strength and pH in the aqueous medium and complex formulations, such as a colloid suspension and an oil-in-water emulsion, thus providing more practical applications as thickeners for a wide variety of complex formulations.     

Waterborne latex coatings of color: I. Component influences on viscosity decreases

For almost two decades, it has been known that the addition of colorants to a waterborne latex coating thicknened with an associative thickener will result in a viscosity loss. The influence of surfactants on viscosity variations in waterborne latex coatings, as discussed in our most recent JCTCoatingsTech article,¹ is the source of the viscosity decreases. To evaluate this problem, aqueous solutions containing large quantities of five different surfactants, and the smallest particle size of the colorants, carbon black (CB), were prepared. Large quantities of surfactant were used to allow for adsorption on, and stabilization of, CB. When traditional associative polymers (HMHEC, HASE, and a telechelic HEUR) were used to thicken carbon black dispersions, viscosity decreases were not observed, for most of the surfactnat is adsorbed on the CB’s surface. There is enough surfactant, however, to promote viscosity decreases in comb-HEUR thickened CB dispersions. Moving beyond the colorant dispersions, the CB, yellow, or red colorants were then added to a commercial latex paint that contains many surfactants, glycol ether, and coalescing aids, and significant viscosity decreases were observed. The decreases were very dramatic as the colorant concentration was increased to obtain deeper color tones, due to the additional excess surfactant added to the coating. Reduction in total surfactant levels in the colorant was an obvious solution, but this led to rub-up incompatibility. The conflict between viscosity retention and rub-up incompatibility was resolved when the surfactant concentration was reduced by adding to the colorant formulation compositionally different hydrophobically-modified poly(oxyethylenes) and hydrophobe-modified maleic acid co-oligomers. Presented in part at the 81st Annual Meeting of the Federation of Societies for Coatings Technology, November 13–14, 2003 in Philadelphia, PA     

Waterborne latex coatings of color: III. Triblock polyether influences on color development and viscosity

Oxyethylene (PEO)/oxypropylene (PPO) triblock polymers are added to colorant formulations to determine the influence of molecular weight and other structural variances on the rheology and color development of tinted latex paints. Waterborne coatings are a matrix of many coating components. In this study, a 108- or a 600-nm latex was thickened with a nonassociative thickener, hydroxyethyl cellulose, or an associative telechelic HEUR thickener. Triblock polymers with internal PPO segments and PEO terminal segments added as a dispersant to colorant packages, lead to better color development than PPO/PEO/PPO triblocks dispersants in carbon black (CB) tinted paints. The increase in color development with high molecular weight (MW) triblocks starts at a very low concentration (2 mM) and plateaus in a Langmuir-type adsorption isotherm. Lower molecular weight triblock polymers also exhibit this behavior in CB-, red-, and yellow-tinted latex coatings; however, increasing the terminal PEO segment sizes leads to better color development only in the CB-tinted coatings. With large PEO terminal units red and yellow tints are high only at very low concentrations (2 mM) of the triblock. This parabolic response in color development, in contrast to CB-tinted formulations, is attributed to the high surface area and porosity of CB that limits the amount of large PEO segments interacting with the talc particle present at twice the volume fraction of the colorant. With the lower surface areas of the red and yellow colorants, the interaction of the large PEO terminal segments with talc particles accounts for the limited triblock concentration for which good color development is observed. This can be reversed by decreasing or eliminating talc from the formulation.     

Performance and Efficiency of Anionic Dishwashing Liquids with Amphoteric and Nonionic Surfactants

