Thermodynamic stability of the P4-P6 domain RNA tertiary structure measured by temperature gradient gel electrophoresis

The P4-P6 domain RNA from the Tetrahymena self-splicing group I intron is an independent unit of tertiary structure that, in the kinetic folding pathway, folds before the rest of the intron and then stabilizes the remainder of the intron's tertiary structure. We have employed temperature gradient gel electrophoresis (TGGE) to examine the unfolding of the tertiary structure of P4-P6. In 0.9 mM Mg2+, the global tertiary fold of the molecule has a melting temperature of approximately 40 degreesC and is completely unfolded by 60 degreesC. Calculated thermodynamic parameters for folding of P4-P6 are DeltaH degrees' = -28 +/- 3 kcal/mol and DeltaS degrees' = -91 +/- 8 eu under these conditions. Chemical probing of the P4-P6 tertiary structure using dimethyl sulfate and CMCT confirms that these TGGE experiments monitor the unfolding of the global tertiary fold of the domain and that the secondary structure is largely unaffected over this temperature range. Thus, unlike the entropically driven P1 docking and guanosine binding steps of Tetrahymenagroup I intron self-splicing, which have positive or zero DeltaH terms, P4-P6 tertiary structure formation is stabilized by a negative DeltaH term. This implies that enthalpically favorable hydrogen bond formation, nucleotide base stacking, and/or binding of Mg2+ within the folded structure are responsible for stabilizing the P4-P6 domain.     

Coaxially stacked RNA helices in the catalytic center of the Tetrahymena ribozyme

Coaxial stacking of helical elements is a determinant of three-dimensional structure in RNA. In the catalytic center of the Tetrahymena group I intron, helices P4 and P6 are part of a tertiary structural domain that folds independently of the remainder of the intron. When P4 and P6 were fused with a phosphodiester linkage, the resulting RNA retained the detailed tertiary interactions characteristic of the native P4-P6 domain and even required lower magnesium ion concentrations for folding. These results indicate that P4 and P6 are coaxial in the P4-P6 domain and, therefore, in the native ribozyme. Helix fusion could provide a general method for identifying pairs of coaxially stacked helices in biological RNA molecules.     

In vitro selection for altered divalent metal specificity in the RNase P RNA

The ribozyme RNase P absolutely requires divalent metal ions for catalytic function. Multiple Mg2+ ions contribute to the optimal catalytic efficiency of RNase P, and it is likely that the tertiary structure of the ribozyme forms a specific metal-binding pocket for these ions within the active-site. To identify base moieties that contribute to catalytic metal-binding sites, we have used in vitro selection to isolate variants of the Escherichia coli RNase P RNA with altered specificities for divalent metal. RNase P RNA variants with increased activity in Ca2+ were enriched over 18 generations of selection for catalysis in the presence of Ca2+, which is normally disfavored relative to Mg2+. Although a wide spectrum of mutations was found in the generation-18 clones, only a single point mutation was common to all clones: a cytosine-to-uracil transition at position 70 (E. coli numbering) of RNase P. Analysis of the C70U point mutant in a wild-type background confirmed that the identity of the base at position 70 is the sole determinant of Ca2+ selectivity. It is noteworthy that C70 lies within the phylogenetically well conserved J3/4-P4-J2/4 region, previously implicated in Mg2+ binding. Our finding that a single base change is sufficient to alter the metal preference of RNase P is further evidence that the J3/4-P4-J2/4 domain forms a portion of the ribozyme's active site.     

Differential chemical probing of a group II self-splicing intron identifies bases involved in tertiary interactions and supports an alternative secondary structure model of domain V

Dimethyl sulfate modification was used to probe for tertiary structural elements in the group II intron PI.LSU/2 from the mitochondrial pre-ribosomal RNA of the brown alga Pylaiella littoralis. Modification of the lariat form of the intron under conditions that allow both native folding and conformational homogeneity is found to be generally consistent with secondary and tertiary structural features identified previously for group II ribozymes. A comparison of chemical probing at temperatures just below and above the first melting transition illustrates the cooperative unfolding of tertiary structure and identifies novel candidates for tertiary interactions in addition to defining elements of secondary structure. Substitution of the GAAA terminal loop of domain V is shown to be compatible with retention of conformational homogeneity (despite the loss of an important tertiary interaction), but produces a concise methylation footprint in domain I at the site previously shown to harbor the receptor for that loop. The analysis also identified two nucleotide positions in domain V with novel secondary and potential tertiary structural roles. The proposed refinement of domain V secondary structure is supported by an expanded comparative analysis of group II sequences and bears increased resemblance to U2:U6 snRNA pairing in the spliceosome.     

