Large-scale fire suppression modeling of corrugated cardboard boxes on wood pallets in rack-storage configurations

In this study, the fire growth and suppression models in FireFOAM were validated for rack-storage commodities consisting of two solid fuels, namely corrugated cardboard boxes and hardwood pallets, which are referred to as Class 2 commodity. Validation experiments included two fire-growth and two fire-suppression configurations with different rack-storage array heights (3 and 5 tiers). In the suppression study, standard-response upright ceiling sprinklers (K-factor of 160 lpm/bar^1/2) were used. The time-resolved chemical heat release rates obtained from the experiments were used to validate the fire growth model. The observed sprinkler activations and fire-spread patterns were used to validate the suppression model. This study identified that lateral flame spread is primarily enabled by flames impinging on the commodity's bottom surfaces. This study also showed that obstructions, such as wood pallets, can significantly impede convective and radiative heat transfer to the underside of the commodity, reducing the lateral flame spread rate. Fire-suppression modeling revealed that both surface water transport and lateral flame spread rates are important when predicting fire-suppression behavior. Therefore, as the rack-storage array height increases, so does the water transport time, which results in the fire becoming more difficult to control. Likewise, as the lateral spread rate increases, e.g., as occurs in the absence of wood pallets, fire-suppression also becomes more difficult.     

Parametric study of urban fire spread using an urban fire simulation model with fire department suppression

Although urban conflagrations are rare now, the threat still exists in two situations—following an earthquake and when a wildland fire reaches an urban area. In this paper, we first extend a previously developed urban fire simulation model to include fire department suppression, making it a complete, integrated ignition-spread-suppression model that can now better estimate urban fire risk and help understand the effectiveness of fire department efforts. We then apply this Urban Fire Simulation model (UFS2) to a case study area in California and conduct a parametric study to examine the key factors that influence fire spread and the interactions among them. The results suggest that urban fire spread is highly variable and under the right combination of unlucky but possible circumstances—many ignitions, high wind speeds, and limited water availability—the losses can be very high, much higher than observed in recent earthquakes. In addition to the three factors mentioned, the locations of the ignitions (relative to wind direction and fire breaks), number of engines, and engine arrival times are shown to be important. Strong interactions are evident between wind speed and number of ignitions, and between water availability and number of engines.     

Measurements of spray-plume interactions for model validation

Fire suppression using automatic fire sprinklers is tremendously successful in reducing loss of life and property in the event of a fire. With the increasing computing power available, as well as the spread of performance-based design methods, the ability to accurately model spray dispersion and suppression is desirable. In this study, experiments were conducted to quantify spray dispersion and spray-plume interactions for model validation. Numerical simulations of these spray interactions were performed using FireFOAM. These simulations were distinguished by the use of comprehensive highly-resolved initial spray measurements to generate the numerical spray. The experimental Sprinkler Array Facility (SAF) used in this study consisted of a centrally located, well-characterized, forced air jet (simulating the updraft from a real fire plume) providing a challenge to the spray. Reliable model boundary conditions were established from detailed measurements of the air jet injection velocities and detailed measurements of the initial spray using the Spatially-resolved Spray Scanning System (4 S). Measurements of volume flux as well as optical measurements of drop size and velocity were obtained at various locations within the air jet. Four flow conditions were investigated with the intent of providing model validation data; close and far sprinkler spacing, each with quiescent air and strong jet conditions. The strong jet was capable of overwhelming the smallest drops within the spray, reversing their direction, and reducing the volume flux at the floor. Computational simulations (informed by detailed initial spray measurements) demonstrated good agreement with the spray dispersion and plume penetration experiments.     

An experimental study of complex fuel burning behavior with water application

This work reports a series of small-scale experiments conducted to characterize the burning behavior of selected complex fuels with water application. The main objective of this work is to provide suitable data for the development and validation of fire suppression sub-models for commodities with multiple fuels and complex geometry (complex fuels). The water transport process and burning behavior of two representative complex fuels are examined using three fuel surface conditions including a regular-closed face (CF), a side-open face (SF) and a top-side-open surface (TF). The fuels are exposed to two water application rates at three different water application times with respect to ignition. The results of water collection rates under no fire condition show that the water transport is delayed in the open surface cases (SF and TF). In the free-burn experiments, the surface conditions are shown to have little impact on the fire growth rates. The results of the fire suppression experiments show that the water application time has the most significant impact on controlling the fire, and that the open-surface conditions tend to adversely affect the suppression outcome.     

