A solid modeler based ball-end milling process simulation

A system for geometric and physical simulation of the ball-end milling process using solid modeling is presented in this paper. A commercially available geometric engine is used to represent the cutting edge, cutter and updated part. The ball-end mill cutter modeled in this study is an insert type ball-end mill and the cutting edge is generated by intersecting an inclined plane with the cutter ball nose. The contact face between cutter and updated part is determined from the solid model of the updated part and cutter solid model. To determine cutting edge engagement for each tool rotational step, the intersections between the cutting edge with boundary of the contact face are determined. The engaged portion of the cutting edge for each tool rotational step is divided into small differential oblique cutting edge segments. Friction, shear angles and shear stresses are identified from orthogonal cutting data base available in the open literature. For each tool rotational position, the cutting force components are calculated by summing up the differential cutting forces. The instantaneous dynamic chip thickness is computed by summing up the rigid chip thickness, the tool deflection and the undulations left from the previous tooth, and then the dynamic cutting forces are obtained. For calculating the ploughing forces, Wu's model is extended to the ball-end milling process [21]. The total forces, including the cutting and ploughing forces, are applied to the structural vibratory model of the system and the dynamic deflections at the tool tip are predicted. The developed system is verified experimentally for various up-hill and down-hill angles.     

New mathematical method for the determination of cutter runout parameters in flat-end milling

The cutting force prediction is essential to optimize the process parameters of machining such as feed rate optimization, etc. Due to the significant influences of the runout effect on cutting force variation in milling process, it is necessary to incorporate the cutter runout parameters into the prediction model of cutting forces. However, the determination of cutter runout parameters is still a challenge task until now. In this paper, cutting process geometry models, such as uncut chip thickness and pitch angle, are established based on the true trajectory of the cutting edge considering the cutter runout effect. A new algorithm is then presented to compute the cutter runout parameters for flat-end mill utilizing the sampled data of cutting forces and derived process geometry parameters. Further, three-axis and five-axis milling experiments were conducted on a machining centre, and resulting cutting forces were sampled by a three-component dynamometer. After computing the corresponding cutter runout parameters, cutter forces are simulated embracing the cutter runout parameters obtained from the proposed algorithm. The predicted cutting forces show good agreements with the sampled data both in magnitude and shape, which validates the feasibility and effectivity of the proposed new algorithm of determining cutter runout parameters and the new way to accurately predict cutting forces. The proposed method for computing the cutter runout parameters provides the significant references for the cutting force prediction in the cutting process.     

A numerical study of the effects of cutter runout on milling process geometry based on true tooth trajectory

Cutter runout is a common phenomenon affecting the cutting performances in milling operations. To date, most of the milling process models considering cutter runout were established based on the circular tooth path approximation, which brought errors into the runout estimation. In this paper, a new approach is presented for modelling the milling process geometry with cutter runout based on the true tooth trajectory of cutter in milling. The mathematical relationship between the trajectories generated by successive cutter teeth with runout is analysed. The milling process geometrical parameters, including the instantaneous undeformed chip thickness, the entry and exit angles of a cutting tooth, and the ideal peripheral machined workpiece surface roughness, are modelled according to the true tooth trajectories. Numerical method is used to solve the derived transcendental equations. A simulation study of the effects of cutter runout on milling process geometry is conducted using the models. It was found that the change of cutter radius for a tooth relative to its preceding one is the most important factor in evaluating the effects of cutter runout.     

Cutting force model considering tool edge geometry for micro end milling process

The analysis of the cutting force in micro end milling plays an important role in characterizing the cutting process, as the tool wear and surface texture depend on the cutting forces. Because the depth of cut is larger than the tool edge radius in conventional cutting, the effect of the tool edge radius can be ignored. However, in micro cutting, this radius has an influence on the cutting mechanism. In this study, an analytical cutting force model for micro end milling is proposed for predicting the cutting forces. The cutting force model, which considers the edge radius of the micro end mill, is simulated. The validity is investigated through the newly developed tool dynamometer for the micro end milling process. The predicted cutting forces were consistent with the experimental results.     

