Effect of Location of Restraint on Fire Response of Steel Beams

Restrained steel beams, when exposed to fire, develop significant restraint forces and often behave as beam-columns. The response of such restrained steel beams under fire depends on many factors including: fire scenario, beam slenderness ratio, location of axial restraint at the supports, and high-temperature properties of steel. A set of numerical studies, using finite element computer program ANSYS, is carried out to study the fire response of steel beam-columns under realistic fire and restraint scenarios. Results from the parametric studies indicate that fire scenario, beam slenderness, location of axial restraint and high-temperature creep have significant influence on the behavior of restrained beams under fire conditions. Severe fires produce high axial forces at early stages of fire exposure; whereas in moderate fires, significant axial force develops only at later stages of fire exposure. Axial restraint enhances the fire resistance due to the development of tensile catenary action in restrained beams. Furthermore, restrained beams with low slenderness ratio exhibit better fire performance when the axial restraint at the support is located at the bottom flange.     

Fire Endurance of High Strength Concrete Columns

In buildings, fire represents one of the most severe environmental conditions, and therefore, should be properly accounted for in the design of high strength concrete (HSC) structural members. The increased use of HSC in buildings has raised concerns regarding the behavior of such concrete in fire. In particular, spalling at elevated temperatures, as identified in studies by a number of laboratories, is a main concern.In this paper, results from an experimental program on the fire resistance of HSC columns are presented. The factors that influence the thermal and structural behavior of HSC concrete columns under fire conditions are discussed. Data from this study indicate that the type of aggregate, concrete strength, load intensity, and detailing and spacing of ties have an influence on the fire resistance performance of HSC columns. Further, the test results show that tie configuration (bending of ties at 135°, ties and provision of cross ties) and closer tie spacing has a significantly beneficial effect on the fire resistance of HSC columns. The results presented will generate data on the fire resistance of HSC columns, and contribute to identifying the factors that influence the behavior of HSC columns.     

三面及四面受火钢骨混凝土柱的耐火性能

在标准火灾条件下进行钢骨混凝土柱的耐火试验。以几何尺寸、三面或四面受火、荷载大小及偏心为参数,研究其对钢骨混凝土耐火性能的影响。结果表明:钢骨混凝土柱三面受火条件下的耐火性能高于四面受火;载荷比和荷载偏心的影响可以忽略;混凝土的剥落降低了柱耐火性能。将试验结果与现有规范进行对比可知,某些条件下,按规范计算的耐火性能可能偏高。     

Response of steel beam–columns exposed to fire

Steel beams when exposed to fire develop significant restraint forces and often behave as beam–columns. The response of such restrained steel beams under fire depends on many factors including fire scenario, load level, degree of restraint at the supports, and high-temperature properties of steel. A set of numerical studies, using finite element computer program ANSYS, is carried out to study the fire response of steel beam–columns under realistic fire, load and restraint scenarios. The finite element model is validated against experimental data, and the importance of high-temperature creep on the fire response of steel beam–columns is illustrated. The validated model is used to carry out a set of parametric studies. Results from the parametric studies indicate that fire scenario, load level, degree of end-restraint and high-temperature creep have significant influence on the behavior of beams under fire conditions. The type of fire scenario plays a critical role in determining the fire response of the laterally-unrestrained steel beam within a space subframe. Increased load level leads to higher catenary forces resulting in lower fire resistance. Rotational restraint enhances the fire resistance of a laterally-unrestrained steel beam, while the axial restraint has detrimental effect on fire resistance.     

Fire behaviour of hollow structural section steel columns filled with high strength concrete

The use of hollow structural section (HSS) steel columns filled with high strength concrete (HSC) is becoming popular due to many advantages they offer. However, whereas the design rules for HSS columns filled with normal strength concrete are well established, there are many uncertainties for HSS columns filled with HSC. Results from numerical studies on the behaviour of HSS columns filled with HSC are presented. The studies were carried out based on both North American and European material properties for HSC and steel. Results show that required fire resistance in HSS columns can be obtained through the use of bar- or steel fibre-reinforcement in HSC.     

Test methods for characterizing concrete properties at elevated temperature

Fire resistance of structural members is dependent on the thermal and mechanical properties of constituent materials and these properties vary as a function of temperature. Currently, there are limited standardized test procedures for evaluating thermal and mechanical properties of construction materials at elevated temperatures. This paper provides a review and assessment of test methods and procedures for evaluating high temperature thermal and mechanical properties of concrete. The drawbacks and variations in currently available test procedures and methods in standards are discussed. Recommendations on the most suitable methods and procedures for measuring thermal and mechanical properties at elevated temperature is presented. In addition, applicability of the proposed high temperature test methods and procedures is illustrated through a case study on conventional concrete specimens. Further, the need for developing standards by organizations such as American Society for Testing and Materials (ASTM), with standardized specifications and test procedures for measuring high temperature properties of construction materials, is laid out.     

Numerical Model for Tracing the Response of FRP-Strengthened RC Beams Exposed to Fire

This paper presents the development of a numerical model for evaluating the performance of fiber-reinforced polymer (FRP)-strengthened RC beams under fire conditions. The model is based on a macroscopic finite-element approach and utilizes moment-curvature relationships to trace the response of insulated FRP-strengthened RC beams from linear elastic stage to collapse under any given fire exposure and loading scenarios. In the analysis, high temperature properties of constitutive materials, load and restraint conditions, material and geometric nonlinearity are accounted for, and a realistic failure criterion is applied to evaluate the failure of the beams. The model is validated against fire test data on FRP-strengthened RC beams and is applied to study the effect of FRP-strengthening, insulation scheme, and failure criterion on the fire response of FRP-strengthened RC beams. Results from the analysis indicate that FRP-strengthened RC beams should be protected with supplemental fire insulation to satisfy fire resistance requirements. A case study is presented to illustrate the application of the model for optimizing the fire insulation scheme to achieve required fire resistance in FRP-strengthened concrete beams.     

Effect of high temperature creep on the fire response of restrained steel beams

At room temperature, and at service load levels, creep has little effect on the performance of steel structures. However, under fire conditions, creep becomes a dominant factor and influences fire resistance of steel members. Under fire conditions, significant forces develop in restrained steel beams and these forces induce high stresses in the steel section. The extent of creep deformations is affected by magnitude and rate of development of stress and temperature in steel. In this paper, the effect of high temperature creep on fire response of restrained beams is investigated. Current high temperature creep models are compared. Finite element model created in ANSYS was validated by comparing the predictions with fire test data. The validated model was applied to investigate the effect of load level, heating rate, fire scenario and fire induced axial restraint on the extent of creep deformations. Results from the parametric study indicate that the influence of high temperature creep increases with the increase in axial restraint, heating rate, and load level. Generally, neglecting high-temperature creep effect stiffens the structural response and leads to reduced deflections but larger restraint forces. Therefore, neglecting high temperature creep in fire resistance analysis of steel structures can lead to unconservative predictions.     

Structures in Fire: State-of-the-Art, Research and Training Needs

Structural fire safety is one of the key considerations in the design and maintenance of the built infrastructure, yet there are serious limitations in the current approaches to structural fire safety and also severe knowledge gaps in the literature. Two main reasons for these limitations are the lack of significant research activities in this field and lack of educational and training programs in the universities. This paper reviews the current state-of-the-art and identifies the research and training needs for improved fire safety in the U.S. These discussions are based on a two-day workshop organized at Michigan State University which brought together many academics from U.S universities, international experts, and design professionals in the structural fire safety field. This paper summarizes the conclusions of the workshop and identifies the top ten research and training needs in structural fire safety.