Liquefaction-Induced Softening of Load Transfer between Pile Groups and Laterally Spreading Crusts

Laterally spreading nonliquefied crusts can exert large loads on pile foundations causing major damage to structures. While monotonic load tests of pile caps indicate that full passive resistance may be mobilized by displacements on the order of 1–7% of the pile cap height, dynamic centrifuge model tests show that much larger relative displacements may be required to mobilize the full passive load from a laterally spreading crust onto a pile group. The centrifuge models contained six-pile groups embedded in a gently sloping soil profile with a nonliquefied crust over liquefiable loose sand over dense sand. The nonliquefied crust layer spread downslope on top of the liquefied sand layer, and failed in the passive mode against the pile foundations. The dynamic trace of lateral load versus relative displacement between the “free-field” crust and pile cap is nonlinear and hysteretic, and depends on the cyclic mobility of the underlying liquefiable sand, ground motion characteristics, and cyclic degradation and cracking of the nonliquefied crust. Analytical models are derived to explain a mechanism by which liquefaction of the underlying sand layer causes the soil-to-pile-cap interaction stresses to be distributed through a larger zone of influence in the crust, thereby contributing to the softer load transfer behavior. The analytical models distinguish between structural loading and lateral spreading conditions. Load transfer relations obtained from the two analytical models reasonably envelope the responses observed in the centrifuge tests.     

Application of Periodic Boundary for Large Pile Group

Full-scale testing of a large pile group is economically not feasible. A concept based on a periodic boundary has been used to study lateral behavior of a large pile group. The approach and findings from anchorage design of a major suspension bridge in California are presented here. Using the repeating nature of soil's displacement field within infinite number of piles arranged in a regular grid pattern, soil-pile interaction phenomenon from the finite area enclosed by one periodic soil boundary effectively represents behavior of the entire pile group. A 3D finite-element analysis was used to create the soil-pile models in which the boundary conditions mimic the repeating nature of the infinite number of piles by slaving the boundary nodes. The soil resistance, as calculated from the finite-element method employing the periodic boundary, is compared with the empirical p-y curve approach for a single isolated pile to determine the group effects. Values of p-multiplier and y-multiplier have been obtained for different pile spacings.     

Dynamic Experiments and Analyses of a Pile-Group-Supported Structure

Experimental data on the seismic response of a pile-group-supported structure was obtained through dynamic centrifuge model tests, and then used to evaluate a dynamic beam on a nonlinear Winkler foundation (BNWF) analysis method. The centrifuge tests included a structure supported on a group of nine piles founded in soft clay overlying dense sand. This structure was subjected to nine earthquake events with peak accelerations ranging from 0.02 to 0.7g. The centrifuge tests and dynamic analysis methods are described. Good agreement was obtained between calculated and recorded structural responses, including superstructure acceleration and displacement, pile cap acceleration and displacement, pile bending moment and axial load, and pile cap rotation. Representative examples of recorded and calculated behavior for the structure and soil profile are presented. Sensitivity of the dynamic BNWF analyses to the numerical model parameters and site response calculations are evaluated. These results provide experimental support for the use of dynamic BNWF analysis methods in seismic soil-pile-structure interaction problems involving pile-group systems.     

Seismic Soil-Pile-Structure Interaction Experiments and Analyses

A dynamic beam on a nonlinear Winkler foundation (or “dynamic p-y”) analysis method for analyzing seismic soil-pile-structure interaction was evaluated against the results of a series of dynamic centrifuge model tests. The centrifuge tests included two different single-pile-supported structures subjected to nine different earthquake events with peak accelerations ranging from 0.02 to 0.7g. The soil profile consisted of soft clay overlying dense sand. Site response and dynamic p-y analyses are described. Input parameters were selected based on existing engineering practices. Reasonably good agreement was obtained between calculated and recorded responses for both structural models in all earthquake events. Sensitivity of the results to dynamic p-y model parameters and site response calculations are evaluated. These results provide experimental support for the use of dynamic p-y analysis methods in seismic soil-pile-structure interaction problems.     

