Functional characterisation of mechanical joints to facilitate its selection during the design of open architecture products

New trends in product design require the use of modularity as key feature aimed to improve functional performance and the generation of open architecture products. For mechanical systems, one of the challenges during early design stages of these products involves the proper selection of joining methods among their constructive components. A robust joint selection process must consider product requirements, life cycle analysis and eventual procedures for assembly and disassembly. However, the general approach towards a Design-for-Assembly (DFA)/Design-for-Disassembly (DFD) only considers design, manufacturing and in some cases final disposal stage. Additionally, most of the works found in the literature are merely focused on assembly operations, disregarding economic and environmental benefits from optimising disassembly complexity. Herein, a functional characterisation of mechanical joint methods for the assembly and disassembly activities that take place throughout the product life cycle is proposed, focusing on open architecture products. Additionally, a classification of joining methods, a joint complexity metric valuation and a selection process are proposed for the conceptual design stage. The approach integrates both DFA and DFD principles in a formal methodology. The proposed selection roadmap can be implemented to increase product sustainability positively regarding resources optimisation, operational time and costs in reuse, remanufacturing and recycling tasks.     

An optimisation support for the design of hybrid production lines including assembly and disassembly tasks

The optimisation problems related to the assignment of tasks to workstations in assembly and disassembly lines have been largely discussed in the literature. They are known, respectively, as Assembly Line Balancing and Disassembly Line Balancing Problems. In this study, both types of task performed on the identical product are integrated in a common hybrid production system. Therefore, the logistic process is simplified and disassembly tasks can supply easier the assembly tasks with the required components. The considered production system has the layout of two parallel lines with common workstations. The product flow is conventional in the assembly line and reverse in the disassembly line. The paper provides a new mathematical model for designing such a hybrid system and an approximate approach based on ant colony optimisation for solving large-scale instances. The solution method is tested in a case study. The obtained results are compared with the solution provided by the design of two independent lines. The analysis of the results highlights the potential benefits of the hybrid production system.     

Integrated assembly and disassembly sequence planning using a GA approach

In a product life cycle, an assembly sequence is required to produce a new product at the start, whereas a disassembly sequence is needed at the end. In typical assembly and disassembly sequence planning approaches, the two are performed as two independent tasks. In this way, a good assembly sequence may contradict the cost considerations in the disassembly sequence, and vice versa. In this research, an integrated assembly and disassembly sequence planning model is presented. First, an assembly precedence graph (APG) and a disassembly precedence graph (DPG) are modelled. The two graphs are transformed into an assembly precedence matrix (APM) and a disassembly precedence matrix (DPM). Second, a two-loop genetic algorithm (GA) method is applied to generate and evaluate the solutions. The outer loop of the GA method performs assembly sequence planning. In the inner loop, the reverse order of the assembly sequence solution is used as the initial solution for disassembly sequence planning. A cost objective by integrating the assembly costs and disassembly costs is formulated as the fitness function. The test results show that the developed method using the GA approach is suitable and efficient for the integrated assembly and disassembly sequence planning. Example products are demonstrated and discussed.     

Product platforms design,selection and customisation in high-variety manufacturing

Product platforms represent an effective strategy implemented by manufacturers to cope with dynamic market demands, decrease lead-time and delay products differentiation. A decision support system (DSS) for product platforms design and selection in high-variety manufacturing is presented. It applies median-joining phylogenetic networks (MJPN) for the platforms design and phylogenetic tree decomposition for platforms selection by determining the product family phylogenetic network and defines the platforms at various levels of assembly corresponding to different trade-offs between number of platforms (variety) and number of assembly/disassembly tasks (customisation effort). Product platforms are reconfigured and customised to derive final product variants. The phylogenetic tree is decomposed in multiple levels, from the native platforms to the final variants. New Platforms Reconfiguration Index (PRI) and Platforms Customisation Index (PCI) were developed as metrics to evaluate the platforms customisation effort. A case study of a large family of plastic valves is used to demonstrate the DSS application. It shows reduction of 60% in platforms variety and increases in platform customisation assembly/disassembly tasks by only 20% leading to significant production and inventory efficiencies and cost savings. This methodology supports companies in the design and selection of best product platforms for high-variety to reduce cost and delivery time.     

