Occupational upper extremity disorders in the federal workforce. Prevalence, health care expenditures, and patterns of work disability

Upper extremity disorders (UEDs) account for a significant number of work-related illnesses in the US workforce. Little information exists on the distribution of UEDs, their associated health care and indemnity costs, or patterns of work disability. The study presented is an analysis of upper extremity claims within the federal workforce. In this study, the universe consisted of all claims accepted by the US Department of Labor, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs (OWCP), from October 1, 1993, through September 30, 1994. A total of 185,927 claims of notices of injury were processed during the study period, and of these, 8,147 or 4.4% had an UED diagnosis coded according to the International Classification of Diseases, Clinical Modification (ICD-9-CM). 5,844 claims involved a single UED diagnosis and were the only claims field by these employees between October 1, 1990, and September 30, 1994. These single claims with single diagnoses comprised the sample for further analysis. Mononeuritis and enthesopathies of the upper limb were the most common diagnoses, accounting for 43% and 31% of the claims, respectively. Women had a higher proportion of carpal tunnel syndrome, "unspecified" mononeuritis, and "unspecified" enthesopathies. The majority of claimants for both the mononeuritis- and enthesopathy-related diagnoses were between 31 and 50 years of age, received only health care benefits, and did not incur wage loss. Health care costs for mononeuritis and enthesopathy claims were $12,228,755 (M = $2,849). Carpal tunnel syndrome (CTS) and enthesopathy of the elbow were the most costly diagnoses, accounting for 57% and 16% of the total, respectively. Surgical services represented the highest expenditures in CTS claims. Physical therapy accounted for the majority of health care costs for enthesopathy cases. The mean number of workdays lost for CTS and enthesopathy claims were 84 and 79, and the average indemnity costs were $4,941 and $4,477, respectively. These findings indicate that while UEDs represent a relatively small percentage of all workers' compensation cases, the health care and indemnity costs are considerable. Also mean duration and pattern of work disability revealed that these disorders can result in chronic work disability similar to that observed in low back pain. The results highlight the need to determine whether interventions that account for the majority of costs significantly impact long-term outcomes. There is also a need to identify risk factors for prolonged disability in those who experience problems with delayed recovery.     

Should extended disability be an exclusion criterion for tertiary rehabilitation? Socioeconomic outcomes of early versus late functional restoration in compensation spinal disorders

STUDY DESIGN: A prospective cohort design with two groups of patients representing short-term or long-term disability (n = 497) who were selected from a larger cohort (n = 938) of consecutively treated spinal disorder patients with chronic compensation injuries. OBJECTIVES: To prospectively evaluate the impact of length of spinal disability on socioeconomic outcomes of medically directed rehabilitation. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Despite an increasing tendency of managed care organizations to limit rehabilitation services for disabled workers with chronic spinal disorders, there has been a surprising lack of prospective research evaluating the impact of length of disability on objective socioeconomic treatment outcomes. Although only approximately 10% of all patients with spinal disorders are disabled beyond 4 months, they account for nearly 80% of all workers' compensation expenditures. Little is known about whether relatively early intervention improves outcomes after chronicity has been established or whether any predictors distinguish between these groups. METHODS: Two comparison groups of functional restoration tertiary treatment graduates were identified from the same community referral pool. The "long-term disabled" group involved a minimum of 18 months of disability (n = 252). This group was compared with a "short-term disabled" group (n = 245), no more than 8 months since injury, but chronic based on a minimum of 4 months after injury. The long-term disabled group showed significantly higher rates of pretreatment surgery than the short-term disabled group (P < 0.001). All patients were evaluated prospectively with specific physical, psychological, and occupational measurements. They also underwent a structured interview 1 year after treatment evaluating work status, health care use, and recurrent injury. RESULTS: The short-term disabled group showed statistically higher return to work (P < 0.001) and work retention (P < 0.05) relative to the long-term disabled group. However, health care use and recurrent lost time injury claims were low in both groups and did not differ significantly. No predictors of outcome were found among the prospectively collected physical performance or psychosocial variables. CONCLUSIONS: This study suggests that early tertiary nonoperative care, once patients with chronic spinal disorders are identified as having potentially high-cost chronic pain and disability, is efficacious in achieving goals of better work return and work retention. Such early rehabilitation may also prevent significant indemnity expense, as well as some late surgical interventions sought by progressively more desperate patients. However, individuals with long-term disability achieve respectable work return and retention rates, while faring no worse on other socioeconomic outcomes that represent major "cost drivers" to the workers' compensation system. Early intervention is not a panacea or a necessary condition for the successful rehabilitation of workers with disabling chronic spinal disorders.     

