Characterization of residual information for SeaWinds quality control

Recent work has shown the important properties of the wind inversion residual or maximum-likelihood estimator (MLE) for quality Control (QC) of QuikSCAT Hierarchical Data Format (HDF) observations. Since March 2000, the QuikSCAT near-real-time (NRT) Binary Universal Format Representation (BUFR) product is available. As this product is used for numerical weather prediction (NWP) assimilation purposes, a QC procedure for the BUFR product is needed. We study the behavior of the MLE in order to determine whether the HDF QC procedure is appropriate for BUFR data. A comparison using real HDF and BUFR data reveals that the MLE distributions of HDF and BUFR differ and are actually poorly correlated. One important difference between BUFR and HDF is the amount of signal averaging prior to wind inversion. The averaging reduces the number of observations used in the wind retrieval for the BUFR product as compared to HDF. We show with a simple example that different MLE distributions are indeed expected due to this averaging. We also run a simulation in order to link theory and reality and better understand the behavior of the MLE. Despite the different MLE behavior in BUFR and HDF, the quality of the retrieved winds, as compared with the European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts winds, is very similar. We develop an MLE-based QC procedure for BUFR, similarly to the one in HDF, and we compare both. The skill of the QC in BUFR is again very similar to the one in HDF, showing that despite the different MLE behavior in both formats, the properties of the MLE as a QC indicator remain very similar.     

On Bayesian scatterometer wind inversion

In a quest for a generic unbiased scatterometer wind inversion method, the different inversion procedures currently in use are revisited in this paper. A careful examination of both the errors in the wind and in the measurement domain, combined with the nonlinear shape of the geophysical model function (GMF), leads to a generic and novel Bayesian wind retrieval approach in the measurement domain. In this approach the shape of the GMF solution manifold in measurement space is more important than the specified noise. This shape is related to the system wind direction sensitivity, and when this sensitivity is uniform, realistic and precise wind direction distributions are retrieved, even when measurements lie far from the GMF manifold. A simplified measurement space transformation that produces such uniform sensitivity for the European Remote Sensing Satellite (ERS) scatterometer is presented and shown to have reduced wind direction bias compared to the more traditional (measurement-noise normalized) inversion for ERS. Moreover, the simplified wind inversion reveals a similar performance to the current operational ERS wind inversion, but is potentially more generally applicable. The simplified method is then applied to SeaWinds but is ineffective. In this case the instrument geometry results in a low sensitivity to wind direction at a few specific directions. As a consequence, certain wind direction solutions remain favored in the SeaWinds inversion.