Galling resistance evaluation of tool steels by two different laboratory test methods for sheet metal forming

Adhesive accumulation of work material on the tool surface is today a major problem in many sheet metal‐forming applications. Different laboratory test methods are used to investigate galling with respect to different tool materials, lubricants and process conditions. In the present study, the galling resistance of a modern nitrogen‐alloyed powder metallurgy tool steel and an conventional ingot cast D2 type tool steel was evaluated under lubricated sliding against ferritic stainless steel sheets using a commercial pin‐on‐disc (POD) and an in‐house made slider‐on‐flat‐surface (SOFS) tribotester. The investigated tool steels ranked similarly in terms of galling resistanc in both test methods. However, sliding distances to galling were longer for the SOFS equipment due to continuous sliding on new lubricated sheet surface. Best performance was demonstrated by the powder metallurgy tool steel treated to 65 HRC. Differences in friction behaviour and galling initiation were analysed on the basis of the two different working conditions, i.e. open (SOFS) and closed (POD) tribosystems. Copyright © 2012 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Comparison of two test methods for evaluation of forming tool materials

Two test methods often used to simulate the tribological performance of forming tool materials are compared in this investigation through an evaluation of the friction and wear properties of four tool steels in dry sliding. One test (slider‐on‐flat‐surface (SOFS)) utilises a vertical disc sliding on a horizontal flat test surface, and the other (load scanner (LS) tests) utilises two crossed cylindrical rods. The test conditions were selected as equal as possible for the two tests, and the following conclusions are made. Somewhat unexpectedly, the friction and wear results differed substantially between the two tests. The SOFS test showed a better potential to evaluate wear resistance since one test sample is in continuous contact with the other. The LS test can generate higher contact pressures since the two rods contact each other in an unworn condition throughout the whole test stroke. LS indicate that two hard and smooth tool steels tested against each other generally give low friction and good galling resistance. The two hard couples tested sustained the highest loads without any detectable surface damage. For the same combinations of hard steels, SOFS gave a higher friction due to the wear of the disc. The carbides in the disc material resist wear better than the matrix and will consequently wear the disc by abrasion, which adds to the friction. The above conclusions are drawn from a rather limited examination using only one set of test parameters. In fact, the two tests are both very flexible as to the way they can be used, and they both have advantages and limitations in tribological studies. They should rather be considered complementary than competitive. Copyright © 2008 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

A new test method for measuring the galling resistance between metal powders and die tool materials in powder compaction

The friction characteristics and galling resistance between metal powder and die tool material in metal powder compaction is of outmost importance since they will influence the porosity and surface quality of the green body and consequently the porosity, tolerances and surface quality of the final sintered product. In the present study, a new test method for evaluating the tribological performance of die tool materials aimed for powder compaction is presented. The test method is based on controlled scratch testing using a commercial scratch tester but instead of the commonly used Rockwell C diamond stylus a sample holder with a small green body of compacted powder particles is drawn over the surface in a well controlled multi pass linear reciprocating sliding contact. The capability of the test method was evaluated for different types of tool materials including two PVD coatings in contact with different types of metal powders to determine the friction characteristics and the adhesion and material transfer tendency at the sliding interface. Post-test examination of the tool surfaces using FEG-SEM and EDS were performed in order to evaluate the mechanisms controlling the friction behavior and the material transfer tendency. The results show that the proposed test is a simple and fast method to obtain relevant data regarding the friction and galling characteristics of die tool materials in metal powder compaction. The mechanisms prevailing at the green body/die tool material interface, e.g. cold welding, can easily be monitored by the friction and acoustic emission signals. Of the die tool materials investigated the low friction PVD a-C:Cr coating displayed the lowest friction and highest galling resistance.     

Tribological Behavior of New Martensitic Stainless Steels Using Scratch and Dry Wear Test

This paper focuses on the tribological characterization of new martensitic stainless steels by two different tribological methods (scratch and dry wear tests) and their comparison to the austenitic standard stainless steel AISI 316L. The scratch test allows obtaining critical loads, scratch friction coefficients, scratch hardness and specific scratch wear rate, and the dry wear test to quantify wear volumes. The damage has been studied by ex situ scanning electron microscopy. Wear resistance was related to the hardness and the microstructure of the studied materials, where martensitic stainless steels exhibit higher scratch wear resistance than the austenitic one, but higher hardness of the martensitic alloys did not give better scratch resistance when comparing with themselves. It has been proved it is possible to evaluate the scratch wear resistance of bulk stainless steels using scratch test. The austenitic material presented lower wear volume than the martensitic ones after the dry wear test due to phase transformation and the hardening during sliding.     