Performance and efficiency of anionic [sodium lauryl ether sulfate (SLES) and sodium α-olefin sulfonate (AOS)] and amphoteric [cocamidopropyl betaine (CAB)] as well as nonionic [cocodiethanol amide (DEA), various ethoxylated alcohols (C₁₂–C₁₅–7EO, C₁₀–7EO and C₉–C₁₁–7EO) and lauramine oxide (AO)] surfactants in various dishwashing liquid mixed micelle systems have been studied at different temperatures (17.0, 23.0 and 42.0 °C). The investigated parameters were critical micelle concentration (CMC), surface tension (γ), cleaning performance and, foaming, biodegradability and irritability of anionic (SLES/AOS) and anionic/amphoteric/nonionic (SLES/AOS/CAB/AO) as well as anionic/nonionic (SLES/AOS/DEA/AO, SLES/AOS/C₁₂-C₁₅-7EO/AO, SLES/AOS/C₁₀–7EO/AO and SLES/AOS/C₉–C₁₁–7EO/AO) dishwashing surfactant mixtures. In comparison to the starting binary SLES/AOS surfactant mixture, addition of various nonionic surfactants promoted CMC and γ lowering, enhanced cleaning performance and foaming, but did not significantly affect biodegradability and irritability of dishwashing formulations. The anionic/nonionic formulation SLES/AOS/C₉–C₁₁–7EO/AO shows both the lowest CMC and γ as well as the best cleaning performance, compared to the other examined dishwashing formulations. However, the results in this study reveal that synergistic behavior of anionic/nonionic SLES/AOS/ethoxylated alcohols/AO formulations significantly improves dishwashing performance and efficiency at both low and regular dishwashing temperatures (17.0 and 42.0 °C) and lead to better application properties.     

Unifying model for associative thickener influences on waterborne coatings: II. Competitive adsorption of nonionic surfactants and HEUR thickeners on titanium dioxide pretreated with inorganic stabilizers and organic oligomeric dispersants

Size exclusion chromatography in tandem with UV absorbance of the surfactant is used to separate and quantify the amount of nonionic surfactant and model hydrophobically modified ethoxylated urethane (HEUR) thickeners adsorbed on different organic oligomeric polyacid, metal oxide-treated TiO₂ surfaces. The isoelectric point imposed on TiO₂ by the metal oxide surface treatment determines the amount of organic dispersant adsorbed. The size of the α-olefin on the maleic acid dispersant is also important in the adsorption of the dispersant. The size of the α-olefin on the organic acid dispersant, in turn, determines the amount of surfactant and HEUR thickener adsorbed. The surfactant, unlike the HEUR thickener, exhibits a dependence on the metal oxide treatment in neutral media, independent in several aspects of the amount of organic dispersant adsorbed. The adsorption dependence of HEUR thickeners and nonionic surfactant on the hydrophobe size of the HEUR is discussed. Presented at the 69th Annual Meeting of the Federation of Societies for Coatings Technology, on October 23, 1996 in Chicago, IL Polymers and Coatings Dept., Dunbar Hall, Fargo, ND 58105. Chestnut Run, Building 709, Wilmington, DE 19898.     

Spray applications: Part IV. Compositional influences of HEUR thickeners on the spray and velocity profiles of waterborne latex coatings

In this study, the focus is on the spray behavior of latex coatings thickened with structurally different surfactant-modified, water-soluble polymers (associative thickeners of the hydrophobically modified, ethoxylated urethane [HEUR] type). Particle image velocimetry (PIV) profiles are considered in the perspective of the dynamic uniaxial extensional viscosity (DUEV) of the coatings and an effort to understand the results in terms of the structural aspects of the thickener molecules is undertaken. A high-M _v hydroxyethyl cellulose (HEC) thickened formulation, with a significant DUEV, does not atomize well. Among the HEUR thickeners, the addition of larger hydrophobes in the terminal positions requires less thickener to achieve a 90 KU viscosity and produces lower DUEVs and lower viscosities at high-shear rates. This is necessary to produce formulations with acceptable spray characteristics (i.e., good atomization). The sprayability of these systems is reflected in their velocity profiles and particle size/particle size distributions. Poorer spray characteristics are reflected in ligaments and broad particles size distributions. This study highlights the ability to control the particle size/size distribution and velocity profiles of coatings formulations through the use of structurally different HEUR associative thickeners. Variations in sprayability among different nozzle geometries are also studied. Presented at the 2006 FutureCoat! conference, sponsored by the Federation of Societies for Coatings Technology, in New Orleans, LA, on November 1–3, 2006.     

