An experimental study on CHF enhancement in flow boiling using Al2O3 nano-fluid

The critical heat flux (CHF) is one of the most important thermal hydraulic parameters in heat transfer system design and safety analyses. CHF enhancement allows higher limits of operation conditions such that heat transfer equipment can be operated safely with greater margins and better economy. The application of nano-fluids is thought to have strong potential for enhancing the CHF. In this study, zeta potentials of Al₂O₃ nano-fluids were measured and flow boiling CHF enhancement experiments using Al₂O₃ nano-fluids were conducted under atmospheric pressure. The CHFs of Al₂O₃ nano-fluids were enhanced up to ～70% in flow boiling for all experimental conditions. Maximum CHF enhancement (70.24%) was shown at 0.01 vol% concentration, 50 °C inlet subcooling, and a mass flux of 100 kg/m² s. Inner surfaces of the test section tube were observed by FE–SEM and the zeta potentials of Al₂O₃ nano-fluids were measured before and after the CHF experiments.     

Effects of high subcooling on two-phase spray cooling and critical heat flux

Experiments were performed with FC-77 using three full-cone spray nozzles to assess the influence of subcooling on spray performance and critical heat flux (CHF) from a 1.0 × 1.0 cm² test surface. The relatively high boiling point of FC-77 (97 °C at one atmosphere) enabled testing at relatively high levels of subcooling. Increasing the subcooling delayed the onset of boiling but decreased the slope of the nucleate boiling region of the spray boiling curve. The enhancement in CHF was relatively mild at low subcooling and more appreciable at high subcooling. CHF was enhanced by about a 100% when subcooling was increased from 22 to 70 °C, reaching values as high as 349 W/cm². The FC-77 data were combined with prior spray CHF data from several studies into a broad CHF database encompassing different nozzles, fluids, flow rates, spray orientations, and subcoolings. The entire CHF database was used to modify the effect of subcooling in a previous CHF correlation that was developed for relatively low subcoolings. The modified correlation shows excellent predictive capability.     

Critical heat flux of steady boiling for saturated liquids jet impinging on the stagnation zone

An experimental investigation was carried out for predicting the critical heat flux (CHF) of convective boiling of saturated liquids for a round jet impinging on the horizontal jet stagnation zone. The model of maximum liquid subfilm thickness based on the Helmholtz instability was used to derive a semi-theoretical equation. The experimental data of four liquids: water, ethanol, R-113 and R-11 were employed to determine the correlation factor. The impact velocity ranged from 0.5 m/s to 10 m/s and the diameters of the jet nozzle ranged from 3 mm to 10 mm. A semi-theoretical correlation was proposed for predicting CHF of convective boiling for saturated liquids jet impinging on the stagnation zone in a wide range.     

Correlation of critical heat flux in hybrid jet impingement/micro-channel cooling scheme

Experiments were performed to investigate the two-phase cooling characteristics of a new hybrid cooling scheme combining the cooling attributes of slot jets and micro-channel flow. A test module was constructed in which dielectric PF-5052 liquid was introduced through five 0.48 mm wide and 12.7 mm long slot jets, each leading to a 1.59 mm wide and 1.02 mm deep channel. Increases in flow rate and subcooling yielded similar trends of delaying the inception of boiling and increasing critical heat flux (CHF). A previous channel flow correlation predicted CHF values far smaller than measured, while those for slot jets yielded closer predictions. This proves the cooling performance of the hybrid configuration is dominated more by jet impingement than by micro-channel flow. By dividing the test surface into a portion that is dominated by jet impingement and another by micro-channel flow, and applying the appropriate CHF correlation for each portion, the CHF data for this hybrid cooling configuration are predicted with a mean absolute error of 8.42%.     

Single-phase and two-phase cooling with an array of rectangular jets

Experiments were performed to explore the effects of jet width, impingement velocity, and inlet subcooling on the cooling performance of an array of three confined rectangular FC-72 and ethanol jets impacting a 3.0 cm × 3.0 cm heated surface. The single-phase heat transfer coefficient increased with increasing jet velocity and/or jet width. A correlation for single-phase cooling was constructed by dividing the flow into impingement zones and confinement channel flow regions that are dominated by wall jet flow. Increases in jet velocity, jet width, and/or subcooling broadened the single-phase region preceding the commencement of boiling and enhanced critical heat flux (CHF). A new correlation was developed which fits the CHF data with good accuracy. Overall, better cooling performance was realized for a given flow rate by decreasing jet width. Pressure drop was for the most part quite modest, even for the smallest jet width and highest velocity tested. Overall, these results prove the present cooling scheme is highly effective at maintaining fairly isothermal surface conditions, with spatial variations of less than 1.2 and 2.6 °C for the single-phase and boiling regions, respectively. These results demonstrate the effectiveness of the present jet-impingement scheme for thermal management of next generation electronics devices and systems.     