A comparative study of the effects of chemical additives on the suppression efficiency of water mist

This paper reports the results of a comparative study of the effects of various salt additives on the flame extinguishing efficiency of fine water sprays. The relative suppression efficiencies are gauged by comparing the extinguishment time of a heptane flame. Preliminary tests are performed in a reduced scale cup-burner; major results are obtained using the closed reduced compartment set-up.The addition of NaCl, KCl or KHCO₃ resulted in large improvements of the suppression efficiency of the water mist. Potassium compounds show the greatest effect as 10% solution of KHCO₃ reduces the average extinction time by up to 96% compared to pure water. The other additives tested have a less noticeable effects, with aqueous solutions of MnCl₂, ZnCl₂ and CuCl₂ showing minimal improvement over water, whereas (NH₄)₂HPO₄, (NH₂)₂CO and FeSO₄·7H₂O actually increasing the time taken to extinguish the flame.     

Using suppression and detection devices to steer CFD fire forecast simulations

Firefighters would greatly benefit from a technology based on predictive fire simulations, able to assist their decision making process. For those simulations to be useful, they need a certain degree of precision and resolution that can only be provided by CFD type fire models. But CFD simulations typically take large periods of time to complete, and their results would thus not be available in time to be of use during an emergency. Due to the high complexity of fire spread dynamics that arises from the interaction between solid and gas phase and the corresponding physical-chemical processes (e.g. pyrolysis), the spread of the fire cannot be predicted from first principles in real-time using contemporary computers, and has to be given as parameters to the model. Data can be incorporated into the model to characterise the fire, but only a limited range of measurements are recorded in current buildings. While it might be possible that buildings of the future incorporate a higher density of sensors than contemporary buildings, it is likely that emergency response systems will have access only to conventional data such as smoke detectors and sprinkler activation time for the foreseeable future. In this study the use of conventional detection and suppression devices for the estimation of fire characteristics by means of an inverse modelling framework is explored. Additionally to the growth rate of the fire, the location of the fire origin is successfully estimated. Inverse CFD modelling and tangent linearisation is used to assimilate the data. The nature of the incoming data is consistent with current detection and suppression devices, in such that only a time of activation is recorded and fed into the model. It is shown that the growth rate of the fire and the location of its origin can be correctly and efficiently estimated using sprinkler and smoke detector activation time only. It is further shown that the estimated spread rate is not sensitive to fire origin location.     

Electrically controlled dynamic sprinkler activation: Computational assessment of potential efficiency

Electrically controlled dynamic sprinkler activation is the novel technology of managing large automatic fire suppression systems that offers considerable potential advantages over conventional (thermal) sprinkler activation. It is designed to reduce the sprinkler response time, to ensure sprinkler activation in case of high ceiling clearance, and it can also be used for dynamic group activation enabling flexible response to the actual fire pattern and preventing the fire spread beyond the area protected by the group. Since the practical experience of using the new sprinkler activation algorithms is yet to be elaborated, this work attempts computational evaluation of the group enforced activation efficiency. Fire suppression dynamics is compared for a growing fire source impacted by the automatic sprinkler systems of two types: with conventional (thermal) and new (group enforced) activation algorithms. The effects of ceiling clearance, water flow rates, spray refinement, and of the horizontal airflow are examined.     

