Thermal comfort in office buildings: Two case studies commented

Air conditioning in offices has become a current practice in North Western Europe. The main reasons for that are high internal loads, solar gains and increased comfort expectations. Hence, the move away from the naturally ventilated cellular office increased thermal comfort complaints.     

湖南某大学校园建筑环境热舒适调查研究

对湖南某大学校园内建筑的环境热舒适度进行了现场调查和分析,采取现场测试与问卷调查相结合的方法。共测试了20间教室和5间学生宿舍,收集问卷调查表1273份。发现温度、风速、着衣热阻等参数对热舒适有明显的影响,但相对湿度对热舒适的影响不大。学生可接受的作用温度范围比ASHRAE标准规定的舒适区温度范围要宽得多,PMV指标与实际情况存在较大差别。讨论了适应性问题,推导出了室内舒适温度与室外平均温度之间的关系式,并将所得结果与其他研究成果进行了比较。     

Comparison of thermal comfort algorithms in naturally ventilated office buildings

With the actual environmental issues of energy savings in buildings, there are more efforts to prevent any increase in energy use associated with installing air-conditioning systems. The actual standard of thermal comfort in buildings ISO 7730 is based on static model that is acceptable in air-conditioned buildings, but unreliable for the case of naturally ventilated buildings. The different field studies have shown that occupants of naturally ventilated buildings accept and prefer a significantly wider range of temperatures compared to occupants of air-conditioned buildings. The results of these field studies have contributed to develop the adaptive approach. Adaptive comfort algorithms have been integrated in EN15251 and ASHRAE standards to take into account the adaptive approach in naturally ventilated buildings. These adaptive algorithms seem to be more efficient for naturally ventilated buildings, but need to be assessed in field studies. This paper evaluates different algorithms from both static and adaptive approach in naturally ventilated buildings across a field survey that has been conducted in France in five naturally ventilated office buildings. The paper presents the methodology guidelines, and the thermal comfort algorithms considered. The results of application of different algorithms are provided with a comparative analysis to assess the applied algorithms.     

Thermal study of school buildings in winter conditions

In this paper, a thermal study of a school building with real occupation levels in winter conditions is presented and a software that evaluates the air quality and simulates the thermal response of buildings with complex topology in steady-state and transient conditions is used. After validation, the numerical model is used, in the first phase, to evaluate the occupants’ comfort levels in several spaces, while in the second phase two solutions, to improve acceptable thermal comfort and air quality levels (1) the electric air-heating systems, with predicted mean vote control, and (2) three solar collectors, placed instead of the roof area, used to heat the air in uncomfortable spaces are studied.     

Thermal comfort study of Kerala traditional residential buildings based on questionnaire survey among occupants of traditional and modern buildings

Thermal comfort studies on traditional residential buildings of Kerala that is known for its use of natural and passive methods for a comfortable indoor environment, are under progress. Scientific analyses of the environmental parameters determining thermal comfort have already been reported. Similar studies on modern residential buildings are underway. In order to compare the results of the scientific analysis with the user responses from the residents of traditional as well as modern residential buildings, a questionnaire survey was conducted during various seasons such as winter, summer and monsoon. A questionnaire was prepared in detail to understand the effect of factors which affect thermal comfort such as temperature, humidity and air flow in the evaluation of thermal comfort. This paper is based on the compilation of responses from the conducted survey. A comparison of the study results with that of scientific analysis already reported is also incorporated at the end of this paper. This study further confirms that Kerala traditional residential buildings are very effective in providing comfortable indoor environment irrespective of various seasons.     

