Emissions of NOx and N2O during co-combustion of dried sewage sludge with coal in a circulating fluidized bed combustor

Emissions of NO_x and N₂O were measured during mono-combustion of dried sewage sludge and co-combustion with coal in a bench-scale circulating fluidized bed combustor (CFBC). The results were compared with previous results obtained using a bubbling fluidized bed combustor (BFBC). The increase in NO_x with sludge ash accumulation in the combustor was less for the CFBC than the BFBC, partly because of the higher attrition rate of sludge ash in CFBC resulting from the higher gas velocity. The influence of sludge ash on the formation of NO_x in CFBC was less than that in BFBC during sludge combustion. The effects of fuel type on NO_x and N₂O emissions were also evaluated.     

Prediction of unburned carbon and NOx in a tangentially fired power station using single coals and blends

Coal blends are now widely used by the power generation industry and the general characteristics are well known. Attention is still directed to the emission of NO_x, which is subject to more stringent regulation, and to the amount of carbon in ash. The latter is increased when low NO_x burners are employed, which is the norm now. It is also increased as a result of additional air staging when over-fire air is added in furnaces, especially tangential fired systems. Such a furnace is studied here. Two approaches can be employed for prediction of NO_x and unburned carbon. The first approach uses global models such as the ‘slice’ model which requires the combustor reaction conditions as an input but which has a detailed coal combustion mechanism. The second involves a computational fluid dynamic model that in principle can give detailed information about all aspects of combustion, but usually is restricted in the detail of the combustion model because of the heavy computational demands. The slice model approach can be seen to be complimentary to the CFD approach since the NO_x and carbon burnout is computed using the slice model as a post-processor to the CFD model computation. The slice model that has been used previously by our group is applied to a commercial tangentially fired combustor operated in Spain and using a range of Spanish coals and imported coals, some of which are fired as blends. The computed results are compared with experimental measurements, and the accuracy of the approach assessed. The CFD model applied to this case is one of the commercial codes modified to use a number of coal combustion sub-models developed by our group. In particular it can use two independent streams of coal and as such it can be used for the combustion of coal blends. The results show that both model approaches can give good predictions of the NO_x and carbon in ash despite the fact that certain parts of the coal combustion models are not exactly the same. However, if a detailed insight into the combustor behaviour is required then the CFD model must be used.     

Pulverized coal combustion in air and in O2/CO2 mixtures with NOx recycle

This paper presents experimental results of a 20 kW vertical combustor equipped with a single pf-burner on pulverised coal combustion in air and O₂/CO₂ mixtures with NO_x recycle. Experimental results on combustion performance and NO_x emissions of seven international bituminous coals in air and in O₂/CO₂ mixtures confirm the previous findings of the authors that the O₂ concentration in the O₂/CO₂ mixture has to be 30% or higher to produce matching temperature profiles to those of coal-air combustion while coal combustion in 30% O₂/70% CO₂ leads to better coal burnout and less NO_x emissions than coal combustion in air. Experimental results with NO_x recycle reveal that the reduction of the recycled NO depends on the combustion media, combustion mode (staging or non-staging) and recycling location. Generally, more NO is reduced with coal combustion in 30% O₂/70% CO₂ than with coal combustion in air. Up to 88 and 92% reductions of the recycled NO can be achieved with coal combustion in air and in 30% O₂/70% CO₂ respectively. More NO is reduced with oxidant staging than without oxidant staging when NO is recycled through the burner. Much more NO is reduced when NO recycled through the burner (from 65 to 92%) than when NO is recycled through the staging tertiary oxidant ports (from 33 to 54%). The concentration of the recycled NO has little influence on the reduction efficiency of the recycled NO with both combustion media—air and 30% O₂/70% CO₂.     

