Area and point approaches in fatigue life evaluation under combined bending and torsion loading

We present a new nonlocal approach to nonuniform stress distribution, consisting in reduction of stresses to representative local ones in the critical plane for fatigue life calculation. The shear and normal stresses are averaged in two overlapping areas of different sizes on the critical plane. The proposed method is compared with the point (in critical distance) method and both are verified by fatigue tests under combined bending and torsion. Verification is done for the experimental and calculated fatigue lives with use of two multiaxial fatigue failure criteria. __________ Translated from Problemy Prochnosti, No. 1, pp. 69–72, January–February, 2008.     

Fatigue life assessment of welded joints under sequences of bending and torsion loading blocks of different lengths

In this work, the nominal stress concept, the notch stress approach and two critical plane approaches are used to analyse the fatigue endurance of a pipe‐to‐plate welded joint subjected to complex loading histories. Both the pipe and the plate were made of S355JR steel. Starting from already known fatigue endurance curves obtained for the same specimens under pure bending and pure torsion, a first series of tests was conducted, in which specimens were loaded in bending for a given fraction of the estimated life and then in torsion until failure. A similar series of tests was then carried out by changing the loading order: specimens were firstly loaded in torsion for a given fraction of the estimated endurance and then in bending until failure. The whole test campaign was repeated for two different fractions of the estimated life, that is, 0.3 and 0.45, respectively. After that, additional three series of tests were carried out, in which the specimens were subjected to consecutive sequences of bending and torsion blocks of different lengths (short, medium and long, respectively); the relative length of the bending and torsion block in each series was determined in order to produce the same damage. The experimental results, in terms of total damage at failure, were analysed using the Palmgren–Miner hypothesis. For all the assessment methods, the characteristic endurance curves were firstly calibrated on the basis of finite element (FE) analyses and of the experimental results obtained under pure bending and pure torsion loadings. The observed damage at failure resulted always greater than 0.5 for all the employed methods and greater than 1 for most of the tests. The different methods gave similar results, with the critical plane methods giving a slightly more stable damage at failure and a correct determination of the failure location. For all the methods, the damage at failure slightly reduces as the block length shortens.     

Selection of the critical plane orientation in two-parameter multiaxial fatigue failure criterion under combined bending and torsion

The present paper is focused on engineering application of the algorithm of fatigue life calculation under multiaxial fatigue loading. For that reason, simple two-parameter multiaxial fatigue failure criterion is proposed. The criterion is based on the normal and shear stresses on the critical plane. Experimental results obtained under multiaxial proportional, non-proportional cyclic loading and variable-amplitude bending and torsion were used to verify the proposed two-parameter criterion and other well-known multiaxial fatigue criteria. Elastic–plastic behaviour of the bulk material was taken into account in calculation of the stress/strain distribution across the specimen cross-section. It is shown that the proposed two-parameter multiaxial fatigue failure criterion gives the best correlation between the experimental and calculated fatigue lives.     

Critical plane approach for the assessment of the fatigue behaviour of welded aluminium under multiaxial loading

ABSTRACT Multiaxial stress states occur in many welded constructions like chemical plants, railway carriages and frames of trucks. Those stresses can have constant and changing principal stress directions, depending on the loading mode. Latest research results on welded steel joints show a loss of fatigue life for changing principal stress directions simulated by out‐of‐phase bending and torsion compared to constant directions given by in‐phase loading. However, aluminium welds reveal no influence of changing principal directions on fatigue life compared to multiaxial loading with constant principal stress directions. This behaviour is not predictable by any conventional hypothesis. A hypothesis on the basis of local normal and shear stresses in the critical plane has been developed and applied to aluminium weldings.     

Fatigue behaviour of tubular AlMgSi welded specimens subjected to bending–torsion loading

This paper is concerned with an experimental and numerical study of the fatigue behaviour of tubular AlMgSi welded specimens subjected to biaxial loading. In‐phase torsion–bending fatigue tests under constant amplitude loading were performed in a standard servo‐hydraulic machine with a suitable gripping system. Some tests in pure rotating bending with and without steady torsion were also performed. The influence of stress ratio R and bending–torsion stress ratio were analysed. Correlation of the fatigue lives was done using the distortion energy hypothesis (DEH), based on the local stresses and strains. The applicability of the local strain approach method to the prediction of the fatigue life of the welded tubular specimens was also investigated. Static torsion has only a slight detrimental influence on fatigue strength. The DEH (von Mises criterion) based on local stresses in the weld toes was shown to satisfactorily correlate fatigue lives for in‐phase multiaxial stress–strain states. The stress–strain field intensity predictions were shown to have less scatter and are in better agreement with the experimental results than the equivalent strain energy density approach.     