Thermal comfort in naturally ventilated buildings in hot-humid area of China

Human responses to thermal environments in naturally ventilated (NV) buildings in hot-humid area of China were systematically investigated in the present study. Thirty local inhabitants long-time living in NV buildings participated in the study and reported their thermal sensations and perceptions and adaptive behaviors while all physical and personal variables were collected. Based on a year-long survey, a close match of indoor physical variables and occupants’ clothing insulation with outdoor climate was found as an important feature of NV buildings. Integrated indices can capture more thermal contexts in the NV buildings in hot-humid area of China than simple indices. Thermal sensation was found to be a good linear function of SET* with the thermal neutrality of 25.4 °C and the 90% (80%) acceptable range of 23.5–27.4 °C (22.1–28.7 °C) in SET*. The adaptive evidences were obtained for clothing adjustment, window opening and using fan respectively and the modified PMV model was validated to be applicable in NV buildings in hot-humid area of China with an expectancy factor of 0.822. Comparisons with other field studies indicate that people can develop various human-environment relationships through thermal adaptation to local climate, resulting in different thermal neutral temperatures in various climates. The subjects in hot-humid area of China are more acclimated and tolerable with hot and humid environments and more uncomfortable and intolerable with cold environments while compared with those in temperate climates.     

Dynamic evaluation of thermal comfort environment of air-conditioned buildings

In this paper, based upon Fanger's thermal comfort concept, several concepts, which utilize computing results obtained from the large eddy simulation (LES), are put forward, such as thermal comfort index based on time-averaged parameters, instantaneous thermal index, time-averaged thermal comfort index and time-averaged thermal comfort index along walking routes. Also their discrepancies and calculation methods are discussed in the paper. Apart from these, we have calculated PD value as an example, whose results indicate that the distributions of four indices are obviously different. Therefore, it is suggested to distinguish different cases and select correspondingly thermal comfort evaluation indices while considering the question of thermal comfort.     

Derivation of the adaptive equations for thermal comfort in free-running buildings in European standard EN15251

The equation for thermal comfort for buildings in the free-running mode (Annexe A2) in European Standard EN15251 rests on the data collected in the EU project Smart Controls and Thermal Comfort (SCATs). Many of these data were from naturally ventilated office buildings which were in free-running mode outside the heating season. Using the data from these buildings a relationship between indoor comfort and outdoor climate was developed for free-running buildings. This paper describes the data and the methods of analysis used to estimate the comfort conditions in the variable environment of free-running buildings. The paper also describes how the indoor comfort conditions were related to the running mean of the outdoor temperature, and addresses the effects of air movement and humidity. The paper considers the proportions of people likely to be comfortable if the temperature differs from the neutral temperature. The differences between the adaptive comfort charts in EN15251 and ASHRAE 55-2004 are discussed.     

Parametric study on the performance of green residential buildings in China

The parametric study of the indoor environment of green buildings focuses on the quantitative and qualitative improvement of residential building construction in China and the achievement of indoor thermal comfort at a low level of energy use. This study examines the effect of the adaptive thermal comfort of indoor environment control in hot summer and cold winter (HSCW) zones. This work is based on a field study of the regional thermal assessment of two typical cases, the results of which are compared with simulated results of various scenarios of “energy efficiency” strategy and “healthy housing” environmental control. First, the simulated results show that the adaptive thermal comfort of indoor environment control is actually balanced in terms of occupancy, comfort, and energy efficiency. Second, adaptive thermal comfort control can save more energy for heating or cooling than other current healthy housing environmental controls in China's HSCW zone. Moreover, a large proportion of energy use is based on the subjective thermal comfort demand of occupants in any building type. Third, the building shape coefficient cannot dominate energy savings. The ratio of the superficial area of a building to the actual indoor floor area has a significant positive correlation with and affects the efficiency of building thermal performance.     

高校学生宿舍夏季热舒适研究

以西安某高校学生宿舍为研究对象,现场测试了宿舍内的温度和相对湿度等参数。通过问卷调查了学生对室内热环境的主观热感觉。研究结果表明,学生宿舍内的热环境处于ASHRAE给定的舒适区之外,80%以上的学生对室内热环境表示不满;但调查结果显示学生对室内热环境有一定的适应性。     

Virtual Building Dataset for energy and indoor thermal comfort benchmarking of office buildings in Greece

