The Green Bay cesarean section study. IV. The physician factor as a determinant of cesarean birth rates for the large fetus

OBJECTIVES: Our purpose was to determine those factors affecting the route of delivery decisions and the effect of delivery route on maternal and newborn outcomes with the macrosomic fetus. Do higher cesarean rates result in improved newborn outcomes? STUDY DESIGN: A 10-year (1985 to 1994) retrospective data set was used to analyze patients with newborns weighing > or = 4536 and 4000 to 4535 gm at two Green Bay hospitals. Patients with newborns weighing 2500 to 3999 gm were similarly analyzed for comparison purposes. Individual and obstetrician group cesarean rates and newborn and maternal outcomes were identified. RESULTS: Cesarean birth rates for the fetus weighing > 4000 gm were low and varied from 12.8% in the low obstetrician cesarean rate group to 24.0% in the high group. Higher obstetrician group cesarean rates did not result in improved newborn outcomes. Newborn morbidity and mortality were very low but significantly higher for cesarean birth newborns. Maternal complications were fairly low with cesarean birth and rare after vaginal delivery. CONCLUSION: Patients with a suspected macrosomic fetus should be given the same opportunity to achieve a vaginal delivery as patients with smaller fetuses.     

Neonatal outcome depending on the mode of delivery and fetal presentation in twin gestation

A retrospective analysis of 301 twin deliveries managed at The Second Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Warsaw Medical Academy, from January 1, 1986 to December 31, 1995 was undertaken in order to investigate the impact of the mode of delivery and twin presentation on neonatal outcome. Vertex presentation of both twins was the most common with an incidence of 47.5% followed by vertex-non-vertex (27.6%) and nonvertex presentation of the first twin (24.9%). 186 (61.8%) patients delivered vaginally, while 115 (38.2%) women underwent caesarean section including 6 operations performed after the vaginal delivery of the first twin. In vertex presentation of the first twin and breech second twin there was no significant difference in neonatal outcome measured by 5-minute Apgar score and birth trauma incidence between second twins delivered vaginally and second twins delivered by caesarean section. Vaginal delivery with internal podalic version of the second twin in vertex-transverse presentations was related to increased risk of lower 5-minute Apgar score and increased risk of birth trauma occurrence compared to caesarean section. Time interval between vaginal delivery of twins had no significant impact on neonatal outcome.     

The effect of a normal vaginal delivery on anal function

BACKGROUND: To determine the effect of an uncomplicated vaginal delivery on anal sphincter function in primiparous women. METHODS: In a prospective study, anal manometry was performed prenatally and at 4-6 weeks postnatally in 18 primiparous women (11 undergoing vaginal delivery; seven having Cesarean section). No patient had any evidence of anal sphincter damage after delivery as determined by anal ultrasound and pudendal nerve terminal motor latency. RESULTS: Vaginal delivery was associated with a significant reduction in the squeeze pressure (SP: prenatal 269 cm H2O vs postnatal 204 cm H2O; p=0.004) but not the resting pressure (RP: prenatal 96 cm H2O vs postnatal 86 cm H2O; p=0.075). Cesarean section was not associated with any significant change in anal pressures. CONCLUSION: A normal vaginal delivery with no evidence of sphincter injury was associated with a significant effect on anal function when measured 4-6 weeks postnatally.     

Resistance to apoptosis of harringtonine-resistant HL60 cells induced by tetrandrine

