Interpretation d'une controverse scientifique : Strategies argumentatives d'adolescentes et d'adolescents quebecois

Résumé

Actualiser la rhétorique scolaire courante sur les sciences et en présenter une vision plus controversée constitue un enjeu éducatif important en vue de préparer les jeunes du secondaire à débattre de manière éclairée autour d'enjeux sociotechniques contemporains. Pour documenter la manière dont de jeunes québécois et québécoises argumentent autour d'une vision socialisée des sciences, nous avons demandé à sept groupes de trois sujets d'interpréter un débat polémique entre deux scientifiques autour de la question du réchauffement climatique planétaire. Nous présentons dans cet article des extraits de l'analyse argumentative de l'un de ces entretiens. Ces jeunes se sont montrés capables de discuter de questions d'épistémologie et de sociologie de sciences. La conception réaliste et empùïste qui oriente leurs discours sur les sciences rend cependant difficilement admissible l'existence même du désaccord en question. Certains moments de complexification conceptuelle ont cependant émergé en cours de discussion, ce qui nous permet de penser que le type de vignette utilisé dans cette recherche pourrait être transposé en classe afin d'initier des discussions fécondes autour de matières controversées en sciences. De la même manière, les outils d'analyse argumentative mis en ?uvre pourraient être réinvestis avec des élèves pour cerner certaines idées courantes sur les sciences et en questionner la légitimité, favorisant ainsi le développement d'un regard plus averti sur ces dernières.     

Linguistic frequent pattern mining using a compressed structure

Traditional association-rule mining (ARM) considers only the frequency of items in a binary database, which provides insufficient knowledge for making efficient decisions and strategies. The mining of useful information from quantitative databases is not a trivial task compared to conventional algorithms in ARM. Fuzzy-set theory was invented to represent a more valuable form of knowledge for human reasoning, which can also be applied and utilized for quantitative databases. Many approaches have adopted fuzzy-set theory to transform the quantitative value into linguistic terms with its corresponding degree based on defined membership functions for the discovery of FFIs, also known as fuzzy frequent itemsets. Only linguistic terms with maximal scalar cardinality are considered in traditional fuzzy frequent itemset mining, but the uncertainty factor is not involved in past approaches. In this paper, an efficient fuzzy mining (EFM) algorithm is presented to quickly discover multiple FFIs from quantitative databases under type-2 fuzzy-set theory. A compressed fuzzy-list (CFL)-structure is developed to maintain complete information for rule generation. Two pruning techniques are developed for reducing the search space and speeding up the mining process. Several experiments are carried out to verify the efficiency and effectiveness of the designed approach in terms of runtime, the number of examined nodes, memory usage, and scalability under different minimum support thresholds and different linguistic terms used in the membership functions.

     

Influences of processing conditions on mechanical properties of recycled epoxy-anhydride vitrimers

The chemically crosslinked network structures make epoxies, the most common thermosets, unable or hard to be recycled, causing environmental problems and economic losses. Epoxy-based vitrimers, polymer networks deriving from epoxy resins, can be thermally malleable according to bond exchange reactions (BERs), opening the door to recycle epoxy thermosets. Here a series of experiments were carried out to study the effects of processing conditions (such as particle size distributions, temperature, time, and pressure) on recycling of an epoxy-anhydride vitrimer. Polymer powders from the epoxy-anhydride vitrimer with different size distributions were prepared and characterized, and the influence of particle size on the mechanical performance of recycled epoxy-anhydride vitrimers was investigated by dynamic mechanical analysis and uniaxial tensile test. Experimental results demonstrated that finer polymer powders can increase the contacting surfaces of recycled materials and thus result in high quality of recycled materials. In addition, the influences of other treating parameters, such as temperature, time, and pressure, were also discussed in this study. Adjusting these treating parameters can help the design of an optimized reprocessing procedure to meet practical engineering applications.     

