Effect of electrical stunning or sticking without stunning on the microstructure of zousoon, a Chinese semi-dry pork product

The microstructure of muscle fibers from pigs killed following electrical stunning was compared to that from pigs killed after tying-resting and sticking. Examination of the muscle fibers demonstrated that electrical stunning resulted in contracture bands that caused tearing and fragmentation of the myofibers/myofibrils. On the other hand, tying-resting and sticking was not accompanied by microstructural fragmentation of the muscle fibers. Results indicate that electrical stunning of hogs causes fragmentation and breakage of the muscle fibers so that the meat is not suitable for production of Zousoon-a semi-dry shredded Chinese pork product and other similar items prepared from prerigor pig muscle. Heating and drying intensify the deteachment of the myofibrils from the muscle fiber bundles, which is caused mainly by electrical stunning or stimulation and improper conditioning following slaughter. The combined effects of electrical stunning and heating-drying appear to be responsible for the fragmentation of the muscle fibers/myofibrils and contribute to the unsuitability of prerigor muscle from electrically stunned pigs for use in the production of Zousoon. Since sticking of pigs without stunning does not meet humane slaughter standards, alternative animal welfare slaughter procedures should be examined from the standpoint of their usefulness in producing Zousoon.     

Preslaughter handling, stunning and slaughter

This paper reviews some of the recent developments in scientific research into preslaughter handling, transport, stunning and slaughter. Particular emphasis has been placed on work published within the past 2 years, and on the welfare and meat quality aspects of the subject.     

The effects of electrical stunning and percussive captive bolt stunning on meat quality of cattle processed by Turkish slaughter procedures

The effects of electrical and percussive captive bolt stunning both on initial and up to 14 days post mortem meat quality of Friesian young bulls were studied. The first group (NS; n=10) were slaughtered without stunning under Turkish slaughter procedure (these animals were slaughtered under conditions acceptable to the appropriate ethics committee) in a modern abattoir. In the second group (ES; n=10) animals were electrically stunned. In the third group (PS; n=10) animals were stunned with percussive captive bolt. Meat quality was assessed by examining muscle glycogen concentration, pH and WHC. Also cooking loss, texture parameters and consumer sensory properties were assessed at 24 h, 4, 7 and 14 days post mortem. Meat colour as L^*, a^*, b^*, C^*, h^* values were evaluated at 0, 48 h, 3, 5, 7, 9 and 14 days post mortem. Pre-slaughter handling affected muscle glycogen concentration (P<0.05). Animals in electrical and percussive captive bolt stunned groups had higher muscle glycogen concentrations compared to animals in the non-stunned group (P<0.05). Although pre-slaughter handling did not affect significantly pH_{24 h} and WHC, differences were significant for cooking loss, colour coordinates and texture parameters at some storage times. For all sensory attributes (odour, flavour, tenderness and overall acceptability) at all ageing periods (24 h, 4, 7 and 14 days) the percussive stunned (PS) group was significantly superior to the non-stunned (NS) group. The electrically-stunned (ES) group also tended to be superior to the NS group although not all differences were statistically significant. These results indicate that percussive captive bolt stunning of cattle improved meat quality compared with cattle electrically stunned using head only tongs and those non stunned under approved Turkish slaughter procedure.     

电击晕处理对肉鸽屠宰应激及宰后鸽肉品质的影响

为探究电击晕处理对肉鸽屠宰应激和宰后鸽肉品质的影响，本实验选取相同饲养条件下日龄为28 d的肉鸽，以击晕电压0 V为对照组，通过测定血液生化指标和肌肉理化指标，分析不同击晕电压(50～90 V)对肉鸽应激反应和宰后胴体品质的变化。结果表明：电击晕处理组肉鸽屠宰后血液中肌酸激酶(creatine kinase,CK)、促肾上腺皮质激素(adrenocorticotropic hormone,ACTH)和乳酸脱氢酶(lactate dehydrogenase,LDH)水平与对照组相比整体上均有一定程度的下降，在击晕电压60 V时总体达到最低水平；血液中皮质酮激素质量浓度随着击晕电压(0～90 V)的增大先降低后增加，在电压超过70 V时高于对照组，说明70 V以上的电击晕处理会增加肉鸽的屠宰应激水平；电击晕处理对宰后鸽胸肉的pH值影响不显著，与对照组相比，宰后24 h鸽胸肉亮度(L^*值)略有降低而红度(a^*值)增大，60～70 V电压处理组鸽肉的滴水损失率、蒸煮损失率及剪切力均保持在较低水平，此时鸽肉的保水性和嫩度相对较好。综上，60～70 V的...     

