Inter-laboratory evaluation studies for establishment of notified ELISA methods for allergic substances (buckwheat)

Inter-laboratory evaluation studies were conducted for the ELISA methods for allergic substances (buckwheat). Extracts of snack, bun and udon spiked with buckwheat standard protein at a level of 5-20 ng/mL as sample solutions were analyzed in replicate at 10 laboratories. Coefficients of variation (CVs) of the ELISA methods using a Buckwheat Protein ELISA Kit (Buckwheat kit) and a FASTKIT Buckwheat ELISA kit (Buckwheat ELISA kit) were mostly below 10%. Mean recoveries of the buckwheat standard protein from the food extracts were over 40% in the two ELISA methods. Repeatability relative standard deviations of buckwheat standard protein in three food extracts were in the ranges of 6.8-78.5% and 5.0-33.9% for the Buckwheat kit and the Buckwheat ELISA kit, respectively. Reproducibility relative standard deviations of buckwheat standard protein in three food extracts were 11.9-69.5% and 16.5-34.1% for the Buckwheat kit and the Buckwheat ELISA kit, respectively. The detection limits of both ELISA methods were 1 ng/mL in sample solutions. These results suggest that the notified ELISA methods are reliable and reproducible for the inspection of buckwheat protein levels in extracts of snack, bun and udon.     

Inter-laboratory evaluation studies for development of notified ELISA methods for allergic substances (wheat)

Extracts of sausage, sauce, pasta sauce, fish paste and cereal spiked with wheat standard protein at a level of 5-20 ng/mL as sample solutions were analyzed in replicate in 10 laboratories. Coefficients of variation (CVs) of both ELISA methods using a Wheat Protein ELISA Kit (Gliadin kit) and a FASTKIT Wheat ELISA Kit (Wheat ELISA kit) were mostly below 10%. Mean recoveries of the wheat standard protein from the food extracts were over 40% in the two ELISA methods except those from cereal extract determined using the Wheat ELISA kit. Repeatability relative standard deviations of wheat standard protein in the five food extracts were in the ranges of 16-26.9% and 3.7-36.2% for the Gliadin kit and the Wheat ELISA kit, respectively. Reproducibility relative standard deviations of wheat standard protein in the five food extracts were 21.6-38.5%, 29.7-53.8% for the Gliadin kit and the Wheat ELISA kit, respectively. The recoveries of wheat standard protein from the cereal extract were improved by the increasing the amount of antibody coated on the plate in the Wheat ELISA kit. The detection limits of both ELISA methods were 1 ng/mL in sample solutions. These results suggested that the notified ELISA methods are reliable and reproducible for the inspection of wheat protein levels in extracts of sausage, sauce, pasta sauce, fish paste and cereal.     

Inter-laboratory evaluation studies for development of notified ELISA methods for allergic substances (milk)

Extracts of sausage, sauce, cookie, cereal and pasta sauce spiked with milk standard protein at a level of 5-20 ng/mL as sample solutions were analyzed in replicate in 10 laboratories. Coefficients of variation (CVs) of the three ELISA methods using a Milk Protein Casein ELISA Kit (Casein kit), a Milk Protein Beta-Lactoglobulin ELISA Kit (Beta-Lactoglobulin kit) and a FASTKIT Milk ELISA Kit (Milk ELISA kit) were mostly below 10%. Mean recoveries of the milk standard protein from the food extracts were over 40% in the three ELISA methods with a few excertions. The recoveries of milk standard protein from the sauce extract in Casein kit were improved by adjusting the extract to neutrality before the Casein kit assay. The recoveries of milk standard protein from cookie, cereal and pasta sauce were improved by the increasing the amount of antibody coated in the Milk ELISA kit. The detection limits of all the ELISA methods were 1 ng/mL in sample solutions. These results suggested that the notified ELISA methods are reliable and reproducible for the inspection of milk protein levels in extracts of sausage, sauce, cookie, cereal and pasta sauce.     

Inter-laboratory evaluation studies for establishment of notified ELISA methods for allergic substances (peanuts)

Inter-laboratory evaluation studies were conducted for ELISA methods for allergic substances (peanuts). Extracts of biscuit, sauce, chocolate and butter spiked with peanut standard protein at a level of 5-20 ng/mL as sample solutions were analyzed in replicate in 10 laboratories. Coefficients of variation (CVs) of the ELISA methods using a Peanut Protein ELISA Kit (Peanut kit) and a FASTKIT Peanut ELISA kit (Peanut ELISA kit) were mostly below 10%. Mean recoveries of the peanut standard protein from the food extracts were over 40% in the two ELISA methods. Repeatability relative standard deviations of peanut standard protein in four food extracts were in the ranges of 15.2-49.7% and 3.0-28.3% for the Peanut kit and the Peanut ELISA kit, respectively. Reproducibility relative standard deviations of peanut standard protein in four food extracts were 23.5-44.4%, 9.6-28.4% for the Peanut kit and the Peanut ELISA kit, respectively. The detection limits of both ELISA methods were 2-2.5 ng/mL in sample solutions. These results suggested that the notified ELISA methods are reliable and reproducible for the inspection of peanut protein levels in extracts of biscuit, sauce, chocolate and butter.     

