Electron capture dissociation in a radio frequency ion trap

We report on the first evidence of electron capture dissociation (ECD) in a radio frequency (rf) ion trap. Peptide ions, [substance P]2+, trapped in a two-dimensional, linear rf ion trap were cleaved by electrons injected along the central axis of the trap. Along the axis, the rf field component was zero and a magnetic field of 50 mT was applied. This electron injection scheme keeps the energy of the electrons below 1 eV, preventing them from heating by the rf field. The present ECD efficiency is approximately 4% by irradiation of electron current of 0.2 microA for 80 ms. ECD in rf traps may open high-throughput and low-cost ECD applications to obtain molecular structure information complementary to collision-induced dissociation.     

Two-dimensional ECD FT-ICR mass spectrometry of peptides and glycopeptides

2D FT-ICR MS allows the correlation between precursor and fragment ions by modulating ion cyclotron radii for fragmentation modes with radius-dependent efficiency in the ICR cell without the need for prior ion isolation. This technique has been successfully applied to ion-molecule reactions, Collision-induced dissociation and infrared multiphoton dissociation. In this study, we used electron capture dissociation for 2D FT-ICR MS for the first time, and we recorded two-dimensional mass spectra of peptides and a mixture of glycopeptides that showed fragments that are characteristic of ECD for each of the precursor ions in the sample. We compare the sequence coverage obtained with 2D ECD FT-ICR MS with the sequence coverage obtained with ECD MS/MS and compare the sensitivities of both techniques. We demonstrate how 2D ECD FT-ICR MS can be implemented to identify peptides and glycopeptides for proteomics analysis.     

Phosphopeptide/phosphoprotein mapping by electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry

Of methods for dissociation of multiply charged peptide and protein ions, electron capture dissociation (ECD) has the advantages of cleaving between a high proportion of amino acids, without loss of such posttranslational modifications as glycosylation and carboxylation. Here this capability is successfully extended to phosphorylation, for which collisionally activated dissociation (CAD) can cause extensive loss of H3PO4 and HPO3. As shown here, these losses are minimal in ECD spectra, an advantage for measuring the degree of phosphorylation. For phosphorylated peptides, ECD and CAD spectra give complementary backbone cleavages for identifying modification sites. For a 24-kDa heterogeneous phosphoprotein, bovine beta-casein, activated ion ECD cleaved 87 of 208 backbone bonds that identified a phosphorylation site at Ser-15, and localized three more among Ser-17,-18, -19, and -22 and Thr-24, and the last among four other sites. This is the first direct site-specific characterization of this key post-translational modification on a protein without its prior degradation, such as proteolysis.     

Plasma electron capture dissociation for the characterization of large proteins by top down mass spectrometry

For the backbone dissociation of large (29 kDa) multiply charged protein ions in the gas phase by electron capture, the main experimental challenges are juxtaposition of the electron and ion for efficient capture, dissociation of tertiary noncovalent bonds that prevent product separation, and minimization of secondary electron capture that destroys larger product ions. A simple alternative methodology is described in which electrons (0.03-100 microA, 0.1-15 eV) are first impinged on a gas pulse in the ion cell of a Fourier transform mass spectrometer, followed by ion beam introduction. For carbonic anhydrase, the resulting plasma conditions produce 87% efficiency for electron capture; a single spectrum yields 512 product ions of 237 different masses from cleavage of 183 of the 258 interresidue bonds, while two spectra cleave 197 of these bonds. The problem of secondary dissociation of product ions is reduced by plasma conditions in which product ions are formed near electrons whose velocities are unfavorable and whose capture cross sections no longer have a square dependence on charge. One plasma ECD spectrum of ubiquitin provides its sequence de novo except for two residue pairs. ECD of casein identifies 126 of 208 interresidue cleavages, providing direct and specific characterization of all its 26 Ser/Thr/Tyr phosphorylation sites.     