The effect of combustion conditions in a full-scale low-NOx coal fired unit on fly ash properties for its application in concrete mixtures

The wide implementation of low-NO_x combustion technologies in pulverized coal combustion can lead to higher levels of carbon in fly ash and increase the adsorptivity toward surfactants of the carbon. Consequently, the air entraining agent (AEA) requirements of the fly ash used for concrete production increases, which can complicate the stabilization of entrained air. In this study, a low-NO_x tangential fired 875 MW_th power plant burning bituminous coal have been operated under extreme conditions in order to test the impact of the operating conditions on fly ash adsorption behavior and NO_x formation. It was found that the AEA adsorption of the fly ash was reduced up to five times compared to reference operation, when the plant was operated with minimum furnace air staging, three levels of burners instead of four and without recycled flue gas. The lower AEA requirements of the fly ash at these conditions were primarily caused by a reduction in total carbon content, while the AEA adsorptivity of the residual carbon was lowered to about 60% of reference value. The tested operation mode, however, increased the NO_x level in the flue gas before the DeNO_x plant by 60% compared to reference operation.     

Emissions of NOx and N2O during co-combustion of dried sewage sludge with coal in a bubbling fluidized bed combustor

Emissions of NO_x and N₂O were measured during mono-combustion of dried sewage sludge and co-combustion with coal in a bench-scale bubbling fluidized bed combustor. After starting the sludge feed, emissions of NO_x increased with time, but N₂O emissions changed only slightly. After a certain amount of sludge was burned, the fuel was switched from sludge to coal. Emissions of NO_x from coal combustion after sludge combustion were higher than those before sludge combustion. These results suggest that the accumulation of sludge ash influenced NO_x emissions. A simple model of ash accumulation and removal was proposed. The transient change in NO_x after starting co-combustion was explained using the model presented here.     

Comparisons of pulverized coal combustion in air and in mixtures of O2/CO2

Pulverized coal combustion in air and the mixtures of O₂/CO₂ has been experimentally investigated in a 20 kW down-fired combustor (190 mm id×3 m). Detailed comparisons of gas temperature profiles, gas composition profiles, char burnouts, conversions of coal–N to NO_x and coal–S to SO₂ and CO emissions have been made between coal combustion in air and coal combustion in various O₂/CO₂ mixtures. The effectiveness of air/oxidant staging on reducing NO_x emissions has also been investigated for coal combustion in air and O₂/CO₂ mixtures. The results show that simply replacing the N₂ in the combustion air with CO₂ will result in a significant decrease of combustion gas temperatures. However, coal combustion in 30% O₂/70% CO₂ can produce matching gas temperature profiles to those of coal combustion in air while having a lower coal–N to NO_x conversion, a better char burnout and a lower CO emission. The results also confirm that air/oxidant staging is very effective in reducing NO_x emissions for coal combustion in both air and a 30% O₂/70% CO₂ mixture. SO₂ emissions are proved to be almost independent of the combustion media investigated.     

CO2 capture using oxygen enhanced combustion strategies for natural gas power plants

This paper describes a series of experiments conducted with natural gas in air and in mixtures of oxygen and recycled flue gas, termed O₂/CO₂ recycle combustion. The objective is to enrich the flue gas with CO₂ to facilitate its capture and sequestration. Detailed measurements of gas composition, flame temperature and heat flux profiles were taken inside CANMET's 0.3 MWth down-fired vertical combustor fitted with a proprietary pilot scale burner. Flue gas composition was continuously monitored. The effects of burner operation, including swirling of secondary stream and air staging, on flame characteristics and NO_x emissions were also studied. The results of this work indicate that oxy-gas combustion techniques based on O₂/CO₂ combustion with flue gas recycle offer excellent potential for retrofit to conventional boilers for CO₂ emission abatement. Other benefits of the technology include considerable reduction and even elimination of NO_x emissions, improved plant efficiency due to lower gas volume and better operational flexibility.     