Correlation of critical heat flux for flow boiling of water in mini-channels

In view of practical significance of a correlation of critical heat flux (CHF) in the aspects of engineering design and prediction, this study is aiming at evaluation of existing CHF correlations for flow boiling of water with available databases taken from small-diameter tubes, and then development of a new, simple CHF correlation. Available CHF databases in the literature for flow boiling of water in small-diameter tubes (0.33 < D_h < 6.22 mm) are collected, covering wide parametric ranges. Three correlations by Bowring, Katto and Shah are evaluated with the CHF data for saturated flow boiling, and three correlations by Inasaka–Nariai, Celata et al. and Hall–Mudawar evaluated with the CHF data for subcooled flow boiling. The Hall–Mudawar correlation and the Shah correlation seem to be the most reliable tools for CHF prediction in the subcooled and saturated flow boiling regions, respectively. In order to avoid the defect of predictive discontinuities often encountered when applying previous correlations, a simple, nondimensional, inlet conditions dependent CHF correlation for saturated flow boiling has been formulated. Its functional form is determined by the application of the artificial neural network and parametric trend analyses to the collected database. Superiority of this correlation has been verified by the database. The new correlation has a mean deviation of 16.8% for this collected databank, smallest among all tested correlations. Compared to many inordinately complex correlations, this new correlation consists only of a single equation.     

Dispersed flow film boiling in vertical narrow annular gaps

Dispersed flow film boiling heat transfer in vertical narrow annular gaps with gap sizes of 1.0, 1.5 and 2.0 mm was experimentally investigated with de-ionized water as the working fluid at low mass velocities. Comparisons of the experimental data with established correlations show that the correlations are not accurate for small gaps. The influences of the heating mode (only one tube heating or both tubes heated), the gap size and the tube diameter were analyzed. The data was correlated in the form of the Groeneveld equation with a modified wall temperature factor as use in the Polomik correlation and a modified gap size factor as use in the Yun and Muthu correlation. A new correlation was developed for dispersed flow film boiling heat transfer based on the experimental data for 1.0–2.0 mm gaps.     

Enhancement of pool boiling critical heat flux in dielectric liquids by microporous coatings

An experimental investigation into the effects of pressure and subcooling on the pool boiling critical heat flux from a bare silicon chip-like heater and from a silicon heater coated with microporous layers, is reported. The dual inline heater package was immersed in FC-72, a dielectric fluid, and the experiments were performed in the horizontal orientation, with subcooling varying between 0 K and 72 K, and the pressure between 101.3 kPa and 303.9 kPa. The maximum CHF values on the diamond-base microporous-coated silicon heater were found to reach 47 W/cm², at 3 atm and nearly 50 K of subcooling, and to provide an average enhancement of approximately 60% over the values attained with un-treated silicon surfaces. An available CHF correlation, with a reported standard deviation of 12.5% for un-treated surfaces over a large range of pressures, subcoolings, and surface conditions, was shown to predict the pressure and subcooling effects on CHF from the surface-enhanced chip with a standard deviation of 12%.     

Boiling heat transfer and critical heat flux of ethanol–water mixtures flowing through a diverging microchannel with artificial cavities

This paper presents an experimental study on the convective boiling heat transfer and the critical heat flux (CHF) of ethanol–water mixtures in a diverging microchannel with artificial cavities. The results show that the boiling heat transfer and the CHF are significantly influenced by the molar fraction (x_m) as well as the mass flux. For the single-phase convection region except for the region near the onset of nucleate boiling with temperature overshoot, the single-phase heat transfer coefficient is independent of the wall superheat and increases with a decrease in the molar fraction. After boiling incipience, the two-phase heat transfer coefficient is much higher than that of single-phase convection. The two-phase heat transfer coefficient shows a maximum in the region of bubbly-elongated slug flow and deceases with a further increase in the wall superheat until approaching a condition of CHF, indicating that the heat transfer is mainly dominated by convective boiling. A flow-pattern-based empirical correlation for the two-phase heat transfer coefficient of the flow boiling of ethanol–water mixtures is developed. The overall mean absolute error of the proposed correlation is 15.5%, and more than 82.5% of the experimental data were predicted within a ±25% error band. The CHF increases from x_m = 0–0.1, and then decreases rapidly from x_m = 0.1–1 at a given mass flux of 175 kg/m² s. The maximum CHF is reached at x_m = 0.1 due to the Marangoni effect, indicating that small additions of ethanol into water could significantly increase the CHF. On the other hand, the CHF increases with increasing the mass flux at a given molar fraction of 0.1. Moreover, the experimental CHF results are compared with existing CHF correlations of flow boiling of the mixtures in a microchannel.     