Time-resolved synchrotron X-ray "footprinting", a new approach to the study of nucleic acid structure and function: application to protein-DNA interactions and RNA folding

Hydroxyl radicals (.OH) can cleave the phosphodiester backbone of nucleic acids and are valuable reagents in the study of nucleic acid structure and protein-nucleic acid interactions. Irradiation of solutions by high flux "white light" X-ray beams based on bending magnet beamlines at the National Synchrotron Light Source (NSLS) yields sufficient concentrations of .OH so that quantitative nuclease protection ("footprinting") studies of DNA and RNA can be conducted with a duration of exposure in the range of 50 to 100 ms. The sensitivity of DNA and RNA to X-ray mediated .OH cleavage is equivalent. Both nucleic acids are completely protected from synchrotron X-ray induced cleavage by the presence of thiourea in the sample solution, demonstrating that cleavage is suppressed by a free radical scavenger. The utility of this time-dependent approach to footprinting is demonstrated with a synchrotron X-ray footprint of a protein-DNA complex and by a time-resolved footprinting analysis of the Mg(2+)-dependent folding of the Tetrahymena thermophilia L-21 ScaI ribozyme RNA. Equilibrium titrations reveal differences among the ribozyme domains in the cooperativity of Mg(2+)-dependent .OH protection. RNA .OH protection progress curves were obtained for several regions of the ribozyme over timescales of 30 seconds to several minutes. Progress curves ranging from > or = 3.5 to 0.4 min-1 were obtained for the P4-P6 and P5 sub-domains and the P3-P7 domain, respectively. The .OH protection progress curves have been correlated with the available biochemical, structural and modeling data to generate a model of the ribozyme folding pathway. Rate differences observed for specific regions within domains provide evidence for steps in the folding pathway not previously observed. Synchrotron X-ray footprinting is a new approach of general applicability for the study of time-resolved structural changes of nucleic acid conformation and protein-nucleic acid complexes.     

The P15-loop of Escherichia coli RNase P RNA is an autonomous divalent metal ion binding domain

We have studied the structure and divalent metal ion binding of a domain of the ribozyme RNase P RNA that is involved in base pairing with its substrate. Our data suggest that the folding of this internal loop, the P15-loop, is similar irrespective of whether it is part of the full-length ribozyme or part of a model RNA molecule. We also conclude that this element constitutes an autonomous divalent metal ion binding domain of RNase P RNA and our data suggest that certain specific chemical groups within the P15-loop participate in coordination of divalent metal ions. Substitutions of the Sp- and Rp-oxygens with sulfur at a specific position in this loop result in a 2.5-5-fold less active ribozyme, suggesting that Mg2+ binding at this position contributes to function. Our findings strengthen the concept that small RNA building blocks remain basically unchanged when removed from their structural context and thus can be used as models for studies of their potential function and structure within native RNA molecules.     

A general module for RNA crystallization

Crystallization of RNA molecules other than simple oligonucleotide duplexes remains a challenging step in structure determination by X-ray crystallography. Subjecting biochemically, covalently and conformationally homogeneous target molecules to an exhaustive array of crystallization conditions is often insufficient to yield crystals large enough for X-ray data collection. Even when large RNA crystals are obtained, they often do not diffract X-rays to resolutions that would lead to biochemically informative structures. We reasoned that a well-folded RNA molecule would typically present a largely undifferentiated molecular surface dominated by the phosphate backbone. During crystal nucleation and growth, this might result in neighboring molecules packing subtly out of register, leading to premature crystal growth cessation and disorder. To overcome this problem, we have developed a crystallization module consisting of a normally intramolecular RNA-RNA interaction that is recruited to make an intermolecular crystal contact. The target RNA molecule is engineered to contain this module at sites that do not affect biochemical activity. The presence of the crystallization module appears to drive crystal growth, in the course of which other, non-designed contacts are made. We have employed the GAAA tetraloop/tetraloop receptor interaction successfully to crystallize numerous group II intron domain 5-domain 6, and hepatitis delta virus (HDV) ribozyme RNA constructs. The use of the module allows facile growth of large crystals, making it practical to screen a large number of crystal forms for favorable diffraction properties. The method has led to group II intron domain crystals that diffract X-radiation to 3.5 A resolution.     