Cooling characteristics of hot oil pool by water mist during fire suppression

Generally water is not favored for use in suppressing hot liquid fuel fires due to concerns of vapor explosion and boil-over, which could present potential danger to nearby personnel or firefighters. This paper reports on a series of full-scale fire experiments in which water mist was used in extinguishing large hot cooking oil fires. It was shown that water mist not only extinguished large fires effectively but also cooled hot oil from its ignition point (up to 360 °C) to below its flash point (200 °C) in a short period of time and prevented the fire from re-igniting. No vapor explosion was observed in the experiments when water droplets touched the hot oil whose temperature was higher than the superheat-limited temperature of water. A boiling layer of mixed bubbles, water droplets and oil was formed in the hot oil after all flames were extinguished, as water droplets boiled, bubbled and expanded in the hot oil. No boil-over or spillage of the oil over the container was observed in the experiments when water mist was discharged into the oil at high temperature (>300 °C) but boil-over did occur in experiments when the water mist was discharged into oil at a relatively moderate temperature (∼200 °C). In this paper, the mechanisms of cooling of hot oil by water mist are investigated, and the formation and development of the boiling layer during cooling are analyzed both experimentally and theoretically.     

Modeling fire growth in a combustible corner

A fire growth model was developed to predict the flame spread and total heat release rate of a fire in a corner configuration with a combustible lining. Input data for the combustible lining were developed using small-scale test data from the ASTM E1354 cone calorimeter and ASTM E1321 LIFT. The fire growth model includes a flame spread model linked with a two zone compartment fire model, CFAST Version 3.1.2. At a user selected time interval, the flame spread model uses the gas temperature from CFAST to predict the heat release rate of the fire at that time interval, and then provides CFAST with a new heat release rate to predict conditions during the next time step. The flame spread model is an improved version of the flat wall flame spread model previously developed for the US Navy. The model is capable of predicting flame spread in a variety of configurations including a flat wall, a corner with a ceiling, flat wall with a ceiling, unconfined ceiling, and parallel walls. The model has been validated against ISO 9705 test data and was used in this study to simulate conditions that develop in three open corner tests each with a different lining material. The model was able to predict the heat release rate of the fire and provide a reasonable estimate of the flame fronts and flame lengths during the growing fire.     

Experimental and numerical study on water mist suppression system on room fire

Full-scale experiment and numerical simulations are carried out on a room fire to study water mist suppression system with heat release rate of 6 MW. A computational fluid dynamics (CFD) model of fire-driven fluid flow, FDS (Fire Dynamics Simulator), is used to solve numerically a form of the Navier–Stokes equations for fire. A fire experiment without water mist is performed and the temperatures are measured to validate the predictions of FDS code against the experimental data. Then a fire experiment with water mist suppression system is performed and the temperatures and extinguishing time are measured. The validated numerical model is used to simulate the experiment; the temperatures, oxygen concentration and extinguishing time are compared and studied. In numerical simulations, the cell size sensitivity is analyzed. The experimental results of temperatures and extinguishing time are compared with the results of numerical simulations. It appears that the numerical results are in good agreement (qualitatively) with the experimental data in temperature fields. These useful data can be helpful in accomplishing the design of water mist suppression system and the design regulations for fire safety management.     

Aircraft cargo compartment fire detection and smoke transport modeling

The US Federal Aviation Administration, along with other regulatory agencies, requires that cargo compartments on passenger carrying aircraft be equipped with fire detection and suppression systems. Current regulations require that the detection system alarms within 1 min of the start of a fire and flight tests are required to demonstrate compliance with these regulations. Due to the high costs of flight tests, extensive ground certification tests are typically conducted to ensure that the detection system will meet the time to alarm requirements during the flight tests. For the purpose of improving the detection system design and certification process, a transient computational fluid dynamics computer code for the prediction of smoke, heat, and gas species transport in cargo compartments has been developed. This simulation tool couples heat, mass, and momentum transfer in a body-fitted coordinate system in order to handle a variety of cargo bay shapes and sizes. Ideally, such a physics-based simulation tool can be used during the certification process to identify worst case locations for fires, optimum placement of detector sensors within the cargo compartment, and sensor alarm levels and algorithms needed to achieve detection within the required time. Validation of the model was completed, and comparison of the predicted results with the results obtained from full-scale fire tests in a variety of actual aircraft cargo compartments provides insight into the model capabilities.     