Head injury and the MMPI-2: Paradoxical severity effects and the influence of litigation.

Minnesota Multiphasic Personality Inventory–2 (MMPI-2) profiles of 30 consecutive patients with moderate/severe head injury were compared with those of 30 consecutive symptomatic minor/mild head injury patients. Of the severely injured, 18 had ongoing litigation and 12 did not. All 30 minor/mild patients were in litigation. The severe litigating group had significant elevations on Hypochondriasis (Hs), Hysteria (Hy), Schizophrenia (Sc), and Health Concerns relative to the severe nonlitigating group. The minor/mild group had significant elevations on Hs, Depression (D), Hy, and Psychasthenia (Pt) over both the litigating and non-litigating severe groups and additional elevations on Sc and Health Concerns over the severe nonlitigating group. Results are discussed in terms of the influence of litigation and injury severity on symptom endorsement on the MMPI-2. A model explaining persisting claims of disability after minor/mild head injury is proposed. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

Evaluation of iatrogenic accessory nerve injury in forensic medical practice

The authors give a survey of the clinical and medical-legal characteristics of the accessory nerve injury. In the past two decades the conception of the successfulness of the surgical treatment of the accessory nerve injury became prevailing. About the medical-legal aspects of the iatrogenic injury of the nerve reported in connection of the reconstructive surgery chiefly also departments of neurosurgery, orthopedics and traumatology. In the case of the authors a 70 year old patient suffered 10 years ago a iatrogenic accessory nerve injury. The mild trapezius palsy recovered spontaneously practically with cosmetic disadvantage. In connection with the development of extreme dorso-lumbal scoliosis associated with torsion the trapezius atrophy worsened. Physical therapy was partly successful. But the patient became unfit for manual work. Their observations sustain the data of authors who established that in the case of accessory nerve injury not only the surgical but also conservative treatment is usually successful. In opposite to certain data of the literature the authors establish that the iatrogenic injuries of the accessory nerve may lead to significant lifelong disability. The diagnosis is not always made in time with consequent delay in repair. This may be regarded as an unfavorable issue during medical-legal discussions. The authors recommend in interest to prevent nerve injury in the posterior triangle of the neck to perform operation in special department.     

The ontological basis of strong artificial life

In 1973, the United States Congress enacted legislation requiring physicians to initiate Peer Review Organizations to monitor utilization and quality of hospital and physician services in the federally funded Medicare program. A hardly noticed provision of the statute intimated the desirability of formulating guidelines for medical treatment. What was originally intended to simplify and universalize general standards by which quality of care could be objectively measured has more recently escalated into formalized projects, subsidized by government, to create "practice parameters". The impetus to define clinical conditions and methods of treatment for specific medical conditions (practice parameters) and standards of practice to avoid or defend malpractice claims (risk management protocols) are part of the movement in the United States for tort reform. If the vague "reasonable man" standard of care in negligence law can be supplanted by a scientifically developed, particularized medical practice standard, it is anticipated that spurious claims and defensive medical practice will be discouraged, quality improved, iatrogenic injury and malpractice litigation diminished. Many U.S. states undertook tort reform in the last decade. A few have embarked on medical-legal reform. One state is conducting a five-year medical liability project that calls for the development of practice parameters and risk management protocols in four medical specialties. The parameters will have the effect of law and may be introduced as evidence in medical malpractice trials. How the parameters are established, their effect on the strategies of litigation, the resultant trial problems in the introduction of evidence and in the burden of proof and their potential for acceptance by a significant number of jurisdictions-are the issues to be explored in this paper.     

Improvement of longitudinal resolution by deblurring technique in helical CT of the head and neck

Patients for cataract surgery in India routinely undergo preoperative syringing to rule out chronic dacryocystitis. We determined the sensitivity and specificity of the clinical test of regurgitation on pressure over the lacrimal sac (ROPLAS) as a screening test for chronic dacryocystitis and compared it to syringing. 621 consecutive outpatients who needed syringing for various reasons (including 318 who had routine syringing prior to cataract surgery) were examined in a masked manner for regurgitation on pressure over the lacrimal sac. They then underwent syringing by a trained (masked) observer. The sensitivity and specificity of ROPLAS were 93.2% and 99.3%, respectively. Using a 6.6% prevalence of chronic dacryocystitis (the prevalence in our cataract population), the negative predictive value of the test was 99.5%. In the presence of regurgitation of pressure over the sac, the high specificity of ROPLAS confirms chronic dacryocystitis. In view of the opportunity costs, when ROPLAS is negative, preoperative syringing in cataract is perhaps unnecessary, unless the findings are equivocal or the index of suspicion for chronic dacryocystitis is very high.     

