Fatigue crack growth analysis of stiffened cracked panel repaired with bonded composite patch

Fatigue crack growth behavior in a stiffened thin 2024-T3 aluminum panel repaired with one-sided adhesively bonded composite patch was investigated through experiments and analyses. The patch had three plies of unidirectional boron/epoxy composite. 2024-T3 aluminum stiffeners were riveted as well as bonded on the panel. Stiffeners were oriented in the loading direction and were spaced at either 102 mm or 152 mm with a crack centered between them. Also, un-repaired cracked panel with and without stiffeners were studied. Experiment involved tension-tension fatigue at constant amplitude with maximum stress of 120 MPa and stress ratio of 0.05. Bonded composite patch repair increased fatigue life about five-fold in the case of stiffened panels while it increased about ten fold in the case of un-stiffened panels. Fatigue life also increased with decrease of the distance between the stiffeners for both repaired and un-repaired panels. A three-dimensional finite element method was used to analyze the experiments. Residual thermal stresses, developed during patch bonding, requires the knowledge of temperature at which adhesive becomes effective in creating a bond between the structure and patch in the analysis. A simple method to estimate the effective curing temperature range is suggested in this study. The computed stress intensity factor versus measured crack growth relationships for all panel configurations were consistent and in agreement with the counterpart from the test material. Thus, the present approach provides a means to analyze the fatigue crack growth behavior of stiffened structures repaired with adhesively bonded composite patch.     

Numerical simulation study of fatigue crack growth behavior of cracked aluminum panels repaired with a FRP composite patch using combined BEM/FEM

A combined boundary element method and finite element method (BEM/FEM) is employed to investigate the fatigue crack growth behavior of cracked aluminum panels repaired with an adhesively bonded fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP) composite patch. Numerical simulation of crack growth process of a cracked aluminum panel repaired with a FRP composite patch under uniaxial cyclic loading has been carried out. The curve of crack length on unpatched side of the cracked panel versus the number of cyclic loading is determined by the numerical simulation, and it agrees well with experimental data. Furthermore, the crack front profiles of the cracked panel during fatigue crack growth and the distributions of stress intensity factors along crack fronts are also numerically simulated.     

Characterization of fatigue crack growth in aluminium panels with a bonded composite patch

This study introduces an analytical procedure to characterize the fatigue crack growth behavior in an aluminium panel repaired with a bonded composite patch. This procedure involves the computation of the stress intensity factor from a two-dimensional finite element method consisting of three layers to model cracked plate, adhesive and composite patch. In this three layer finite element analysis, as recently introduced by the authors, two-dimensional Mindlin plate elements with transverse shear deformation capability are used. The computed stress intensity factor is then compared with the experimental counterpart. The latter was obtained from the measured fatigue crack growth rate of an aluminium panel with a bonded patch by using the power law relationship (Paris Law) of an unpatched aluminum panel. Both a completely bonded patch (with no debond) and a partially bonded patch (with debond) are investigated in this study. This procedure, thus, provides an effective and reliable technique to predict the fatigue life of a repaired structure with a bonded patch, or alternatively, it can be used to design the bonded composite patch configuration to enhance the fatigue life of cracked structure.     

Nonlinear analysis of bonded composite patch repair of cracked aluminum panels

Analyses of adhesively bonded composite patches to repair cracked structures have been the focus of many studies. Most of these studies investigated the damage tolerance of the repaired structure by using linear analysis. This study involves nonlinear analysis of the adhesively bonded composite patch to investigate its effects on the damage tolerance of the repaired structure. The nonlinear analysis utilizes the three-layer technique which includes geometric nonlinearity to account for large displacements of the repaired structure and also material nonlinearity of the adhesive. The three-layer technique uses two-dimensional finite element analysis with Mindlin plate elements to model the cracked plate, adhesive and composite patch. The effects of geometric nonlinearity on the damage tolerance of the cracked plate is investigated by computing the stress intensity factor and fatigue growth rate of the crack in the plate. The adhesive is modeled as a nonlinear material to characterize debond behavior. The elastic-plastic analysis of the adhesive utilizes the extended Drucker-Prager model. A detailed discussion on the effects of nonlinear analysis for a bonded composite patch repair of a cracked aluminum panel is presented in this paper.     