Heat transfer characteristics during subcooled flow boiling of a kerosene kind hydrocarbon fuel in a 1 mm diameter channel

The subcooled flow boiling heat transfer characteristics of a kerosene kind hydrocarbon fuel were investigated in an electrically heated horizontal tube with an inner diameter of 1.0 mm, in the range of heat flux: 20–1500 kW/m², fluid temperature: 25–400 °C, mass flux: 1260–2160 kg/m² s, and pressure: 0.25–2.5 MPa. It was proposed that nucleate boiling heat transfer mechanism is dominant, as the heat transfer performance is dependent on heat flux imposed on the channel, rather than the fuel flow rate. It was found that the wall temperatures along the test section kept constant during the fully developed subcooled boiling (FDSB) of the non-azeotropic hydrocarbon fuel. After the onset of nucleate boiling, the temperature differences between inner wall and bulk fluid begin to decrease with the increase of heat flux. Experimental results show that the complicated boiling heat transfer behavior of hydrocarbon fuel is profoundly affected by the pressure and heat flux, especially by fuel subcooling. A correlation of heat transfer coefficients varying with heat fluxes and fuel subcooling was curve fitted. Excellent agreement is obtained between the predicted values and the experimental data.     

Maximum heat flux in relation to quenching of a high temperature surface with liquid jet impingement

Experimental investigation has been conducted for quenching of hot cylindrical blocks made of copper, brass and steel with initial block temperature 250–400 °C by a subcooled water jet of diameter of 2 mm. The subcooling was from 5 to 80 K and the jet velocity was from 3 to 15 m/s. After impingement, the jet stagnates for a certain period of time in a small region near the centre and then the wetting front starts moving outwards. During this movement, when the surface temperature at the wetting front drops to 120–200 °C, the surface heat flux reaches its maximum value due to forced convection nucleation boiling. The maximum heat flux is a strong function of the position on the hot surface, jet velocity, block material properties and jet subcooling. A new correlation for maximum heat flux is proposed.     

Dry-out CHF correlation for R134a flow boiling in a horizontal helically-coiled tube

An experimental study was carried out to investigate the R134a dry-out critical heat flux (CHF) characteristics in a horizontal helically-coiled tube. The test section was heated uniformly by DC high-power source, and its geometrical parameters are the outer diameter of 10 mm, inner diameter of 8.4 mm, coil diameter of 300 mm, helical pitch of 75 mm and valid heated length of 1.89 m. The experimental parameters are the outlet pressures of 0.30–0.95 MPa, mass fluxes of 60–500 kg m^?2 s^?1, inlet qualities of ?0.36–0.35 and heat fluxes of 7.0 × 10³–5.0 × 10⁴ W m^?2. A method based on Agilent BenchLink Data Logger Pro was developed to determine the occurrence of CHF with a total of 68 T-type thermocouples (0.2 mm) set along the tube for accurate temperature measurement. The characteristics of wall temperatures and the parametric effect on dry-out CHF showed that temperature would jump abruptly at the point of CHF, which usually started to form at the front and offside (270° and 90°) of the outlet cross-section. The CHF values decrease nearly linearly with increasing inlet qualities, while they decrease more acutely with increasing critical qualities, especially under larger mass flux conditions. The mass flux has a positive effect on CHF enhancement, but the pressure has negative one. A new dimensionless correlation was developed to estimate dry-out CHF of R134a flow boiling in horizontal helically-coiled tubes under current experimental conditions and compared to calculated results from Bowring and Shah correlations.     