Fatigue life estimation for 30CrNiMo8 steel under in- and out-of-phase combined bending and torsion with variable amplitudes

Fatigue life successively calculated according to three criteria of multiaxial fatigue for randomly varying loading is compared with fatigue life obtained by Sanetra and Zenner in testing cylindrical specimens of 30CrNiMo8 steel by in- and out-of-phase bending and torsion with variable amplitudes. The position of the plane of fatigue fracture is determined using the variance method. The histories of equivalent stresses are schematically represented by the Monte Carlo method. Fatigue damage was computed using the Palmgren-Miner hypothesis. The most realistic estimates of fatigue life in the scatter band of the results with a factor of 3 are obtained on the basis of the criterion of maximum tangential stresses and normal stresses in the fracture plane with shear stresses taken into account.Published in Fiziko-Khimicheskaya Mekhanika Materialov, Vol. 31, No. 1, pp. 31–38, January – February, 1995.     

A multiaxial fatigue criterion for random loading

ABSTRACT A multiaxial fatigue criterion for random loading is proposed. Firstly, the orientation of the critical plane, where fatigue life estimation is carried out, is determined from the weighted mean position of the principal stress directions. Then, the scalar value of the normal stress vector N (t) perpendicular to the critical plane is taken as the cycle counting variable since the direction of such a vector is fixed with respect to time (conversely to the time‐varying direction of the shear stress vector C (t)), and a nonlinear combination of normal and shear stress components acting on the critical plane is used to define an equivalent stress amplitude. Finally, a damage accumulation model is employed to process such an equivalent stress amplitude and to determine fatigue endurance. This criterion is herein applied to some relevant random fatigue tests (proportional bending and torsion).     

A computer simulation of four-point bending fatigue of a rear axle assembly

The bending fatigue test of a rear axle assembly is simulated by using a FE-integrated fatigue analysis methodology. The presented technique is based on local stress–strain approach in conjunction with two critical plane damage parameters. The stress–strain response at a material point is computed with a cyclic plasticity model coupled with a notch stress–strain approximation scheme. Linear elastic FE stress analyses are used in the calculation of local fatigue loading. All computational modules are implemented into the software tool and used in the four-point bending fatigue test simulation of rear axles made of a high-strength alloy steel. In fatigue models, proportional loadings with a static preload are considered, and the effects of residual stresses are neglected. The fatigue test cycles and crack initiation locations are predicted using Smith–Watson–Topper and Fatemi–Socie fatigue damage parameters. Both damage parameters provided conservative test cycle estimates for the test conditions simulated. It is also observed that von Mises stress distributions cannot be used to predict fatigue crack initiation locations while Smith–Watson–Topper critical plane parameter estimated the cracking location suitably. Comparisons with the prototype tests showed the applicability of the proposed approach.     

Determination of the critical plane by a weight-function method based on the maximum shear stress plane under multiaxial high-cycle loading

A weight function method for the determination of the critical plane is here proposed for the case of specimens under combined bending and torsion in the high cycle fatigue regime. The critical plane is assumed to be coincident with the mean maximum absolute shear stress plane, which is calculated by averaging the instantaneous angle between the specimen axis and the normal to the maximum absolute shear stress plane. Two kinds of weight functions are proposed to determine such a plane. The proposed method to determine the critical plane is verified by employing fatigue data available in the literature in terms of experimental fracture planes, and the multiaxial fatigue life is also predicted by a reformulation of the criterion proposed by Carpinteri et al. to verify the determined critical plane. The results show that the proposed method can be applied to determine the critical plane under both constant and variable amplitude loading.     

FATIGUE UNDER OUT-OF-PHASE BENDING AND TORSION

Test data on fatigue under out-of-phase bending and torsion has been reanalysed. For the materials tested failure has been found to be consistent with the plane of maximum range of maximum range of maximum principal stress, as for the in-phase case. The critical shear planes are assumed to be those associated with this principal stress plane. A multiaxial fatigue damage parameter based on the maximum range of shear stress on the critical shear plane allowing for the effect of the range of normal stress occurring on this plane has been used to develop a proposed set of design curves for in-phase bending and torsion which are conservative for the long life out-of-phase case.     

Multiaxial fatigue limits and material sensitivity to non-zero mean stresses normal to the critical planes