Numerical analysis of the stress intensity factors for repaired cracks from a notch with bonded composite semicircular patch

In this paper, we investigated the crack growth behaviour of cracked thin aluminium plate repaired with bonded composite patch. The finite element method is used to study the performance of the bonded composite reinforcement or repair for reducing the stress concentration at a semicircular lateral notch and repairing cracks emanating from this kind of notch. The effects of the adhesive properties and the patch size on the stress intensity factor variation at the crack tip in mode I were highlighted. The obtained results show that the stress concentration factor at the semicircular notch root and the stress intensity factor of a crack emanating from notch are reduced with the increase of the diameter and the number of the semicircular patch. The maximal reduction of stress intensity factor is about 42% and 54%, respectively, for single and double patch. However, the gain in the patch thickness increases with the increase of the crack length and it decreases when the patch thickness increases. The adhesive properties must be optimised in order to increase the performance of the patch repair or reinforcement.     

Comparison between composite and metallic patches for repairing aircraft structures of aluminum alloy 7075 T6

In this study, experimental and numerical investigations were carried out in order to compare the performances of composite and metallic patches for repairing aircraft structures. In the experimental part, an accelerating aging of the composite was realized by the immersion of the composite patch in distilled water. The fatigue lives of notched plates repaired with aged composite patch, non-aged composite patch and aluminum patch were measured. The obtained results show that the composite patch is more beneficial than the aluminum patch if there is no significant water absorption by the composite. In the numerical part, the stress intensity factor at the crack tip was computed for aged and non-aged composite patches and for aluminum patches. The numerical results confirm the experimental ones, the reduction of the stress intensity factor by the composite patch is more significant than the aluminum patch but the water absorption reduces significantly the repair efficiency.     

Progressive edge cracked aluminium plate repaired with adhesively bonded composite patch under full width disbond

In this study, the crack growth behaviour of an aluminium plate cracked at the tip and repaired with a bonded boron/epoxy composite patch in the case of full-width disbond was investigated. This effect is the imperfection which could result during the bonded patch of the repaired structure. Disbonds of various sizes and situated at different positions with respect to the crack tip as well as the effect of adhesive and patch thickness on repair performance were examined. An analysis procedure involving the efficient finite element modelling applied to cracked plate, adhesive and composite patch was used to compute the stress intensity factors. The crack growth rate is dominated by the stress intensity factor near the location and size of the pre-existing disbonds. The cracked plate and disbond propagation result in an increase in the patch deformation. The patch does not have an influence on the crack growth when the ratio 2a/d_R exceeds 0.8.     

The effects of disbonds on the pure mode II stress intensity factor of aluminium plate reinforced with bonded composite materials

Adhesively bonded composite patch repair has been widely used to restore or extend the service life of cracked structural components due to its effectiveness to mechanical repair technique. In this work, the finite element method is applied to analyse the performance of the bonded composite patch for repairing cracks emanating from semicircular notch root in pure mode II. The stress intensity factor was computed at the crack tip repaired using a boron/epoxy patch for different orientation of fibers, taking into account the disbond. In this case, the increase of a patch thickness reduces the negative effects of disbond. When this effect is significant between the patch and the plate, it reduces the repair effectiveness. The maximum reduction obtained by using a boron/epoxy of fibers in the x-direction is of the order of 20% more important compared to a patch having its fibers in the y-direction. The stress intensity factor exhibits an asymptotic behaviour as the disbond size increases.     

Comparison between rectangular and trapezoidal bonded composite repairs in aircraft structures: A numerical analysis

The optimization of the patch shape of bonded composite repair in aircraft structures is a good way to improve the repair performance. In this study, the three-dimensional finite element method is used to compare the repair performance of patches with rectangular and trapezoidal shapes in aircraft structures. The comparison is done by analysing the stress intensity factor (SIF) at the tip of repaired crack and the distribution of the adhesive stresses for the two patch shapes. The obtained results show that, when the crack length is ranged from 5 to 20 mm, the trapezoidal shape presents lower stress intensity factor at the crack tip, which is beneficial for the fatigue life and lower adhesives stresses, which is beneficial for the repair durability. These advantages disappear when the crack length reaches the value of 40 mm. It is also shown that the use of the trapezoidal shape reduce the mass of the patch, which can reduce the repair cost.     