Trends in disability duration and cost of workers' compensation low back pain claims (1988-1996)

Previously published epidemiologic studies of low back pain (LBP) have reported that the prevalence of low back disability has increased dramatically. These studies based their findings on either the number of disability claims filed, the disability duration, or both. This information was from countries other than the United States or from the US Social Security Disability Insurance data, with findings reported only to the early 1980s. More recent studies of US workers' compensation LBP claims reported a decrease in the incidence rate from the late 1980s to the mid-1990s. No studies have been found that report on the trends of disability duration for workers' compensation LBP claims. This study examined recent trends in the length of disability (LOD) for LBP claims and associated costs, using a large sample of claims from the privately insured US workers' compensation market. LOD and cost information were derived for injuries from 1988, 1990, 1992, 1994, and 1996. For each year, the distributions of LOD and cost were skewed, with the small percentage of claims that lasted more than one year (4.6%-8.8%, depending on the year) accounting for a large percentage of the total disability days (77.6%-90.1%) and cost (64.9%-84.7%). From 1988 to 1996, the average LOD decreased 60.9%, from 156 days to 61 days. The probability of being on disability for a long period of time has decreased over the years. Over the study period, the average cost of a claim decreased 41.4%, while the median cost increased 19.7%. The most influential change in the LOD and cost distributions was a reduction in expensive claims with a long disability duration. The evolution of LOD and cost is also detailed for different disability durations for the study period.     

Evaluation of intranasal zinc sulfate treatment on olfactory discrimination in rats

The effects of intranasal syringing with 5% zinc sulfate were assessed in rats trained in a wind-tunnel olfactometer to detect the presence of an odor or to discriminate odors of graded intensities. The syringing produced a severe but brief interference in olfactory performance. Full recovery of detection performance occurred within 72 hr after treatment. Initial recovery of odor intensity discrimination occurred in 2-8 days and full recovery within 8-10 days. These results suggest that intranasal syringing with ZnSO4 is not an adequate control for the effects of anosmia produced by olfactory bulbectomy.     

Comparison of disability behavior after different sites and types of injury in a workers' compensation population

In this study, an extensive data set from a regional workers' compensation system was analyzed to determine whether particular sites or types of injury were associated with prolonged disability. This data shows a similar pattern of vocational disability for almost all sites and types of injury. A workers' compensation carrier collects data for financial purposes related to insurance, and such data therefore has several serious potential deficiencies when used for clinical research. However, published data on disablement after nonoccupational trauma shows similar patterns of vocational and nonvocational disability, and also shows dependence on severity of injury. In both settings, head injury is associated with greater occupational disability. Because treatment, policy, and medicolegal decisions are based on the impression of "typical disability" for particular sites and types of injury, there is a need for better documentation of post-traumatic disablement in compensation settings and in noncompensation settings. This should include better classification of the cause, type, and severity of the injury, and of the functional outcome in terms of both the resumption of occupational and nonoccupational roles, and of persistence in these roles.     

Preparation of void-free casts from vinyl polysiloxane impressions

PURPOSE: To investigate two techniques to produce void-free casts from vinyl polysiloxane impressions. MATERIALS AND METHODS: Thirty casts prepared using a conventional technique were compared with 30 casts prepared using a technique involving syringing of stone in terms of numbers of surface voids. RESULTS: Significantly fewer surface voids were observed in the casts prepared using syringing technique. CONCLUSION: The syringing technique investigated is considered to have advantages over the conventional technique for the production of casts from vinyl polysiloxane impressions.     

Does clinical status change in anticipation of a PTSD disability examination?