Behavior of Slender Piles Subject to Free-Field Lateral Soil Movement

Soil movements associated with slope instability induce shear forces and bending moments in stabilizing piles that vary with the buildup of passive pile resistance. For such free-field lateral soil movements, stress development along the pile element is a function of the relative displacement between the soil and the pile. To investigate the effects of relative soil-pile displacement on pile response, large-scale load tests were performed on relatively slender, drilled, composite pile elements (cementitious grout with centered steel reinforcing bar). The piles were installed through a shear box into stable soil and then loaded by lateral translation of the shear box. The load tests included two pile diameters (nominal 115 and 178?mm) and three cohesive soil types (loess, glacial till, and weathered shale). Instrumentation indicated the relative soil-pile displacements and the pile response to the loads that developed along the piles. Using the experimental results, an analysis approach was evaluated using soil p-y curves derived from laboratory undrained shear strength tests. The test piles and analyses helped characterize behavioral stages of the composite pile elements at loads up to pile section failure and also provided a unique dataset to evaluate the lateral response analysis method for its applicability to slender piles.     

Strain Wedge Model Capability of Analyzing Behavior of Laterally Loaded Isolated Piles, Drilled Shafts, and Pile Groups

This paper demonstrates the application of the strain wedge (SW) model to assess the response of laterally loaded isolated long piles, drilled shafts, and pile groups in layered soil (sand and/or clay) and rock deposits. The basic goal of this paper is to illustrate the capabilities of the SW model versus other procedures and approaches. The SW model has been validated and verified through several comparison studies with model- and full-scale lateral load tests. Several factors and features related to the problem of a laterally loaded isolated pile and pile group are covered by the SW model. For example, the nonlinear behavior of both soil and pile material, the soil-pile interaction (i.e., the assessment of the p-y curves rather than the adoption of empirical ones), the potential of soil to liquefy, the interference among neighboring piles in a pile group, and the pile cap contribution are considered in SW model analysis. The SW model analyzes the response of laterally loaded piles based on pile properties (pile stiffness, cross-sectional shape, pile-head conditions, etc.) as well as soil properties. The SW model has the capability of assessing the response of a laterally loaded pile group in layered soil based on more realistic assumptions of pile interference as compared to techniques and procedures currently employed or proposed.     

Horizontal Bearing Capacity of Piles in a Lateritic Soil

The behavior of pile foundations subjected to horizontal loading is typically evaluated using horizontal load tests. Although load tests are valuable to understand site-specific soil-structure interaction phenomena, validated predictive methods are also useful during the design phase. In this study, the results from horizontal load tests are compared with methods which predict the horizontal bearing capacity of piles using in situ measurements of soil behavior. Specifically, several horizontal load tests were performed in order to evaluate the behavior of two 12-m long Strauss piles and four bored piles with similar length, all installed in a lateritic soil profile. Two prediction methods were evaluated using p-y curves computed from the results of Marchetti’s dilatometer test (DMT) results. The predictive methods using the p-y curves from the DMT showed good agreement with the behavior observed in the pile loading test.     

Applicability of Conventional p-y Relations to the Analysis of Piles in Laterally Spreading Soil

This paper presents a kinematic analysis of a single pile embedded in a laterally spreading layered soil profile and discusses the relevancy of conventional analysis models to this load case. The research encompasses the creation of three-dimensional (3D) finite-element (FE) models using the OpenSees FE analysis platform. These models consider a single pile embedded in a layered soil continuum. Three reinforced concrete pile designs are considered. The piles are modeled using beam-column elements and fiber-section models. The soil continuum is modeled using brick elements and a Drucker-Prager constitutive model. The soil-pile interface is modeled using beam-solid contact elements. The FE models are used to evaluate the response of the soil-pile system to lateral spreading and two alternative lateral load cases. Through the computation of force density-displacement (p-y) curves representative of the soil response, the FE analysis (FEA) results are used to evaluate the adequacy of conventional p-y curve relationships in modeling lateral spreading. It is determined that traditional p-y curves are unsuitable for use in analyses where large pile deformations occur at depth.     