The knowledge of building stock energy data of a country is a very significant tool for energy benchmarks establishment, energy rating procedures and building classification boundaries determination, according to the Directive 2002/91/EC and its implementation in EU Member States. The lack of building energy databases in many EU Countries, including Greece, and the difficulties of collecting them lead to the investigation of other potential solutions. The aim of this paper is to present a method of a Virtual Building Dataset (VBD) creation for office buildings in Greece. The philosophy of VBD is based on the creation and simulation of random office buildings that could be found or built in Greece, taking into account the Greek constructional and operational characteristics of office buildings and Greek legislation. The VBD consists of 30,000 buildings (10,000 in each climatic zone) with their detailed constructional and operational data and of their simulation outputs: the annual specific energy consumption for heating, cooling, artificial lighting, office equipment and an indoor thermal comfort indicator. Based on VBD results the energy and indoor thermal comfort benchmarks for office building sector in Greece are assessed and presented.     

Using the adaptive model of thermal comfort for obtaining indoor neutral temperature: Findings from a field study in Hyderabad,India

There is a dearth of thermal comfort studies in India. It is aimed to investigate into the aspects of thermal comfort in Hyderabad and to identify the neutral temperature in residential environments. This was achieved through a thermal comfort field study in naturally ventilated apartment buildings conducted during summer and monsoon involving over 100 subjects. A total of 3962 datasets were collected covering their thermal responses and the measurement of the thermal environment. The comfort band (voting within –1 and +1), based on the field study, was found to be 26–32.45°C, with the neutral temperature at 29.23°C. This is way above the indoor temperature standards specified in Indian Codes. It was found that the regression neutral temperature and the globe temperature recorded when voting neutral converged when mean thermal sensation of the subjects was close to 0. This happened during the period of moderate temperature when the adaptive measures were adequate. The indoor temperatures recorded in roof-exposed (top floor) flats were higher than the lower floors. The thermal sensation and preference votes of subjects living in top floors were always higher. Consequently, their acceptance vote was also lower. It was found that the subjects living in top floor flats had a higher neutral temperature when the available adaptive opportunities were sufficient. This was due to their continuous exposure to a higher thermal regime due to much higher solar exposure. This study calls for special adaptive measures for roof-exposed flats to achieve neutrality at higher temperature.     

Simulation of energy use, human thermal comfort and office work performance in buildings with moderately drifting operative temperatures

Annual primary energy use in a central module of an office building consisting of two offices separated with a corridor was estimated by means of dynamic computer simulations. The simulations were conducted for conventional all-air VAV ventilation system and thermo active building system (TABS) supplemented with CAV ventilation. Simulations comprised moderate, hot–dry and hot–humid climate. Heavy and light wall construction and two orientations of the building (east–west and north–south) were considered. Besides the energy use, also capability of examined systems to keep a certain level of thermal comfort was examined. The results showed that with the moderate climate, the TABS decreased the primary energy use by about 16% as compared with the VAV. With hot–humid climate, the portion of the primary energy saved by TABS was ca. 50% even with the supply air dehumidification taken into account. The TABS working in a moderate climate kept the predicted percentage of dissatisfied (PPD) <10% during 60–80% of the working hours per year. Optimization of the TABS's control strategy (circulation pump dead-band, water supply temperature) resulted in significant reduction of the annual working hours with PPD > 10%; 1.4% in comparison to 17.5% h/yr. The highest estimated loss of occupants’ productivity related to their thermal sensation hasn’t exceeded 1% in whole year average.     

电热膜供暖的热舒适性分析

通过对低温辐射电热膜供暖系统的温度场和热舒适性的分析，指出目前在我国住宅中采用的单片功率为20W的电热膜，会导致室内PMV过大，造成温度过高而使人感到不舒适。建议开发单片功率较小的电热膜用于顶棚敷设。     

热舒适、健康与环境

从生理学、心理学角度分析了热舒适产生的过程，探讨了热舒适、健康及环境之间的关系。指出稳定、舒适的环境不一定有利于健康，它削弱了人体适应环境的能力。空调环境的相对稳定的低温可能是导致不舒适的一个原因。交替生活在室内外两种差异较大的环境可能会给人的生理、心理及适应能力带来影响。     