Although there has been considerable research on forensic aspects of disability evaluations for mental health claims, there has been little focus on the clinical impact of disability system participation. Using a prospective design, we examined whether disability system participation affected psychiatric symptom and disability levels in claimants filing for VA disability benefits on the basis of posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Claimants had high levels of PTSD symptoms and disability at the time of claim initiation. Modest increases in illness severity were observed at the time of the disability examination. Factors associated with symptom change were income level and employment status. Negative expectations about the disability claims process were associated with severity of PTSD symptoms, but not with change in symptom levels over time. (PsycINFO Database Record (c) 2010 APA, all rights reserved)     

LAD-1 is absent in a subset of junctional epidermolysis bullosa patients

BACKGROUND: Awareness during anaesthesia has been estimated to occur in 0.2%-0.4% of patients undergoing general surgery. In Finland, according to the Patient Injury Act, compensation is paid for an injury caused by medical treatment. We have analysed the claims for compensation involving awareness under anaesthesia filed between May, 1987 and December, 1993. METHODS: Original claims, hospital notes, and expert advisor's comments as well as the comments of the anaesthesiologist in charge of the anaesthesia, and decisions of the Patient Injury Association, were reviewed. RESULTS: A total of 23363 claims of patient injury were made during the study period. Of these, 391 considered anaesthetic treatments, and there were four cases of awareness with recall. CONCLUSION: Claims of compensation for awareness during anaesthesia were surprisingly few, possible reasons of which are discussed. Compensations paid were low in comparison with some other countries.     

Evaluation of disability pensions by a medical polyclinic: 1990-1995

The question if and in what manner changes of the labour market, in first line increasing unemployment, may influence the composition of the collective demanding a disability pension on one hand and the diagnoses relevant for assessment of requests on the other hand have been investigated as well as possible influences on the criteria for assessments. To this end all expert reports elaborated by the Medical Outpatient Clinic of the University Hospital of Zürich and submitted to the disability insurance between 1990 and 1995 have been evaluated retrospectively. The results show that the fraction of men remained stable around 70% over the whole observation period. The number of persons employed in auxiliary functions remained also constantly high. Over the whole period of observation there was a high, growing percentage of foreign applicants. The most marked change during the observation period was a significant increase of unemployment in the collective. This increase particularly affected applicants with higher ranking jobs or persons over 50. Foreigners became an important part of the unemployed applicants. Rheumatoid disorders and "back pain" in particular were of increasing importance among the relevant diagnoses for assessment of disability. There was a significant decline in the extent of invalidity acknowledged in marked contrast to our initial expectation that the strictness of the applied criteria would weaken when confronted with an increasing number of applications.     

Relation between number of cardiovascular risk factors/events and noninvasive Doppler ultrasound assessments of aortic compliance

BACKGROUND: Health care episodes are traditionally created for a specific condition using defined relevant diagnosis and procedure codes and a start and end period. Our goal is to use 1987 to 1989 medical claims data to create distinct episodes of care as a result of injury. METHODS: Claims for 102,000 people younger than 65 years were obtained from Medstat Systems, Inc. Injury claims were identified by International Classification of Diseases, 9th Revision, Clinical Modification diagnosis codes and separated into 10 body regions. Using linked inpatient and outpatient claims data, we established clear zones--a maximum period for a return visit for medical treatment--for each of 10 body regions injured by hospitalization status. These clear zones were used to create episodes of injury. RESULTS: A total of 295,165 injury claims created 79,564 episodes of injury. Limb and trunk injuries typically have the most follow-ups in terms of number of claims and spacing between claims. Brain injuries, even for admitted patients, result in an average of fewer than two follow-up claims. On average, hospitalized patients require only one more follow-up than nonadmitted patients. CONCLUSIONS: This paper presents a method for identifying injury episodes using a medical claims database. The analysis suggests that follow-up to check for minor long-term sequelae of brain injury is rare.     

Neurology and psychiatry

This study examined 4,547 workers' compensation claims accepted for hearing-related conditions in Washington state between 1984 and 1991; 80% resulted in disability compensation (n = 3,660). Acute hearing-related conditions comprised 11% of accepted conditions (95% confidence interval [CI], 2-15%); most claims were for chronic noise-related hearing loss. Tinnitus was reported in 64% of accepted claims (95% CI, 54-75%). The median binaural-equivalent hearing loss in compensated claims was 12.5% (inter-quartile interval, 5-22%; 90th percentile, 34%), although it declined by 30% during the study period. The number of claims and associated impairment increased with claimant age, but the number of claims dropped dramatically after age 65. Annual total disability settlements almost tripled in 8 years, totaling $22.8 million. This study indicates that occupational hearing-related conditions: 1) are manifested by mild to moderate hearing loss, accompanied by tinnitus in a majority of cases; 2) may be under-recognized in older, formerly noise-exposed individuals; and 3) were associated with substantial increases in compensation and medical costs over time, through 1991.     