Forecasting the cloud point of alkoxylated nonionic surfactants

The highest effectiveness of detergency for nonionic surfactants is observed in the proximity of the cloud point. This phenomenon is primarily influenced by surfactant molecular structure, such as carbon chain length and type of the hydrophilic components. Target of this investigation is to identify a relationship between the cloud point and the structure of nonionic surfactants based on ethoxylated (C_nE_m), ethoxylated-propoxylated (C_nE_mP_p) and propoxylated-ethoxylated (C_nP_pE_m) fatty alcohols. Three hundred and fifty nonionic surfactants have been prepared for this purpose. These surfactants differ in the C-chain lengths, C₄/C₆ to C₂₀/C₂₂, and the amount of ethylene oxide (EO range [n] 2–22 ethoxylation) and propylene oxide (PO range [p] 0–12 propoxylation) moieties. Mapping the differences in the performance allows us to propose a high-accuracy topological model describing the structure influence on the cloud point.     

Surfactant behavior and its influence on the viscosity of associative thickeners solutions, thickened latex dispersions, and waterborne latex coatings

Surfactants, varying in their chemical composition and hydrophobic behavior, are used in the formulation of a waterborne coating. These differences influence their aggregation in micellar structures, their interaction with associative thickeners, and in particular, the synergies present in their competitive adsorptions on the disperse phases in a waterborne coating. Adsorption of HEUR thickeners on latexes and the ability of surfactants to displace them from those surfaces is an important variable in the dispersion’s viscosity. With large particle latexes, viscosity increases arise primarily from the network built through the interaction of HEURs with surfactants in the aqueous phase. Fluorescence is used to verify the mechanism by which surfactants enhance associative thickener viscosities. That is best achieved with nonionic surfactants, because of their synergies with large hydrophobe HEURs at low concentration. With decreasing latex particle size the adsorbed species is an important contributor to the dispersion’s viscosity through its contribution to the latex’s effective volume fraction increase and when the size of the adsorbed HEUR is matched to the separation distances of the latex at 0.25 volume fraction. Achieving controlled shear-thinning behavior in small particle size latex paints with the economic constraints on the amount of HEUR required to obtain 90 KU viscosities are discussed. Presented at the 80th Annual Meeting of the Federation of Societies for Coatings Technology, October 30–November 1, 2002, in New Orleans, LA. Polymer and Coatings Dept., Fargo, ND 58103.     

On the measurement of critical micelle concentrations of pure and technical-grade nonionic surfactants

The critical micelle concentrations (CMC) of nine commercial nonionic surfactants (Tween 20, 22, 40, 60, and 80; Triton X-100; Brij 35, 58, and 78) and two pure nonionics [C₁₂(EO)₅ and C₁₂(EO)₈] were determined by surface tension and dye micellization methods. Commercially available nonionic surfactants (technical grade) usually contain impurities and have a broad molecular weight distribution owing to the degree of ethoxylation. It was shown that the surface tension method (Wilhelmy plate) is very sensitive to the presence of impurities. Much lower CMC values were obtained with the surface tension method than with the dye micellization method (up to 6.5 times for Tween 22). In the presence of highly surfaceactive impurities, the air/liquid interface is already saturated at concentrations well below the true CMC, leading to a wrong interpretation of the break in the curve of surface tension (γ) vs. concentration of nonionic surfactant (log C). The actual onset of micellization happens at higher concentrations, as measured by the dye micellization method. Furthermore, it was shown that when a commercial surfactant sample (Tween 20) is subjected to foam fractionation, thereby removing species with higher surface activity, the sample yields almost the same CMC values as measured by surface tension and dye micellization methods. It was found that for monodisperse pure nonionic surfactants, both CMC determination methods yield the same results. Therefore, this study indicates that precaution should be taken when determining the CMC of commercial nonionic surfactants by the surface tension method, as it indicates the surface concentration of all surface-active species at the surface only, whereas the dye method indicates the presence of micelles in the bulk solution.     

