Laparoscopic repair and groin hernia surgery

Over the past 15 years, laparoscopic herniorrhaphy has made the transition from an experimental to a proven procedure. With increasing laparoscopic skills in the surgical community, many surgeons are now faced with the question of when to recommend laparoscopic herniorrhaphy to their patients. A surgeon's best hernia repair is the one with which they have had the greatest experience. This results in the lowest recurrence and complication rate in his or her hands. Certainly, simple, unilateral hernias and bilateral hernias can be repaired with either anterior or laparoscopic techniques. Many times, laparoscopic herniorrhaphy is too much surgery for a young patient with a unilateral hernia. In such a case, repair is best performed with the patient under local anesthesia. Also, young patients in whom it is advantageous to avoid mesh should not undergo laparoscopic herniorrhaphy. The authors prefer laparoscopic TEP herniorrhaphy in patients with recurrent hernias, bilateral hernias, and unilateral hernias with a suspected contralateral hernia. There is also a consensus that patients with multiple recurrent hernias in whom a preperitoneal repair is appropriate are best served with a laparoscopic repair. Surgeons without advanced laparoscopic skills or without the time to develop the skills necessary to perform laparoscopic herniorrhaphy should consider referring patients with recurrent hernias to surgeons with experience in TEP. TEP is preferable to TAPP because of its lower complication and recurrence rates and in the authors' hands is the "best repair." TAPP should be reserved for patients with prior lower abdominal wall incisions that make the dissection of the peritoneum from the underside of the incision impossible. Patients who cannot tolerate general anesthesia or who have had extensive lower abdominal surgery should not undergo laparoscopic herniorrhaphy. Complication and recurrence rates, although initially higher than traditional repairs, have now fallen to equal or lower levels at centers experienced in laparoscopic techniques. Prospective randomized trials prove that when patients are selected properly and surgeons are adequately trained and proctored, laparoscopic herniorrhaphy can be performed with acceptably low incidences of recurrence and complications.     

Etiology and pathophysiology of primary and recurrent groin hernia formation

The cause of primary groin hernia is multifactorial with evolutionary, hereditary, congenital, environmental aspects, and the general state of health all playing their part. Besides maintaining general body fitness and not smoking tobacco, there is little one can do to avoid this common affliction. On the other hand, recurrent groin hernia is largely due to easily controllable human factors and can be avoided by choosing an experienced surgeon with a particular interest and understanding of the subject, preferably one who specializes in and confines himself to the surgery of groin hernias, working in a unit dedicated to herniology he will select the best operation for the particular type of hernia and execute it to conform to the highest acceptable standards, using the best materials and techniques. The patient will rapidly, within a matter of days, return to his full, normal activities and can look forward to a success rate of over 99%.     

Effects of dietary coconut oil, butter and safflower oil on plasma lipids, lipoproteins and lathosterol levels

BACKGROUND: Complications that develop in groin hernias, such as irreducibility and obstruction, with or without strangulation may make an easily treatable condition a life-threatening one. Identification of risk factors that may predict development would help place the patient in a high-risk group. Priority admission and early elective surgery for such a patient would avoid significant mortality and morbidity. METHODS: This is a 10-year combined prospective and retrospective study of children and adults. Records of complicated groin hernias were identified from July 1985 to July 1995 from the outpatient department and available inpatient medical records. The same number of controls of simple uncomplicated hernias were then chosen using random number tables from among the large number belonging to the same time period. These two groups were then compared and analysed using statistical methods for age, sex, side of hernia, site of hernia (inguinal/femoral), duration of hernia, length of the waiting list for elective surgery, and contents of the hernial sac along with some other parameters to identify patients with high-risk factors. RESULTS: Age was found to be a significant risk factor and predicted complications in both elderly adults and very young children. Sex of the patient (male) and side of hernia (right) were significant risk factors in children only. Site of hernia was an important risk factor and adults with femoral hernia were most likely to experience complications. Duration of hernia for less than a year proved to be the most important risk factor for both children and adults. The majority of patients with complicated hernias had not presented earlier in the outpatient department, which implies that most hernias that become complicated do so within a very short time before patient referral. Mortality was high in patients with coexisting diseases, while morbidity was affected by viability of contents of the hernial sac which in turn was directly affected by duration of irreducibility or delay in presentation. CONCLUSIONS: The risk factors useful in predicting complications in an adult patient with groin hernia were age (older age group), duration of hernia (short duration), type of hernia (femoral more than inguinal) and coexisting medical illness. In children, the risk factors were age (very young), gender (male), short duration of hernia and side (right side).     