Numerical and experimental fatigue crack growth analysis in mode-I for repaired aluminum panels using composite material

Crack-front shape is an important parameter influencing the stress intensity factor and crack propagation rate in asymmetric repaired panels. In this study, the numerical and experimental fatigue crack growth behaviour of centrally cracked aluminum panels in mode-I condition repaired with single-side composite patches are investigated. It is shown that the crack growths non-uniformly from its initial location through the thickness of a single-side repaired panel. There is a good agreement between the propagated crack-front shapes obtained from finite element analysis with those obtained from the experiments for various repaired panels with different patch thicknesses. Furthermore, effects of plate and patch thickness on the crack growth life of the repaired panels are investigated. The experimental results show that the crack growth life of thin panels may increase up to 236% using a 16 layers patch. However, for thick panels, the life may extend about 21–35% using a 4 layers patch. Implementing of 8 and 16 layers patches has not a significant effect on the life extension of thick panels with respect to the 4 layers patch life.     

FE analysis of the behaviour of octagonal bonded composite repair in aircraft structures

Bonded composite repair has been recognized as an efficient and economical method to extend the fatigue life of cracked aluminium components. In this work, the finite element method is applied to analyze the central crack’s behaviour repaired by a boron/epoxy composite patch. The knowledge of the stress distribution in the neighbourhood of cracks has an importance for the analysis of their repair according to the patch geometry. The effects of mechanical and geometrical properties of the patch on the variation of the stress intensity factor at the crack tip were highlighted. The obtained results show that the stress intensity factor at the repaired crack with composite patch of height 2c/3 is reduced about 5% compared to cracks repaired with octagonal patch of size c. For patch height of c/3 the reduction is about 7%. The adhesive properties must be optimised in order to increase the repair performances and to avoid the adhesive failure.     

Comparison of the effectiveness of boron/epoxy and graphite/epoxy patches for repaired cracks emanating from a semicircular notch edge

The adhesively bonded composite patch repair technique has been used to restore or extend the service life of the cracked aluminium structural components because of its efficiency. In this study, the finite element method is used to analyse the performance of the different bonded composite patches at a semicircular lateral notch and the repair of cracks emanating from this kind of notch. The knowledge of the stress distribution in the neighbourhood of the cracks is important for the analysis of their repair according to the geometry of the patch. The effects of the mechanical and geometrical properties on the variation of the stress intensity factor in the crack tip were highlighted. The effects of the adhesive properties and of the patch size on the stress intensity factor variation at the crack tip in mode I were also highlighted. The comparison between the double and single patch repairs is also given in this study. The results obtained show that the stress intensity factor of the crack tip repaired by two composite patches, is reduced to a half compared to the one that is repaired only by one patch. The orientation of fibres possessing a higher rigidity perpendicularly to the crack propagation considerably influences the reduction of the stress intensity factor. The adhesive properties must be optimised in order to increase the performance of the patch repair or the reinforcement.     

Fracture analysis of Kevlar-49/epoxy and e-glass/epoxy doublers for reinforcement of cracked aluminum plates

Adhesively bonded composite patch repair is efficient means to regain load carrying capacity, alleviate the crack growth, and improve the service life of the damaged structure. In this paper, three dimensional finite element models are developed to examine the fracture behavior of a single edge V-notched Aluminum plate repaired with Kevlar-49/epoxy or e-glass/epoxy pre-preg patches on both sides. Contour integral method was used for evaluating the stress intensity factor (SIF), an indicator of the crack stability. The load transfer mechanisms, stress distribution, damage variable (D), and crack mouth opening displacement (CMOD), were also presented to estimate the effectiveness of composite patch repair. The influence of the patch material, crack length and the adhesive thickness has been investigated. Results have shown that the crack induced damage increased nonlinearly with a larger crack size. With the composite patch repairs, SIF is reduced to 1/7–1/10 of that of the bare plate and CMOD decreased by 79%. The damage variable is reduced significantly and the load capacity is increased. A thinner adhesive layer results in a higher percentage of load shared by the composite patch.     

Numerical analysis of the beneficial effect of the double symmetric patch repair compared to single one in aircraft structures

This paper concerns a numerical study by the finite element method of the cracked structure repaired by single and double bonded composite patches. The stress intensity factor is used as fracture criteria. The obtained results showed the advantage of the double patch compared to single on the reduction of the stress intensity factor at the crack tip. The effects of the properties of the plate and the patch and the adhesive on the beneficial effect of the double patch are highlighted. The adhesive properties must be optimised in order to increase the advantage of the double patch and to avoid the adhesive failure. The patch properties have a significant effect on the beneficial effects of the double symmetric patch.     