The effect of ZDDP and MoDTC additives in engine oil on the friction properties of DLC‐coated and steel cam followers

Friction tests simulating cam follower sliding conditions were conducted using a pin‐on‐disc test rig. In the case of SAE 5W‐30 class engine oil, the friction coefficient of the combination of steel pins sliding on a steel disc increased from 0.11 to 0.12, while that of steel pins sliding on a diamond‐like carbon (DLC)‐coated disc decreased from 0.12 to 0.10. For 5W‐20 oil containing the friction modifier MoDTC (molybdenum dithio‐carbamates), the friction coefficient of steel pins sliding on a steel disc decreased markedly from 0.12 to 0.04. In contrast, that of steel pins sliding on a DLC‐coated disc decreased more moderately, from 0.11 to 0.08. In both cases, Zn, P, S, and Mo elements derived from ZDDP (zinc dialkyldithiophosphate) and MoDTC additives were not detected on the DLC‐coated disc, while these elements were detected on the steel disc and pins using electron probe microanalysis and X‐ray photo‐electron spectroscopy surface analysis. It appears that a tribochemical reaction film did not form on the DLC material due to its inactive chemical properties. Therefore, an increase in friction due to the formation of the film derived from ZDDP and a decrease in friction due to the formation of the film derived from MoDTC were clearly suppressed in the case of the steel pins sliding on the DLC‐coated disc. It is thought that the tribo‐chemical reaction film was instrumental in reducing friction substantially. The lateral force of the film formed on the steel disc was then measured using an atomic force microscopy lateral force microscopy test. The lateral force of the film resulting from the 5W‐30 oil was much higher than that of the film formed from the 5W‐20 oil with MoDTC. This result coincided well with the results of the friction tests. Judging from these results, it is thought that the high friction coefficient observed for the steel pins on the steel disc for the 5W‐30 oil was caused by the higher shear strength of the film formed from ZDDP. On the other hand, the very low friction coefficient observed for the steel pin‐steel disc combination for the 5W‐20 oil was presumably caused by the formation of a solid MoS₂ lubricant from the MoDTC additive.     

钢球展开过程运动学及动力学分析

钢球表面质量检测常用的办法是依靠展开机构中的摩擦力将钢球表面完全展开,摩擦力对钢球表面检测效率和精度有着重要影响。为分析摩擦对钢球展开的影响,根据展开轮与钢球接触的几何约束关系,对钢球与展开轮接触模型进行运动学分析,得到钢球与展开轮接触点位置的变化规律;由于展开装置构件之间全部依靠干摩擦接触约束,在古典Coulomb摩擦模型基础上,结合展开装置特性,建立修正的Coulomb摩擦模型,建立钢球和展开轮的运动微分方程,得到钢球与展开轮接触点处摩擦力的变化规律,并分析接触点处接触力的影响因素;同时根据展开原理构建实体模型进行虚拟仿真并搭建物理样机进行试验,结果表明驱动轮转速直接影响钢球与展开轮接触点法向接触力变化,从而影响接触点处摩擦力变化特性,通过摩擦力变化特性,解释了展开轮能实现钢球表面展开的工作原理。     

Development of Iron-Base Seal Materials for High Temperature Applications

This paper describes an experimental investigation of materials for use as high temperature rubbing seals.

The results of a comprehensive evaluation of the rubbing properties of commercial high speed tool steels are presented. It is shown that molybdenum steels have desirable high temperature seal characteristics. Tungsten steels, on the other hand, exhibit inferior properties. The best overall performance is demonstrated by a steel containing both molybdenum and tungsten in combination with cobalt.

These commercial tool steels are not effective over 1000 F; therefore, new material combinations were sought. Using powder metallurgy techniques, a series of iron-base alloys containing molybdenum and cobalt was studied. It was found that alloys containing from 5 to 20% of both molybdenum and cobalt exhibit excellent rubbing properties up to 1200 F, and in general, are superior to the tool steels tested.

Further testing of Fe-Mo-Co materials revealed that friction and wear are markedly dependent upon the test conditions. A minimum coefficient of friction was obtained with the highest surface speed (150 fps) and with the highest ambient temperature (1200 F).

The desirable rubbing properties of this family of materials are explained in terms of surface oxidation products which act as solid-film lubricants during high temperature rubbing.     