A rapid in vitro method for obtaining RNA accessibility patterns for complementary DNA probes: correlation with an intracellular pattern and known RNA structures

A technique is described to identify the rare sequences within an RNA molecule that are available for efficient interaction with complementary DNA probes: the target RNA is digested by RNase H in the presence of a random pool of complementary DNA fragments generated from the same DNA preparation that was used for target RNA synthesis. The DNA region was amplified by PCR, partially digested with DNase and denatured prior to RNA binding. In the presence of single-stranded DNA fragments the RNA was digested with RNase H such that, on average, each molecule was cut once. Cleavage sites were detected by gel electrophoresis either directly with end-labeled RNA or by primer extension. The pattern of accessible sites on c- raf mRNA was determined and compared with the known profile of activity of oligonucleotides found in cells, showing the merit of the method for predicting oligonucleotides which are efficient for in vivo antisense targeting. New susceptible sites in the 3'-untranslated region of c- raf mRNA were identified. Also, four RNAs were probed to ascertain to what extent structure predicts accessibility: the P4-P6 domain of the Tetrahymena group I intron, yeast tRNAAsp, Escherichia coli tmRNA and a part of rat 18S rRNA.     

Mutations in the conserved P loop perturb the conformation of two structural elements in the peptidyl transferase center of 23 S ribosomal RNA

Evidence is presented for the participation of the P loop (nucleotides G2250-C2254) of 23 S rRNA in establishing the tertiary structure of the peptidyl transferase center. Single base substitutions were introduced into the P loop, which participates in peptide bond formation through direct interaction with the CCA end of P site-bound tRNA. These mutations altered the pattern of reactivity of RNA to chemical probes in a structural subdomain encompassing the P loop and extending roughly from G2238 to A2433. Most of the effects on chemical modification in the P loop subdomain occurred near sites of tertiary interactions inferred from comparative sequence analysis, indicating that these mutations perturb the tertiary structure of this region of RNA. Changes in chemical modification were also seen in a subdomain composed of the 2530 loop (nucleotides G2529-A2534) and the A loop (nucleotides U2552-C2556), the latter a site of interaction with the CCA end of A site-bound tRNA. Mutations in the P loop induced effects on chemical modification that were commensurate with the severity of their characterized functional defects in peptide bond formation, tRNA binding and translational fidelity. These results indicate that, in addition to its direct role in peptide bond formation, the P loop contributes to the tertiary structure of the peptidyl transferase center and influences the conformation of both the acceptor and peptidyl tRNA binding sites.     

A Pneumocystis carinii group I intron ribozyme that does not require 2' OH groups on its 5' exon mimic for binding to the catalytic core

The recent increase in the population of immunocompromised patients has led to an insurgence of opportunistic human fungal infections. The lack of effective treatments against some of these pathogens makes it important to develop new therapeutic strategies. One such strategy is to target key RNAs with antisense compounds. We report the development of a model system for studying the potential for antisense targeting of group I self-splicing introns in fungal pathogens. The group I intron from the large ribosomal subunit RNA of mouse-derived Pneumocystis carinii has been isolated and characterized. This intron self-splices in vitro. A catalytically active ribozyme, P-8/4x, has been constructed from this intron to allow measurement of dissociation constants for potential antisense agents. At 37 degrees C, in 50 mM Hepes (25 mM Na+), 15 mM MgCl2, and 135 mM KCl at pH 7.5, the exogenous 5' exon mimic r(AUGACU) binds about 60 000 times more tightly to this ribozyme than to r(GGUCAU), a mimic of its complementary binding site on the ribozyme. This enhanced binding is due to tertiary interactions. This tertiary stabilization is increased by single deoxynucleotide substitutions in the exon mimic at every position except for the internal A, which is essentially unchanged. Thus 2' OH groups of the 5' exon mimic do not form stabilizing tertiary interactions with the P-8/4x ribozyme, in contrast to the Tetrahymena L-21 ScaI ribozyme. Furthermore, at 37 degrees C, the exogenous 5' exon mimic d(ATGACT) binds nearly 32 000 times more tightly to the P-8/4x ribozyme than to r(GGUCAU). Therefore, oligonucleotides without 2' OH groups can exploit tertiary stabilization to bind dramatically more tightly and with more specificity than possible from base pairing. These results suggest a new paradigm for antisense targeting: targeting the tertiary interactions of structural RNAs with short antisense oligonucleotides.     

