Timing of artificial insemination of dairy cows: fixed time once daily versus morning and afternoon

Nonreturn rates to professional technician service of 7240 first AI Holstein cows were calculated to evaluate differences between once daily and a.m.-p.m. AI. To determine whether management practices affected nonreturn rates, participating herd owners were surveyed for methods used for detection of estrus. Nonreturn rates for once daily and a.m.-p.m. AI were 64.6 and 65.6% for 60-d, 60.1 and 60.6% for 75-d, and 58.4 and 57.8% for 90-d nonreturn periods. Signs of estrus for AI and interval from detection of estrus to AI were related to nonreturn rates. Nonreturn rate was highest, 63.4%, when cows were in standing estrus. Nonreturn rates were lowest, 36%, when cows were bred after treatment with PGF2 alpha without being detected in estrus or bred strictly on veterinary advice based on palpation. Nonreturn rates were similar for different times of the day when once daily AI was practiced. However, AI in the midmorning may have some advantages. The highest nonreturn rate for a 3-h period was 68.2% for 0800 and 1100 h; the lowest was 54.7% for 1300 to 1600 h. Movement before observation for estrus and an observation period > 15 min improved nonreturn rates for once daily AI. Once daily AI can be used effectively with no difference from the traditional a.m.-p.m. system; results are best when AI is based on standing estrus and performed between 0800 and 1100 h.