Simplified Approach for the Seismic Response of a Pile Foundation

Pseudostatic approaches for the seismic analysis of pile foundations are attractive for practicing engineers because they are simple when compared to difficult and more complex dynamic analyses. To evaluate the internal response of piles subjected to earthquake loading, a simplified approach based on the “p-y” subgrade reaction method has been developed. The method involves two main steps: first, a site response analysis is carried out to obtain the free-field ground displacements along the pile. Next, a static load analysis is carried out for the pile, subjected to the computed free-field ground displacements and the static loading at the pile head. A pseudostatic push over analysis is adopted to simulate the behavior of piles subjected to both lateral soil movements and static loadings at the pile head. The single pile or the pile group interact with the surrounding soil by means of hyperbolic p-y curves. The solution derived first for the single pile, was extended to the case of a pile group by empirical multipliers, which account for reduced resistance and stiffness due to pile-soil-pile interaction. Numerical results obtained by the proposed simplified approach were compared with experimental and numerical results reported in literature. It has been shown that this procedure can be used successfully for determining the response of a pile foundation to “inertial” loading caused by the lateral forces imposed on the superstructure and “kinematic” loading caused by the ground movements developed during an earthquake.     

Permanent Strains of Piles in Sand due to Cyclic Lateral Loads

The strain superposition concept, proposed for ballast study, is applied here to evaluate strain accumulation for laterally loaded piles in sand. It is shown that the soil properties, types of pile installation, cyclic loading types, pile embedded length, and pile∕soil relative stiffness ratio are important factors that influence the pile behavior under mixed lateral loads. These factors are quantified by means of a degradation factor, t, which is derived from the results of 20 full-scale pile load tests and then verified using 6 additional full-scale pile load tests.     

Modeling Lateral Soil-Pile Response Based on Soil-Pile Interaction

Although most designers prefer the p-y curve method as compared to elastic continuum or finite-element analysis of laterally loaded pile behavior, the profession has reached a state where it is time that closer scrutiny be given to the traditional “Matlock-Reese” p-y curves used in the analysis. The traditional p-y curves were derived from a number of well-instrumented field tests that reflect a limited set of conditions. To consider these p-y curves as unique is questionable. As important as such curves have been to advancing the practice from elastic to nonlinear beam on elastic foundation analysis, such calibrated∕verified p-y curves reflect the specific field test conditions (particularly the pile properties) encountered. As presented in this paper, there are additional influences such as pile bending stiffness, pile cross-sectional shape, pile-head fixity, and pile-head embedment that have an effect on the resulting p-y curves. It is argued that strain wedge (SW) model formulation can be used to characterize such effects. SW model analysis predicts the response of laterally loaded piles and has shown very good agreement with actual field tests in sand, clay, and layered soils. The advantage of the SW model is that it is capable of taking into account the effect of changes in soil and pile properties on the resulting p-y curves.     

黏土中静压沉桩离心模型

采用西澳大学室内鼓轮式离心机,在预先固结的高岭黏土中开展不同离心力场(50g,125g及250g,g为重力加速度)条件下的模型压桩试验、T-bar试验和静力触探试验,分析了模型桩在贯入过程、静置稳定过程中桩身径向应力(σ_r)的变化规律,并对后期桩体拉伸载荷阶段的径向应力变化值(Δσ_r)及桩侧摩阻力变化情况行了探讨,揭示了在不同超固结比(OCRs)黏土中静压桩侧摩阻力的演变特性.在此基础上,通过两种经验公式方法对桩侧摩承载力进行了预测计算和对比分析.研究结果表明:沉桩过程中桩端相对高度(h/B)对桩身径向应力的发展变化有很大的影响,桩身不同位置(h/B)的总径向应力对同一贯入深度而言,存在桩侧径向应力退化现象;基于静力触探试验提出的经验方法,能有效考虑静力触探锥端阻力(q_t)和桩端相对高度(h/B)因素的影响,将其应用于黏土沉桩时桩侧摩阻力的预测,可取得与试验实测结果较吻合的结果.研究成果对软土地区静压桩施工与承载力设计具有一定的工程指导意义.     