Enhanced flow boiling heat transfer of FC-72 on micro-pin-finned surfaces

For the purpose of cooling electronic components with high heat flux efficiently, some experiments were conducted to study the flow boiling heat transfer performance of FC-72 on silicon chips. Micro-pin-fins were fabricated on the chip surface using a dry etching technique to enhance boiling heat transfer. Three different fluid velocities (0.5, 1 and 2 m/s) and three different liquid subcoolings (15, 25 and 35 K) were performed, respectively. A smooth chip (chip S) and four micro-pin-finned chips with the same fin thickness of 30 μm and different fin heights of 60 μm (chip PF30–60) and 120 μm (chip PF30–120), respectively, were tested. All the micro-pin-finned surfaces show a considerable heat transfer enhancement compared to the smooth one, and the critical heat flux increases in the order of chip S, PF30–60 and PF30–120. For a lower ratio of fin height to fin pitch and/or higher fluid velocity, the fluid velocity has a positive effect on the nucleate boiling curves for the micro-pin-finned surfaces. At the velocities lower than 1 m/s, the micro-pin-finned surfaces show a sharp increase in heat flux with increasing wall superheat, and the wall temperature at the critical heat flux (CHF) is less than the upper limit, 85 °C, for the reliable operation of LSI chips. The CHF values for all surfaces increase with fluid velocity and subcooling. The maximum CHF can reach nearly 150 W/cm² for chip PF30–120 at the fluid velocity of 2 m/s and the liquid subcooling of 35 K.     

Critical heat flux on flow boiling of methanol–water mixtures in a diverging microchannel with artificial cavities

This study constitutes an experimental investigation into the convective boiling heat transfer and critical heat flux (CHF) of methanol–water mixtures in a diverging microchannel with artificial cavities. Flow visualization shows that bubbles are generally nucleated at both the artificial cavities and side walls of the channel. This confirms the proper functioning of such artificial cavities. Consequently, the wall superheat of the onset nucleate boiling is significantly reduced. Experimental results show that the boiling heat transfer and CHF are significantly influenced by the molar fraction (x_m) as well as the mass flux. The CHF increases with an increase in mass flux at the same molar fraction. On the other hand, the CHF increases slightly from x_m = 0 to 0.3, and then decreases rapidly from x_m = 0.3 to 1 at the same mass flux. The maximum CHF is reached at x_m = 0.3, particularly for a mass flux of 175 kg/m² s, due to the Marangoni effect. Flow visualization confirms that the Marangoni effect helps a region with a liquid film breakup persist to a higher heat flux, and therefore a higher CHF. Moreover, a new empirical correlation involving the Marangoni effect for the CHF on the flow boiling of methanol–water mixtures is developed. The present correlation prediction shows excellent agreement with the experimental data, and further confirms that the present correlation may predict the Marangoni effect on the CHF for the convective boiling heat transfer of binary mixtures.     

Subcooled flow boiling CHF enhancement with porous surface coatings

The effect of micro/nanoporous inside surface coated vertical tubes on CHF was determined during water flow boiling at atmospheric pressure. CHF was measured for smooth and three different coated tubes, at mass fluxes (100–300 kg/m² s) and two inlet subcooling temperatures (50 °C and 75 °C). Greater CHF enhancement was found with microporous coatings than with nanoporous coatings. Al₂O₃ microporous coatings with particle size <10 μm and coatings thickness of 50 μm showed the best CHF enhancement. Maximum increase in CHF was about 25% for microporous Al₂O₃. A wettability test was performed to study an increase of CHF with microporous coated surfaces.     

Correlation of critical heat flux and two-phase friction factor for subcooled convective boiling in structured surface microchannels

Critical heat flux (CHF) and pressure drop of subcooled flow boiling are measured for a microchannel heat sink containing 75 parallel 100 μm × 200 μm structured surface channels. The heated surface is made of a Cu metal sheet with/without 2 μm thickness diamond film. Tests and measurements are conducted with de-ionized water, de-ionized water +1 vol.% MCNT additive solution, and FC-72 fluids over a mass velocity range of 820–1600 kg/m² s, with inlet temperatures of 15(8.6)°C, 25(13.6)°C, 44(24.6)°C, and 64(36.6)°C for DI water (FC-72), and heat fluxes up to 600 W/cm². The CHF of subcooled flow boiling of the test fluids in the microchannels is measured parametrically. The two-phase pressure drop is also measured. Both CHF and the two-phase friction factor correlation for one-side heating with two other side-structured surface microchannels are proposed and developed in terms of the relevant parameters.     