Experimental study of water mist fire suppression in tunnels under longitudinal ventilation

This paper studies water mist fire suppression under different longitudinal ventilation velocities in tunnels by small-scale experiments. After a scaling study, two mist nozzles are used for suppressing crib fires under 5 ventilation speeds. The result comes out that fire suppression process can be divided into three stages including flame unitary restraining stage, surface flame extinguishing stage and inside flame suppression stage. Several factors influencing efficiency are investigated. When the interval between mist nozzle and fire source enlarges, the relationship curve between fire suppression time and ventilation velocity shows a ‘V’ figure. The best ventilation speed exists. Following the rules summarized, a coupling system of water mist and ventilation may increase fire suppression efficiency remarkably.     

浅谈某商住小区的消防供水设计

本着"安全适用、技术先进、经济合理"的防火设计理念,较详细地介绍了某商住小区的室内、外消火栓系统,自动喷淋、大空间智能型主动喷水、水喷雾、自动喷水—泡沫联用灭火系统的消防水源、水量及各系统的设计参数。同时,总结了消防供水设计中的一些设计体会。     

Experimental study on the extinction of liquid pool fire by water droplet streams and sprays

This paper provides evidence about the interaction between the water droplet stream and the flame, and explains how the interaction affects the suppression effectiveness. Two purpose-built gasoline pools were used to generate different open fires. The mono-disperse water droplet streams and water sprays were used as the flame suppressant. The first pool with a circular shape was equipped with a concentric pipe to allow the droplet stream to pass through the flame without impinging the gasoline. The second pool with a long narrow shape was equipped with expandable sides and allowed to extend the fire size. The passing ways of the droplet stream were systematically varied. The results clearly show two modes of flame inhibition; one is by blocking or interfering with the mixing of gasoline vapor and fresh air, and the other by cooling down the flames. For the stream case, the direction of the stream passing through the flame can affect the effectiveness of the suppression which increases as the angle is changed from vertical to horizontal. Also, there is an optimum distance between the stream axis and gasoline surface for flame inhibition. Moreover, the ability can be affected by the droplet size. On the same volume flow rate, the larger the droplet size, the more effective the flame suppression. For the water spray passing through the flame in the long groove pool, whenever the quantity of water vaporization reaches a critical value, the effectiveness of flame suppression by combining the obstructing and cooling effects becomes better.     

Directions for improving manual fire suppression using a physically based computer simulation

The Swedish Fire Research Board and the U.S. Federal Emergency Management Agency are sponsoring a project to further the understanding of the basic mechanisms involved, as well as to support the development of standards for and to seek ways of improving the performance of portable fire suppression systems used by fire departments.This paper describes a physically based computer model developed to simulate one aspect of the problem: the manual suppression of postflashover fires. This includes: (1) an overview of the physical basis behind the model; (2) a comparison of model predictions with available experimental data, and (3) an analysis of fire suppression effectiveness using the model.The analysis concludes that, when direct access and extinguishment of the burning fuel is not possible, improved fire control occurs with water sprays having a Rosin-Rammler distribution of droplet sizes with volume-median-drop diameters in the 0.15 to 0.35 mm range. This agrees with available experimental data. It is also shown that fire fighting venting and standoff distance requirements may lead to more severe fires requiring more water for control; although venting and water spray induced air/gas flow also serve to channel hot steam and gases away from the fire fighter adding to his safety. The analysis also shows that allowing higher gas and surface temperatures at fire control through improved fire fighter protective clothing and equipment design reduces water flow rate requirements. Additional experimental work is recommended before all these conclusions are considered definitive. Reference: L. M. Pietrzak and G. A. Johanson, Directions for Improving Manual Fire Suppression Using a Physically Based Computer Simulation,Fire Technology, Vol. 22, No. 3, August, 1986, p. 184.     

细水雾灭空间不同位置油池火的数值模拟

细水雾灭火以其高效、环保的特点，已成为最具潜力的哈龙灭火系统替代技术之一。本文采用计算流体力学（CFD）的方法，使用火灾场模拟软件FDS4．05模拟研究细水雾灭火系统对空间4个位置油池火的灭火效果。研究结果表明，细水雾对喷头正下方的火源灭火效果最好，且灭火效果随火源距离喷头横向距离的增加而减弱。