Evaluation of the use of coal volatiles as reburning fuel for NOx reduction

In this study, computational fluid dynamic (CFD) and kinetic models were used to investigate the relative performances of coal volatiles and natural gas reburning. This modeling approach considers fluid dynamic and non-isothermal effects, which were not considered in past laboratory flow reactor studies. The commercial CFD code FLUENT 6.1 was used to predict the residence times and temperatures for reburning tests in the down-fired combustor (DFC), a 0.5 MMBTU/h research combustor at The Pennsylvania State University. To predict NO_x concentrations within the combustor, this data was then applied to an advanced reburning kinetic model used in past studies. For equal firing rates and stoichiometric ratios, reburning using methane yielded lower concentrations of NO_x (and, therefore, better NO_x reduction performance) than reburning using coal volatiles. The coal volatiles give increased flame temperature over natural gas, which apparently offsets the increased reburn zone hydrocarbon radical yield of coal volatiles over natural gas.     

Major gaseous and PAH emissions from a fluidized-bed combustor firing rice husk with high combustion efficiency

This experimental work investigated major gaseous (CO and NO_x) and PAH emissions from a 400 kW_th fluidized-bed combustor with a cone-shaped bed (referred to as ‘conical FBC’) firing rice husk with high, over 99%, combustion efficiency. Experimental tests were carried out at the fuel feed rate of 80 kg/h for different values of excess air (EA). As revealed by the experimental results, EA had substantial effects on the axial CO and NO_x concentration profiles and corresponding emissions from the combustor. The concentration (mg/kg-ash) and specific emission (μg/kW h) of twelve polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs), acenaphthylene, fluorene, phenanthrene, fluoranthene, pyrene, benz[a]anthracene, chrysene, benzo[b]fluoranthene, benzo[k]fluoranthene, benzo[a]pyrene, dibenz[a,h]anthracene and indeno[1,2,3-cd]pyrene, were quantified in this work for different size fractions of ash emitted from the conical FBC firing rice husk at EA = 20.9%. The total PAHs emission was found to be predominant for the coarsest ash particles, due to the effects of a highly developed internal surface in a particle volume. The highest emission was shown by acenaphthylene, 4.1 μg/kW h, when the total yield of PAHs via fly ash was about 10 μg/kW h.     

Rice husk co-firing with coal in a short-combustion-chamber fluidized-bed combustor (SFBC)

This study encompassed the characteristics and performance of co-firing rice husk, a by-product of rice-milling process, with coal in a short-combustion-chamber fluidized-bed combustor (SFBC). Bed phenomena investigated in a cold-flow model combustor showed that with the different mixes of materials, the anticipated offshoot of combustion, the minimum fluidizing velocity (U_mf) was 0.4-0.8 m/s. In concord with axial temperature profiles, axial gas concentration profiles implied that a recirculating ring was able to circumscribe CO within the short-main chamber. The formation, decomposition, and eventual maturity of NO_x characterized the NO_x evolution, inferred from concentration profiles. The impacts of fluidizing velocity and blending ratio on gas emissions and combustion efficiency (E_c) are described. The fluidizing velocity had consequential effect on gas emissions, except NO_x. Surprisingly, NO_x did not hinge much on increased N-content of the mixtures with coal. As expected, increased SO₂ was relevant to increased coal mass. Increased fluidizing velocity adversely affected E_c while increased coal fraction enhanced E_c, mostly >97%.     

Co-firing characteristics of rice husk and coal in a cyclonic fluidized-bed combustor (Ψ-FBC) under controlled bed temperatures

This study extensively investigated temperature and emission characteristics, and the performance of co-firing rice husk with coal in a cyclonic fluidized-bed combustor (Ψ-FBC) of 125 kW_th nominal capacity. The Ψ-FBC integrated the distinct features of cyclonic/vortex and fluidized-bed combustion. Fluidization, without any inert material, can be accomplished by the stirring blades and vortex ring. The combustor was equipped with a multi-passes water coil to regulate the bed temperatures, varying 800-900 °C. Rice husk was co-fired with coal, a supplementary fuel, with coal blending ratios of 0-25% by thermal basis. The radial temperature profiles displayed vortex combustion along the wall, while the axial temperature profiles suggested a well-mixed condition in the lower part. The large depletion of O₂ and proliferation of CO in the lower part revealed vigorous combustion beneath the vortex ring. A reducing atmosphere appeared unfavorable to NO_x formation. The combustor showed satisfied E_c, mostly >98.5%. The optimum operating conditions with respect to NO_x emissions were: (1) the thermal percentage of coal not >20%, and (2) bed temperatures between 800 and 850 °C. Otherwise, NO_x emissions would exceed the regulations; even CO and SO₂ emissions were well acceptable.     