This paper is concerned with an attempt to reformulate the so-called Modified Wöhler Curve Method (MWCM) in order to more efficiently account for the detrimental effect of non-zero mean stresses perpendicular to the critical planes. In more detail, by taking as a starting point the well-established experimental evidence that engineering materials exhibit different sensitivities to superimposed tensile static stresses, an effective value of the normal mean stress relative to the critical plane was attempted to be calculated by introducing a suitable correction factor. Such a mean stress sensitivity index was assumed to be a material constant, i.e. a material parameter to be determined by running appropriate experiments. The accuracy of the novel reformulation of the MWCM proposed here was systematically checked by using several experimental data taken from the literature. In particular, in order to better explore the main features of the improved MWCM, its accuracy in estimating multiaxial high-cycle fatigue damage was evaluated by considering fatigue results generated not only under non-zero mean stresses but also under non-proportional loading. Such a validation exercise allowed us to prove that the systematic use of the mean stress sensitivity index resulted in estimates falling within an error interval equal to about ±10%, and this held true independently of considered material and complexity of the investigated loading path. Finally, such a novel reformulation of the MWCM was also applied along with the Theory of Critical Distances (TCD) to predict the high-cycle fatigue strength of notched samples tested under in-phase bending and torsion with superimposed tensile and torsional static stresses: again our method was seen to be highly accurate, correctly predicting high-cycle multiaxial fatigue damage also in the presence of stress concentration phenomena.     

The Modified Manson–Coffin Curve Method to estimate fatigue lifetime under complex constant and variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue loading

This paper investigates the accuracy of the so-called Modified Manson–Coffin Curve Method (MMCCM) in estimating fatigue lifetime of metallic materials subjected to complex constant and variable amplitude multiaxial load histories. The MMCCM postulates that fatigue damage is maximised on that material plane experiencing the maximum shear strain amplitude. In the present investigation, the orientation of the critical plane was determined through that direction along which the variance of the resolved shear strain reaches it maximum value. Under variable amplitude complex load histories, this direction was also used to count the resolved shear strain cycles via the classic Rain-Flow method. Further, the degree of multiaxiality and non-proportionality of the time-variable stress states at the assumed critical locations was directly quantified through a suitable stress ratio which accounts for (i) the mean value and the variance of the stress perpendicular to the critical plane as well as for (ii) the variance of the shear stress resolved along the direction experiencing the maximum variance of the resolved shear strain. The accuracy and reliability of the proposed approach was checked against approximately 650 experimental data taken from the literature and generated by testing un-notched metallic materials under complex constant and variable amplitude multiaxial load histories. The sound agreement between estimates and experimental results which was obtained strongly supports the idea that the proposed design technique is a powerful engineering tool allowing metallic materials to be designed against constant and variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue by always reaching a remarkable level of accuracy. This approach offers a complete solution to the strain based multiaxial fatigue problem.     

A multiaxial criterion for notch high-cycle fatigue using a critical-point method

In the present paper, a high-cycle critical plane-based multaxial fatigue criterion, recently proposed by the first two authors to determine the fatigue strength of smooth components, is extended to notched ones by using the so-called point method. Accordingly, once the location of the ‘hot spot’ (crack initiation point) on the notch surface is determined, the orientation of the critical plane (where to perform fatigue strength assessment) is assumed to be correlated with some averaged principal stress directions in the hot spot itself. Some experimental results related to round bars with a surface circular notch (an artificially drilled surface hole) submitted to three types of cyclic loading (bending, torsion and combined in-phase bending and torsion) are compared with the theoretical predictions of the criterion herein proposed. The comparison, which is instrumental in highlighting the notch size-effect (as the hole diameter varies) under uniaxial and biaxial far-field stress conditions, appears to be quite satisfactory.     

A review of multiaxial fatigue of weldments: experimental results, design code and critical plane approaches

A survey of biaxial (bending or tension and torsion) constant amplitude fatigue of welded connections is presented. Re-analysis of 233 experimental results from eight different studies has been performed based on hot spot stresses and three potential damage parameters: maximum principal stress range; maximum shear stress range; and a modified critical plane model for welds. Of the three methods, the critical plane model was most successful in resolving the data to a single S – N line. The design curve for all toe failures based on the critical plane model was FAT 97 with a slope of 3. By excluding butt welds and including only fillet welds that failed at the weld toe, the design curve was increased to FAT 114 with a slope of 3. However, observed scatter was 70–100% larger than that observed in uniaxial loaded specimens analysed using the hot spot approach.     

Fatigue life calculation by means of the cycle counting and spectral methods under multiaxial random loading

The paper contains a new algorithm for estimation of fatigue life in HCF regime under multiaxial random loading using spectral methods. Loading of Gaussian distribution and narrow‐ and broad‐band frequency spectra were assumed. Various characteristic states of multiaxial loading were considered. The equivalent stress history was determined with use of the failure criteria of multiaxial fatigue based on the critical plane. For determination of the critical plane position, the method of variance was applied. During simulation, the authors compared the results obtained by a spectral method in the frequency domain with those from the rain‐flow algorithm in the time domain. The paper also contains the results of fatigue tests for 18G2A structural steel subjected to bending and combined bending with torsion. The tests were performed in order to verify the proposed algorithms for determination of fatigue life. It has been shown that under multiaxial random loading results of fatigue life calculated according to the considered algorithms in frequency and time domains are well correlated with the results of experiments.     