Risks and benefits of laparoscopic hernia-plasty (TAPP). 5 years experiences with 3,400 hernia repairs

In the present study, for the first time the aspects of risk, benefit and the costs of laparoscopic hernioplasty in the transabdominal technique with preperitoneal placement of a polypropylene mesh are examined prospectively in a very large group of patients with 3,400 hernia repairs. The median operation time was 45 min for unilateral primary hernias, 50 min for unilateral recurrent hernias and 76 min for bilateral hernias. The frequency of complications showed a significant dependence on the individual steps in the development of the method and the individual learning curve. The same is true for the rate of recurrency. Whereas initially the rate of serious complications was 2.75%, the rate of minor complications 11% and the rate of recurrences 4.5% the corresponding figures are at present 0.4%, 4.4% and 0.5%. Laparoscopic hernioplasty proved to be equally as effective in the treatment of primary hernias, recurrent hernias and bilateral hernias. The large number of 11 surgeons participating proves that laparoscopic hernioplasty can be learned and that even in a teaching hospital it can be performed safely, efficiently and cost-effectively.     

Laparoscopic hernia surgery--status of minimal invasive techniques in a spectrum of surgical indications

Endoscopic surgery led in the nineties to a discussion on surgical treatment of hernias. At the present time there are three groups of operative procedures: the conventional procedure--Shouldice, Bassini--the open tension-free procedure with implantation of a mesh--Lichtenstein, Gilbert-Rutkow--and the endoscopic procedure (predominantly transabdominal preperitoneal hernioplasty (TAPP) and total extraperitoneal hernioplasty (TEP)). The debate on the optimal therapy of hernias is understandable in view of the large number of hernia operations which are carried out. Numerous studies, some randomized, have demonstrated both the advantages and the disadvantages of the individual operative procedures. In addition to the recurrence rate and the complications, the cost factor and the associated socio-economic aspects of the particular operation play an increasingly important role in the decision on the method that should be used. In December 1995 some Austrian surgeons, who concerned themselves with problems of hernia repair already before the definitive introduction of laparoscopic hernia repair in today's surgery, came together on the occasion of a "Consensus Conference". During the meeting a summary of all relevant aspects of the complex of problems was worked out and summarized in a catalog of indications for the different operative interventions. The main statement was that the traditional open surgery, which can be performed under local anesthesia is indicated for an unilateral primary hernia. In case of an unclear finding at the contralateral side, as well as in case of a recurrent hernia, an endoscopic procedure is indicated. Meanwhile the Hernia Forum of Zürs ("Zürser Hernienforum") was founded. The function of this forum is the realization of a prospective randomized study for hernia repair in Austria.     

Musculo-aponeurotic flap in the treatment of inguinal hernias, apropos of 1,600 operations

Morbidity, absention and duration of cares are important factors for the treatment of groin hernias. Deep and tension free cure is a key element to decrease the rate of recurrence. Utilization of prosthesis cannot provide a rate of 100%. This must be taken into consideration for indications. Beside we must take into account specific risks of each technique. Hernia treatment cannot be unique. This parietal surgery must remain a technique with low morbidity. As for treatment of unilateral hernia, we have qualified a technique of hernioplastia depending upon theses criteria, by inguinal incision, without prosthesis. Our technique includes: A complete dissection of the inguinal canal. The resection of the sac of the hernia at the internal ring. A deep cure of the fascia transversalis. A systematic incision of discharge on the anterior face of the rectus sheath. This incision is extremely internal and constitutes a large musculo-aponeurotic flap of 8 to 12 cm that makes this cure tension free possible. In the term of 10 years, our recurrence rate is below 1% for type I or II hernias in Nyhus classification. Consequently we discuss the indications for prosthesis. They must be reserved for hernias with high recurrence risk, bilateral hernias of for recurrent hernias.     