Determination of peptide topology through time-resolved double-resonance under electron capture dissociation conditions

Characterizing the conformation of biomolecules by mass spectrometry still represents a challenge. With their knotted structure involving a N-terminal macrolactam ring where the C-terminal tail of the peptide is threaded and sterically trapped, lasso peptides constitute an attractive model for developing methods for characterizing gas-phase conformation, through comparison with their unknotted topoisomers. Here, the kinetics of electron capture dissociation (ECD) of a lasso peptide, capistruin, was investigated by electrospray ionization-Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry and compared to that of its branched-cyclic topoisomer, lactam-capistruin. Both peptides produced rather similar ECD spectra but showed different extent of H(?) transfer from c(i)' to z(j)(?) ions. Time-resolved double-resonance experiments under ECD conditions were performed to measure the formation rate constants of typical product ions. Such experiments showed that certain product ions, in particular those related to H(?) transfer, proceeded through long-lived complexes for capistruin, while fast dissociation processes predominated for lactam-capistruin. The formation rate constants of specific ECD product ions enabled a clear differentiation of the lasso and branched-cyclic topoisomers. These results indicate that the formation kinetics of ECD product ions constitute a new way to explore the conformation of biomolecules and distinguish between topoisomers and, more generally, conformers.     

Fragmentation of peptides in MALDI in-source decay mediated by hydrogen radicals

In-source decay (ISD) in matrix-assisted laser desorption/ionization (MALDI) shares some similarities with the novel fragmentation technique electron capture dissociation (ECD). In both reactions, the otherwise strong N-C(alpha) bond is cleaved, forming fragment ions of the c and z types, while labile posttranslational modifications are preserved. Therefore, it is tempting to assume that ISD and ECD have some mechanistic aspects in common. Because electrons are present in the MALDI plume, we investigated the previously suggested possibility that ISD is a variation of ECD. However, experiments with peptides with only one site for efficient protonation revealed that ISD is not caused by electron capture. Instead, ICD seems to be induced by hydrogen atoms generated by a photochemical reaction of the matrix. We provide evidence for this reaction by hydrogen/deuterium exchange experiments with peptides containing a minimal number of exchangeable hydrogen atoms. The hydrogen atom model in ECD is indirectly supported by the proposed fragmentation mechanism for ISD, because our data suggest that hydrogen radicals can induce fragmentation by cleavage of the N-C(alpha) bond, independent from their origin.     

Analytical utility of small neutral losses from reduced species in electron capture dissociation studied using SwedECD database

Small neutral losses from charge-reduced species [M + nH] (( n-1)+* ) is one of the most abundant fragmentation channels in both electron capture dissociation, ECD, and electron transfer dissociation, ETD. Several groups have previously studied these losses on particular examples. Now, the availability of a large (11 491 entries) SwedECD database ( http://www.bmms.uu.se/CAD/indexECD.html) of high-resolution ECD data sets on doubly charged tryptic peptides has made possible a systematic study involving statistical evaluation of neutral losses from [M + 2H] (+ * ) ions. Several new types of losses are discovered, and 16 specific (>94%) losses are characterized according to their specificity and sensitivity, as well as occurrence for peptides of different lengths. On average, there is more than one specific loss per ECD mass spectrum, and two-thirds of all MS/MS data sets in SwedECD contain at least one specific loss. Therefore, specific neutral losses are analytically useful for improved database searching and de novo sequencing. In particular, N and GG isomeric sequences can be distinguished. The pattern of neutral losses was found to be remarkably dissimilar with the losses from radical z* fragment ions: e.g., there is no direct formation of w ions from the reduced species. This finding emphasizes the difference in fragmentation behaviors of hydrogen-abundant and hydrogen-deficient species.     

Strategy for the identification of sites of phosphorylation in proteins: neutral loss triggered electron capture dissociation