The repeatability of friction and wear results obtained from unlubricated reciprocating sliding tests

Laboratory tests can help in the analysis of tribological failures of elements, and improve tribo‐systems by choosing appropriate materials. In order to characterise the friction and wear behaviour of candidate materials, various different test methods have been developed in the past and are still in use. One such method is the reciprocating sliding of a ball against a disc. In the work reported here, the repeatability of friction and wear results was evaluated with ten tests under identical conditions with a steel (100Cr6) or alumina (Al₂O₃) ball against a steel (100Cr6) disc under unlubricated conditions at room temperature. The influence of ambient humidity on friction and wear behaviour was determined in three additional tests in dry and in moist air, respectively. The repeatability of friction coefficient in normal air was better than 5% for alumina/100Cr6 and 12% for 100Cr6/100Cr6, while the repeatability of volumetric wear was slightly better than 10% for alumina/steel, and slightly worse than 10% for steel/steel. For both couples the coefficient of friction is lowest in moist air and about 50% higher in dry air. The coefficient of wear is also least in moist air and higher by a factor of 3(5) in dry air for tests with a 100Cr6 (alumina) ball.     

Influence of Temperature and Relative Humidity on the Friction and Wear of Unlubricated Reciprocating Sliding Steel/ Steel Couples

Many tribosystems are subjected to different conditions with respect to temperature and humidity. Reciprocating sliding tests with steel/steel couples were performed using a laboratory test rig in air with varying relative humidity and temperature. During each test the friction force, the total linear wear, the electrical contact resistance, and the acoustic emission were recorded. Tests with self‐mated couples of bearing steel (100r6) and of stainless steel (X10CrNiMoNb18‐10/X5CrNi18‐9) in a ball‐on‐disc arrangement revealed small effects of temperature and humidity on friction, but a strong effect of the water vapour content on the wear rate of the system. Attempts were made to correlate changes of wear behaviour with different wear mechanisms.     

The effect of nitrogen on the scratch resistance of austenitic stainless steels

High nitrogen stainless steels (HNSS) are being considered a new promising class of engineering materials. When nitrogen is added to austenitic steels it can simultaneously improve fatigue life, strength and wear and localized corrosion resistance. In this work, a single pass pendulum scratch test was used to study the effect of nitrogen on the scratch resistance of an UNS S30403 austenitic stainless steel. Samples with increasing nitrogen contents at the surface were obtained through high temperature gas nitriding. The thermochemical treatments were performed at 1473 K in (N₂+Ar) gas atmospheres for 36.0 ks, obtaining fully austenitic cases (surface nitrogen contents up to 0.5 wt%) ca. 1.5 mm in depth. The scratch tests were performed in a single-pass pendulum, equipped with strain gages to measure normal and tangential forces during scratching. The specific absorbed energy was calculated as the ratio between the measured absorbed energy and the amount of mass removed from the specimen. An increase of the specific absorbed energy with increasing nitrogen content was observed. The results of the scratch tests were analyzed taking into account the stress–strain behavior during depth sensing indentation tests and the energy absorbed during Charpy impact tests. The improvement in scratch resistance due to nitrogen alloying was attributed to the strong hardening effect of nitrogen in solid solution, which does not affect significantly work hardening and toughness. A comparison between the scratch resistance and the cavitation-erosion resistance, measured in previous work, was made too.     

Investigation of antiwear coatings deposited by the pvd process

The tribological properties of various PVD‐deposited coatings (vacuum arc method) have been tested, both single‐layer coatings (TiN, CrN, Ti(C,N), and Cr(C,N)) and multilayer coatings (Cr(C,N)/CrN/Cr and CR(C,N)/(CrN+Cr₂N)/CrN/Cr). An unlubricated ball‐on‐disc tribosystem was used in which an Al₂O₃ ball is pressed against a coated steel disc rotating in the horizontal plane. A novelty of the method is the removal of wear debris from the contact zone using a draught of dry argon. This improves the repeatability of the test results and the stability of the tribological characteristics. It is shown that CrN coatings exhibit the best antiwear properties and Ti(C,N) the worst. Multilayer coatings have better antiwear properties than single‐layer ones. The friction coefficients for CrN and Cr(C,N) coatings are much smaller than for the commonly used TiN. A correlation has also been found between the physical properties of the coatings tested (adhesion of the coating to the substrate assessed in scratch tests, and coating hardness) and their antiwear properties. An improvement in coating‐substrate adhesion results in wear reduction, while greater hardness (causing a coating embrittlement increase and a change in the wear mechanism) brings about greater wear. There is no correlation between the physical properties and the friction coefficients of the coatings tested.     

Wear data from friction pairs for microscale piezoelectric actuators

This paper presents friction and wear data from a series of physical tests on numerous friction pairs. The tests were designed to simulate the loads, motions, and conditions typical in microscale piezoelectric actuator applications. The friction pairs tested included various combinations of steels, ceramics, and surface‐treated steels. Both high‐cycle tests and low‐endurance tests were performed and the optimum friction pairs for these applications were identified based on high friction, low wear, and low roughness.     