Operator assignment with cell loading and product sequencing in labour-intensive assembly cells – a case study of a bicycle assembly company

This research deals with an operator assignment problem in which cell loading and product sequencing are taken into account in labour-intensive assembly cells. In each cell the number of assembly tasks is more than the number of operators, so multi-assembly tasks are assigned to each operator. Because the assembly procedure and time required for each assembly task are quite different for different products, some tasks will be transferred when the product changes. Reducing the number of task transfers can smooth the process of product change. A four-phase methodology is proposed to minimise the total manpower required and task transfers at the same time. The four phases are manpower configuration design, calculating the number of task transfers, manpower requirement minimization and cell loading and product sequencing optimization. A case study from a bicycle assembly company is introduced. For comparison, two methodologies are applied. The results show that the proposed four phase methodology can provided the solution with fewer task transfers based on the same total manpower requirement. However, when the number of products increases, the computation time of the proposed four-phase methodology increases rapidly.     

Proactive assessment of basic complexity in manual assembly: development of a tool to predict and control operator-induced quality errors

A major challenge for manufacturing companies today is to manage a huge amount of product variants and build options at the same time in manufacturing engineering and in production. The overall complexity and risk of quality errors in manual assembly will increase placing high demands on the operators who must manage many different tasks in current production. Therefore, methods for decreasing and controlling assembly complexity are urgent because managing complex product and installation conditions will result in distinct competitive advantages. The objective of this paper is to present a method for predictive assessment of basic manual assembly complexity and explain how included complexity criteria were arrived at. The verified method includes 16 high complexity and 16 low complexity criteria to aid designers in preventing costly errors during assembly and create good basic assembly conditions in early design phases of new manufacturing concepts.     

Profit-oriented disassembly-line balancing

As product and material recovery has gained importance, disassembly volumes have increased, justifying construction of disassembly lines similar to assembly lines. Recent research on disassembly lines has focused on complete disassembly. Unlike assembly, the current industry practice involves partial disassembly with profit-maximization or cost-minimization objectives. Another difference between assembly and disassembly is that disassembly involves additional precedence relations among tasks due to processing alternatives or physical restrictions. In this study, we define and solve the profit-oriented partial disassembly-line balancing problem. We first characterize different types of precedence relations in disassembly and propose a new representation scheme that encompasses all these types. We then develop the first mixed integer programming formulation for the partial disassembly-line balancing problem, which simultaneously determines (1) the parts whose demand is to be fulfilled to generate revenue, (2) the tasks that will release the selected parts under task and station costs, (3) the number of stations that will be opened, (4) the cycle time, and (5) the balance of the disassembly line, i.e. the feasible assignment of selected tasks to stations such that various types of precedence relations are satisfied. We propose a lower- and upper-bounding scheme based on linear programming relaxation of the formulation. Computational results show that our approach provides near optimal solutions for small problems and is capable of solving larger problems with up to 320 disassembly tasks in reasonable time.     

Assembly/disassembly task planning and simulation using expert Petri nets

Automatic assembly/disassembly planning is recognized as an important tool for reducing the manufacturing costs in concurrent product and process development. This paper developed a knowledge-based expert Petri net model by incorporating expert system techniques in artificial intelligence into ordinary Petri nets for an analytical framework of understanding, representing and reasoning the assembly/disassembly tasks. Substantial extensions have been made to ordinary Petri nets by adding control places, time constraints, and place and transition knowledge annotations. The proposed expert Petri net model can be considered as the hybrid of expert systems and ordinary Petri nets. Through these extensions, the capacities of modelling and representation of ordinary Petri net models are largely enhanced, and thus the expert Petri net models are more powerful than ordinary Petri nets. Such intelligent Petri net models can combine the abilities of modelling, planning, and performance evaluation for assembly/disassembly tasks in an integrated and intuitive way, and can therefore be applied to either linear/non-linear, static/dynamic, or on-line/off-line assembly/disassembly tasks at both high and low levels. The developed assembly/disassembly planning system can generate the best strategies and plans for assembly/disassembly. The research findings are exemplified with a real assembly to show the effectiveness of the method.     