NOx generation from the combustion of Australian brown and subbituminous coals

The formation of NO_x during the combustion of pulverized brown and subbituminous coals from Victoria and Queensland respectively was investigated in an entrainment reactor. As no NO₂ was detected, all the NO_x was present in the form of NO. The brown coals exhibited a significantly greater potential for NO emission under fuel-lean conditions than did the subbituminous coal, even though the latter coal had a higher nitrogen content. However, under fuel-rich conditions the conversion of coal nitrogen to NO for the subbituminous coal was higher than for the brown coals. The differences in conversion efficiency may have been related in part to the nature and reactivity of the volatile nitrogen species. Reactivity differences between the chars produced from the brown and subbituminous coals may also have accounted for different extents of removal of NO. There was a significant reduction in the amount of NO emitted when brown coal was added to a combustion gas stream containing an appreciable quantity of NO before coal injection.     

Experimental investigation on NOx emission and carbon burnout from a radially biased pulverized coal whirl burner

Experiments have been performed on 1 MW pulverized coal (pc) furnace in order to investigate the characteristics of coal combustion and NO_x emission from a new type of radially biased dual register whirl burner. The burner is characterized by a primary air pipe with a continuously changing cross-section and an impact ring. The mixture of pulverized coal and air inside the primary pipe is split into two streams, which are the outer pc rich annular jet and the inner pc lean annular jet respectively. Three Chinese coals, which are high rank bituminous coal, low rank bituminous coal and meager coal respectively, are used in the experiments. We examine the influences of various parameters such as the relative position of the over-fire air (OFA) nozzle, over-fire air ratio (19.1%), primary air ratio, inner secondary air ratio, outer secondary air ratio, inner secondary air swirling intensity, and outer secondary air swirling intensity on NO_x formation and unburned carbon in fly ash. With the primary air ratio increasing from 13.4% to 23.4%, the value of the NO_x emission of the SH coal decreases by 26.7% at first, and then increases by 21.7%. In contrast, the value of the carbon in fly ash (C_FA) increases by 40.1% at first, and then decreases by 58.3%.According to the experimental results, the influence of each individual parameter on NO_x formation and unburned carbon in fly ash agrees well with the existing literature. In this study, the influences of various combinations of these parameters are also examined, thus providing some reference for the design of the radial biased whirl burner, the configuration of the furnace and the distribution of the air.     

Impact of air staging along furnace height on NOx emissions from pulverized coal combustion

Experiments were carried out on an electrically heated multi-path air inlet one-dimensional furnace to assess NO_x emission characteristics of an overall air-staged (also termed air staging along furnace height) combustion of bituminous coal. The impact of main parameters of overall air-staged combustion technology, including burnout air position, air stoichiometric ratio, levels of burnout air (the number of burnout air arranged at different heights of the furnace), and the ratios of the burnout air flow rates and pulverized coal fineness of industrial interest, on NO_x emission were simulated to study in the experimental furnace, as well as the impact of air staging on the carbon content of the fly ash produced. These results suggest that air-staged combustion affects a pronounced reduction in NO_x emissions from the combustion of bituminous coal. The more deeply the air is staged, the further the NO_x emission is reduced. Two-level air staging yields a greater reduction in NO_x emission than single-level air staging. For pulverized coal of differing fineness, the best ratio between the burnout air rates in the two-level staging ranges from 0.6 to 0.3. In middle air-staged degree combustion with f_M = 0.75, pulverized coal fineness, R₉₀ (%), has a greater influence on NO_x emission, whereas R₉₀ has little influence on NO_x emission for deep air-staged degree with f_M = 0.61. Air-staged combustion with proper burnout air position has little effect on the burnout. For overall air-staged combustion, proper burnout air position and air-staged rate should be considered together in order to achieve high combustion efficiency.     