Ribosomal protein L15 as a probe of 50 S ribosomal subunit structure

L15, a 15 kDa protein of the large ribosomal subunit, interacts with over ten other proteins during 50 S assembly in vitro. We have probed the interaction L15 with 23 S rRNA in 50 S ribosomal subunits by chemical footprinting, and have used localized hydroxyl radical probing, generated from Fe(II) tethered to unique sites of L15, to characterize the three-dimensional 23 S rRNA environment of L15. Footprinting of L15 was done by reconstituting purified, recombinant L15 with core particles derived from Escherichia coli 50 S subunits by treatment with 2 M LiCl. The cores migrate as compact 50 S-like particles in sucrose gradients, contain 23 S and 5 S rRNA, and lack a subset of the 50 S proteins, including L15. Using both Fe(II).EDTA and dimethyl sulfate, we have identified a strong footprint for L15 in the region spanning nucleotides 572-654 in domain II of 23 S rRNA. This footprint cannot be detected when L15 is incubated with "naked" 23 S rRNA, indicating that formation of the L15 binding site requires a partially assembled particle.Protein-tethered hydroxyl radical probing was done using mutants of L15 containing single cysteine residues at amino acid positions 68, 71 and 115. The mutant proteins were derivatized with 1-[p-(bromo-acetamido)benzyl]-EDTA. Fe(II), bound to core particles, and hydroxyl radical cleavage was initiated. Distinct but overlapping sets of cleavages were obtained in the footprinted region of domain II, and in specific regions of domains I, IV and V of 23 S rRNA. These data locate L15 in proximity to several 23 S rRNA elements that are dispersed in the secondary structure, consistent with its central role in the latter stages of 50 S subunit assembly. Furthermore, these results indicate the proximity of these rRNA regions to one another, providing constraints on the tertiary folding of 23 S rRNA.     

RNA catalysis

Our understanding of the relationship between the structure of RNA and its catalytic activity has advanced significantly in the past year. These advances include time-resolved crystallographic studies on the hammerhead ribozyme, as well as new structures of a group I intron, a lead(II)-cleavage ribozyme, a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme, and components of the spliceosome machinery and the peptidyl transferase center of the ribosome and, most significantly, the structure of the ribosome itself.     

Crystal structure of a hepatitis delta virus ribozyme

The self-cleaving ribozyme of the hepatitis delta virus (HDV) is the only catalytic RNA known to be required for the viability of a human pathogen. We obtained crystals of a 72-nucleotide, self-cleaved form of the genomic HDV ribozyme that diffract X-rays to 2.3 A resolution by engineering the RNA to bind a small, basic protein without affecting ribozyme activity. The co-crystal structure shows that the compact catalytic core comprises five helical segments connected as an intricate nested double pseudoknot. The 5'-hydroxyl leaving group resulting from the self-scission reaction is buried deep within an active-site cleft produced by juxtaposition of the helices and five strand-crossovers, and is surrounded by biochemically important backbone and base functional groups in a manner reminiscent of protein enzymes.     