Head current during and blood splashes after electrical stunning in relation to characteristics of the pig's body

In order to evaluate electrical stunning in relation to the incidence of blood splashes, meat quality and carcass quality parameters, 2035 pigs, heterozygous for the halothane gene, were observed during slaughter at a commercial slaughterhouse. The head current during electrical stunning is significantly higher (P<0.01) in gilts with a lower live weight (P<0.0001) or cold carcass weight (P<0.0001) and a higher lean meat percentage (P<0.0001). Also the incidence of blood splashes in the ham is significantly higher in gilts (P<0.0001) with a higher lean meat percentage (P=0.0028; odds ratio=1.11), a lower live weight (P=0.003; odds ratio=0.98) and a lower type number (P=0.0074; odds ratio=0.64). For barrows, no significant parameters were revealed. These results suggest that the variability in incidence of blood splashes can be explained by the variability of current density depending both on sex and body characteristics. Thus, electrical stunning can be improved by providing an energy level, based on the body characteristics of the pig.     

Recent concerns about stunning and slaughter

This review summarises information that is relevant to concerns that have recently been expressed about stunning and slaughter. It is known that captive bolt stunning can result in brain material passing to the lungs via the jugular veins. If future studies show that BSE prions pass beyond the lungs to the edible carcass, there will be a move away from captive bolt stunning in large cattle towards electrical stunning. Greater use of electrical stunning in large cattle will increase the importance of blood splash in the beef industry. The theoretical causes of blood splash are reviewed to improve our understanding of this problem. In some situations it can be due to excessive venous pressure causing rupture of a capillary bed some distance from the source of the pressure rise, but it is not known whether this applies to electrical stunning. Gas stunning is replacing electrical stunning for poultry because it can reduce blood spots, which is a similar condition to blood splash. Several gas stunning methods are now being used, but it is not clear which of these is the most humane. Anoxic stunning leads to carcass convulsions and this causes more carcass damage. In fish, recent developments in electrical stunning are showing promise in overcoming problems with carcass damage. It is recommended that rock lobsters should be chilled or frozen before butchery, to ensure a humane death.     

Methods of stunning freshwater fish: impact on meat quality and aspects of animal welfare

 Taking into account aspects of meat quality and animal welfare, three methods of stunning fish were compared: a manual technique (blow on the head, stab in the neck), one using electricity and one using CO₂. The following results were obtained using eel (n=72), carp (n=120) and trout (n=54). From the viewpoint of animal welfare, the effects on the fish were judged. Excitation and mucus secretion as well as the time taken for the fish to be anaesthetized were recorded. With manual and electrical stunning, all fish were anaesthetized almost immediately, while using CO₂ it took 3.2 min (trout), 9.2 min (carp) and 109.7 min (eel) on average. After slaughter and after 3 and 8 days of storage on ice, the fish meat quality parameters, i.e. pH value, water-holding capacity and rigor mortis, were measured. CO₂ stunning gave rise to the lowest pH values and water-holding capacities. Rigor mortis in carp and eel advanced the most. Testing of raw and prepared fish was performed by a panel assessing organoleptic properties. In many cases, fish anaesthetized manually were ranked to be better than those in the other groups. Received: 4 June 1996 / Revised version: 5 July 1996     

Methods of stunning freshwater fish: impact on meat quality and aspects of animal welfare

 Taking into account aspects of meat quality and animal welfare, three methods of stunning fish were compared: a manual technique (blow on the head, stab in the neck), one using electricity and one using CO₂. The following results were obtained using eel (n=72), carp (n=120) and trout (n=54). From the viewpoint of animal welfare, the effects on the fish were judged. Excitation and mucus secretion as well as the time taken for the fish to be anaesthetized were recorded. With manual and electrical stunning, all fish were anaesthetized almost immediately, while using CO₂ it took 3.2 min (trout), 9.2 min (carp) and 109.7 min (eel) on average. After slaughter and after 3 and 8 days of storage on ice, the fish meat quality parameters, i.e. pH value, water-holding capacity and rigor mortis, were measured. CO₂ stunning gave rise to the lowest pH values and water-holding capacities. Rigor mortis in carp and eel advanced the most. Testing of raw and prepared fish was performed by a panel assessing organoleptic properties. In many cases, fish anaesthetized manually were ranked to be better than those in the other groups. Received: 4 June 1996 / Revised version: 5 July 1996     