10 years experience in performing Shouldice operation

206 male patients were operated for primary direct and indirect inguinal hernia, or both, by Shouldice technique at general surgical departments of Madadeni Hospital, Newcastle, South Africa, Pásztó Hospital and Szolnok MAV Hospital, Hungary between 1986 and 1996. Mean age was 51 yrs +/- 15 yrs (17-91 yrs). The operations were performed by the original way of Shouldice described that type of hernia repair in 1945. 175 patients had spinal and 31 patients had local anesthesia with intravenous fluid and sedation respectively. Studies indicate that collagen metabolic dysfunction plays a major rule in the etiology of groin hernia. Until this is more clearly defined, surgeons will continue to repair groin hernias constitute 15% of operations in general surgery. In approach to groin hernia, the best view for examination of the inguinal region can be obtained by Shouldice technique to decide the proper surgical intervention to repair groin hernia. With low recurrence rate and rapid rehabilitation, author reports 2% of recurrence rate, the Shouldice operation highly recommended.     

Herniography in the investigation of groin pain in adults

Herniography is a useful investigation in adults with unexplained groin pain in whom there is no clinical evidence of a hernia, thus ensuring appropriate surgery. The technique is described, normal anatomy and different types of hernias illustrated.     

Pediatric hernias and hydroceles

Hernias and hydroceles are common conditions of infancy and childhood, and inguinal hernia repair is one of the most frequently performed pediatric surgical operations. As a result of improved neonatal intensive care, more and more premature babies are being delivered, and consequently the incidence of neonatal inguinal hernia is increasing. The most important aspect of the management of neonatal inguinal hernias relate to its risk on incarceration, and emphasis is placed on this point. This article covers the embryology, incidence, clinical presentation, and treatment of groin hernias and hydroceles, as well as dealing with abdominal wall hernias other than umbilical hernias. This article places special emphasis on when a patient with a hernia or hydrocele should be referred to a pediatric surgeon.     

Management of complicated incisional hernias with underlay-technique implanted polypropylene mesh. An effective technique in French hernia surgery

Incisional hernia repair with conventional techniques (simple closure, Mayo-technique) is associated with unacceptable recurrence rates of 30-50%. Therefore, surgical repair using different prosthetic biomaterials is becoming increasingly popular. Further to favourable results by French hernia surgeons, we studied the results of underlay prosthetic mesh repair using polypropylene mesh in complicated and recurrent incisional hernias. METHOD: After preparation and excision of the entire hernia sac, the posterior rectus sheath is freed from the muscle bellies on both sides. The peritoneum and posterior rectus sheaths are closed with a continuous looped polyglyconate suture. The prosthesis used for midline hernias is positioned on the posterior rectus sheath and extends far beyond the borders of the myoaponeurotic defect. The anterior rectus sheath is closed with a continuous suture. The prosthesis for lumbar and subcostal hernias is placed in a prepared space between the transverse and oblique muscles. Intraperitoneal placement of the mesh must be avoided. RESULTS: Between January 1996 and August 1997 we performed a total of 33 incisional hernia repairs (14 primary hernias, 19 recurrent hernias) using this technique (16 women, 17 men, mean age 56.19 +/- 12.92 years). Local complications occurred in four patients (12%): superficial wound infection (n = 2), postoperative bleeding, requiring reoperation (n = 1), minor hemato-seroma (n = 1). One patient suddenly died on the 3rd post-operative day from severe pulmonary embolism (mortality 3%). Twenty-two patients with a minimum follow up to 6 months were re-examined clinically. The average follow-up time for this group was 9 months (range 6-17 months). To date no recurrent hernias have been observed. There were only minor complaints like "a feeling of tension" in the abdominal wall (n = 3) and slight pain under physical stress (n = 6). CONCLUSIONS: The use of prosthetic mesh should be considered for repair of large or recurrent incisional hernias, especially in high-risk patients (obesity, obstructive lung disease) and complicated hernias. The aforementioned technique of underlay prosthetic repair using polypropylene mesh fixed onto the posterior rectus sheath allows for anatomical and consolidated reconstruction of the damaged abdominal wall with excellent results and low complication rates.     