Dynamic disassembly planning for remanufacturing of multiple types of products

With the increased need for remanufacturing of end-of-life products, achieving economic efficiency in remanufacturing is urgently needed. The purpose of this study was to devise a cost-minimisation plan for disassembly and remanufacturing of end-of-life products returned by consumers. A returned end-of-life product is disassembled into remanufacturable parts, which are supposed to be used for new products after being remanufactured. Each end-of-life product is disassembled into parts at variable levels and through variable sequences as needed, taking into account not only disassembly but also manufacturing, remanufacturing, and holding inventory of remanufacturable parts. This study proposes a mixed integer linear programming (MILP) model for derivation of the optimal disassembly plan for each returned product, under deterministically known demand and return flows. For the purposes of an illustrative example, the proposed model was applied to the formulation of an optimal disassembly and remanufacturing plan of ‘fuser assembly’ of laser printers. The solution reveals that variable-level disassembly of products saves a significant remanufacturing cost compared with full disassembly.     

A Petri Net based approach to determine the disassembly strategy of a product

In order to protect the environment and regain value added to products, a process known as disassembly has come into the limelight. This process is to be applied to reuse abandoned goods and materials. Manufacturers are being forced to establish disassembly plants and to develop their products' designs so as to maintain the government's dictate to dispose off their products in an environmentally responsible manner. This research presents a cost-based heuristic analysis for a circuit board assembly. Various components of the product and their assembly relationships are represented by a Petri Net diagram. Firing the transitions of the disassembly Petri Net is integrated with cost-based indices to develop an effective disassembly strategy. The methodology discussed here simplifies the decisionmaking process involved in disassembly planning. A comprehensive disassembly process planning system is proposed here and is exemplified by a case study of circuit board assembly.     

Capacitated disassembly scheduling with random demand

This paper considers disassembly scheduling, which is the problem of determining the quantity and timing of the end-of-use/life products to be disassembled while satisfying the demand for their parts obtained from disassembling the products over a planning horizon. This paper focuses on the problem with stochastic demand of parts/modules, capacity restrictions on disassembly resources, and multiple product types with a two-level product structure. The two-level product structure implies that an end-of-use/life product is hierarchically decomposed into two levels where the first level corresponds to the parts/modules and the second level corresponds to the product. We formulate the problem as a stochastic inventory model and to solve the problem we propose a Lagrangian heuristic algorithm as well as an optimisation algorithm for the sub-problems obtained from Lagrangian decomposition. The test results on randomly generated problems show that the Lagrangian heuristic algorithm demonstrates good performance in terms of solution quality and time.     

Modelling and planning of the disassembly processes using an enhanced expert Petri net

A sound disassembly Petri net model for the effective planning of disassembly processes and tasks is outlined. Owing to the unmanageable complexity associated with modelling of the disassembly processes and tasks, it becomes essential to have a more powerful Petri net model developed by incorporating the concepts of expert system, knowledge representation techniques, etc. Disassembly task planning at high and low levels can easily be represented by proposed high- and low-level expert Petri net. An algorithmic approach is also suggested for evaluating the end-of-life values of a product. These values are used to determine an optimal disassembly sequence and it is incorporated in the expert disassembly Petri net. A proposed expert enhanced high-level coloured disassembly Petri net is empowered to express such details vividly. The application of the proposed expert enhanced high-level coloured disassembly Petri net model is demonstrated through the sample disassembly of a flashlight.     

Disassembly line in product recovery

There are several situations in a product recovery environment where products may be disassembled for economical and regulatory reasons. The disassembly line is perhaps the most suitable setting for disassembly of large products (consisting of numerous components) as well as small products received in large quantities. This paper discusses the importance of a disassembly line in product recovery. The objective of the disassembly line is to utilize the available resources as efficiently as possible while meeting the demand for recovered parts. However, there are many complicating matters that need to be considered to create an efficient disassembly line. Our primary goal is to discuss these issues and provide a better understanding of the complications and their effects on the disassembly line. We also demonstrate how some important factors in disassembly can be accommodated to balance a paced disassembly line by modifying the existing concept of assembly line balancing. An example is presented to illustrate the approach.     

维修拆装工艺规划系统的研究

结合装备维修活动中的拆卸与装配问题,明确了研发面向维修的拆装工艺规划系统的必要性.提出了一个拆装工艺规划系统的构架,论述了系统的主要功能模块、工作流程以及所采用的关键技术.实现了装配建模、拆装序列规划、拆装序列评估与优化,以及拆装作业仿真等关键功能.实践表明该原型系统的设计切实可行,具有良好的应用前景.     