Kurzrisswachstum bei mehrachsig nichtproportionaler Beanspruchung

Short fatigue crack growth under multiaxial nonproportional loading Initiation and short fatigue crack growth have been investigated under nonproportional cyclic loading. A critical plane approach based on fracture mechanics is used for modelling the fatigue process. A Paris‐type crack growth law, formulated using the effective cyclic J‐integral as crack driving force parameter, is integrated to give crack growth curves. Crack opening stresses and strains are calculated with approximation equations. Jiang's plasticity model is used to predict the stress‐strain path. The good agreement between model and real damage evolution is shown comparing experimentally determined crack growth curves, crack orientations, and life curves.     

An Application of the Cell Method to Multiaxial Fatigue Assessment of a Test Component under Different Criteria

Abstract: A recent numerical method, the cell method, was applied for the dynamic analysis of an L‐shaped steel plate subjected to a sinusoidal load. The calculated stress time histories were post‐processed in order to assess fatigue life under four different high‐cycle fatigue criteria: two formulations of the equivalent Von Mises approach and two critical plane methods. The latter require the definition of amplitude and mean value of the shear stress acting on a material plane: when considering periodic stress histories, this is commonly achieved by the construction of the minimum circumscribed circle (MCC), encompassing the shear stress load path on the assumed fracture plane. In this study, a novel algorithm to determine the MCC has also been proposed and applied. The fatigue life assessment results were discussed and compared to point out the relevant characteristics of each method.     

A Review of Critical Plane Orientations in Multiaxial Fatigue Failure Criteria of Metallic Materials

The paper presents a review of multiaxial fatigue failure criteria based on the critical plane concept. The criteria have been divided into three groups, according to the fatigue damage parameter used in the criterion, i.e. (i) stress, (ii) strain and (iii) strain energy density criteria. Each criterion was described mainly by the critical plane orientation. Multiaxial fatigue criteria based on the critical plane concept usually apply different loading parameters in the critical plane whose orientation is determined by (a) only shear loading parameters (crack Mode II or III), (b) only normal loading parameters (crack Mode I) or sometimes (c) mixed loading parameters (mixed crack Mode). There are also criteria based on few critical plane orientations and criteria based on critical plane orientations determined by a weighted averaging process of rotating principal stress axes.     

Long-life torsion fatigue with normal mean stresses

Relatively simple fatigue tests have been performed on two common engineering materials, cast ductile iron and low-carbon steel, using two stress states, cyclic torsion and cyclic torsion with static axial and hoop stresses. Tests were designed to discriminate between normal stress and hydrostatic stress as the most suitable mean stress correction term for high cycle fatigue analysis. Microscopy shows that cracks in low-carbon steel nucleate and grow on maximum shear planes, while for cast iron pre-existing flaws grow on maximum normal stress planes. The data illustrate that tensile normal stress acting on a shear plane significantly reduced fatigue life and is an appropriate input for fatigue analysis of ductile materials. Static normal stresses did not significantly affect the fatigue life for the cast iron because the net mean stress on the maximum normal stress plane was zero. Mean torsion significantly reduced the fatigue strength of the cast iron. A critical plane long-life parameter for nodular iron which accounts for both stress state and mean stress is proposed, and is found to accurately correlate experimental data.     

Estimating fatigue damage under variable amplitude multiaxial fatigue loading

The present paper is concerned with the use of the modified Wöhler curve method (MWCM) to estimate both lifetime and high‐cycle fatigue strength of plain engineering materials subjected to complex load histories resulting, at critical locations, in variable amplitude (VA) multiaxial stress states. In more detail, when employed to address the constant amplitude (CA) problem, the MWCM postulates that fatigue damage reaches its maximum value on that material plane (i.e. the so‐called critical plane) experiencing the maximum shear stress amplitude, fatigue strength depending on the ratio between the normal and shear stress components relative to the critical plane itself. To extend the use of the above criterion to those situations involving VA loadings, the MWCM is suggested here as being applied by defining the critical plane through that direction experiencing the maximum variance of the resolved shear stress. Such a direction is used also to perform the cycle counting: because the resolved shear stress is a monodimensional quantity, stress cycles are directly counted by the classical rain‐flow method. The degree of multiaxiality and non‐proportionality of the time‐variable stress state at the assumed critical sites instead is suggested as being measured through a suitable stress ratio which accounts for the mean value and the variance of the stress perpendicular to the critical plane as well as for the variance of the shear stress resolved along the direction experiencing the maximum variance of the resolved shear stress. Accuracy and reliability of the proposed approach was checked by using several experimental results taken from the literature. The performed validation exercise seems to strongly support the idea that the approach formalized in the present paper is a powerful engineering tool suitable for estimating fatigue damage under VA multiaxial fatigue loading, and this holds true not only in the medium‐cycle, but also in the high‐cycle fatigue regime.