We have previously demonstrated the suitability of data-dependent electron capture dissociation (ECD) for incorporation into proteomic strategies. The ability to directly determine sites of phosphorylation is a major advantage of electron capture dissociation; however, the low stoichiometry associated with phosphorylation means that phosphopeptides are often overlooked in data-dependent ECD analyses. In contrast, collision-induced dissociation (CID) tends to result in loss of the labile phosphate group, often at the expense of sequence fragments. Here, we demonstrate a novel strategy for the characterization of phosphoproteins which exploits the neutral loss feature of CID such that focused ECD of phosphopeptides is achieved. Peptides eluting from a liquid chromatograph are first subjected to CID, and if a neutral loss of 98 Da (corresponding to H3PO4) from the precursor is observed, ECD of that same precursor is performed; i.e., the method comprises neutral loss triggered ECD (NL-ECD-MS/MS). The method was applied to tryptic digests of beta-casein and alpha-casein. For alpha-casein, four sites of phosphorylation were identified with NL-ECD-MS/MS compared with a single site identified by ECD-MS/MS. The method also resulted in ECD of a doubly phosphorylated peptide. A further benefit of the method is that overall protein sequence coverage is improved. Sequence information from nonphosphorylated peptides is obtained as a result of the CID step.     

Combined electron capture and infrared multiphoton dissociation for multistage MS/MS in a Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer

We have mounted a permanent on-axis dispenser cathode electron source inside the magnet bore of a 9.4-T Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer. This configuration allows electron capture dissociation (ECD) to be performed reliably on a millisecond time scale. We have also implemented an off-axis laser geometry that enables simultaneous access to ECD and infrared multiphoton dissociation (IRMPD). Optimum performance of both fragmentation techniques is maintained. The analytical utility of performing either ECD or IRMPD on a given precursor ion population is demonstrated by structural characterization of several posttranslationally modified peptides: IRMPD of phosphorylated peptides results in few backbone (b- and y-type) cleavages, and product ion spectra are dominated by neutral loss of H3PO4. In contrast, ECD provides significantly more backbone (c- and z*-type) cleavages without loss of H3PO4. For N-glycosylated tryptic peptides, IRMPD causes extensive cleavage of the glycosidic bonds, providing structural information about the glycans. ECD cleaves all backbone bonds (except the N-terminal side of proline) in a 3-kDa glycopeptide with no saccharide loss. However, only a charge-reduced radical species and some side chain losses are observed following ECD of a 5-kDa glycopeptide from the same protein. An MS3 experiment involving IR laser irradiation of the charge-reduced species formed by electron capture results in extensive dissociation into c- and z-type fragment ions. Mass-selective external ion accumulation is essential for the structural characterization of these low-abundance (modified) peptides.     

Localization of O-glycosylation sites in peptides by electron capture dissociation in a Fourier transform mass spectrometer.

The novel technique electron capture dissociation (ECD) of electrospray generated [M + nH]n+ polypeptide cations produces rapid cleavage of the backbone NH-Ca bond to form c and z ions (in the modified notation of Roepstorff and Fohlman). The potential of the Fourier transform mass spectrometry equipped with ECD in structure analysis of O-glycosylated peptides in the 3 kDa range has been investigated. Totally, 85% of the available interresidue bonds were cleaved in five glycopeptides; more stable c ions accounted for 62% of the observed fragmentation. The c series provided direct evidence on the glycosylation sites in every case studied, with no glycan (GalNAc and dimannose) losses observed from these species. Less stable z ions supported the glycan site assignment, with minor glycan detachments. These losses, as well as the observed formation of even-electron z ions, are attributed to radical-site-initiated reactions. In favorable cases, complete sequence and glycan position information is obtained from a single-scan spectrum. The "mild" character of ECD supports the previously proposed non-ergodic (cleavage prior to energy randomization) mechanism, and the low internal energy increment of fragments.     

Electron capture dissociation of tyrosine O-sulfated peptides complexed with divalent metal cations