Studies on Surfactant–Ionic Liquid Interaction on Clouding Behaviour and Evaluation of Thermodynamic Parameters

The present study investigates the effect of tetraethyl ammonium tetrafluoroborate [TEA(BF₄)] ionic liquid (IL) on the cloud point (CP) of the following nonionic surfactants in aqueous solution: ter‐octylphenol ethoxylates with 9.5 and 4.5 ethylene oxide groups (abbreviated TOPEO9.5 and TOPEO4.5, respectively), cetyl alcohol ethoxylate with 10 ethylene oxide groups (C16EO10), and sorbitan monolaurate and monooleate both with 20 ethylene oxide groups (SMLEO20 and SMOEO20, respectively) in aqueous solutions. The thermodynamic parameters of these mixtures were calculated at different IL concentrations. The CP of most of the tested nonionic surfactants increased with the increment of IL concentrations with the exception of C16EO10 for which it decreased. The solubility of a nonionic surfactant containing polyoxyethylene (POE) hydrophilic chain was considered as maximum at the CP, hence the thermodynamic parameters were calculated at the same temperature. The results showed that the standard Gibbs free energy (?G_CP⁰), the enthalpy (?H_CP⁰) and the entropy (?S_CP⁰) of the clouding phenomenon were found to be positive for ethoxylated octylphenol and sorbitan esters, whereas ?H_CP⁰ and ?S_CP⁰ were found to be negative for C16EO10. It was found that the overall clouding process is endothermic for ethoxylated octylphenol and sorbitan esters and exothermic for C16EO10. For all the studied systems, ?H_CP⁰ > T?S_CP⁰ indicated that the process of clouding is guided by both enthalpy and entropy. The positive value of standard Gibbs free energy (?G_CP⁰) for the all mixed systems indicated that the process proceeds non‐spontaneously. The ?G_CP⁰ decreased with increasing IL concentration for all the nonionic surfactants; however, it decreased with increasing surfactant concentration for TOPEO9.5, C16EO10, and SMOEO20, and increased with increasing surfactant concentration for TOPEO9.5 and SMLEO20.     

Performance and properties of nonionic surfactants from linear secondary alcohols

Surfactants based on the linear secondary alcohols provide a new source of biodegradable detergents. The nonionic surfactants of these alcohols are discussed in relationship to their surfactant properties and performance in detergent formulations. The performance properties in detergent formulations are defined by the results of detergency and foam stability tests. The surfactant properties presented are viscosity, surface tension, wetting and alkaline color stability. The above properties of the nonionic surfactants from the linear secondary alcohols have been compared to the properties of the less degradable nonylphenol nonionics and to the nonionic surfactants from the linear alkylphenol, oxo alcohol and Ziegler alcohol hydrophobes.     

Effects of Surfactant Headgroups on Oil-in-Water Emulsion Droplet Formation: An Experimental and Simulation Study

Nonpolar oils such as kerosene and diesel oil are common collectors in coal flotation. Surfactants are usually added to the pulp to emulsify the oil collectors. The present study used dodecane as the oil collector and anionic sodium dodecyl sulfonate (SDS) and nonionic tetraethylene glycol monododecyl ether (C₁₂EO) with different headgroups and identical chain alkyls to investigate the effect of the surfactant headgroups on oil-in-water emulsion droplet formation. The morphology and stability of dodecane emulsions were determined experimentally. Density functional theory (DFT) and molecular dynamics (MD) simulations were used to explain the microscopic mechanism. The results of DFT indicated a larger interaction between SDS and the water molecules than that between C₁₂EO and water molecules. The results obtained by MD suggested that the SDS headgroup exhibited a loose arrangement and a relatively large gap size, thereby weakening the interaction between SDS and water molecules at the dodecane/water interface. In contrast, the headgroups of C₁₂EO were bent and interwoven with others to form a tight reticulation at the interface. According to the simulation results, the ability of the surfactant to form dodecane-in-water emulsion droplets depends on the arrangement of the surfactants at the oil–water interface rather than on the interaction strength between the headgroups of the surfactants and water molecules. The presented microscopic mechanism of the surfactant headgroup formation of oil-in-water emulsion droplets offers surfactant selection and design references.     