Example of examination of allergic substances (egg, milk) in commercial foods

Allergic substances (eggs, milk) in commercial foods were measured by means of the notified ELISA methods using FASTKIT ELISA kit (N kit) and "Tokuteigenzairyo sokutei kit" (M kit). Some samples were also analyzed with the notified western blot method using "Tokuteigenzairyo western blot kit". In the methods for detection of eggs, proteins of fish egg and chicken muscle were examined using the ELISA and Western blotting methods to check for cross-reaction. Sujiko was false positive with the M kit. Difficulties were also encountered in the notified ELISA and Western blotting methods with raw chicken. In foods labeled as containing eggs, it was difficult to detected in the heart-processed food using both notified methods. In the method for detection of milk, foods containing thickening polysaccharides, showed cross-reaction with the N kit. However, this cross-reaction was eliminated when an improved N kit was used. Foods labeled as containing milk did not present any difficulty.     

Comparison between old and new methods for detection of allergenic substances (egg and milk)

The old ELISA method for detection of allergenic substances (egg and milk) in Kanagawa prefecture from 2003 to 2007, employed before improvement of the food allergen labeling system, yielded detection rates of 20% for egg and 30% for milk. In 2005, after improvement of the labeling system, the detection rate using the new ELISA in solutions containing 1% SDS and 7% 2-mercaptoethanol increased by about 10% for egg, but decreased by half for milk. There were 4 positive samples (over 10 μg/g) for both egg and milk proteins, on account of contamination by ingredients at the manufacturing line and the lack of proper food labeling. In 2009, the contamination levels of egg and milk proteins in labeled commercial foods were low. In a comparison between the new and old methods with the same samples, both the new ELISA and Western-blot analyses showed an increase in the detection rate of egg protein. In relation to milk protein, the detection rates were decreased with the new ELISA, although the ELISA detection rate and consistency rates with Western-blot analysis were increased. On the other hand, in the case of a protein content below 5 μg/g, it was impossible to determine ovomucoid and casein by Western-blot analysis.     

Method-performance studies of notified analytical method for inabenfide

Method-performance studies were conducted for the notified revised analytical method of inabenfide in unpolished rice. Six laboratories analyzed unpolished rice spiked with 0.05 microgram/g of inabenfide in replicate. Mean recovery from rice was 85.0%. Repeatability relative standard deviation value was 4.2% and reproducibility relative standard deviation value was 8.1%. The detection limits were 0.002-0.01 microgram/g.     

Method-performance studies of notified analytical method for chinomethionat

Method-performance studies were conducted for the notified revised analytical method of chinomethionat in agricultural products by interlaboratory study. Six laboratories analyzed unpolished rice, cabbage, squash, lettuce and orange spiked with 0.1 microgram/g of chinomethionat in replicate. Mean values of recovery from the 5 crops ranged from 90.2 to 100.5%. Repeatability relative standard deviations ranged from 4.4 to 7.7% and reproducibility relative standard deviations ranged from 10.9 to 17.1%. The detection limits were 0.003-0.012 microgram/g.     

Method-performance studies of notified analytical method for clofentezine

Method-performance studies were conducted for the notified revised analytical method of clofentezine. Clofentezine spiked in azuki beans, apple, orange, banana, grape, tea powder and tea extract at the level of 0.2 microgram/g (2 micrograms/g for tea) was analyzed in replicate in 6 laboratories. Mean values of recovery from 7 crops ranged from 78.4 to 85.2%. Repeatability relative standard deviation values ranged from 2.2 to 4.6% and reproducibility standard deviation values ranged from 4.8 to 10.3%. The detection limits were 0.005-0.01 microgram/g. These results show the notified analytical method has good performance.     

Laboratory-performance study of the notified methods to detect genetically modified papaya (55-1)

To investigate important factors affecting the reliability of the analytical results, proficiency tests were attempted for the histochemical method (GUS method) and the qualitative PCR method (PCR method) to detect genetically modified papaya (55-1) in the Japanease official method. The test samples were distributed to twenty-three laboratories that participated in the study and were examined according to the protocol. All the data collected from participating laboratories were statistically analyzed. In the PCR method, one negative sample was detected as positive using detection primers in one laboratory, though the sample was negative when checked using confirmation primers. Contamination might have occurred in the step of the preparation of the PCR sample solution using detection primers. In the GUS method, all the test samples were identified as expected. Thus, all the laboratories reported correct results overall.     