BACKGROUND: Elective manual removal of the placenta and routine uterine exploration following vaginal delivery are controversial procedures. Although advocated in the past, little is known about current attitudes and practices related to these procedures. METHODS: Using a mailed questionnaire, we surveyed all 178 Iowa obstetrician-gynecologists and a random sample of 163 Iowa family physicians to determine their practice patterns related to selected aspects of the third stage of labor. The data were analyzed using odds ratios and multiple logistic regression. RESULTS: The analysis was based on answers from 302 physicians. Physicians in the oldest age quartile were three times more likely than physicians in the youngest age quartile to routinely explore the uterus after a vaginal delivery (P < .01). After controlling for specialty, younger physicians were more likely to believe that manual removal of the placenta is a risk factor for endometritis (adjusted odds ratio [OR] 0.7 for each 10-year increase in age, 95% confidence interval [CI] 0.6 to 1.0). Controlling for age, family physicians were more likely than obstetrician-gynecologists to routinely order prophylactic antibiotics after manually removing the placenta (adjusted OR 2.0, 95% CI 1.1 to 3.7). CONCLUSIONS: Both physician age and specialty were associated with selected practice patterns involving the third stage of labor. Older physicians were less likely to believe that manually removing a placenta increases the risk of postpartum endometritis, and they were more likely to routinely explore the uterus after a vaginal delivery.     

Comparison of two low-molecular-weight heparins for the prevention of postoperative venous thromboembolism after elective hip surgery. Reviparin Study Group

BACKGROUND: Many physicians today are employed by another physician, group, hospital, HMO, or other organization. However, the differences in the characteristics, practice patterns, and patient outcomes of self-employed and employed physicians are not well understood. METHODS: The practices of 108 community family physicians in northeast Ohio were assessed using a multimethod cross-sectional design. Physician characteristics were assessed by questionnaire. Direct observation of 3536 consecutive patient visits was used to measure time use and the delivery of preventive services recommended by the US Preventive Services Task Force. Patient satisfaction was assessed with the Medical Outcomes Study (MOS) 9-item Visit Rating Form. RESULTS: Employed physicians were more likely to be female, in group practice, work fewer hours, and see fewer patients. Job satisfaction was similar between the two groups, but employed physicians reported greater satisfaction with leisure and family time. Employed physicians spent more time per patient visit, scheduled a larger percentage of well-care visits, and were more likely to refer to specialists. Employed physicians also spent a greater proportion of their patients' visit time performing history-taking and eliciting family information, and a lesser proportion of time on physical examination, planning treatment, providing health education, and chatting. Recommended screening and health habits counseling preventive services were more likely to be delivered by employed physicians. Patient satisfaction was similar for the two groups. CONCLUSIONS: Primary care physician characteristics and practice patterns differ by employment status. The consequences of the trend toward a largely employed physician workforce as reported in this study should be carefully considered.     

Rural and urban differences in physician resource use for low-risk obstetrics

OBJECTIVE: To explore the hypothesis that rural obstetricians (OBs) and family physicians (FPs) utilized fewer resources during the care of the low-risk women who initially booked with them than did their urban counterparts of the same specialties. DATA SOURCES/STUDY DESIGN: A stratified random sample of Washington state rural and urban OBs and FPs was selected during 1989. A participation rate of 89 percent yielded 209 participating physicians. The prenatal and intrapartum medical records of a random sample of the low-risk patients who initiated care with the sampled providers during a one-year period were abstracted in detail and analyzed with the physician as the unit of analysis. Complete data for 1,683 patients were collected. Resource use elements (e.g., urine culture) were combined by standardizing them with average charge data so that aggregate resource use could be analyzed. Intraspecialty comparisons for resource use by category and overall were performed. FINDINGS/CONCLUSIONS: Results show that rural physicians use fewer overall resources in caring for nonreferred low-risk-booking obstetric patients than do their urban colleagues. Resource use unit expenditures showed the hypothesized pattern for both specialties for total, intrapartum, and prenatal care with the exception of FPs for prenatal care. Approximately 80 percent of the resource units used by each physician type were related to hospital care. No differences were shown in patterns of care for most clinically important aspects of care (e.g., cesarean delivery rates), and no evidence suggested that outcomes differed. The overall differences were due to specific components of care (e.g., fewer intrapartum hospital days and less epidural anesthesia).     