On the rise paths of single vapor bubbles after the departure from nucleation sites in subcooled upflow boiling

A photographic study was carried out for the subcooled flow boiling of water to elucidate the rise characteristics of single vapor bubbles after the departure from nucleation sites. The test section was a transparent glass tube of 20 mm in inside diameter and the flow direction was vertical upward; liquid subcooling was parametrically changed within 0–16 K keeping system pressure and liquid velocity at 120 kPa and 1 m/s, respectively. The bubble rise paths were analyzed from the video images that were obtained at the heat flux slightly higher than the minimum heat flux for the onset of nucleate boiling. In the present experiments, all the bubbles departed from their nucleation sites immediately after the inception. In low subcooling experiments, bubbles slid upward and consequently were not detached from the vertical heated wall; the bubble size was increased monotonously with time in this case. In moderate and high subcooling experiments, bubbles were detached from the wall after sliding for several millimeters and migrated towards the subcooled bulk liquid. The bubbles then reversed the direction of lateral migration and were reattached to the wall at moderate subcooling while they collapsed due to the condensation at high subcooling. It was hence considered that the mechanisms of the heat transfer from heated wall and the axial growth of vapor volume were influenced by the difference in bubble rise path. It was observed after the inception that bubbles were varied from flattened to more rounded shape. This observation suggested that the bubble detachment is mainly caused by the change in bubble shape due to the surface tension force.     

Experimental study of CHF in a vertical spirally internally ribbed tube under the condition of high pressures

In the present paper, experiments of CHF were, respectively, conducted in a smooth tube and a four-head spirally internally ribbed tube. The smooth tube has an average inner diameter of 11.69 mm (∅18×3 mm). The four-head spirally internally ribbed tube has an average inner diameter of 11.26 mm (∅22×5.5 mm). The test section was vertically installed in the test loop and was uniformly heated by electricity. The working fluid was water, which entered into the test tube upward with an inlet subcooled temperature of 40–50 °C. The test pressure ranged from 10 to 21 MPa. The mass flux ranged from 400 to 1600 kg·m⁻²·s⁻¹. The effects of various parameters such as mass flux and pressure on CHF are presented. The experimental results in the smooth tube and the four-head spirally internally ribbed tube are compared with each other. It shows that CHF can be enhanced by the four-head spirally internally ribbed tube in the test range. The experimental data in the smooth tube are used to evaluate a precise CHF correlation available in the literature. Good agreements are obtained.     

Flow boiling CHF enhancement with surfactant solutions under atmospheric pressure

Surfactant effect on CHF (critical heat flux) was determined during water flow boiling at atmospheric pressure in closed loop filled with solution of tri-sodium phosphate (TSP, Na₃PO₄ · 12H₂O). TSP was added to the containment sump water to adjust pH level during accident in nuclear power plants. CHF was measured for four different water surfactant solutions in vertical tubes, at different mass fluxes (100–500 kg/m² s) and two inlet subcooling temperatures (50 °C and 75 °C). Surfactant solutions (0.05–0.2%) at low mass flux (～100 kg/m² s) showed the best CHF enhancement. CHF was decreased at high mass flux (500 kg/m² s) compared to the reference plain water data. Maximum increase in CHF was about 48% as compared to the reference data. Surfactant caused a decrease in contact angle associated with an increase of CHF from surfactant addition.     

Saturated flow boiling heat transfer and critical heat flux in small horizontal flattened tubes

This paper presents experimental results for flow boiling heat transfer coefficient and critical heat flux (CHF) in small flattened tubes. The tested flattened tubes have the same equivalent internal diameter of 2.2 mm, but different aspect height/width ratios (H/W) of ¼, ½, 2 and 4. The experimental data were compared against results for circular tubes using R134a and R245fa as working fluids at a nominal saturation temperature of 31 °C. For mass velocities higher than 200 kg/m²s, the flattened and circular tubes presented similar heat transfer coefficients. Such a behavior is related to the fact that stratification effects are negligible under conditions of higher mass velocities. Heat transfer correlations from the literature, usually developed using only circular-channel experimental data, predicted the flattened tube results for mass velocities higher than 200 kg/m²s with mean absolute error lower than 20% using the equivalent diameter to account for the geometry effect. Similarly, the critical heat flux results were found to be independent of the tube aspect ratio when the same equivalent length was kept. Equivalent length is a new parameter which takes into account the channel heat transfer area. The CHF correlations for round tubes predicted the flattened tube data relatively well when using the equivalent diameter and length. Furthermore, a new proposed CHF correlation predicted the present flattened tube data with a mean absolute error of 5%.