Cost-benefit analysis of the use of TBT: the case for a treatment approach

The current climate of hostility towards the use of tributyltin (TBT) as an active ingredient in ship anti-fouling paint appears to be based on a very biased assessment of its environmental impact. While many national and international regulatory agencies are moving towards further restriction, and a complete ban is under active discussion, a number of factors appear to have been ignored. The economic impact of a ban on TBT when no adequate substitute exists could be substantial. Environmentally, consequences would include a substantial increase in the consumption of fossil fuel, with corresponding increases in carbon dioxide and sulphur dioxide emissions; the construction of more vessels; the transfer of ship-building, ship-repairing and ship-breaking activities from well-regulated to unregulated or under-regulated areas in the developing world; and a shift from sea transport to less environmentally acceptable forms of transport. Experience in Europe and other parts of the developed world shows that existing restrictions, where they are properly enforced, are probably adequate to alleviate the environmental damage associated with TBT. Some existing legislation acts to inhibit the search for effective substitutes. The environmental benefits of TBT have been ignored. Little thought has been given to a technical, rather than a legislative solution to controlling TBT inputs to the environment. A method is described for treating TBT-contaminated wastewaters, which has been successfully tested in prototype at full scale. Legislative measures against TBT will do nothing to address the problem of the existing backlog of contaminated material, nor even to permit the IMO proposal for the removal of TBT from all ships by 2008 to be successfully concluded in an environmentally safe manner, since no provision has been made for the disposal of the existing TBT; most probably it will be dumped in environmentally sensitive, unregulated areas in the developing world.     

Treatment of poultry manure wastewater using a rotating biological contactor

A pilot scale, six stage rotating biological contactor was used to evaluate the feasibility of this process for the stabilization of liquid animal manures. Total disc surface area was approx. 16.7 m². Treatment efficiencies were determined at various waste strengths and influent flow rates.With loading rates of 14.7–322 g m⁻² day⁻¹, the average COD reduction was 61%. With loading rates of 4.88-24.4 g m⁻² day⁻¹, the average BOD₅ reduction was 87%. Total nitrogen removal averaged approximately 30% for the entire study. Mixed liquor oxygen uptake rates were generally in excess of 80 mg 1⁻¹ h⁻¹.Clarified effluent was non-odorous and suitable to be reused for manure flushing or spray irrigation. Treatment was not sufficient to permit effluent discharge to surface waters.     

Predictions of nitrate diffusion in sediment using horizontal attenuated total reflection (HATR) by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometry

Using a novel and simple method based on horizontal attenuated total reflection (HATR) by Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectrometry, the effective diffusion coefficient, De, of nitrate in a contaminated anthropogenic sediment was estimated as 7.34 x 10(-6)cm2 s(-1). This method, which requires as little as 1 mL of sediment sample, was able to measure the De of a chemical species with a reproducibility of +/-3% in about 5h. Based on this De and a pre-determined nitrate reduction rate, the profiles of nitrate concentration in two sediment columns were satisfactorily predicted from a mathematical model. Results showed that the profile in this aged sediment depended mainly on the diffusion of nitrate and, only to a much lesser degree, the rate of nitrate reduction. Measurements in 55 anthropogenic sediment samples collected from five locations and various depths of a contaminated site further showed that the De of nitrate increased linearly with the water content of the sediment, but decreased with the sediment density. The technique demonstrated in this study shall be applicable for the risk assessment of toxic pollutants in contaminated sediments, and for planning the spatial and time intervals of nitrate injection strategy in bioremediation.     

Effect of surfactants on the determination of aluminium in waters

Eleven surfactants representing pure cationic, anionic and nonionic detergents, four commercial detergents, sodium pyrophosphate, sodium tripolyphosphate, a soap and nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA) were investigated for their effect on the determination of aluminium in water using the eriochrome cyanine R, ferron-orthophenanthroline and chrome azurol S methods. Cationic, anionic and nonionic detergents at concentrations up to 2, 100 and 1000 mg l⁻¹, respectively, did not interfere. Sodium tripolyphosphate interfered badly above 1.0 mg l⁻¹, and therefore the interference by formulated detergents containing tripolyphosphate was serious. Concentrations of NTA, soap and sodium pyrophosphate had to be below 0.5, 10 and 20 mg l⁻¹, respectively, to limit the error to 5%.     

Formation of alkylated aromatic acids in groundwater by anaerobic degradation of alkylbenzenes