Prognostic relevance of transforming growth factor alpha (TGF-alpha) and tumor necrosis factor alpha (TNF-alpha) detected in breast cancer tissues by immunohistochemistry

BACKGROUND: Reducing inappropriate hospital admissions could lead to lower total health care costs without compromising the quality of care. Research suggests that a sizeable portion of hospital admissions are inappropriate. Other studies indicate that family physicians use health care resources, including hospitalizations, less often than other primary care physicians. To gain additional insight into family physicians' decisions to admit patients, we performed an exploratory study using the Appropriateness Evaluation Protocol, a validated, clinically based utilization review instrument. METHODS: We assessed admissions by community-based and residency-based family physicians to a single university-affiliated hospital during calendar year 1988. A total of 905 patients were admitted to the hospital by family physicians during the study period. Of these, 889 records had complete data. Each was reviewed for appropriateness of admission. We calculated percentages of inappropriate admissions and used logistic regression to ascertain variables that were significant predictors of inappropriateness. RESULTS: Overall, 5.4 percent of admissions were categorized as inappropriate. Omitting obstetric cases, the rate was 10.5 percent. Inappropriate admissions did not cluster around a small number of diagnoses or diagnosis-related groups. Using logistic regression, we found that urgency of admission, patient insurance status, and residency-based physician admission versus community-based physician admission were significant predictors of inappropriate hospital use. Of the inappropriate admissions, 70 percent were so rated because diagnostic procedures or treatments could have been performed on an outpatient basis. CONCLUSIONS: In contrast with other studies for which physician specialty was not controlled, family physicians less frequently admitted patients inappropriately. Predictors of inappropriateness differed from those found in other studies. Changes in hospital systems, in addition to educational efforts directed toward individual physicians, hold promise as a strategy for reducing inappropriate hospital use.     

Repair of postinfarction ventricular septal defects

OBJECTIVES: To assess the impact of breech labor management using the WHO partograph on fetal and maternal outcomes of labor. METHOD: All 1,740 breech presentations in a larger multicenter hospital-based study in South East Asia of the use of the WHO partograph in labor management were studied. The partograph was introduced into each hospital during the study and a before and after analysis of various labor outcomes was conducted. RESULTS: There were 923 breech presentations prior to implementation of the partograph and 817 after. The overall Cesarean section rate was 29.7% (21.6% emergency and 7.6% elective). Introducing the partograph reduced Cesarean sections for multigravida from 27.1% to 19.3% (non-significant) but had no impact on the rate for primigravida (38.5% to 38.7%). Prolonged labor (> 18 hours) was reduced significantly among multigravida and primigravida (p < 0.05), despite a reduced use of oxytocin. Intrapartum stillbirths fell (non-significantly) from 1.9% to 1.1% (all parities combined). Fetal outcome, as measured by intrapartum deaths and Apgar scores < 7 at 1 minute, was significantly better (P < 0.05) when delivery was by Cesarean section rather than vaginally, regardless of use of the partograph. CONCLUSION: The use of the WHO partograph in the management of breech labor reduces prolonged labor and (among multigravida) Cesarean sections and improves fetal outcome. In this study, however, Cesarean section was a safer method of delivery for the baby, regardless of use of the partograph.     

Potential risk factors for vertical HIV-1 transmission in Catalonia, Spain: the protective role of cesarean section. The Working Group on HIV-1 Vertical Transmission in Catalonia