Cutting force prediction for ball nose milling of inclined surface

Ball nose milling of complex surfaces is common in the die/mould and aerospace industries. A significant influential factor in complex surface machining by ball nose milling for part accuracy and tool life is the cutting force. There has been little research on cutting force model for ball nose milling on inclined planes. Using such a model ,and by considering the inclination of the tangential plane at the point of contact of the ball nose model, it is possible to predict the cutting force at the particular cutting contact point of the ball nose cutter on a sculptured surface. Hence, this paper presents a cutting force model for ball nose milling on inclined planes for given cutting conditions assuming a fresh or sharp cutter. The development of the cutting force model involves the determination of two associated coefficients: cutting and edge coefficients for a given tool and workpiece combination. A method is proposed for the determination of the coefficients using the inclined plane milling data. The geometry for chip thickness is considered based on inclined surface machining with overlapping of previous pass. The average and maximum cutting forces are considered. These two forces have been observed to be more dominating force-based parameters or features with high correlation with tool wear. The developed cutting force model is verified for various cutting conditions.     

An improved cutting force model for micro milling considering machining dynamics

Micro milling, as a versatile micro machining process, is kinematically similar to conventional milling; however, it is significantly different from conventional milling with respect to chip formation mechanisms and uncut chip thickness modelling, due to the comparable size of the edge radius to the chip thickness, and the small per-tooth feeding. Considering tool runout and dynamic displacement between the tool and the workpiece, the contour of the workpiece left by previous tool paths is typically in a wavy form, and the wavy surface provides a feedback mechanism to cutting force generation because the instantaneous uncut chip thickness changes with both the vibration during the current tool path and the surface left by the previous tool paths. In this study, a more accurate uncut chip thickness model was established including the precise trochoidal trajectory of the cutting edge, tool runout and dynamic modulation caused by the machine tool system vibration. The dynamic regenerative effect is taken into account by considering the influence of all the previous cutting trajectories using numerical iteration; thus, the multiple time delays (MTD) are considered in this model. It is found that transient separation of the tool-workpiece occurring at a low feed per tooth, caused by MTD and the existing cutting force models, is no longer applicable when transient tool-workpiece separation occurs. Based on the proposed uncut chip thickness model, an improved cutting force model of micro milling is developed by full consideration of the ploughing effect and elastic recovery of the workpiece material. The proposed cutting force model is verified by micro end milling experiments, and the results show that the proposed model is capable of producing more accurate cutting force prediction than other existing models, particularly at small feed per tooth.     

Mechanistic modelling of the milling process using complex tool geometry

Mechanistic models of the milling process must calculate the chip geometry and the cutter edge contact length in order to predict milling forces accurately. This task becomes increasingly difficult for the machining of three dimensional parts using complex tool geometry, such as bull nose cutters. In this paper, a mechanistic model of the milling process based on an adaptive and local depth buffer of the computer graphics card is compared to a traditional simulation method. Results are compared using a 3-axis wedge shaped cut – a tool path with a known chip geometry – in order to accommodate the traditional method. Effects of cutter nose radius on the cutting and edge forces are considered. It is verified that there is little difference (1.4% at most) in the predicted force values of the two methods, thereby validating the adaptive depth buffer approach. The numerical simulations are also verified using experimental cutting tests of aluminium, and found to agree closely (within 12%).     

A new method for cutting force prediction in peripheral milling of complex curved surface

The instantaneous uncut chip thickness and entry/exit angle of tool/workpiece engagement vary with tool path, workpiece geometry and cutting parameters in peripheral milling of complex curved surface, leading to the strong time-varying characteristic for instantaneous cutting forces. A new method for cutting force prediction in peripheral milling of complex curved surface is proposed in this paper. Considering the tool path, cutter runout, tool type(constant/nonconstant pitch cutter) and tool actual motion, a representation model of instantaneous uncut chip thickness and entry/exit angle of tool/ workpiece engagement is established firstly, which can reach better accuracy than the traditional models. Then, an approach for identifying of cutter runout parameters and calibrating of specific cutting force coefficients is presented. Finally, peripheral milling experiments are carried out with two types of tool, and the results indicate that the predicted cutting forces are highly consistent with the experimental values in the aspect of variation tendency and amplitude.     

Cutter workpiece engagement region and surface topography prediction in five-axis ball-end milling

Based on the machining tool path and the true trajectory equation of the cutting edge relative to the workpiece, the engagement region between the cutter and workpiece is analyzed and a new model is developed for the numerical simulation of the machined surface topography in a multiaxis ball-end milling process. The influence of machining parameters such as the feed per tooth, the radial depth of cut, the angle orientation tool, the cutter runout, and the tool deflection upon the topography are taken into account in the model. Based on the cutter workpiece engagement, the cutting force model is established. The tool deflections are extracted and used in the surface topography model for simulation. The predicted force profiles were compared to the measured ones. A reasonable agreement between the experimental and the predicted results was found.     