Wedge Failure Analysis of Soil Resistance on Laterally Loaded Piles in Clay

A fundamental study of pile-soil systems subjected to lateral loads in clay soil was conducted by using experimental tests and a lateral load-transfer approach. The emphasis was on an improved wedge failure model developed by considering three-dimensional combination forces and a new hyperbolic p-y criterion. A framework for determining the p-y curve on the basis of both theoretical analysis and experimental load test results is proposed. The proposed p-y method is shown to be capable of predicting the behavior of a large-diameter pile under lateral loading. The proposed p-y curves with an improved wedge model are more appropriate and realistic for representing a pile-soil interaction for laterally loaded piles in clay than the existing p-y method.     

Lateral Behavior of Pile Groups in Layered Soils

Assessment of the response of a laterally loaded pile group based on soil–pile interaction is presented in this paper. The behavior of a pile group in uniform and layered soil (sand and/or clay) is evaluated based on the strain wedge model approach that was developed to analyze the response of a long flexible pile under lateral loading. Accordingly, the pile’s response is characterized in terms of three-dimensional soil–pile interaction which is then transformed into its one-dimensional beam on elastic foundation equivalent and the associated parameter (modulus of subgrade reaction Es) variation along pile length. The interaction among the piles in a group is determined based on the geometry and interaction of the mobilized passive wedges of soil in front of the piles in association with the pile spacing. The overlap of shear zones among the piles in the group varies along the length of the pile and changes from one soil layer to another in the soil profile. Also, the interaction among the piles grows with the increase in lateral loading, and the increasing depth and fan angles of the developing wedges. The value of Es so determined accounts for the additional strains (i.e., stresses) in the adjacent soil due to pile interaction within the group. Based on the approach presented, the p–y curve for different piles in the pile group can be determined. The reduction in the resistance of the individual piles in the group compared to the isolated pile is governed by soil and pile properties, level of loading, and pile spacing.     

Nonlinear Finite-Element Modeling of Batter Piles under Lateral Load

In this paper, a finite-element model is developed in which the nonlinear soil behavior is represented by a hyperbolic relation for static load condition and modified hyperbolic relation, which includes both degradation and gap for a cyclic load condition. Although batter piles are subjected to lateral load, the soil resistance is also governed by axial load, which is incorporated by considering the P-Δ moment and geometric stiffness matrix. By adopting the developed numerical model, static and cyclic load analyses are performed adopting an incremental-iterative procedure where the pile is idealized as beam elements and the soil as elastoplastic spring elements. The proposed numerical model is validated with published laboratory and field pile test results under both static and cyclic load conditions. This paper highlights the importance of the degradation factor and its influence on the soil resistance-displacement (p-y) curve, number of cycles of loading, and cyclic load response.     

Effect of Soil Permeability on Centrifuge Modeling of Pile Response to Lateral Spreading

This paper presents experimental results and analysis of six model centrifuge experiments conducted on the 150?g-ton Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute centrifuge to investigate the effect of soil permeability on the response of end-bearing single piles and pile groups subjected to lateral spreading. The models were tested in a laminar box and simulate a mild infinite slope with a liquefiable sand layer on top of a nonliquefiable layer. Three fine sand models consisting of a single pile, a 3×1 pile group, and a 2×2 pile group were tested, first using water as pore fluid, and then repeated using a viscous pore fluid, hence simulating two sands of different permeability in the field. The results were dramatically different, with the three tests simulating a low permeability soil developing 3–6 times larger pile head displacements and bending moments at the end of shaking. Deformation observations of colored sand strips, as well as measurements of sustained negative excess pore pressures near the foundations in the “viscous fluid” experiments, indicated that an approximately inverted conical zone of nonliquefied soil had formed in these tests at shallow depths around the foundation, which forced the liquefied soil in the free field to apply its lateral pressure against a much larger effective foundation area. Additional p-y and limit equilibrium back-analyses support the hypothesis that the greatly increased foundation bending response observed when the soil is less pervious is due to the formation of such inverted conical volume of nonliquefied sand. This study provides evidence of the importance of soil permeability on pile foundations response during lateral spreading for cases when the liquefied deposit reaches the ground surface, and suggests that bending response may be greater in silty sands than in clean sands in the field. Moreover, the observations in this study may serve as basis for realistic practical engineering methods to evaluate pile foundations subjected to lateral spreading and pressure of liquefied soil.     