We compare electron capture dissociation (ECD) of doubly protonated and divalent metal-adducted tyrosine O-sulfated peptides without basic amino acid residues. ECD of doubly protonated Tyr2-sulfated cholecystokinin (CCKS) and doubly protonated Tyr12-sulfated gastrin II (GST) resulted in complete loss of SO3 from all product ions. Thus, contrary to typical ECD behavior, localization of the sulfate groups was not possible. By contrast, ECD of Ca-, Mn-, Zn-, and Fe-adducted CCKS and ECD of deprotonated GST with two calcium adducts, i.e., [GST + 2Ca - H]3+, resulted in sulfated c'- and z.-type product ions with high sequence coverage, thereby allowing both sequencing and sulfate localization. In addition, divalent metal adduction provided improved positive mode ionization efficiency for these peptides. The drastically different fragmentation behavior observed in ECD of protonated and metal-adducted CCKS and GST, respectively, is proposed to be a consequence of the absence of basic amino acid residues, promoting a mobile proton-like fragmentation mechanism, including abundant sulfate loss, for protonated species. Retention of sulfate groups was also observed in electron detachment dissociation (EDD) of CCKS and GST. However, the EDD fragmentation efficiency was much lower than that of ECD and very limited fragmentation was observed in EDD of GST, precluding localization of the sulfate group in that peptide.     

Electron capture dissociation for structural characterization of multiply charged protein cations

For proteins of < 20 kDa, this new radical site dissociation method cleaves different and many more backbone bonds than the conventional MS/MS methods (e.g., collisionally activated dissociation, CAD) that add energy directly to the even-electron ions. A minimum kinetic energy difference between the electron and ion maximizes capture; a 1 eV difference reduces capture by 10(3). Thus, in an FTMS ion cell with added electron trapping electrodes, capture appears to be achieved best at the boundary between the potential wells that trap the electrons and ions, now providing 80 +/- 15% precursor ion conversion efficiency. Capture cross section is dependent on the ionic charge squared (z2), minimizing the secondary dissociation of lower charge fragment ions. Electron capture is postulated to occur initially at a protonated site to release an energetic (approximately 6 eV) H. atom that is captured at a high-affinity site such as -S-S- or backbone amide to cause nonergodic (before energy randomization) dissociation. Cleavages between every pair of amino acids in mellitin (2.8 kDa) and ubiquitin (8.6 kDa) are represented in their ECD and CAD spectra, providing complete data for their de novo sequencing. Because posttranslational modifications such as carboxylation, glycosylation, and sulfation are less easily lost in ECD than in CAD, ECD assignments of their sequence positions are far more specific.     

Localization of intramolecular monosulfide bridges in lantibiotics determined with electron capture induced dissociation

Electron capture induced dissociation (ECD) and collisionally activated dissociation (CAD) experiments were performed on four lanthionine bridge-containing antibiotics. ECD of lantibiotics produced mainly c and z* ions, as has been observed previously with other peptides, but more interestingly, the less common c* and z ions were observed in abundance in the ECD spectra. These fragments specifically resulted from the cleavage of both a backbone amine bond and the thioether bond in a lanthionine bridge. ECD seemed to induce mainly cleavages near the lanthionine bridges. This fragmentation pattern indicates that lanthionine bridges play a key role in the selectivity of the ECD process. A new mechanism is postulated describing the formation of c* and z ions. Comparative low-energy CAD did not show such specificity. Nondissociative ECD products were quite abundant, suggesting that relatively stable double and triple radicals can be formed in the ECD process. Our results suggest that ECD can be used as a tool to identify the C-terminal attachment site of lanthionine bridges in newly discovered lantibiotics.     

Supplemental activation method for high-efficiency electron-transfer dissociation of doubly protonated peptide precursors

Electron-transfer dissociation (ETD) delivers the unique attributes of electron capture dissociation to mass spectrometers that utilize radio frequency trapping-type devices (e.g., quadrupole ion traps). The method has generated significant interest because of its compatibility with chromatography and its ability to: (1) preserve traditionally labile post-translational modifications (PTMs) and (2) randomly cleave the backbone bonds of highly charged peptide and protein precursor ions. ETD, however, has shown limited applicability to doubly protonated peptide precursors, [M + 2H]2+, the charge and type of peptide most frequently encountered in "bottom-up" proteomics. Here we describe a supplemental collisional activation (CAD) method that targets the nondissociated (intact) electron-transfer (ET) product species ([M + 2H]+*) to improve ETD efficiency for doubly protonated peptides (ETcaD). A systematic study of supplementary activation conditions revealed that low-energy CAD of the ET product population leads to the near-exclusive generation of c- and z-type fragment ions with relatively high efficiency (77 +/- 8%). Compared to those formed directly via ETD, the fragment ions were found to comprise increased relative amounts of the odd-electron c-type ions (c+*) and the even-electron z-type ions (z+). A large-scale analysis of 755 doubly charged tryptic peptides was conducted to compare the method (ETcaD) to ion trap CAD and ETD. ETcaD produced a median sequence coverage of 89%-a significant improvement over ETD (63%) and ion trap CAD (77%).     

