Vernacular architecture: questions of comfort and practicability

A paradoxical situation exists where vernacular building traditions are in a state of decline and are being replaced by modern counterparts, but they are repeatedly cited in the academic literature as exemplary models of environmental practice. This paradox is examined through research on whether vernacular passive cooling systems in the hot and dry climates of present-day Iran are practicable for the provision of comfortable indoor temperatures. Investigating their technical thermal performance as well as user perceptions and behaviour, positive and negative attributes of the cooling systems are identified. If conclusions about the long-term viability of vernacular buildings are to be drawn, then social, cultural, economic and environmental attributes need to be taken into consideration. Despite rather widespread and persistent assumptions, vernacular building traditions are not necessarily able to survive and the choices made by local people regarding the continuation or abandonment of specific traditions are influenced by a variety of cultural and practical factors. This substantiates the necessity of an integrated and holistic approach that engages with these variables in order to acquire a better understanding of the conditions for the survival of vernacular traditions.

Le fait que les traditions architecturales vernaculaires se trouvent dans un état de déclin et sont remplacées par leurs équivalents modernes, alors même qu'elles sont citées à maintes reprises dans la littérature universitaire comme des modèles exemplaires de pratique environnementale, constitue une situation paradoxale. Ce paradoxe est étudié au travers de recherches visant à déterminer si les systèmes de refroidissement passif vernaculaires sous les climats chauds et secs de l'Iran d'aujourd'hui peuvent être mis en pratique pour assurer des températures intérieures confortables. L’étude de leurs performances thermiques techniques aussi bien que des perceptions et du comportement des utilisateurs permet d'identifier les attributs positifs et négatifs des systèmes de refroidissement. S'il faut tirer des conclusions concernant la viabilité à long terme des bâtiments vernaculaires, il est alors nécessaire de prendre en considération les attributs sociaux, culturels, économiques et environnementaux. En dépit de présomptions plutôt répandues et tenaces, les traditions architecturales vernaculaires ne sont pas nécessairement capables de survivre et les choix opérés par les populations locales quant à la poursuite ou l'abandon de traditions spécifiques sont influencés par divers facteurs culturels et pratiques. Ceci confirme la nécessité d'une approche intégrée et holistique qui, par ces variables, incite à acquérir une meilleure compréhension des conditions propres à assurer la survie des traditions vernaculaires.

Mots clés: confort adaptatif, performances des bâtiments, attentes, traditions locales, occupants, refroidissement passif, architecture vernaculaire, Iran     

Global warming and thermohaline circulation stability

The Atlantic thermohaline circulation (THC) plays an important role in global climate. Theoretical and palaeoclimatic evidence points to the possibility of rapid changes in the strength of the THC, including a possible quasi-permanent shutdown. The climatic impacts of such a shutdown would be severe, including a cooling throughout the Northern Hemisphere, which in some regions is greater in magnitude than the changes expected from global warming in the next 50 years. Other climatic impacts would likely include a severe alteration of rainfall patterns in the tropics, the Indian subcontinent and Europe. Modelling the future behaviour of the THC focuses on two key questions. (i) Is a gradual weakening of the THC likely in response to global warming, and if so by how much? (ii) Are there thresholds beyond which rapid or irreversible changes in the THC are likely? Most projections of the response of the THC to increasing concentrations of greenhouse gases suggest a gradual weakening over the twenty-first century. However, there is a wide variation between different models over the size of the weakening. Rapid or irreversible THC shutdown is considered a low-probability (but high-impact) outcome; however, some climate models of intermediate complexity do show the possibility of such events. The question of the future of the THC is beset with conceptual, modelling and observational uncertainties, but some current and planned projects show promise to make substantial progress in tackling these uncertainties in future.     

Some rationales for risk sharing and financing adaptation.

Current climate variability and anticipated climate change challenge our water systems and our financial resources. The sharing of economic losses due to weather related hazards and the sharing of costs that result from protecting lives and property take place in different forms, but are currently insufficient. In this paper we discuss three different rationales for financing disaster losses through public and private arrangements, as well as options for financing adaptation, with a special focus on water management. We propose that financial arrangements for risk sharing and climate change adaptation should be reconsidered, in a more structured approach, to be able to deal with both disaster losses and the costs that arise because of climate change adaptation, e.g. for water management, in both developing and developed countries.     

Quantifying the effect of heat stress on daily milk yield and monitoring dynamic changes using an adaptive dynamic model