Sequence specificity of a group II intron ribozyme: multiple mechanisms for promoting unusually high discrimination against mismatched targets

Group II intron ai5 gamma was reconstructed into a multiple-turnover ribozyme that efficiently cleaves small oligonucleotide substrates in-trans. This construct makes it possible to investigate sequence specificity, since second-order rate constants (kcat/K(m), or the specificity constant) can be obtained and compared with values for mutant substrates and with other ribozymes. The ribozyme used in this study consists of intron domains 1 and 3 connected in-cis, together with domain 5 as a separate catalytic cofactor. This ribozyme has mechanistic features similar to the first step of reverse-splicing, in which a lariat intron attacks exogenous RNA and DNA substrates, and it therefore serves as a model for the sequence specificity of group II intron mobility. To quantitatively evaluate the sequence specificity of this ribozyme, the WT kcat/Km value was compared to individual kcat/Km values for a series of mutant substrates and ribozymes containing single base changes, which were designed to create mismatches at varying positions along the two ribozyme-substrate recognition helices. These mismatches had remarkably large effects on the discrimination index (1/relative kcat/K(m)), resulting in values > 10,000 in several cases. The delta delta G++ for mismatches ranged from 2 to 6 kcal/mol depending on the mismatch and its position. The high specificity of the ribozyme is attributable to effects on duplex stabilization (1-3 kcal/mol) and unexpectedly large effects on the chemical step of reaction (0.5-2.5 kcal/mol). In addition, substrate association is accompanied by an energetic penalty that lowers the overall binding energy between ribozyme and substrate, thereby causing the off-rate to be faster than the rate of catalysis and resulting in high specificity for the cleavage of long target sequences (> or = 13 nucleotides).     

A minor groove RNA triple helix within the catalytic core of a group I intron

Close packing of several double helical and single stranded RNA elements is required for the Tetrahymena group I ribozyme to achieve catalysis. The chemical basis of these packing interactions is largely unknown. Using nucleotide analog interference suppression (NAIS), we demonstrate that the P1 substrate helix and J8/7 single stranded segment form an extended minor groove triple helix within the catalytic core of the ribozyme. Because each triple in the complex is mediated by at least one 2'-OH group, this substrate recognition triplex is unique to RNA and is fundamentally different from major groove homopurine-homopyrimidine triplexes. We have incorporated these biochemical data into a structural model of the ribozyme core that explains how the J8/7 strand organizes several helices within this complex RNA tertiary structure.     

An active domain of the nuclear RNase P RNA

The P10/11-P12 RNA domain of yeast nuclear RNase P RNA has been characterized using genetic and biochemical analysis. This RNA domain contains some of the most conserved nucleotides throughout yeast species and shares considerable homology with the P10-P11-P12 bacterial RNase P RNA domain. Viable yeast variants generated by sequence randomization of the conserved internal loop nucleotides have demonstrated magnesium-sensitive growth defects. Partial purification and characterization of the RNase P holoenzyme from these variants reveals that the mutations affect the catalytic rate of the enzyme and increased magnesium concentrations are required to achieve maximal activity compared to wild type enzyme. Biochemical structure probing has been employed to address the interaction of the RNA domain with magnesium. Several nucleotides within the loop portion of the domain show magnesium-induced changes in reagent accessibility. These include the highly conserved nucleotides shared between yeast and bacteria, which become less accessible in the presence of magnesium. Conversely, accessibility of other regions of the RNA increases. The genetic and biochemical data suggest that the P10/11-P12 RNA domain, and the conserved nucleotides in particular, interacts with magnesium in a manner that affects catalysis by RNase P.     

Modification of primary structures of hairpin ribozymes for probing active conformations

Hairpin ribozymes consist of two stem-loop domains, and these domains are assumed to interact with each other to produce the self-cleavage activity. We have studied the relationship of the tertiary structure of the hairpin ribozyme and the cleavage activity by dividing and re-joining the domains. A hairpin ribozyme (E50) was divided at the hinge region, and the main part was joined to a substrate (S1) using tri- or penta-cytidylates. These ribozymes retained the cleavage activity in the presence of the rest of the molecule, indicating that the active conformation could be maintained if the two domains interacted with each other. Based on the these results, we designed a new type of hairpin ribozyme by replacing one of the domains. To maintain the interaction of the domains, oligocytidylates were inserted at a junction. These reversely jointed ribozyme complexes showed cleavage activity that was dependent on the linker lengths. These modifications in the primary structure of the hairpin ribozyme confirm the structural requirement for the catalytic reaction and provide information for the correlation of the tertiary structure with the cleavage of the hairpin ribozyme.