Dissolution of Soap Scum by Surfactant Part I: Effects of Chelant and Type of Soap Scum

The equilibrium solubilities of two model soap scums [calcium stearate and magnesium stearate: Ca(C₁₈)₂ and Mg(C₁₈)₂] were measured in aqueous solutions containing three different types of surfactants: methyl ester sulfonate (MES) as an anionic; alcohol ethoxylate (EO9) as a nonionic; and dimethyldodecylamine oxide (DDAO) as an amphoteric with and without a chelating agent [disodium ethylenediaminetetraacetate (Na₂EDTA)]. The solubility of calcium soap scum was generally higher than that of magnesium soap scum, the exception being some DDAO systems. The use of the DDAO surfactant with the Na₂EDTA chelating agent at high pH gives the highest solubilities of both studied soap scums. The soap scum solubility is on the order of 2,000 times that in water at high pH. The DDAO is the most effective surfactant under all conditions. The MES is more effective than the EO9 at low pH with the opposite trend observed at high pH. The synergism from added chelant is generally greater at higher pH and is greatest for DDAO followed by EO9.     

Effect of alkyl carbon chain length and ethylene oxide content on the performance of linear alcohol ethoxylates

A grid of 30 surfactants varying from C₈ to C₁₈ in carbon chain length and from 40 to 80% in ethylene oxide (EO) content were examined to determine the effect of molecular structure on the physical properties (density, melting point, solution viscosity) and performance properties (surface activity, detergency, hard-surface cleaning, foaming, wetting) of linear alcohol ethoxylates. Results show that while physical propeties are influenced primarily by EO content, both carbon chain length and EO content are important to performance. Optimum carbon chain length is also shown to depend strongly on surfactant concentration. Presented at the AOCS meeting in New Orleans in May 1987.     

Phase behaviors and film properties of dispersions and coatings containing associative and conventional thickeners

Phase-separation behaviors of latex dispersions, using commercial latices of three different median sizes, and pigmented coatings are examined. Both the dispersions and pigmented coatings at a 0.32 volume fraction of total dispersed phase were thickened with water-soluble polymers, with and without surfactant hydrophobes. Latex dispersions thickened with water-soluble polymers without hydrophobe modification follow the phase-separation behavior described by the volume restriction flocculation (VRF) concept (i.e., molecular weight of the thickener or particle size of the latex). This is surprising since commercial latices contain a variety of surface-stabilizing moieties, in addition to surfactant. Latex dispersions thickened with commercial and model hydrophobically modified ethoxylated urethane (HEUR) polymers do not follow the phase-separation behavior predicted by the VRF concept. The lack of correlation of phase behavior with latex median size in HEUR-thickened formulations led to an examination of four secondary thickeners, noted for providing high viscosities at low shear rates. With an all-acrylic, large median-size latex, the combinations of commercial HEURs with secondary thickeners are effective in eliminating phase separation; only partial reduction in phase separation is observed with a vinyl acetateacrylic large-particle latex. The influence of HEUR/secondary thickener blends on the film properties also is discussed. © 1993 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.     

Associative polymer/latex dispersion phase diagrams II: HASE thickeners

The colloidal interactions of HASE associative polymers and latexes in the presence of surfactant are complicated and subject to a number of variables. Both bridging and depletion flocculation can occur, in addition to good particle dispersion. Dispersion phase diagrams have been developed to help visualize these interactions. The various dispersion states can have a significant effect on coating formulations and film properties. Examples of dispersion phase diagrams are presented for a model HASE anionic associative thickener and various model latexes in the presence of sodium dodecyl-sulfate and nonionic surfactants. The major variables affecting dispersion behavior are associative polymer concentration, latex particle size, latex surface hydrophobicity, electrolyte concentration, and surfactant concentration. The dispersion phase behavior of the HASE systems is compared to that of HEUR thickened systems reported previously. A significant difference is that much less bridging flocculation is observed in the HASE systems. In addition, nonionic surfactants induced depletion flocculation in the HASE systems but not in the HEUR systems.     