Early physician notification of patient disability risk and clinical guidelines after low back injury: a randomized, controlled trial

STUDY DESIGN: Back-injured workers with high disability risk scores on a predictive questionnaire participated in a randomized, controlled trial of physician notification, with outcomes follow-up 3 months after injury. OBJECTIVES: To test whether physician intervention improves return to work and self-assessment outcomes for people at relatively high risk for disability. SUMMARY OF BACKGROUND DATA: Only a small number of back-injured workers suffer significant disability. Quick identification of these people would facilitate more efficient targeting and trials of interventions. Controlling variations in practice through practice guidelines has been recommended as a promising strategy for improving care and reducing disability. METHODS: Workers filing back injury reports responded to a disability prediction questionnaire. Those with high risk scores were randomly assigned to control or intervention groups. Patient-designated physicians in the intervention group received two letters identifying the patient's risk and making recommendations for care, including the Agency for Health Care Policy and Research's algorithms for acute low back pain. Predictive accuracy of the questionnaire and efficacy of physician intervention were evaluated on the basis of work status and self-assessments 3 months after injury. RESULTS: Of the 268 workers completing the questionnaire portion of the study, 32 (12%) were out of work because of back pain 3 months after injury. The questionnaire's predictive accuracy included maximum kappa of 0.277 and a receiver operating curve area of 0.78. Fifty-three people completed the physician intervention trial. The intervention had no significant impact on return to work, self-assessed pain, or satisfaction with health care. CONCLUSIONS: Stratification of back-injured people according to disability risk can can increase intervention efficiency by identifying those who require treatment and sparing those who do not. The apparent failure of risk notification and practice guidelines to reduce disability in this study may be improved by different application methods in the future.     

Neonatal bladder rupture: an unusual complication of umbilical catheterization

Bladder injury in the neonatal period is an exceedingly rare phenomenon that is usually iatrogenic. Bladder rupture as a complication of umbilical catheterization in a newborn with urinary ascites, respiratory distress and hematuria is presented and discussed.     

Lower pole calicostomy for the management of iatrogenic ureteropelvic junction obstruction

It is often possible to use endoscopic techniques for the management of iatrogenic upper ureteral or ureteropelvic junction obstruction. However, in some cases with severe stricture disease or significant ischemic injury open surgical reconstruction is necessary. We report our experience with ileal ureter-lower pole calicostomy for the management of these complex urological injuries. During the last 3 years we treated 3 patients with severe ureteral/ureteropelvic junction obstruction secondary to iatrogenic injuries, including ureteral avulsion during ureteroscopic stone extraction, ureteral laceration during dilation for diagnostic ureteropyeloscopy, and ureteral ligation with ureteropelvic junction disruption and large peri-pelvic urinoma. In all cases unsuccessful attempts at endoscopic management necessitated open repair. Lower pole heminephrectomy was performed in all patients to expose the lower pole calix and ileal ureter-lower pole calicostomy was created due to the injury of large segments of the ureter. Satisfactory results were demonstrated on postoperative excretory urography and by a lack of symptoms. Followup averaged 23 months (range 20 to 26) with stable renal function in all patients. We believe that ileal ureter-lower pole calicostomy represents an attractive alternative for the management of severe ischemic, iatrogenic upper ureteral or ureteropelvic junction obstruction when endoscopic maneuvers are not possible or ineffective.     

Sport-related dental injury claims to the New Zealand Accident Rehabilitation & Compensation Insurance Corporation, 1993-1996: analysis of the 10 most common sports, excluding rugby union

A large number of New Zealanders participate in sport, either formally or informally; sporting injuries are common. In New Zealand, the Accident Rehabilitation & Compensation Insurance Corporation (ACC) is the main organisation that covers sports-related dental claims. Rugby union claims are the most common. The ACC's national data from 1993 to 1996 relating to dental claims for sports injuries (excluding rugby union) were analysed. This study identified 45 other sports in which participants are also at risk for dental injuries. Total claims per sport for each year were determined, and the "top 10" sports for claims per year were identified and compared for any change over the years studied. The top 10 sports for 1993 and 1994 were, in descending order: swimming, rugby league, basketball, cricket, hockey, soccer, netball, squash, softball-baseball, and tennis. Data for 1995 and 1996 revealed a similar trend, except that touch rugby displaced tennis as the tenth-ranked sport. The most common age group for claims was the age group 10-19 years, with a male:female ratio of approximately 2:1. Many sports, in addition to rugby union, place their participants at risk of dental injury. Awareness of prevention of dental injuries should be more widely promoted for all sports.