A force-model-based approach to estimating cutter axis offset in ball end milling

Cutter runout due to cutter axis offset is quite common in a milling process, yet it is difficult to directly measure the runout geometry of a ball end cutter during the cutting process. This paper presents an analytical method for the estimation of cutter radial offset via forces in ball end milling. Closed form expression for the total milling force in the presence of cutter offset is first obtained. Fourier series coefficients for the offset related force component are shown to be expressed explicitly in terms of the offset geometry and serve as the basis for the identification of the offset geometry from the measured cutting forces. The offset geometry including its magnitude and the phase angle are directly calculated from the measured force component at the spindle frequency through two algebraic expressions. The identification method is finally validated by milling experiments.     

Study on the influence of meso-geometrical features on milling force in precision machining of titanium alloy

Titanium Alloy is a typical material difficult to be processed for its characteristics of low thermal conductivity, and high chemical activity, which result in tool wear and the poor quality of the machined surface. In order to solve the problems existing in the processing of Titanium Alloy, considering the tool edge, micro-texture is implanted into the cemented carbide ball end milling cutter. The article analyzes the influence law of micro-texture and the tool edge radius of ball end milling cutter on mechanical properties of Titanium Alloy, establishes and verifies a mechanical predictive model of milling Titanium Alloy with ball end milling cutter surface based on the effect of micro-texture and the tool edge. Finally, with regard to the minimum cutting force as the target, the article uses genetic algorithm to optimize meso-geometrical features parameters of the cemented carbide ball end milling cutter. The article also provides the foundation for efficient and high-quality processing of Titanium Alloy.     

螺旋棒铣刀铣削力建模与仿真

在对螺旋棒铣刀铣削力建模中考虑了切削厚度变化对铣削力影响的指数关系、铣刀偏心对实际切削厚度、切入与切出角、铣削力波动的影响,并提出采用实测各刀齿铣削最大值比求解铣刀偏心和识别铣削力系数的方法。在考虑铣刀偏心因素的情况下仿真与实测的铣削力达到非常好的一致性。提出的铣削力仿真方法充分反映了铣削力的实际状态,提高了铣削力仿真精度。     

Extracting cutting constants via harmonic force components for a general helical end mill

Mechanistic cutting constants serve well in predicting milling forces, monitoring the milling process as well as in helping to understand the mechanistic phenomena of a machining process for a unique pair of workpiece and cutter materials under various types of cutting edge geometry. This paper presents a unified approach in identifying the six shearing and ploughing cutting constants for a general helical end mill from the dynamic components of the measured milling forces in a single cutting test. The identification model is first presented assuming the milling force is measured with a known phase angle of the cutter spindle. When the phase angle of the cutter rotation is not available, as is the case for most milling machines, it is shown that the true phase angle can be identified through the theoretical phase relationship between the different harmonic components of the milling forces measured with an arbitrary phase angle. The numerical simulation and the experimental results for ball and cylindrical end mills are presented to demonstrate and validate the identification methods.     

Envelope surface formed by cutting edge under runout error in five-axis flank milling

This paper investigates the analytical envelope surface model formed by specially designed cutting edge under cutter runout error, including axis offset error and tilt error, in five-axis flank milling. This model, which is independent of the machine tool type, is determined by the tangency condition in envelope theory. First, the cutter runout is defined by four parameters, namely offset distance, offset direction angle, locating angle, and tilt angle. Then, the cutting edge represented by cubic B-spline curve is used as the generator of cutter rotation surface to formulate the closed-form envelope surface model. In particular, the runout error and feedrate are both integrated into the model. In addition, we study special cases of the analytical model and the runout effect on envelope surface. Finally, computer example validates the feasibility of the proposed model with runout. We find that envelope surface formed by cutter edge is different from each other at the existence of runout, and envelope surface dedicated to final machined surface is generated by the composition of some segments of cutter edges. The results can be applied to tool path optimization in five-axis flank milling and NC simulation with cutter runout.     

Development and experimental validation of a mechanistic model of cutting forces in micro- ball end milling of full slots

In the present work, a mechanistic model of cutting forces is developed with a novel approach to arrive at the cutting edge geometry as well as the cutting mechanics. The geometry of cutting elements derived and verified using a virtual tool generated in CAD environment is considered. The cutting and edge force coefficients at every discrete point on the cutting edge of micro-ball end mill are established in a novel way from the basic metal cutting principles and fundamental properties of materials, considering edge radius and material strengthening effects. Further, measured edge radius is used in the model. Full slot micro-ball end milling experiments are conducted on a high-precision high-speed machining center using a 0.4 mm diameter tungsten carbide tool and cutting forces are measured using a high-sensitive piezo-electric dynamometer. It is established that the predicted as well as experimental cutting forces are higher at very low uncut chip thickness in comparison with the cutting edge radius in micro-ball end milling also. Amplitudes of cutting forces and instantaneous values with incremental rotation of the tool are compared with predicted values over two revolutions for validation of proposed model.     