Stunning and animal welfare from Islamic and scientific perspectives

The transformation of an animal into pieces fit for human consumption is a very important operation. Rather than argue about halal slaughter without stunning being inhumane or stunning being controversial from the Islamic point of view, we discuss slaughter, stunning and animal welfare considering both Islamic and animal welfare legislation requirements. With the world Muslim population close to two billion, the provision of halal meat for the Muslim community is important both ethically and economically. However, from the animal welfare standard point of view, a number of issues have been raised about halal slaughter without stunning, particularly, about stressful methods of restraint and the latency of the onset of unconsciousness. This paper sets out to, discuss the methods of stunning that are acceptable by Islamic authorities, highlight the requirements for stunning to be acceptable in Islam and suggest practical ways to improve the humanness of slaughter.     

Effect of stunning conditions on occurence of PSE defects in hams of rn+/RN(-) pigs

Pigs of the same genetic type at the RN and HAL loci, i.e. rn⁺RN⁻/NN were reared in similar conditions of feeding and housing. They were slaughtered in two abattoirs (referred to as A1 and A2) using a mixture of air (30%) and CO₂ (70%), at a rate of 300 pigs per hour per slaughterline. One hundred and thirty-two pigs from 11 farms were slaughtered in A1 using a corusinga restrainer and 127 pigs from 5 farms were slaughtered in A2 with the backloading technique. pH at 40 min, 2.5 h and 24 h after slaughter and colour (L*, a*, b*) at 24 h after slaughter were measured in the semimembranosus muscle. Meat quality of the ham was scored as follows: 1, no PSE-zone; 2, doubtful; 3, PSE-zones in the semimembranosus and sometimes on the internal flexor muscles; 4, PSE-zones in all the flexor muscles. The muscle pH value was higher in A2 than in A1 at 40 min post mortem (P<0.01), but not at 2.5 and 24 h. L* (P<0.001) and b* (P<0.05) were higher in A1 than in A2. There was a remarkable difference in meat quality scores, with 50% of the hams scoring 3 or 4 in A1, vs 13% in A2. Lairage time before slaughter affected (P<0.01) the pH value at 2.5 h (5.69 vs 5.93). The values of pH1 and pH2.5 decreased with increasing the meat quality score. The values of L* and b* increased markedly with the score. The results of the present study indicate that the method of bringing the slaughter pigs to the stunning device affects the frequency and importance of PSE meat in the ham. The automated driving of groups of animals to the stunning machine combined with the backloading of a nacelle, compared to a traditional system driving pigs in single file using electrical goads and a restrainer was beneficial with respect to both meat quality and animal welfare.     

Effect of electrical stunning on meat quality of lamb

The effects of stunning on both initial and up to 2 weeks post mortem storage meat quality of Spanish Manchega breed lamb were studied. Twenty-four lambs were distributed into two groups. The first group (US; n =12) were slaughtered without previous stunning. In the second group (ES; n =12) animals were electrically stunned. Meat quality was assessed by examining pH, colour as L*, a*, b* values, water holding capacity (WHC) and shear force (SF). Stunning did not affect any parameter studied in the first 24 h post mortem. There were increasing differences between groups in pH (P<0.001) from 5 days onwards. In general stunning did not have an effect on WHC, SF and colour parameters. Ageing of meat affected SF in the ES group but not in the US one; however, there were no significant differences between treatments at any of the ageing times.     

Effect of different carbon dioxide concentrations and exposure times in stunning of slaughter pigs: Impact on animal welfare and meat quality

The objective of this study was to determine the impact of different slaughter procedures on animal welfare and meat quality. Before slaughter in a dip-lift, one-gondola system, 460 pigs were exposed to an atmosphere containing either 80% or 90% CO(2) for 70 or 100s, and at the longer exposure time with stun-to-stick intervals of either 25-35 or 40-50s. Clinical parameters (reflexes, catecholamines and lactate) showed deficiencies in animal welfare after stunning with 80% CO(2) for 70 and 100s, with an interval of 40-50s, and with 90% CO(2) for 70s. Stunning with 80% CO(2) for 70 or 100s always induced stress, as indicated by higher lactate levels, and reduced meat quality as indicated by low pH(24) values (5.4 in Musculus longissimus and 5.5 in Musculus semimembranosus) and low impedance (Py(24)) values, especially in combination with the longer stun-to-stick interval (40-50s). Stunning with 80% or 90% CO(2) in a dip-lift system was found to be acceptable for animal welfare (percentage of clinical reflexes) only in combination with the longer exposure time of 100s and the shorter stun-to-stick times of 25-35s. When 90% CO(2) was used, the longer stun-to-stick interval of 40-50s also gave results acceptable with regard to animal welfare. Generally, in comparison to 80% CO(2) stunning meat quality was superior (higher pH(24) and Py(24) values) after stunning with 90% CO(2).     