A thermomechanical constitutive model for an epoxy based shape memory polymer and its parameter identifications

This paper presents a three-dimensional (3D) finite deformation thermomechanical model to study the glass transition and shape memory behaviors of an epoxy based shape memory polymer (SMP) (Veriflex E) and a systematic material parameter identification scheme from a set of experiments. The model was described by viscoelastic elements placed in parallel to represent different active relaxation mechanisms around glass transition temperature in the polymer. A set of standard material tests was proposed and conducted to identify the model parameter values, which consequently enable the model to reproduce the experimentally observed shape memory (SM) behaviors. The parameter identification procedure proposed in this paper can be used as an effective tool to assist the construction and application of such 3D multi-branch model for general SMP materials.     

The Relational Aspect to High Reliability Organization

The literature on ‘high reliability organizations’ demonstrates how central reliability is to organizing in certain highly demanding settings. In more mundane settings, however, where there may not be a dominant type of catastrophic failure, the meaning attributed to reliability is less likely to be unambiguous and consensual. It is more likely to be explicitly relational: a quality of the relationship between an entity that is being relied on and an entity that is relying on it. This draws attention to the importance of the relying process in contributing to how a system performs and whether it meets expectations. A field study was carried out in a highway construction and maintenance organization to analyse the various understandings of reliability that organizational members had in different contexts. It found that there were multiple understandings – involving a capacity not only to achieve particular outcomes but also comply with norms, fit behaviour to situations, and communicate about what could and could not be achieved. It also found that reliability problems were not solved in some simple sense. Instead they were transformed into other reliability problems that then had to be managed by further effort or by other organizations. We suggest that recognizing the multiple meanings of reliability, the importance of relying, and the way in which reliability problems are transformed from one form to another all have important practical implications.     

A qualitative energy-based unified representation for buildings

This paper presents the development of energy-based unified representations for buildings called Archi Bond Graphs and then specialises them as qualitative Archi Bond Graphs that combine graphical representations and qualitative equations. They can be applied to simulations of people behaviour and people-energy behaviour in space-people systems, building energy flows and building energy variations in different building energy systems, and energy interactions between these building subsystems. The applicability of qualitative Archi Bond Graphs is demonstrated through a building simulation for the dynamic energy interactions between the space-people system and building energy systems, including lighting system, and hydraulic system in a town-house design.     

Gold nanoshell density variation with laser power for induced hyperthermia

The thermal profile effects of nanoshell density, laser power, and laser arrangement are presented for ideal cases of nanoshell-assisted photothermal therapy. A one-dimensional thermal model utilizing the P₁ approximation is used to simulate the penetration of laser radiation and subsequent heating of 1-cm slabs of nanoshell-embedded tissue exposed to a 633-nm collimated light source. It is shown that adding too many nanoshells or increasing power can cause overheating in the entry region while leaving the rear region heated only by conduction, producing an undesirable temperature differential. An opposing dual-laser approach is presented that mitigates this issue.     

Unique orientation of lamellae in film processed poly (phenylene sulfide)

The morphology of poly(phenylene sulfide), PPS, obtained as processed film has been studied using wide angle X-ray scattering (WAXS), scanning electron microscopy (SEM), and differential scanning calorimetry (DSC). A unique morphology has been identified in the original film. The spherulites are very small in size and possess a cylindrical symmetry with their lamellae oriented on the edge. In these processed PPS films, the a-axis of the lattice is preferentially aligned perpendicular to the film plane, while the b and c axes are predominantly in the film plane. In the PPS isothermally crystallized from the melted, original film, there is no such preferential orientation. Thermal analysis of the original and melt crystal-lized PPS shows that while the degree of crystallinity is about the same, the nature of the amorphous phase in the two materials is different. In the original film, we did not observe a heat capacity increment at a glass transition temperature by DSC, indicating that all of the amorphous phase belongs to the category of rigid amorphous phase. In the melt crystallized PPS, a distinct glass transition was seen, though only a portion of the amorphous phase becomes mobile at T_g. The differences in orientation and mobility of the amorphous phase in the original film compared to melt crystallized PPS are explained by the different thermal processing procedures used for the two materials.