Characteristics and composition of fly ash from Canadian coal-fired power plants

Fly ashes were collected from the electrostatic precipitator (ESPs) and/or the baghouse of seven coal-fired power plants. The fly ashes were sampled from power plants that use pulverized subbituminous and bituminous feed coals. Fly ash from bituminous coals and limestone feed coals from fluidized-bed power plant were also sampled. The fly ashes were examined for their mineralogies and elemental compositions. The fly ashes from pulverized low sulfur coals are ferrocalsialic, those from high sulfur coals are ferrosialic and the fly ashes from the fluidized bed coals are ferrocalcic. The concentrations of As, Cd, Hg, Mo, Ni, and Pb in fly ash are related to the S content of the coal. Generally, those feed coals with a high S content contain higher concentrations of these elements. The concentrations of these elements are also greater for baghouse fly ash compared to ESP fly ash for the same station. The S content of fly ash from high S coal is 0.1% for pulverized ESP fly ash and 7% for baghouse fly ash from the fluidized bed, indicating that most of the S is captured by fly ash in the fluidized bed. The baghouse fly ash from the fluidized bed has the highest content of Cd, Hg, Mo, Pb, and Se, indicating that CaO, for the most part, captures them. Arsenic is captured by calcium-bearing minerals and hematite, and forms a stable complex of calcium or a transition metal of iron hydroxy arsenate hydrate [(M²⁺)₂Fe₃(AsO₄)₃(OH)₄·10H₂O] in the fly ash. Most elements in fly ash have enrichment indices of greater than 0.7 indicating that they are more enriched in the fly ash than in the feed coal, except for Hg in all ESP ashes. Mercury is an exception; it is more enriched in baghouse fly ash compared to ESP. Fly ash collected from a station equipped with hot side ESP has a lower concentration of Hg compared to stations equipped with cold side ESP using feed coals of similar rank and mercury content. Fly ash particles from fluidized bed coal are angular and subangular with cores of quartz and calcite. The quartz core is encased in layer(s) of calcium-rich aluminosilicates, and/or calcium/iron oxides. The calcite core is usually encased in an anhydrite shell.     

Optimization of air staging in a 1 MW tangentially fired pulverized coal furnace

This paper deals with an experimental study of air staging in a 1 MW (heat input power) tangentially fired pulverized coal furnace. The influences of several variables associated with air staging on NO_x reduction efficiency and unburned carbon in fly ash were investigated, and these variables included the air stoichiometric ratio of primary combustion zone (SR₁), the locations of over-fire air nozzles along furnace height, and the ratio of coal concentration of the fuel-rich stream to that of the fuel-lean one (RRL) in primary air nozzle. The experimental results indicate that SR₁ and RRL have optimum values for NO_x reduction, and the two optimum values are 0.85 and 3:1, respectively. NO_x reduction efficiency monotonically increases with the increase of OFA nozzle location along furnace height. On the optimized operating conditions of air staging, NO_x reduction efficiency can attain 47%. Although air staging can effectively reduce NO_x emission, the increase of unburned carbon in fly ash should be noticed.     

Coal characterisation for NOx prediction in air-staged combustion of pulverised coals

A series of world-traded coal samples has been tested using the Imperial College high temperature wire mesh apparatus (HTWM) in order to assess the relationship between high temperature (1600°C) char nitrogen content and NO_x formation in Hemweg Power Station (in the Netherlands) using deep furnace air staging. A linear relationship between high temperature char nitrogen and NO_x formation has been confirmed. These results suggest that high temperature char N content is the main factor limiting NO_x emissions with deep air-staged combustion.Char N and (hence apparently deep air-staged NO_x) can be predicted with an accuracy of approximately ±20% for most coals from the coal proximate and ultimate analysis—but this might not be sufficient for stations operating close to their emission limits. Measuring high temperature char N directly reduces the likely uncertainty in deep air-staged NO_x emissions for coals (and most blends) to approximately ±10%. Its use should be considered on a routine basis for coal selection on plants employing this technology.     