Characterization of oligodeoxynucleotides by electron detachment dissociation fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometry

Electron detachment dissociation (EDD), recently introduced by Zubarev and co-workers for the dissociation of multiply charged biomolecular anions via a radical ion intermediate, has been shown to be analogous to electron capture dissociation (ECD) in several respects, including more random peptide fragmentation and retention of labile posttranslational modifications. We have previously demonstrated unique fragmentation behavior in ECD compared to vibrational excitation for oligodeoxynucleotide cations. However, that approach is limited by the poor sensitivity for oligonucleotide ionization in positive ion mode. Here, we show implementation of EDD on a commercial Fourier transform ion cyclotron resonance mass spectrometer utilizing two different configurations: a heated filament electron source and an indirectly heated hollow dispenser cathode electron source. The dispenser cathode configuration provides higher EDD efficiency and additional fragmentation channels for hexamer oligodeoxynucleotides. As in ECD, even-electron d/w ion series dominate the spectra, but we also detect numerous a/z (both even-electron and radical species), (a/z - B), c/x, (c/x - B), and (d/w - B) ions with minimal nucleobase loss from the precursor ions. In contrast to previous high-energy collision-activated dissociation (CAD) and ion trap CAD of radical oligonucleotide anions, we only observe minimum sugar cross-ring cleavage, possibly due to the short time scale of EDD, which limits secondary fragmentation. Thus, EDD provides fragmentation similar to ECD for oligodeoxynucleotides but at enhanced sensitivity. Finally, we show that noncovalent bonding in a DNA duplex can be preserved following EDD, illustrating another analogy with ECD. We believe the latter finding implies EDD has promise for characterization of nucleic acid structure and folding.     

MS/MS simplification by 355 nm ultraviolet photodissociation of chromophore-derivatized peptides in a quadrupole ion trap

Ultraviolet photodissociation (UVPD) of chromophore-modified peptides enhances the capabilities for de novo sequencing in a quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. Attachment of UV chromophores allows efficient photoactivation of not only the precursor ions but also any fragments that retain the chromophore functionality. For doubly protonated peptides, UVPD leads to a vast reduction in MS/MS complexity. The array of b and y ions typically seen upon collisionally activated dissociation is reduced to a single series of either y or b ions by UVPD depending on the location of the chromophore (i.e., N- or C-terminus). The sulfonation reagent Alexa Fluor 350 (AF350) provided the best overall results for the singly and doubly charged peptides by UVPD. The nonsulfonated analogue of AF350, 7-amino-4-methylcoumarin-3-acetic acid, also led to simplified spectra for doubly charged, but not singly charged, peptides by UVPD. Dinitrophenyl-peptides also yielded simplified spectra by UVPD albeit with a small amount of internal fragments accompanying the series of diagnostic y ions. The success of this MS/MS simplification process stems from extensive secondary fragmentation of any chromophore-containing fragments upon exposure to subsequent laser pulses. Energy-variable UVPD reveals that the abundances of non-chromophore-containing y fragment ions increase linearly with laser pulse energy, suggesting secondary dissociation of these species is insignificant. The abundances of chromophore-containing a/b fragment ions follow a quadratic trend due to the extensive secondary fragmentation at higher laser energies or multiple pulses.     