Femoral hernia: the dire consequences of a missed diagnosis

Femoral hernia has always presented more difficulty in diagnosis than other external abdominal hernias. The incidence of incarceration and strangulation is higher in our series than the published literature would suggest. A retrospective study was performed at our institution from February 1990 to June 1995. In that period, 22 patients were operated on for femoral hernia. There were 16 women and 6 men, average ages 51 and 48 years, respectively. The men weighed on average 209 lb, and the women, 154 lb. Three of our patients had elective repair of their hernias (16%); 19 were performed urgently or emergently (86%). Of the emergency repairs, 3 had strangulated small bowel requiring resection (16%), 1 had a strangulated vermiform appendix with abscess formation (5%), 3 had strangulated omentum requiring excision (16%), giving a total of 7 patients with strangulation and necrosis of the hernial contents (36%). The remainder had viable contents in the hernia sac. The time from the onset of symptoms to presentation at the hospital varied from 1 day to 3 years. The time from strangulation to presentation was between a few hours and 4 days. Surgery was performed on the day of admission (within 24 hours) on all but 2 of our patients. Procedures performed were McVay repair, 13; Bassini, 4; laparoscopic with Marlex mesh, 1 patient; drainage of a groin abscess in 2 patients with later repair; and on 2 patients the type of repair was not specified. One of the patients died. Postoperative wound infection occurred in 2 heavily contaminated patients, and 3 had pneumonia. Patients with no regular physician and no routine physical examinations are at higher risk for developing strangulation of femoral hernias. Emergency physicians and general practitioners are in the best position to diagnose these hernias early, when treatment can be elective.     

Inguinal hernia--which method leads to the goal? Endoscopic and open surgical procedures are available

In recent years, the methods available for repair of inguinal hernia have greatly expanding, resulting in confusion as to what constitutes a suitable choice. Is it to be laparoscopy or open surgery, plastic mesh yes or no, general anesthesia or local anesthesia? Bassini's operation has now been ousted by the Shouldice procedure, which is suitable for all primary forms of hernia. The Lichtenstein procedure is readily and rapidly carried out under local anesthesia, making it suitable for use in multimorbid and old patients; the recurrence rate is low. The laparoscopic approach can be recommended for patients who, for private or occupational reasons need to be up and about again as soon as possible. It is also particularly suitable for the treatment of recurrent hernias or for the simultaneous repair of bilateral hernias. Disadvantages are the high costs, a lack of long-term results and unusual complications that are not seen in open surgery.     

A measurement of the ability to drive after different types of inguinal hernia repair

Recovery following different types of inguinal hernia repair has been objectively assessed by measuring reaction times when the subject performs an emergency stop in a driving simulator. A control group of patients who underwent varicose vein surgery to the groin under general anaesthetic without any muscle dissection demonstrated no alteration in response times. Eighty-two percent of those who underwent laparoscopic repair and 64% of those who underwent Lichtenstein repair returned to their preoperative times by 7 days after surgery. There was no difference in recovery of response times after Lichtenstein repair performed under local or general anaesthetic, in comparison with 33% of patients after Bassini repair. These results may influence the advice given by surgeons to patients after inguinal hernia surgery.     

Current practice of incisional hernia reconstruction in Germany

The results of a nationwide survey regarding the treatment of incisional hernias following open laparotomy revealed that the Mayo-duplication is the surgical technique preferred by the majority of surgeons. However, in exceptional situations alloplastic material is implanted by up to 50% of the surgeons asked. More than one forth of the departments performed more than 30 incisional hernia repairs per year. Even for complicated cases the surgeons' own estimation of their recurrence rates was 11.7%. Compared with the data (recurrence rate of the Mayo-duplication of 30%-50%) published in the literature there seems to be a quantitative and qualitative underestimation of the treatment of incisional hernias.     