Synergistic effect of diisopropyl phosphite and over‐based calcium sulphonate additives on tribological properties of AISI 52100 steel/Al2O3 ceramics

The friction‐reducing and anti‐wear effect of the 500SN base oil containing diisopropyl phosphite (T451) and over‐based calcium sulphonate (KT5447) on AISI 52100 steel/Al₂O₃ ceramic were investigated with a ball‐on‐disc tribometer at a light load of 200 N and a high load of 400 N. The results indicate that the 500SN base oil containing T451 and KT5447 appears to have a synergistic effect on the pair. For the light load of 200 N, the effective composition is 3 wt% T451 + 2–3 wt% KT5447. For the high load of 400 N, the combination of T451 and KT5447 appears to have a synergistic friction‐reducing and anti‐wear effect. The scanning electron microscope images show that ploughed grooves, pitting, spalling and corrosion are the dominant wear modes for both 200 and 400 N. However, no evidence for the formation of the expected sulphur‐containing or phosphorus‐containing chemical compound is found according to X‐ray photoelectron spectroscopy analysis of the worn steel ball surface at both loads. Copyright © 2011 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

High temperature tribological behaviour of tool steels during sliding against aluminium

Soldering and abrasive wear of die-casting tools are some of the biggest problems facing the aluminium die-casting industry. The understanding of the tribological behaviour is crucial to design new tool steels and tool steel-coating systems. The present study aims at investigating aluminium adhesion of aluminium/tool steel pair, performing sliding tests at high temperature with ball-on-disc configuration to reproduce solid/solid interaction. Different test conditions have been conducted in order to select the optimal test parameters to obtain aluminium adhesion on disc surface. Once the lab test has been designed, the high temperature tribological performance of different hot work tool steels (uncoated and coated by PVD) sliding against aluminium has been studied to allow proper die material design and selection.     

Design of a high speed friction and wear machine with test results for steels

A high speed pin-on-disc wear tester designed for 250–3000 cm s^?1 speeds and 25–150 gf loads was operated to determine the roles of loading system moment inertia and mechanical compliance on the wear of both hard tool steels and soft mild steel.Sensible wear was observed only for the soft pin-soft disc combination. Results indicated that the inertia and compliance have major effects on the wear rate of soft steel and its friction force. This force was found to be composed of a series of discrete pulses with peak values much greater than the average value. When either the pin or the disc was a hardened steel, the friction pulse amplitude diminished. A qualitative analysis of the machine parameters consistent with test results was developed.     

Effect of Ag nanoparticles additive on the tribological behavior of multialkylated cyclopentanes (MACs)

Monodisperse Ag nanoparticles with a particle size of about 6–7 nm and low volatile multialkylated cyclopentanes (MACs) lubricant were prepared. The effect of Ag nanoparticles as additive in MACs base oil on the friction and wear behavior of MACs was investigated. The friction and wear test of a steel disc sliding against the same steel counterpart ball was carried out on an Optimal SRV oscillating friction and wear tester. The morphology and elemental distribution of the worn surface of both the steel ball and steel disc and the chemical feature of typical element thereof were examined using a JEM-1200EX scanning electron microscope (SEM) equipped with a Kevex energy dispersive X-ray analyzer attachment (EDS) and X-ray photoelectron spectroscope (XPS), respectively. Friction and wear test indicates that the wear resistance and load-carrying capacity of MACs base oil were markedly raised and its friction coefficient changed little when 2% Ag nanoparticles were added in it. Results of SEM/EDS and XPS show that Ag nanoparticles were deposited on the friction pair surfaces to form low shearing stress metal Ag protective film in rubbing process.     

Comparison of wear properties of tool steels AISI D2 and O1 with the same hardness

Two commercial cold work tool steels, AISI D2 and O1, were heat treated in order to obtain the same hardness 700 HV (60 HRc) and were subsequently tested in three different modes of wear, namely in adhesion, three-body and two-body abrasion, by using pin-on-disk, dry sand/rubber wheel apparatus and pin abrasion on SiC, respectively. Even though AISI O1 and D2 steel are heat treated to the same hardness, they perform differently under the three modes of wear examined. The results show that the steel microstructures play the most important role in determining the wear properties. For relatively low sliding speeds AISI O1 steel performs up to 12 times better than AISI D2 steel in adhesive wear. For higher sliding speeds, however, this order is reversed due to oxidation taking place on the surface of the AISI D2 steel. The wear rate of both tool steels in three-body and two-body abrasion wear is proportional to the applied load. In three-body abrasive wear, AISI D2 exhibits a normalised wear rate about two times lower than the AISI O1 tool steel, and this is due to the presence of the plate-like hard carbides in its microstructure. Both tool steels perform 3–8 times better in three-body abrasive wear conditions than in two-body abrasive wear.     