OBJECTIVE: To evaluate the roles of certain potential risk factors on the vertical transmission of HIV-1. DESIGN: Prospective registry of infants born to HIV-1-infected women in Catalonia (north-east Spain) from 1987 to 1992. METHODS: A total of 599 infants, born in Catalan hospitals to 520 women who were identified as being HIV-1-infected during gestation or at delivery, were included. Data on mode of delivery, birth weight, gestational age and breast-feeding as well as the mother's age, her route of HIV-1 infection, clinical stage and p24 antigenaemia, were recorded. HIV-1 infection status of 489 (82%) of the infants was determined according to the criteria of the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Risk estimates and odds ratio (OR) were calculated and logistic regression was performed. RESULTS: The overall rate of vertical transmission was 18.6% (95% confidence interval, 15.2-22.0%). Multivariate analyses revealed that Cesarean section was associated with a lower rate of vertical transmission (OR = 0.3; P = 0.001), as was maternal HIV-1 infection via injecting drug use (OR = 0.44; P = 0.02). Breast-feeding (OR = 6.9; P = 0.001), very low birth weight (< 1500 g; OR = 6.3; P = 0.001) and p24 antigenaemia (OR = 4.6; P = 0.04) were all related to increased risk. The crude rate of HIV-1 transmission was 6% among Cesarean births compared with 21% for infants born via vaginal deliveries. The population-attributable risk for vaginal deliveries was 61.7%. CONCLUSIONS: The results show a protective effect of Cesarean section in the absence of zidovudine prophylaxis. However, current research should be directed towards the individual and combined effects that antiretroviral agents and Cesarean section may have on mother-to-child HIV-1 infection.     

Factors that influence route of delivery--active versus traditional labor management

OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to compare maternal and fetal factors that influence the route of delivery with active management of labor and a traditional labor management protocol. STUDY DESIGN: Data were collected prospectively on 346 consecutive patients receiving active management of labor and 354 patients who were managed traditionally. Within each group demographic and labor characteristics of patients undergoing cesarean section were compared with those of patients having vaginal deliveries by means of the Student t test, chi 2 analysis, and stepwise logistic regression. RESULTS: With both active management of labor and traditional labor management success in achieving vaginal delivery was related to the station of the fetal vertex at admission, the need for oxytocin augmentation of labor, the uterine response to oxytocin, the use of epidural anesthesia, and the development of chorioamnionitis. By means of multiple logistic regression analysis maternal age, height, payor status, and birth weight were also identified as risk factors for cesarean section with traditional labor management but not with active management of labor. CONCLUSIONS: Differences were identified in risk factors for cesarean section between active management and traditional labor management. Active management of labor may diminish or eliminate some patient characteristics as risk factors for cesarean birth.     

Effects of long-term pravastatin treatment on spermatogenesis and on adrenal and testicular steroidogenesis in male hypercholesterolemic patients

STUDY OBJECTIVE: To determine if there are significant differences in birth outcomes and survival for infants delivered by certified nurse midwives compared with those delivered by physicians, and whether these differences, if they exist, remain after controlling for sociodemographic and medical risk factors. DESIGN: Logistic regression models were used to examine differences between certified nurse midwife and physician delivered births in infant, neonatal, and postneonatal mortality, and risk of low birthweight after controlling for a variety of social and medical risk factors. Ordinary least squares regression models were used to examine differences in mean birthweight after controlling for the same risk factors. STUDY SETTING: United States. PATIENTS: The study included all singleton, vaginal births at 35-43 weeks gestation delivered either by physicians or certified nurse midwives in the United States in 1991. MAIN RESULTS: After controlling for social and medical risk factors, the risk of experiencing an infant death was 19% lower for certified nurse midwife attended than for physician attended births, the risk of neonatal mortality was 33% lower, and the risk of delivering a low birthweight infant 31% lower. Mean birthweight was 37 grams heavier for the certified nurse midwife attended than for physician attended births. CONCLUSIONS: National data support the findings of previous local studies that certified nurse midwives have excellent birth outcomes. These findings are discussed in light of differences between certified nurse midwives and physicians in prenatal care and labour and delivery care practices. Certified nurse midwives provide a safe and viable alternative to maternity care in the United States, particularly for low to moderate risk women.     