Integrated approach for disassembly processes generation and recycling evaluation of an end-of-life product

An integrated approach for noble recycling is presented that puts forward the functional value of products and components. In a first step, the approach determines all feasible automatic disassembly sequences and in a second step all applicable recycling activities. This allows one to determine the most appropriate recycling process for an end-of-life product considering concurrent recycling techniques. The feasible automatic disassembly sequences are established by simulation in a virtual environment. The required generic disassembly product model, as well as the generic disassembly activity model, is presented by means of static and dynamic object-oriented diagrams. The recycling evaluation establishes an efficient solution responding to economic and ecological decision criteria. It is calculated applying a Goal-Programming approach transforming the multi-objective linear problem into a monocriteria linear program. The techno-economic decision model applied is Linear Activity Analysis. It allows one to integrate the generated disassembly processes based on single disassembly activities as well as other recycling techniques.     

A graph-based model for manufacturing complexity

This paper presents a graph-based model to measure the relative manufacturing complexity of and the manufacturing similarity of products in job shop manufacturing systems. This model depicts the impact of the complexity factors on the profit realisable from products based on their manufacturing process and required resources/skills. These resources deal with the process required for a component to reach assembly, the process of assembling the components to a whole product. This relative manufacturing complexity measure not only can support assembly and production cost estimation, but also can provide a guideline for creating a product with the most effective balance of manufacturing and assembly. Also, the results of this study can help improve budgeting and resource allocation, and the product life cycle cost estimation for future products. A numerical example is also presented to demonstrate the application of the proposed approach.     

Application of an evolutionary fuzzy system for the estimation of workforce deployment and cross-training in an assembly environment

Owing to the increased customer demands for make-to-order products and smaller product life-cycles, today assembly lines are designed to ensure a quick switch-over from one product model to another for companies' survival in market place. The complexity associated with the decisions pertaining to the type of training and number of workers and their exposition to the different tasks especially in the current era of customized production is a serious problem that the managers and the HRD gurus are facing in industry. This paper aims to determine the amount of cross-training and dynamic deployment policy caused by workforce flexibility for a make-to-order assembly. The aforementioned issues have been dealt with by adopting the concept of evolutionary fuzzy system because of the linguistic nature of the attributes associated with product variety and task complexity. A fuzzy system-based methodology is proposed to determine the amount of cross-training and dynamic deployment policy. The proposed methodology is tested on 10 sample products of varying complexities and the results obtained are in line with the conclusions drawn by previous researchers.     

Simultaneous design of a product family and its related supply chain using a Tabu Search algorithm

Product family design is currently facing a multitude of challenges, the main problem stemming from the diversity offered to consumers. To design a product family, designers have to define an efficient bill of materials which ensures product assembly within a predefined length of time in order to satisfy the synchronised delivery principle. In addition, the modules used to assemble the finished products have to be competitive in terms of logistical costs. The ability to anticipate the constraints associated with the production process and with transportation is consequently of great interest. In this paper, we focus on the process of identifying a set of modules to be used in the assembly of the finished product. The objective is to define the bill of materials for each product from the modules belonging to that set, and to assign these modules to distant facilities where they will be manufactured and then shipped to a nearby facility for final assembly within a specific time. We use a set partitioning formulations to represent the problem, and solve it by adapting a Tabu Search algorithm in which the assembly process and the supply chain design are considered at the same time.     

Developing assembly line layout for delayed product differentiation using phylogenetic networks

Effective formation of product platforms helps adapt to product demand changes and decrease time-to-market and lead time. The product platform groups the core elements of product family members into a common module used to derive different product variants by combining it with different components. A new delayed product differentiation (DPD) platform network model, which applies median-joining phylogenetic networks (MJPN), is proposed. It is used for forming product platforms and determining the assembly line layout of modular product families. The MJPN is traditionally used for DNA sequences’ mapping, analysis, clustering and tracing evolutionary trends. The concept of assembly/disassembly modular platforms, whereby both assembly and disassembly of components are used to derive the final product variants from the platform, is utilised. The proposed model determines the required number and composition of a product platform and defines the DPD points. The developed dynamic assembly/disassembly platforms enhance routing and product mix flexibility due to having different platforms that can be used to produce the same product variant. A family of household kettles is used to demonstrate the application of the proposed model. A metric is presented for determining the effectiveness of a given platform in delaying the product differentiation, hence increasing the efficiency of mass customisation. The proposed metric, applied to the case study, demonstrated that the proposed platform formation model using MJPN is more capable of postponing the product differentiation point.