Automation and use of robots are increasingly being used within dairy farming and result in large amounts of real time data. This information provides a base for the new management concept of precision livestock farming. From 2003 to 2006, time series of herd mean daily milk yield were collected on 6 experimental research farms in the Netherlands. These time series were analyzed with an adaptive dynamic model following a Bayesian method to quantify the effect of heat stress. The effect of heat stress was quantified in terms of critical temperature above which heat stress occurred, duration of heat stress periods, and resulting loss in milk yield. In addition, dynamic changes in level and trend were monitored, including the estimation of a weekly pattern. Monitoring comprised detection of potential outliers and other deteriorations. The adaptive dynamic model fitted the data well; the root mean squared error of the forecasts ranged from 0.55 to 0.99 kg of milk/d. The percentages of potential outliers and signals for deteriorations ranged from 5.5 to 9.7%. The Bayesian procedure for time series analysis and monitoring provided a useful tool for process control. Online estimates (based on past and present only) and retrospective estimates (determined afterward from all data) of level and trend in daily milk yield showed an almost yearly cycle that was in agreement with the calving pattern: most cows calved in winter and early spring versus summer and autumn. Estimated weekly patterns in terms of weekday effects could be related to specific management actions, such as change of pasture during grazing. For the effect of heat stress, the mean estimated critical temperature above which heat stress was expected was 17.8 ± 0.56°C. The estimated duration of the heat stress periods was 5.5 ± 1.03 d, and the estimated loss was 31.4 ± 12.2 kg of milk/cow per year. Farm-specific estimates are helpful to identify management factors like grazing, housing and feeding, that affect the impact of heat stress. The effect of heat stress can be decreased by modifying these factors.     

Interaction between cracking, delamination and buckling in brittle elastic thin films

A discrete lattice based model for the interaction of cracking, delamination and buckling of brittle elastic coatings is presented. The model is unique in its simultaneous incorporation of the coating and of disorder in the interface and material properties, leading to realistic 3D bending (and buckling) behavior. Results are compared to the literature. In the case of cracking, the key role of a stress transfer correlation length ξ in establishing a scaling behavior for the brittle fracture of thin films is shown to extend to all geometrical and material properties involved. In the scaling regime of crack density in uniaxial tension cracking and delamination are found to occur simultaneously. In uniaxial tension of films with an internal biaxial compressive stress, the predicted initiation of buckles above delaminated areas near crack edges in the model is remarkably similar to experimental results.     

Crack propagation along polymer/non-polymer interfaces

Mechanisms of the propagation of crack fronts along interfaces between a glassy polymer and metal or glass are discussed. Specifically, the systems studied are Poly-Ethylene Terephthalate (PETG) spin-coated on Al, PETG-glass and PETG hot-pressed on Cr-sputtered glass. Cracks studied propagate in an Assymetric Double Cantilever Beam (ADCB) geometry. Dependence of microscopic crack front geometry on propagation speed is found. The local stress state is found to have an impact on macroscopic as well as microscopic crack front geometry. Simple lattice model calculations of propagating crack fronts illustrate the impact of disorder and residual stress state on propagation mechanisms and macroscopic crack front shape respectively.     

Gas permeation and temperature effects in laser-induced delamination

Laser-induced delamination (LID) is a technique aimed at measuring the work of adhesion of thin polymer coatings on metal substrates. A laser pulse is used to create a blister that initiates delamination of the film under pressure. The stress fields in the blister wall and the work of adhesion of the interface are determined using a linear elastic model.In this paper we discuss validity of the LID results addressing permeation of gas through the blister wall and the initial high temperature of the substrate. A procedure to account for the effect of gas permeation in the calculations of the work of adhesion is proposed. Permeation of gas is also considered under compressive and tensile in-plane stresses. Modeling of the permeation process demonstrates a good agreement with the experiment.At early stage of the blister formation the metal substrate and the blister gas experience high temperatures. The time scales of the cooling processes are estimated. Possible effects of the high temperatures on the permeation of gas and on the process of delamination are discussed.     

Adhesion along metal–polymer interfaces during plastic deformation

In this paper a numerical study is presented that concentrates on the influence of the interface roughness that develops during plastic deformation of a metal, on the work of adhesion and on the change of interface energy upon contact with a glassy polymer. The polymer coating is described with a constitutive law that mimics the behavior of Poly-Ethylene Terephthalate. It includes an elastic part, a yield stress, softening and hardening with increasing strains. For the interface between the metal and the polymer a mixed-mode (mode I and II) stress-separation law is applied that defines the interface energy and an interaction length scale. At the onset of deformation the surface of the substrate has a self-affine roughness characterized by the so-called Hurst exponent, a correlation length and an rms roughness amplitude, that evolves as a function of increasing strain. The findings are the following: the interface energy decreases until the strain at yield of the polymer coating. Interestingly, after yielding as the polymer starts to soften macroscopically, the decreasing average stress levels result in partial recovery of the interface energy at the interface. At higher strains, when macroscopic hardening develops the recovery of the interface stops and the interface energy decreases. The effect of coating thickness is discussed as well as the physical relevance of various model parameters.     

Local delamination on heavily deformed polymer–metal interfaces: evidence from microscopy

In this work the microstructure of interfaces present in heavily bi-axially deformed polymer-coated metal is studied. Cross sections of deformed polymer-coated steel are prepared using several polishing strategies, including the use of focused ion beam, and are imaged using optical microscopy and scanning electron microscopy. We find that the interfaces show significant details right down to the smallest scale observable with the preparation techniques used of about ~10 nm. Local delamination events at these deformed interfaces are observed and are found to be preferentially associated with overhanging parts on the interface. Overhanging parts are frequently observed, but only below a certain length-scale on the interfaces that are otherwise found to be self-affine up to a certain correlation length. The smallest detail includes the tail of the size distribution of the overhanging features. Together this suggests that the physical mechanisms determining the formation of critical features for adhesion operate at sub-grain level as well as at grain level.