Influence of Ionic Surfactants on the Formation of Liquid Crystals in Oleic Acid/Glycol/Water Systems

The influence of surfactant structure on the formation of lamellar liquid crystals with very low surfactant concentration was investigated for systems composed of oleic acid, diethyleneglycol ethyl ether and water. Surfactants belonging to anionic and cationic families were checked: phosphated oleyl ether 3 EO (PO₃EO), triethanolamine oleate (TEAO) and sodium lauryl ether sulphate (SLES) as anionic surfactants and two alkyl trimethylammonium bromide type (C₁₂TAB and C₁₄TAB) as cationic surfactants. For each of the surfactants, the appropriate relationships between surfactant, oleic acid and glycol to furnish lamellar liquid crystals when these basic compositions were further diluted with water were established. The appropriate ranges of dilution allowing the liquid crystal formation were also determined. These liquid crystals presented an attractive appearance because of their transparency and high viscosity, although in the beginning of its formation, a short range of less viscous compositions (so called liquid/gel compositions) appears in some cases. Through water dilution, the initial surfactant percentages are noticeably reduced being possible liquid crystals with 2–5 wt% of surfactant.

Laundry Detergency of Solid Nonparticulate Soil or Waxy Solids: Part II. Effect of the Surfactant Type

In this work, methyl palmitate with a melting point around 30°C was used as a model of waxy soil. Its detergency was evaluated with a hydrophilic surface (cotton) or a hydrophobic surface (polyester) using different surfactants: alcohol ethoxylate (EO9), sodium dodecyl sulfate (SDS), methyl ester sulfonate (MES), methyl ester ethoxylate (MEE), and two extended surfactants (C_12,14-10PO-2EO-SO₄Na and C_12,14-16PO-2EO-SO₄Na). The detergency efficiency at a 0.2 wt.% surfactant and 5 wt.% NaCl gradually increased while redeposition gradually decreased with increasing washing temperature in most studied surfactant solutions; this was observed both above and below the melting point of methyl palmitate on both studied fabrics. If the methyl palmitate was heated above the melting point when deposited on the fabric, it was better able to penetrate into the fabric matrix as compared to deposition below the melting point, resulting in poorer detergency for heated deposition, particularly for washing temperatures lower than the melting point. Among the surfactants studied, the nonionic surfactant (EO9) showed the highest detergency efficiency (73–94%) at any washing temperature especially on the polyester fabric. For washing temperatures below the melting point, detergency performance correlated well with the contact angle of surfactant solution on the solid methyl palmitate surface for all studied surfactants when salinity was varied. In this work, conditions resulting in the highest detergency below the melting point corresponded to the highest detergency above the melting point, suggesting this as a systematic approach to formulating below the melting point of the soil. Charge of particles or fabric was not observed to be important to the detergency mechanism, but steric factors resulting from surfactant adsorption were observed to be important mechanistic factors in waxy solid detergency.     

Hydrotropic and surfactant properties of novel diisopropyl naphthalene sulfonates

A novel surfactant and hydrotrope, sodium diisopropylnaphthalene sulfonate (SDIPNS) has been developed. It contains about 92% diisopropylnaphthalene sulfonate, compared to other materials which are less than 50% diisopropylnaphthalene sulfonate. Aqueous solutions of 34–36% active SDIPNS have dual functionality. They have excellent surface properties and are compatible with conventional anionic, nonionic, and amphoteric surfactants. They demonstrate good laundering detergency in combination with sodium lauryl ethoxy sulfate, with or without builder. They maintain surface activity in 150 ppm hard water (Ca²⁺/Mg²⁺=2∶1), 5% NaCl, pH 2, and pH 12. They are effective hydrotropes. They enhance surfactant solubility, raise the cloud point of nonionic surfactants, and modify the viscosity of surfactant formulations. They are light in color and are low-foaming. Presented as a Poster Session at the American Oil Chemists' Society Annual Meeting, May 9–12, 1999, Orlando, Florida.