Lysozyme in wine: A risk evaluation for consumers allergic to hen's egg

Lysozyme used in wine production could present a risk for consumers allergic to hen's egg. Thus, precautionary labeling of lysozyme on wines has been adopted within the European Community by updating Annex IIIa by Directive 2007/68/EC on November 27, 2007. Since no scientific data is known about the actual amounts and risks of lysozyme in wines, various in vitro efforts and skin prick tests were applied in this study to evaluate the presence of lysozyme in wines and the reactivity of those residues in allergic individuals and to fulfill the claim of updating Annex IIIa announced in Directive 2003/89/EC. Depending on the wine's color (red or white wine) and fining with bentonite, which is known as an important step to remove unstable proteins mainly from white wines, diverse results were obtained concerning the amounts of lysozyme in finished wines and their in vitro and in vivo reactivity in humans allergic to hen's egg.     

Method-performance studies of notified analytical method for fenbutatin oxide and cyhexatin

Method-performance studies were conducted for the notified revised analytical method of fenbutatin oxide (FBTO) and cyhexatin (CHT). FBTO and CHT spiked into rice, soybeans, spinach, orange, tea powder and tea extract at the level of 0.5 microgram/g for FBTO and 0.1 microgram/g for CHT were analyzed in replicate in 6 laboratories. Means recoveries of FBTO were 85.2-96.5% and those of CHT were 83.5-89.2% except from soybeans (46.5%). Repeatability relative standard deviation values of FBTO and CHT in each crop were in the ranges of 2.3-9.4% and 3.2-6.3%, respectively. Reproducibility relative standard deviations were 3.9-12.6% for FBTO and 8.3-12.9% for CHT. Detection limits were 0.015-0.05 microgram/g for FBTO and 0.005-0.02 microgram/g for CHT.     

Laboratory-performance study of the notified methods to detect genetically modified maize (CBH351) and potato (NewLeaf Plus and NewLeaf Y)

To investigate the key factors affecting the reliability of the analytical results, a laboratory-performance study was attempted for the notified methods to detect genetically modified (GM) maize (CBH351) and GM potato (NewLeaf Plus and NewLeaf Y). The test samples were designed as three pairs of blind duplicates, which included 0%, 0.1% and 1.0% GM maize (CBH351) or GM potato (NewLeaf Plus or NewLeaf Y). Fourteen laboratories participated in the study. The test samples were sent to the participating laboratories along with the protocol. The data were collected from all laboratories and statistically analyzed. For the 0% sample of the CBH351 maize, one laboratory reported a false-positive result. It was considered that contamination could have occurred via the common use of equipment or tools for the test. For the 0.1% samples of the NewLeaf Plus potato or NewLeaf Y potato, on the other hand, three laboratories reported false-negative results. It was presumed that these results were due to changes of the conditions of the electrophoresis and agarose-gel staining. The other laboratories reported appropriate results. It was considered that the method employed in this study was suitable for the assessment of laboratory performance.     

Inter-laboratory validation studies of biological method for determination of streptomycin in royal jelly

Inter-laboratory validation studies were conducted in 6 laboratories to validate the biological method for determination of streptomycin in royal jelly. Streptomycin spiked at the level of 0.2 and 1.0 ppm was analyzed. Mean recoveries were 89 and 96%, reproducibility relative standard deviations (RSD(R)) were 15.0 and 14.0%, HORRAT(R) values were 0.7 and 0.9. Samples containing residues at the levels of 0.25 and 0.80 ppm were analyzed. Mean recoveries were 113 and 99%, RSD(R) were 15.0 and 10.4%, and HORRAT(R) values were 0.8 and 0.6. The determination limit was 0.1 ppm. These results show that this method has good performance.     

Inter-laboratory validation studies of analytical method for determination of chloramphenicol in royal jelly

Inter-laboratory validation studies were conducted in 6 laboratories to validate the analytical method for determination of chloramphenicol in royal jelly. Chloramphenicol spiked at the levels of 0.1 and 0.5 ppm was analyzed. Mean recoveries were 89 and 89%, reproducibility relative standard deviations (RSD(R)) were 10.5 and 6.8%, HORRAT(R) values were 0.5 and 0.4. Samples containing residues at the levels of 0.25 and 0.80 ppm were analyzed. Mean recoveries were 89 and 84%, RSD(R) were 9.8 and 12.3%, and HORRAT(R) values were 0.5 and 0.7. The determination limit was 0.05 ppm. These results show that this method has good performance.     

Inter-laboratory validation studies of biological method for determination of tetracyclines in royal jelly

Inter-laboratory validation studies were conducted in 5 laboratories to validate the biological method for determination of tetracyclines in royal jelly. Oxytetracycline spiked at the levels of 0.2 and 1.0 ppm was analyzed. Mean recoveries were 88 and 90%, reproducibility relative standard deviations (RSD(R)) were 13.7 and 7.8%, and HORRAT(R) values were 0.7 and 0.5. Samples containing residues at the levels of 0.25 and 0.80 ppm were analyzed. Mean recoveries were 73 and 77%, RSD(R) were 12.6 and 10.5%, and HORRAT(R) values were 0.6 and 0.6. The determination limit was 0.1 ppm (oxytetracycline, tetracycline) and 0.02 ppm (chlortetracycline). These results show that this method has good performance.