The effect of physician practice organization on efficient utilization of hospital resources

OBJECTIVE: This study examines variations in the efficient use of hospital resources across individual physicians. DATA SOURCES AND SETTING: The study is conducted over a two-year period (1989-1990) in all short-term general hospitals with 50 or more beds in Arizona. We examine hospital discharge data for 43,625 women undergoing cesarean sections and vaginal deliveries without complications. These data include physician identifiers that permit us to link patient information with information on physicians provided by the state medical association. STUDY DESIGN: The study first measures the contribution of physician characteristics to the explanatory power of regression models that predict resource use. It then tests hypothesized effects on resource utilization exerted by two sets of physician level factors: physician background and physician practice organization. The latter includes effects of hospital practice volume, concentration of hospital practice, percent managed care patients in one's hospital practice, and diversity of patients treated. Efficiency (inefficiency) is measured as the degree of variation in patient charges and length of stay below (above) the average of treating all patients with the same condition in the same hospital in the same year with the same severity of illness, controlling for discharge status and the presence of complications. PRINCIPAL FINDINGS: After controlling for patient factors, physician characteristics explain a significant amount of the variability in hospital charges and length of stay in the two maternity conditions. Results also support hypotheses that efficiency is influenced by practice organization factors such as patient volume and managed care load. Physicians with larger practices and a higher share of managed care patients appear to be more efficient. CONCLUSIONS: The results suggest that health care reform efforts to develop physician-hospital networks and managed competition may promote greater parsimony in physicians' practice behavior.     

Dynamic extension assist splinting of acute central slip lacerations

BACKGROUND: Effective clinical practice guidelines should improve clinical outcomes, and measures of physician use of clinical practice guidelines should correlate with improved outcomes. This study translates a clinical practice guideline on heart failure into review criteria to measure physician performance and the effectiveness of the clinical practice guideline. METHODS: A panel of 11 family physicians and 1 cardiologist systematically reviewed the clinical practice guideline for its clinical importance, educational relevance, and evaluative appropriateness. Then a subset of 4 family physicians rigorously applied each recommendation to established criteria for measurability and developed an evaluation tool useful in medical record review. RESULTS: The heart failure clinical practice guideline was found to be an excellent educational tool. Using it to measure physician performance, however, was limited to diagnostic tests and drug prescribing. Of 45 recommendations, 5 fulfilled criteria for measurability; 1 recommendation had A-level evidence, whereas 2 recommendations had B-level and 2 had C-level evidence. CONCLUSION: This study illustrates the logistic issues and challenges in developing a measure of physician adherence to clinical practice guidelines. Medical record review is inadequate to measure many recommendations. Physicians use of this clinical practice guideline must be evaluated as an intermediate step to measuring the effectiveness of clinical practice guidelines based on patient outcomes.     

Factors associated with the use of flexible sigmoidoscopy as a screening test for the detection of colorectal carcinoma by primary care physicians

BACKGROUND: Despite current recommendations of flexible sigmoidoscopy as a screening test for the detection of colorectal carcinoma, relatively few asymptomatic patients undergo this procedure. To enhance the use of sigmoidoscopy, differences in the use of screening, as well as barriers to screening among specific physician groups, should be defined. METHODS: The authors surveyed 1762 practicing primary care physicians to determine their self-reported ability to perform sigmoidoscopy and perceived obstacles to either initiating or enhancing screening. RESULTS: A total of 884 physicians (50%) responded. Ninety percent of primary care physicians reported that they offered sigmoidoscopic screening to their patients, with 46% referring patients and 44% performing the procedure themselves. Physician characteristics were not associated with the overall use of sigmoidoscopy. In contrast, compared with physicians who referred patients for the procedure, physicians who performed sigmoidoscopy themselves were more often board certified, male, and graduated from medical school after 1970 (P < 0.001). In a multivariate analysis, these characteristics were also independently associated with the ability to perform sigmoidoscopy. The barrier to sigmoidoscopy cited most often was poor patient acceptance, whether or not the physician performed or referred patients for sigmoidoscopic screening. Other barriers cited were lack of training, lack of equipment, and time required, each of which was identified most often by physicians who did not screen at all. CONCLUSIONS: Most physicians surveyed reported using sigmoidoscopic screening to some degree in their practice, although many did not perform the procedure themselves. Population-based interventions to increase screening may benefit from targeting specific physician subgroups and attempting to improve patient acceptance of the procedure.     