Effects of charge state and cationizing agent on the electron capture dissociation of a peptide

Electron capture dissociation (ECD) is a promising method for de novo sequencing proteins and peptides and for locating the positions of labile posttranslational modifications and binding sites of noncovalently bound species. We report the ECD of a synthetic peptide containing 10 alanine residues and 6 lysine residues uniformly distributed across the sequence. ECD of the (M + 2H)(2+) produces a limited range of c (c(7)-c(15)) and z (z(9)-z(15)) fragment ions, but ECD of higher charge states produces a wider range of c (c(2)-c(15)) and z (z(2)-z(6), z(9)-z(15)) ions. Fragmentation efficiency increases with increasing precursor charge state, and efficiencies up to 88% are achieved. Heating the (M + 2H)(2+) to 150 degrees C does not increase the observed range of ECD fragment ions, indicating that the limited products are due to backbone cleavages occurring near charges and not due to effects of tertiary structure. ECD of the (M + 2Li)(2+) and (M + 2Cs)(2+) produces di- and monometalated analogues of the same c and z ions observed from the (M + 2H)(2+), with the abundance of dimetalated fragment ions increasing with fragment ion mass, a result consistent with the metal cations being located near the peptide termini to minimize Coulombic repulsion. In stark contrast to the ECD results, collisional activation of cesiated dications overwhelmingly results in ejection of Cs(+). The abundance of cesiated fragment ions formed from ECD of the (M + Cs + Li)(2+) exceeds that of lithiated fragment ions by 10:1. ECD of the (M + H + Li)(2+) results in exclusively lithiated c and z ions, indicating an overwhelming preference for neutralization and cleavage at protonated sites over metalated sites. These results are consistent with preferential neutralization of the cation with the highest recombination energy.     

Ion activation in electron capture dissociation to distinguish between N-terminal and C-terminal product ions

We present a method to distinguish N-terminal from C-terminal product ions in electron capture dissociation (ECD) MS/MS due to the change in relative abundances of even-electron (prime) and odd-electron (radical) product ions produced in consecutive ECD and activated ion-ECD mass spectra. The method is based on the rate and direction of hydrogen atom transfer between N-terminal and C-terminal ECD products and its dependence on ion internal energy. We demonstrate that increasing ion internal energy by vibrational activation prior to ECD results in decreased ratio of radical/prime N-terminal product ions (c*/c' ratio), but increased ratio of radical/prime C-terminal product ions (z*/z' ratio) in many cases. The combination of AI-ECD and ECD promises to increase the confidence of mass spectrometry-based peptide sequencing and protein identification.     

Liquid chromatography-atmospheric pressure electron capture dissociation mass spectrometry for the structural analysis of peptides and proteins

Atmospheric pressure electron capture dissociation (AP-ECD) is an emerging technique with the potential to be a more accessible alternative to conventional ECD/electron transfer dissociation (ETD) methods because it can be implemented using a stand-alone ion source device suitable for use with any existing or future electrospray ionization mass spectrometer. With AP-ECD, no modification of the main instrument is required, so it may easily be retrofitted to instruments not originally equipped with ECD/ETD capabilities. Here, we present our first purpose-built AP-ECD source and demonstrate its use in conjunction with capillary LC for the analysis of substance P, a tryptic digest of bovine serum albumin, and a phosphopeptide mixture. Quality ECD spectra were obtained for all the samples at the low femtomole level, proving that LC-AP-ECD-MS is suitable for the structural analysis of peptides and protein digests, in this case using an unmodified quadrupole time-of-flight mass spectrometer built ca. 2002.     

Activated ion electron capture dissociation for mass spectral sequencing of larger (42 kDa) proteins

In previous studies, electron capture dissociation (ECD) has been successful only with ionized smaller proteins, cleaving between 33 of the 153 amino acid pairs of a 17 kDa protein. This has been increased to 99 cleavages by colliding the ions with a background gas while subjecting them to electron capture. Presumably this ion activation breaks intramolecular noncovalent bonds of the ion's secondary and tertiary structure that otherwise prevent separation of the products from the nonergodic ECD cleavage of a backbone covalent bond. In comparison to collisionally activated dissociation, this "activated ion" (AI) ECD provides more extensive, and complementary, sequence information. AI ECD effected cleavage of 116, 60, and 47, respectively, backbone bonds in 29, 30, and 42 kDa proteins to provide extensive contiguous sequence information on both termini; AI conditions are being sought to denature the center portion of these large ions. This accurate "sequence tag" information could potentially identify individual proteins in mixtures at far lower sample levels than methods requiring prior proteolysis.