Mechanistic modeling of cutting forces in micro-end-milling considering tool run out,minimum chip thickness and tooth overlapping effects

This work proposed an improved mechanistic model for prediction of cutting forces in micro-milling process. The combined influences of tool run out, trochoidal trajectory of the tool center, overlapping of tooth, edge radius and minimum chip thickness are incorporated in this model to realize the exact cutting phenomenon. Moreover, an improved undeformed chip thickness algorithm has been presented by considering tool run out, minimum chip thickness and trajectory of all passing teeth for one complete revolution of the tool instead of only the current tooth trajectory. For estimation of tool run out, a model based on the geometry of the two fluted end mill cutter has been developed. Effects of trochoidal trajectory of the tool center and tool run out are found to be significant as each tooth has a different chip load. Further, the effect of minimum chip thickness is found to be significant at lower feed value. The proposed model has been validated by micro-milling experiments on Ti6Al4V-titanium alloys using uncoated flat end mill cutter. The predicted cutting forces were found to be in good agreement with the experimental cutting forces in both feed and cross feed directions.     

Dynamic Force Modelling for a Ball-End Milling Cutter Based on the Merchant Oblique Cutting Theory

A new dynamic force model for a ball-end milling cutter is presented in this paper. Based on the principle of the power remaining constant in cuts, the Merchant oblique cutting theory has been successfully used for the differential cutting edge segment of a ball-end milling cutter. A concise method for characterising the relationship of the complex geometry of a ball-end milling cutter and the milling process variables is determined, so that the force coefficients can be decomposed. The geometric property of a ball-end milling cutter and the dynamics of the milling process are integrated into the general model to eliminate the need for the experimental calibration of each cutter geometry and milling process variable. The milling experiments prove that this model can predict accurately the cutting forces in three Cartesian directions.     

径向跳动对球面铣刀切削力的影响研究

研究了径向跳动对刀齿的实际切削半径、切屑形状以及切屑厚度的影响机理。研究了各刀齿沿刀刃螺旋线的切削微元实际切削半径的数学表示和变化规律,实际切削半径的变化改变了刀齿的切削路径,使各刀齿上切屑形状分布不均匀。建立了三维切削下切屑厚度的数学表示,提出了递延累加切屑厚度计算算法。实验验证表明,计算的切削力与测量结果能很好地吻合,瞬时切削力、切削力峰值、平均切削力的预测精度达到85%以上。     

An Improved Method for the Determination of 3D Cutting Force Coefficients and Runout Parameters in End Milling

A simple improved method is suggested for determining constant cutting force coefficients, irrespective of the cutting condition and cutter rotation angle. This can be achieved through the combination of experimentally deternimed cutting forces with those from simulation, performed by a mechanistic cutting force model and a geometric uncut chip thickness model. Additionally, this study presents an approach that estimates runout-related parameters, and the runout offset and its location angle, using only one measurement of cutting force. This method of estimating 3D end milling force coefficients was experimentally verified for a wide range of cutting conditions, and gave significantly better predictions of cutting forces than any other methods. The estimated value of the runout offset also agreed well with the measured value.     

Improved dynamic cutting force model in ball-end milling. Part I: theoretical modelling and experimental calibration

An accurate cutting force model of ball-end milling is essential for precision prediction and compensation of tool deflection that dominantly determines the dimensional accuracy of the machined surface. This paper presents an improved theoretical dynamic cutting force model for ball-end milling. The three-dimensional instantaneous cutting forces acting on a single flute of a helical ball-end mill are integrated from the differential cutting force components on sliced elements of the flute along the cutter-axis direction. The size effect of undeformed chip thickness and the influence of the effective rake angle are considered in the formulation of the differential cutting forces based on the theory of oblique cutting. A set of half immersion slot milling tests is performed with a one-tooth solid carbide helical ball-end mill for the calibration of the cutting force coefficients. The recorded dynamic cutting forces are averaged to fit the theoretical model and yield the cutting force coefficients. The measured and simulated dynamic cutting forces are compared using the experimental calibrated cutting force coefficients, and there is a reasonable agreement. A further experimental verification of the dynamic cutting force model will be presented in a follow-up paper.