Modeling and validation of composite patch repair to cracked thick and thin metallic panels

A two-dimensional finite element analysis is presented to predict crack growth behavior of cracked panels repaired with bonded composite patch. Fatigue experiments were conducted with precracked aluminum specimens of two thicknesses (1 and 6.35 mm), with and without debond, and repaired asymmetrically. Fatigue lives of thick and thin repaired panels extended four and ten times relative to unrepaired cases, respectively. The predicted fatigue crack growth rates were in agreement with experimental values at the unpatched face but not at the patched face. Thus, the present analysis provides a conservative assessment of durability and damage tolerance of repaired thin and thick panels.     

Study of composite patch repair by analytical and numerical methods

A combined analytical and numerical study of an isotropic cracked plate that was repaired by using a bonded composite patch was conducted. The analytical work was based on Rose's equations, whereas for the numerical investigation a three-dimensional finite element analysis was implemented. A number of cracked plates with different crack lengths and overall dimensions of the composite repair were considered. The composite patch was made of unidirectional laminates with different stacking sequences. Both, one- and two-sided patches were analysed. Results are presented for the stress intensity factor in the patched crack and the maximum stress reinforcement stress and adhesive strain. It was found that for the case of a two-sided reinforcement the results obtained by both methods were in good agreement. However, for the case of a single reinforcement the accuracy of the analytical method decreased due to the tendency to out-of-plane bending as a result of bonding a reinforcing patch to only one face of a plate, which is ignored in the analysis.     

Crack growth induced delamination on steel members reinforced by prestressed composite patch

ABSTRACT Prestressed composite patch bonded on cracked steel section is a promising technique to reinforce cracked details or to prevent fatigue cracking on steel structural elements. It introduces compressive stresses that produce a crack closure effect. Moreover, it modifies the crack geometry by bridging the crack faces and so reduces the stress intensity range at the crack tip. Fatigue tests were performed on notched steel plate reinforced by CFRP strips as a step toward the validation of crack patching for fatigue life extension of riveted steel bridges. A crack growth induced debonded region in the adhesive‐plate interface was observed using an optical technique. Moreover, the size of the debonded region significantly influences the efficiency of the crack repair. Debond crack total strain energy release rate is computed by the modified virtual crack closure technique (MVCCT). A parametric analysis is performed to investigate the influence of some design parameters such as the composite patch Young's modulus, the adhesive thickness and the pretension level on the adhesive‐plate interface debond.     

Modelling fatigue crack propagation of a cracked metallic member reinforced by composite patches

The concept of fracture for material elements at front of a crack for fatigue crack propagation was extended to the fatigue crack propagation of a cracked metallic member reinforced with a composite patch in this paper. From static mechanics and linear elastic fracture mechanics, force transfer on a cracked member through a composite patch was analyzed and a formula connecting the stress intensity factor with crack length was obtained. Thereafter, a fracture model for fatigue crack propagation of a repaired cracked metallic member was proposed. A new expression for the fatigue crack propagation rate has thus been derived. The expression was verified objectively by the test data. It is in good agreement with the test results.     

Bonded aircraft repairs under variable amplitude fatigue loading and at low temperatures

Bonded repairs can replace mechanically fastened repairs for aircraft structures. Compared to mechanical fastening, adhesive bonding provides a more uniform and efficient load transfer into the patch, and can reduce the risk of high stress concentrations caused by additional fastener holes necessary for riveted repairs. Previous fatigue tests on bonded Glare (glass‐reinforced aluminium laminate) repairs were performed at room temperature and under constant amplitude fatigue loading. However, the realistic operating temperature of ?40 °C may degrade the material and will cause unfavourable thermal stresses. Bonded repair specimens were tested at ?40 °C and other specimens were tested at room temperature after subjecting them to temperature cycles. Also, tests were performed with a realistic C‐5A Galaxy fuselage fatigue spectrum at room temperature. The behaviour of Glare repair patches was compared with boron/epoxy ones with equal extensional stiffness. The thermal cycles before fatigue cycling did not degrade the repair. A constant temperature of ?40 °C during the mechanical fatigue load had a favourable effect on the fatigue crack growth rate. Glare repair patches showed lower crack growth rates than boron/epoxy repairs. Finite element analyses revealed that the higher crack growth rates for boron/epoxy repairs are caused by the higher thermal stresses induced by the curing of the adhesive. The fatigue crack growth rate under spectrum loading could be accurately predicted with stress intensity factors calculated by finite element modelling and cycle‐by‐cycle integration that neglected interaction effects of the different stress amplitudes, which is possible because stress intensities at the crack tip under the repair patch remain small. For an accurate prediction it was necessary to use an effective stress intensity factor that is a function of the stress ratio at the crack tip R_{crack tip} including the thermal stress under the bonded patch.