Capacity, Settlement, and Energy Dissipation of Shallow Footings Subjected to Rocking

The effectiveness of structural fuse mechanisms used to improve the performance of buildings during seismic loading depends on their capacity, ductility, energy dissipation, isolation, and self-centering characteristics. Although rocking shallow footings could also be designed to possess many of these desirable characteristics, current civil engineering practice often avoids nonlinear behavior of soil in design, due to the lack of confidence and knowledge about cyclic rocking. Several centrifuge experiments were conducted to study the rocking behavior of shallow footings, supported by sand and clay soil stratums, during slow lateral cyclic loading and dynamic shaking. The ratio of the footing area to the footing contact area required to support the applied vertical loads (A/Ac), related to the factor of safety with respect to vertical loading, is correlated with moment capacity, energy dissipation, and permanent settlement measured in centrifuge and 1 g model tests. Results show that a footing with large A/Ac ratio (about 10) possesses a moment capacity that is insensitive to soil properties, does not suffer large permanent settlements, has a self-centering characteristic associated with uplift and gap closure, and dissipates seismic energy that corresponds to about 20% damping ratio. Thus, there is promise to use rocking footings in place of, or in combination with, structural base isolation and energy dissipation devices to improve the performance of the structure during seismic loading.     

Undrained Lateral Pile Response in Sloping Ground

Three-dimensional finite element analyses were performed to study the behavior of piles in sloping ground under undrained lateral loading conditions. Piles of different diameter and length in sloping cohesive soils of different undrained shear strength and several ground slopes were considered. Based on the results of the finite element analyses, analytical formulations are derived for the ultimate load per unit length and the initial stiffness of hyperbolic p-y curves. New p-y criteria for static loading of piles in clay are proposed, which take into account the inclination of the slope and the adhesion of the pile-slope interface. These curves are used through a commercial subgrade reaction computer code to parametrically analyze the effect of slope inclination and pile adhesion on lateral displacements and bending moments. To validate the proposed p-y curves, a number of well documented lateral load tests are analyzed. Remarkable agreement is obtained between predicted and measured responses for a wide range of soil undrained shear strength and pile diameter, length, and stiffness.     

DSC Model for Soil and Interface Including Liquefaction and Prediction of Centrifuge Test

Realistic predictions of dynamic soil–structure interaction problems require appropriate constitutive models for the characterization of soils and interfaces. This paper presents a unified model based on the disturbed state concept (DSC). The parameters for the models for the Nevada sand, and sand–metal interface are obtained based on available triaxial test data on the sand and interfaces. The predicted stress–strain–pore water pressure behavior for the sand using the DSC model is compared with the test data. In addition, a finite element procedure with the DSC model, based on the generalized Biot’s theory, is used to predict the measured responses for a pile (aluminum) sand foundation problem obtained by using the centrifuge test. The predictions compared very well with measured pore water pressures. The DSC model is used to identify microstructural instability leading to liquefaction. A procedure is proposed to apply the proposed method for analysis and design for dynamic response and liquefaction.     

Lateral Loaded Pile Response in Liquefiable Soil

This paper provides a new analysis procedure for assessing the lateral response of an isolated pile in saturated sands as liquefaction develops in response to dynamic loading such as that generated during earthquake shaking. This new procedure predicts the degradation in pile response and soil resistance due to the free-field excess porewater pressure generated by the earthquake, along with the near-field excess porewater pressure generated by lateral loading from the superstructure. The new procedure involves the integration of the developing (free- and near-field) porewater pressure in the strain wedge (SW) model analysis. The current SW model, developed to evaluate drained response (a nonlinear three-dimensional model) of a flexible pile in soil, has been extended in this paper to incorporate the undrained response of a laterally loaded pile in liquefied sand. This new procedure has the capability of predicting the response of a laterally loaded isolated pile and the associated modulus of subgrade reaction (i.e., the p–y curve) in a mobilized fashion as a result of developing liquefaction in the sand. Current design procedures assume slight or no resistance for the lateral movement of the pile in the liquefied soil which is a conservative practice. Alternatively, if liquefaction is assessed not to occur, some practitioners take no account of the increased free-field porewater pressure, and none consider the additional near-field porewater pressure due to inertial interaction loading from the superstructure; a practice that is unsafe in loose sands.