Evidence for the presence of previously unreported alkylated aromatic acids in anaerobic groundwater samples from a jet fuel-contaminated site is presented. The redox conditions are dominated by sulfate reduction. A gas chromatography/mass spectrometry screening showed a composition of aromatic hydrocarbons ranging from BTEX (C(0)-C(2)-substituted benzenes) up to C(7)-benzenes. Known metabolites like methylbenzoates (C(1)-BA), C(2)-BA, C(3)-BA as well as methylbenzylsuccinates (C(1)-BSA) were detected. Additionally, previously unreported metabolites of higher alkylated benzenes have been identified in the extracts: those are C(2)-BSA to C(5)-BSA as well as C(4)-BA to C(6)-BA, which were detected in the microg/l-concentration range. The formation of C(1)- and C(2)-BSA as well as the C(1)- and C(2)-BA can be linked to structurally corresponding parent contaminants like the xylene isomers and the trimethylbenzene isomers. The C(3)-BSA and C(3)-BA represent metabolites of C(4)-benzenes. The occurrence of C(4)-C(5)-BSA and C(4)-C(6)-BA is attributed to C(5)-C(7)-benzenes acting as parent compounds. The concentration of total aromatic contaminants decreased along the plume centre line. In contrast, benzoates and benzylsuccinates (BA and BSA) showed constant concentrations over a distance of 84 m. BA concentrations were up to 162 times higher compared to BSA, as indicated by the ratio f(BA/BSA). A pronounced transient behaviour of BSA or an overall persistent behaviour of BA can explain this. Hence, along the plume centre line, f(BA/BSA) was constant over a distance of 128 m. The degradation products detected in a monitoring well are not necessarily tied to contaminants detected in that well. Therefore, the metabolite plume is partly located in front of the contaminant plume, but does not significantly migrate downstream the plume toe.     

Radon and 'King Solomon's Miners': Faynan Orefield, Jordanian Desert

Concentrations of 222Rn were measured in ancient copper mines which exploited the Faynan Orefield in the South-Western Jordanian Desert. The concentrations of radon gas detected indicate that the ancient metal workers would have been exposed to a significant health risk and indicate that any future attempt to exploit the copper ores must deal with the hazard identified. Seasonal variations in radon concentrations are noted and these are linked to the ventilation of the mines. These modern data are used to explore the differential exposure to radon and the health of ancient mining communities.     

Arsenic and heavy metals in soils associated with regional geochemical anomalies in South-West England

Regional geochemical maps have shown extensive anomalies of arsenic, copper and other heavy metals in those parts of South-West England associated with mineralised zones around the granite intrusion. Studies in the vicinity of the River Tamar and of the metamorphic aureole around Dartmoor have confirmed significantly higher concentrations of arsenic and heavy metals in soils contaminated by mining, smelting and mineralisation compared with those from nearby control areas. Arsenic and copper show the greatest degree of enhancement ranging up to 900 ppm As and 2000 ppm Cu in both alluvial and upland topsoils within the Tamar area. Preliminary analyses indicate that the trace metal content of pasture herbage-reflects in part the degree of soil contamination. Maximum concentrations of 35 ppm As and 22 ppm Cu in autumn sampled herbage were found at contaminated sites compared with mean values of less than 0.5 ppm As and 8 ppm Cu in control areas. Geochemical reconnaissance surveys based on stream sediment sampling provide a useful indication of areas wherein widescale soil contamination may occur.     

Influences of iron, manganese, and dissolved organic carbon on the hypolimnetic cycling of amended mercury

The biogeochemical cycling of iron, manganese, sulfide, and dissolved organic carbon were investigated to provide information on the transport and removal processes that control the bioavailability of isotopic mercury amended to a lake. Lake profiles showed a similar trend of hypolimnetic enrichment of Fe, Mn, DOC, sulfide, and the lake spike ((202)Hg, purity 90.8%) and ambient of pools of total mercury (HgT) and methylmercury (MeHg). Hypolimnetic enrichment of Fe and Mn indicated that reductive mobilization occurred primarily at the sediment-water interface and that Fe and Mn oxides were abundant within the sediments prior to the onset of anoxia. A strong relationship (r(2)=0.986, n=15, p<0.001) between filterable Fe and Mn indicated that reduction of Fe and Mn hydrous oxides in the sediments is a common in-lake source of Fe(II) and Mn(II) to the hypolimnion and that a consistent Mn:Fe mass ratio of 0.05 exists in the lake. A strong linear relationship of both the filterable [Fe] (r(2)=0.966, n=15, p<0.001) and [Mn] (r(2)=0.964, n=15, p<0.001) to [DOC] indicated a close linkage of the cycles of Fe and Mn to DOC. Persistence of iron oxides in anoxic environments suggested that DOC was being co-precipitated with Fe oxide and released into solution by the reductive dissolution of the oxide. The relationship between ambient and lake spike HgT (r(2)=0.920, n=27, p<0.001) and MeHg (r(2)=0.967, n=23, p<0.001) indicated that similar biogeochemical processes control the temporal and spatial distribution in the water column. The larger fraction of MeHg in the lake spike compared to the ambient pool in the hypolimnion suggests that lake spike may be more available for methylation. A linear relationship of DOC to both filterable ambient HgT (r(2)=0.406, n=27, p<0.001) and lake spike HgT (r(2)=0.314, n=15, p=0.002) suggest a role of organic matter in Hg transport and cycling. However, a weak relationship between the ambient and lake spike pools of MeHg to DOC indicated that other processes have a major role in controlling the abundance and distribution of MeHg. Our results suggest that Fe and Mn play important roles in the transport and cycling of ambient and spike HgT and MeHg in the hypolimnion, in part through processes linked to the formation and dissolution of organic matter-containing Fe and Mn hydrous oxides particles.