我国湿热地区自然通风建筑热舒适与热适应现场研究

在2008—2009年为期1年的广州某高校自然通风建筑现场调研的基础上,对23周共计921人次的调研数据在热环境、人体热反应及适应行为等方面进行了分析,得到了我国湿热地区典型自然通风建筑的室内热环境全年变化特征,获取了热感觉与标准有效温度的确定关系,验证了修正的PMV模型的适用性,分析得到我国湿热地区自然通风建筑的期望因子为0.8,同时获得了调整服装、开窗与使用风扇等适应行为的变化规律。     

大空间建筑室内气流组织数值模拟与舒适性分析

分别对采用百叶侧送侧回、喷口侧送侧回、散流器顶送下回、分层空调、置换通风方式的大空间建筑空调室内气流的速度场和温度场进行了数值模拟,并对其结果进行了实验验证。根据ADPI指标对这几种送回风方式进行了热舒适性评价.结果表明,分层空调和置换通风是大空间建筑中较好的气流组织方式。     

Thermal comfort evaluation of naturally ventilated public housing in Singapore

Field survey was conducted to evaluate thermal comfort perception of the occupants in naturally ventilated public housing in Singapore. Thermal acceptability assessment was performed to find out whether the naturally ventilated indoor environment meets the ASHRAE Standard-55's 80% acceptability criteria. The study investigated whether thermal perception was influenced by different sessions of the day, building height, and flat types. Comparative analysis of thermal sensation and thermal comfort votes revealed that a high proportion of people experiencing sensations of +2,+3 still found the conditions to be comfortable. The survey also examined the adaptive behavior of the occupants in the usage of climatic control such as windows, fans and air-conditioning to modify the indoor environment.     

Indoor thermal conditions and thermal comfort in air-conditioned domestic buildings in the dry-desert climate of Kuwait

The summer season in the state of Kuwait is long with a mean daily maximum temperature of 45 °C. Domestic air conditioning is generally deployed from the beginning of April to the end of October. This accounts for around 75% of Kuwaiti electrical power consumption. In terms of energy conservation, increasing the thermostat temperature by 1 °C could save about 10% of space cooling energy 1 and 2. However, knowledge of indoor domestic temperatures and thermal comfort sensations is important to aid future advice formulation and policy-making related to domestic energy consumption. A field study was therefore conducted during the summers of 2006 and 2007 to investigate the indoor climate and occupants' thermal comfort in 25 air-conditioned domestic buildings in Kuwait. The paper presents statistical data about the indoor environmental conditions in Kuwait domestic residences, together with an analysis of domestic-occupant thermal comfort sensations. With respect to the latter, a total of 111 participants provided 111 sets of physical measurements together with subjective information via questionnaires that were used to collect the data. By using linear regression analysis of responses on the ASHRAE-seven-point thermal sensation scale, the neutral operative temperatures based on Actual Mean Vote (AMV) and Predicted Mean Vote (PMV) were found to be 25.2 °C and 23.3 °C, respectively, in the summer season. Findings from this study provide information about the indoor domestic thermal environment in Kuwait, together with occupant thermal comfort sensations. This knowledge can contribute towards the development of future energy-related design codes for Kuwait.     

我国湿热地区自然通风建筑夏季热舒适研究——以广州为例

2008年夏季对广州某高校学生在自然通风建筑中进行了501人次的热舒适现场调查,调查内容包括热感觉、热舒适度、热可接受度及潮湿感,并对相应的室内干球温度、相对湿度、黑球温度和风速等热环境参数进行了测试记录。通过对数据的整理分析发现,自然通风建筑的夏季室内温湿度均高于ASHRAE标准的舒适区域,但人们对该环境有较好的适应性。调查结果表明,我国湿热地区自然通风建筑的热中性温度为28.1℃(ET*=29.3℃),可接受的热环境温度的上限为29.7℃(ET*=30.9℃),相对湿度上限为78%。