Characterisation of biomass and coal co-firing on a 3 MWth Combustion Test Facility using flame imaging and gas/ash sampling techniques

Co-firing of biomass with pulverised coal at existing coal power stations remains a practical option available to power plant operators and is being widely adopted as one of the main technologies for reducing greenhouse gas emissions. However, there is a range of technological problems that are not well understood. This paper presents experimental investigations into the co-firing of pulverised coal directly co-milled with 5–20% biomass on a 3 MWth Combustion Test Facility. A number of combustion parameters, including flame temperature and oscillation frequency and particle size distribution, were measured under a range of co-firing conditions. The gas species within the flame and fly ash in flue gas were also sampled and analysed. The experimental data collected are used to study the impact of biomass additions to pulverised coal on the combustion characteristics of the co-firing process. The relationships between the flame characteristics, gas species and ash deposition of the furnace are investigated. The results suggest that, due to the varying physical and chemical properties of the biomass fuels, the biomass additions have impact on the combustion characteristics in a very complicated way. It has been found that the biomass addition to coal would improve the combustion efficiency because of the lower CO concentrations and higher char burnout level in co-firing. In addition, NO_x emission has been found closely linked to the flame stability, and SO_x emission reduced in general for all co-firing cases.     

Measurement and prediction of the emission of pollutants from the combustion of coal and biomass in a fixed bed furnace

The effect of co-combustion of coal and biomass has been studied for a fixed bed appliance originally designed for coal and in widespread use in many parts of the world especially Eastern Europe. Organic, inorganic and gaseous emissions have been measured. Organic compounds have been determined for a range of fuel combinations. These include polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons PAH, alkyl PAH, a range of oxygenated compounds (including phenols, aldehydes and ketones, oxygenated polycyclic aromatic compounds (O-PAC) and dioxins), polycyclic aromatic sulphur hydrocarbons (PASH), nitrogenated polycyclic aromatic compounds (N-PAC) and common volatile organic compounds (VOC). Inorganic species include trace heavy metals, as well as the gases, CO, CO₂, SO_x and NO_x. The concentration of the trace metals in the ash and fly ash have been compared to equilibrium calculations of the emission profiles during co-combustion.     

Optimisation of NOx reduction in advanced coal reburning systems and the effect of coal type

The advanced reburning process for NO_x emission control was studied in a down-fired 20 kW combustor by evaluating the performance of 15 pulverised coals as reburning fuels. The proximate volatile matter contents of the coals selected ranged from around 4 to 40 wt% (as received) with elemental nitrogen contents from around 0.6 to 2.0 wt%. The effects of reburn fuel fraction, reburning zone residence time, ammonia agent injection delay time (relative to the reburn fuel and burnout air injection points) and the nitrogen stoichiometric ratio are reported in detail and the optimum configurations for advanced reburning, established as a function of operating condition and coal type. The experimental results show that advanced reburning can reduce NO_x emissions up to 85%. The maximum benefits of advanced reburning over conventional reburning were observed at the lower reburn fuel fractions (around 10%). The results demonstrate that under advanced reburning conditions equivalent or higher levels of NO_x reduction can be achieved while operating the reburn zone closer to stoichiometric conditions compared with conventional reburning operating at high reburn fuel fractions (20-25%). Thus the practical problems associated with fuel-rich staged operation can be reduced. The effect of coal properties on the advanced reburning performance was also investigated. As with conventional reburning, the fuel nitrogen content of the coal used was found to have little influence on the NO_x reduction efficiency except at the highest reburn fuel fractions. There was, however, a strong correlation between the effectiveness of advanced reburning and the volatile content of the reburning fuels, which not only depended on the reburn fuel fraction, but also the mode (rich or lean) of advanced reburning operation. These parameters are mapped out experimentally to enable the best operating mode to be selected for advanced reburning as a function of the reburning fuel fraction and volatile content.