Blood in the respiratory tract during slaughter with and without stunning in cattle

Bovine respiratory tracts were examined for blood following shechita without stunning, halal slaughter without stunning, and captive bolt stunning with sticking. In all three methods the cattle were in the upright (standing) position at the start of bleeding. Those that had not been stunned continued to breathe during the early part of bleeding whilst those that were stunned were not breathing. Nineteen percent of the shechita, 58% of the halal and 21% of the stunned plus stuck cattle had blood lining the inner aspect of the trachea. Thirty six percent, 69% and 31% had blood in the upper bronchi, respectively. Ten percent, 19% and 0% had fine bright red blood-tinged foam in the trachea, respectively. It was concluded that concerns about suffering from airway irritation by blood could apply in animals that are either not stunned before slaughter or do not lose consciousness rapidly whilst blood is present in the respiratory tract.     

Evaluation of electrical stunning in commercial rabbits effect on brain function

Effect of electrical stunning on brain function in commercial rabbits was evaluated in electrophysiological studies. In addition to measuring duration of spontaneous physical activity and times to signs of recovery, electrocorticogram (ECOG) recordings and evoked responses were analysed following electrical stunning with 100 V for 1 s in eight rabbits. Epileptiform and other types of activity indicating insensibility were observed in the ECOG. Evoked responses were absent from 24 to 204 s following stunning. Application of a minimum current of 140 mA followed by prompt sticking should prevent welfare problems at stunning and slaughter in rabbits.     

The effect of two handling and slaughter systems on skin damage, meat acidification and colour in pigs

In order to minimize the high proportion of carcass and meat quality defects recorded in commercially slaughtered pigs, the optimum handling, stunning and bleeding-out conditions must be implemented. In this study improvements in pig handling resulted in the elimination of electric goading within the raceways, which reduced the skin blemish score by 50%. Furthermore, the application of higher stunning voltage (200 V) and the immediate bleeding-out in the prone position improved the post-mortem acidification rate in the Longissimus thoracis (LT) and Semimembranosus (SM) muscles. This resulted in a sharp reduction of the PSE incidence in both muscles. A positive effect on muscle metabolism was also showed by the lower release of CPK into the bloodflow. These results show that, under commercial conditions, the design of slaughter handling systems and the slaughter procedures can have an effect on skin damage and on the quality of the pig meat.     

The effect of stress, applied immediately before stunning, on pork quality

The effect on meat quality characteristics of stress, applied during a short period just before stunning, was studied on slaughterpigs (113 boars, 85 gilts). Sexes were kept separately and only pigs that had been stunned correctly were included. Aggressive behaviour during lairage occurred more frequently in boars (about twice) than in gilts. Just before stunning, two animals of the same sex, that were lairaged for an equal period at the slaughter facility, were moved as quietly as possible to the stunning pen, after which one pig was stunned immediately and the other subsequently forced to move through the stunning pen over a period of 1 min. Stress resulted in lower pH values and higher temperatures in the semimembranosus (SM) and the longissimus lumborum (LL) muscles and a higher rigor mortis value of the SM, at 45 min post mortem. Stress affected water holding capacity of the LL negatively at 24 h p.m. Statistically significant interactions were present for sex×stress for several meat quality traits. In general, gilts reacted more strongly to short periods of stress than did boars.     

Dissemination of central nervous system tissue from the brain and spinal cord of cattle after captive bolt stunning and carcass splitting

In the absence of reliable live animal tests for the presence of BSE in cattle, a number of measures have been applied to exclude specified risk materials (SRM) from the human food chain. However, concerns remain that current practices in the stunning and slaughter of cattle may disseminate central nervous system (CNS) tissue to meat and meat contact surfaces. The objective of this study was to establish the particular risks of CNS tissue dissemination associated with captive bolt stunning and carcass splitting. The study applied enzyme linked immunosorbent assays (ELISAs) in the detection and quantification of two CNS proteins, syntaxin 1b and GFAP. The study observed extensive dispersal of both CNS proteins onto equipment, beef hide and personnel. These results demonstrate that despite the rigorous application of current SRM control policies, normal slaughter practices continue to present significant opportunities for CNS material including BSE prion present in the CNS of any sub-clinically infected cattle to contaminate meat entering the human food chain.     