Combined surgical treatment with prosthesis of recurrent ventral and inguinal hernias

The presence of associated incisional and groin hernias is relatively rare and it represents an important problem in surgical treatment. The authors here report their experience of three patients treated with no reabsorbable prostheses placed according to Rives' technique for incisional hernias, and according to Stoppa's for inguinal hernias.     

Incisional hernia recurrence following "vest-over-pants" or vertical Mayo repair of primary hernias of the midline

A series of 68 primary midline incisional hernias with a vertical Mayo repair was evaluated retrospectively. Patients without documented hernia recurrence following this repair were invited for physical examination. Life-table methods were used for statistical analysis. The 1-, 3-, 5-, and 10-year cumulative recurrence rates were 35%, 46%, 48%, and 54%, respectively. Also, generally accepted risk factors were studied. Multivariate analysis identified the size of the hernia (p = 0.02) and the use of steroids (p = 0.04) as the most important independent risk factors of first time recurrent incisional hernia. Considering the high recurrence rates found, the results of this study strongly suggest that the vest-over-pants repair should no longer be used for closure of midline incisional hernias.     

Laparoscopic herniorrhaphy in girls

BACKGROUND/PURPOSE: Laparoscopy has been used to evaluate the contralateral side in inguinal hernias. Once a hernia was identified in such procedures, laparoscopy was terminated and a conventional groin exploration was undertaken. This study presents a purely laparoscopic approach using miniature instruments without the use of a groin incision. METHODS: The technique was applied in 14 girls (median age, 6.5 years). The laparoscope was inserted via the umbilicus. Two 1.7- or 2-mm instruments were advanced (without a trocar) trough the abdominal wall for intraabdominal suturing of the open inguinal rings by the placement of two to three Z-sutures. RESULTS: With this procedure the diagnosis is easy, although the placing of miniature suturing needs practice. When there is doubt about an inguinal ring during laparoscopy, an open processus vaginalis also can be sutured using the same approach. There were no recurrences or complications. The longest follow-up period is 1 year. CONCLUSIONS: A purely laparoscopic approach using miniature instruments combines diagnosis and immediate treatment without the need for conversion to another technique. There is rapid recovery and excellent cosmetic results.     

Classification systems and groin hernias

The once simple division of groin hernias into indirect and direct inguinal and femoral components is no longer adequate to reflect a more sophisticated understanding of the pathophysiology and management of these lesions. Similarly, the availability of a concise, easy-to-use, logical, and recognizable classification scheme would facilitate a better understanding of modern repair techniques and confirmation of operative results.     

Laparoscopic hernia repair in Leicester General Hospital: a prospective audit of 94 patients

Conventional hernia repair is effective in terms of cure but is associated with considerable postoperative pain and delay in return to normal activity. Laparoscopic repair has the potential to reduce pain and speed return to normal activity, but there have been few published reports of the outcome of this operation in the UK. We present a prospective audit of 94 patients who underwent laparoscopic repair. Of the 94 patients, 87 (92.6%) were male and 7 (7.4%) were female. Thirteen of the repairs were bilateral and 12 were recurrent. Two had to be converted to open repair. The mean operating time for unilateral repair was 56 min and for bilateral repair 98 min. Sixty-three patients (67%) were discharged within 24 h and 21 (22.4%) were discharged within 48 h. There were minor complications in 20 patients (21%), eight of whom (8.5%) developed a haematoma. The other minor complications included seromas (2), bruising at the site of the entry port (2), hyperaesthesia in the groin (2), port hernia (1), shoulder tip pain after surgery (3) and postoperative urinary retention (2). Nine (9.5%) patients claimed to have had no pain or discomfort at all; 35 (37.2%) were pain and discomfort free in 2 weeks. Thirty-two (34%) patients returned to normal activities in 2 weeks. With a median follow-up of 8 months 3 (3.2%) recurrences were noted. It is emphasised that this series represents a learning curve and that the operation is developmental. We are now restricting laparoscopic repair to recurrent and bilateral hernias where the technique offers particular advantages.