Strokes, CVAs, or brain attacks: by any name they need quick attention

BACKGROUND: Excluding sterilization procedures, no experience with laparoscopic procedures in the postpartum period has been reported. The postpartum patient may have unique characteristics that must be recognized for safe management. METHODS: The authors prospectively studied 1,100 consecutive biliary patients in a private surgical practice since the introduction of laparoscopic cholecystectomy (LC). The group includes 34 patients who presented with biliary tract disease and were operated upon within 6 weeks of obstetrical delivery. Laparoscopic procedures were performed on these 34 patients 1 to 42 days following vaginal (26) or Cesarean (8) deliveries. RESULTS: All patients had calculous cholecystitis. Choledocholithiasis was documented in 10 (29%) patients, including 3 patients (9%) with missed common duct stones, and strongly suggested in 5 (15%) others. Open biliary procedures were required for 2 patients. One patient returned to surgery for an ERCP-related complication. Follow up is known for all patients. There were no delayed complications. CONCLUSIONS: The laparoscopic approach to biliary tract disease in the postpartum period is safe. Recent vertical Cesarean incisions can withstand the strain of a reduced pneumoperitoneum. The high incidence of choledocholithiasis calls for routine cholangiography in the postpartum patient.     

Trial of labor in patients with a previous lower uterine vertical cesarean section

OBJECTIVE: Our purpose was to determine the efficacy and safety of a trial of labor in patients previously delivered at least once by a lower uterine vertical cesarean section. STUDY DESIGN: A retrospective review was performed at a single tertiary perinatal center, The University of Florida Health Science Center, Jacksonville. The medical records of all patients with a previous low vertical cesarean section who underwent a trial of labor during a 72-month period from January 1988 until December 1993 were reviewed. The medical records of the next two patients who did not have a prior uterine incision admitted to labor and delivery after the index case served as the controls. The duration and outcome of labor, including mode of delivery, maternal and perinatal morbidity, and birth trauma were evaluated. RESULTS: Of 77 patients with a previous low vertical cesarean incision, 11 (14.3%) had a repeat operation compared with 14 of 154 patients (9.0%) in the no previous cesarean section group (not significant). No differences were noted in the incidences of operative vaginal deliveries or prolonged duration of the first or second stages of labor, or in the rate or maximum dose of oxytocin infusion between the two groups. One patient in the previous cesarean section group had uterine rupture. The incidence of umbilical artery pH < or = 7.20 was similar. No difference in the number of infants with 1- or 5-minute Apgar scores < or = 7 was noted. CONCLUSION: A trial of labor in women with previous low vertical cesarean sections results in an acceptable rate of vaginal delivery and appears safe for both mother and fetus.     

What do physicians know and say about fetal alcohol syndrome: a survey of obstetricians, pediatricians, and family medicine physicians

Pediatricians, obstetricians, and family practice physicians in Michigan were surveyed by mail for their knowledge and opinions about Fetal Alcohol Syndrome (FAS) and Fetal Alcohol Effects (FAE). Physicians said that about 67% of their patients raised questions about drinking during pregnancy but only 2% specifically referred to FAS or FAE. Most physicians were uncertain about whether their colleagues were sufficiently aware of FAS, whether FAS could be diagnosed at birth, or if physicians were acquainted with the syndrome's major criteria. However, most believed FAS was not being overdiagnosed and believed that making a diagnosis of FAS at birth could lead to improved treatment of an affected child. Physicians also believed that physician counseling was a more effective way of reducing the incidence of FAS/FAE than warning labels. Forty-one percent of the physicians placed the threshold for FAS at one to three drinks per day and 38% placed the threshold at one or fewer drinks a day. Thirty-five percent placed the estimated incidence of FAS at 1 to 2 per 1000 in the United States. We conclude that physicians are in relative agreement about the effects of drinking during pregnancy and the value of physician counseling but are misguided as to what constitutes a true risk level of drinking as far as the etiology of FAS is concerned.