Electrical stunning in commercial rabbits: Effective currents, spontaneous physical activity and reflex behaviour

Electrical stunning was evaluated in commercial slaughter rabbits. Different voltage applications with varying current duration were tested in recovery experiments in 71 animals. Stunning parameters and duration of insensibility were measured and analysed for assessing stunning effectiveness. A minimum stunning current of 140 mA which can be achieved with application of 100 V was recommended.     

Effects of the stunning procedure and the halothane genotype on meat quality and incidence of haemorrhages in pigs

A total of 313 pigs (127 halothane-free, NN, and 186 heterozygous halothane, Nn) were slaughtered in four batches at two commercial abattoirs with two different stunning systems, an automatically head-only followed by head-to-chest electrical stunner and a compact carbon dioxide (CO(2)) stunning unit. Meat quality on the loin muscle was assessed by measuring electrical conductivity (PQM) and colour (Minolta CR 200) at 7 h post mortem, and ultimate pH. Loins showing PQM >6.0 μs were classified as clearly pale, soft and exudative (PSE) meat. The incidence of petechiae, ecchymosis and haematomas in the shoulders, loins and hams was also evaluated. In the abattoir equipped with the electrical stunning system, a higher incidence of potentially PSE meat was found compared with the abattoir equipped with CO(2) stunning (35.6 vs. 4.5%). Likewise, electrical stunning increased significatively the incidence of petechiae in the loins, shoulders and hams, and ecchymosis in the loins and hams. Also, the incidence of PSE meat was higher in the Nn pigs compared with NN pigs (24.7 vs. 7.9%). It is suggested that for improving meat quality and reducing incidence of haemorrhages electrical stunning should be avoided. Further improvements in meat quality can be achieved by eliminating the halothane gene specially in CO(2)-stunned pigs.     

Effects of electrical and mechanical stunning methods on meat quality in ostriches

The effect of electrical and captive needle air pressure stunning methods on some meat quality parameters was examined in ostriches under practical conditions. One hundred and fifteen ostriches were used in three experiments. The ostriches were stunned either electrically (head only) or by using a captive needle with air pressure. In the first experiment the ostriches were stunned at 90 V (～effectively 52 V), 200 V and by captive needle using air pressure. In the second experiment voltages of 175 and 200 V were applied and a captive needle stunning method using air pressure. In the third experiment the birds were stunned at 175 V with a short stun/stick interval. Experiments 2 and 3 were performed in a different slaughterhouse from experiment 1. Meat quality was assessed by measuring the pH, temperature and colour at 45 min and 18 h post mortem and by determining water binding capacity and haemorrhage score at 18 h post mortem in the big drum, tender loin and triangular filet muscles. The measured stunning parameters in the first experiment were 204±96 mA (～52 V) during 11±1 s and 556±85 mA (～200 V) during 6±0 s. The stun/stick interval was 136±38 s. The rigor mortis value in the tender loin and both pH(1) and pH(2) in the big drum, tender loin and triangular filet muscles were (p<0.05) lower when stunned with air pressure compared with electrical stunning. Moreover internal light scattering remained higher. The measured currents in the second experiment were 561±226 mA (～173 V) during 6±2 s and 518±120 mA (～200 V) during 6 s. The stun/stick interval was 39±12 s. The pH at 45 min and 18 h differed (p<0.05) in the tender loin and triangular filet muscles as did the temperature at 45 min in the three muscles between the different stunning groups. The stunning in the third experiment was carried out with 548±180 mA during 6±2 s. The stun/stick interval was 5±2 s. After the short stun/stick interval the pH(2) was lower (p<0.05) for the tender loin and triangular filet muscles and the wetness of the filter paper of the big drum was (p<0.05) lower compared with the other groups. Our experiments showed that stunning methods affected several meat quality parameters. Using a high electrical stunning current, captive needle stunning or a short stun/stick interval may positively affect some parameters. More research is necessary to examine effects of pre slaughter handling on meat quality.