Experimental study of the friction and wear behaviour of a polymer disc/primer coating combination used in ball‐joints by means of large‐scale testing

The surfaces of a heavily loaded ball‐joint were initially covered with a sliding spray, and suffer wear. A solution is found by incorporating ultra high molecular weight polyethylene (UHMWPE) discs with a carbon fibre/epoxy reinforced ring as sliding material into the chairs of the structure. The ball side is covered with a zinc phosphate primer coating. For design purposes the local static and dynamic behaviour of the hybrid UHMWPE discs in contact with steel or Zn‐coated counterfaces should be large‐scale tested in terms of their loading capacity, low friction and wear resistance. Also the influence of creep and wear on friction is examined. After the large‐scale verification tests in laboratory, a good correlation is found with a test in the field. Copyright © 2006 John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.     

Self-assembled monolayer protective films for hybrid sliding contacts

Abstract

Silicon nitride as an energy efficient material is replacing conventional steels for new generation engineering components such as bearings, cutting tools, electronics and engine parts in automotive, aerospace and wind industries. Compared with steel bearings, silicon nitride bearings can be operated at much higher temperatures and speeds with >60% weight reduction and up to 80% friction reduction. These are all due to its unique material properties, including high wear and corrosion resistance, low density and heat generation. Current lubrication solutions for hybrid contacts, where silicon nitride balls and steel races are used, are mostly relying on the protection film formed on the metal surfaces. Self-assembled monolayers (SAMs) have been found very useful in modifying surfaces, especially for microelectromechanical system and nanoscale applications, e.g. atomic force microscopy tips, etc. This study aims to investigate the feasibility of forming a SAM protection film on industrial grade bearing material silicon nitride to reduce the friction for the oil lubricated hybrid contacts. Four silanes with different functional head groups, including octadecyltrichlorosilane (OTS), octyltrichlorosilane, chlorodimethyloctadecylsilane and octadecyltrimethoxysilane, were initially investigated to form SAMs on industrial grade silicon nitride surfaces. The effects of concentration and immersion time of the silanes on the formation of SAMs on the silicon nitride surface were evaluated using contact angle measurements. The preliminary results show that the wetting properties of the silicon nitride surface can be effectively modified by the formation of SAMs from the silane solutions. OTS can form an order and compact SAM on the silicon nitride surfaces within 2 min at the concentration of 2··5 mM in decane solution, while the other three alkylsilanes can also effectively modify silicon nitride surfaces given sufficient immersion time, e.g. over 1 h. Tribological tests were subsequently carried out on a ball on disc rig where a steel ball and a silicon nitride disc were used. The effect of the formation of alkylsilane SAMs on the friction between the sliding contacts has been evaluated in two different methods. The first method was to test preformed SAM films under dry conditions, and the second was to premix one of the surfactants with Shell Vitrea ISO 32 mineral base oil and then spray the mixture to the contacts during the ball on disc testing. The test results show that an average of over 40 and 30% friction reduction was achieved for the hybrid contact when lubricated with the base oil mixed with OTS (>2··5 mM) and octadecyltrimethoxysilane (5 mM) respectively compared with that of the sliding contact lubricated by the base oil only. Since OTS may produce corrosive byproducts during SAM formation, octadecyltrimethoxysilane may be a more suitable additive for the hybrid contacts.     

Tribological behavior of Fe-based bulk metallic glass

The unlubricated tribological characteristics of coating layers containing an Fe-based amorphous matrix have been investigated in air using an alumina ball with a diameter of 3.1 mm. From the ball-on-disk test system, the friction coefficient could be measured for up to 3,000 seconds. The temperature changes on the worn surfaces were also simultaneously measured using an infrared thermometer. Three different types of coating layers having an Fe-based amorphous matrix, an Fe-based amorphous matrix with embedded Ni-based self-fluxing alloy particles, and an Fe-based amorphous matrix with embedded WC particles were prepared through a high velocity oxy-fuel (HVOF) process. Although the coating layers have certain levels of porosity, unique frictional characteristics attributed to the amorphous matrix were observed during the friction tests. Compared with conventional bearing steels such as AISI 521000 (Hv=840), excellent tribological and wear characteristics were obtained, demonstrating that an Fe-based bulk metallic glass powder is a viable engineering material for practical anti-wear coating applications.