Responses of human glioblastoma cells to human natural tumor necrosis factor-alpha: susceptibility, mechanism of resistance and cytokine production studies

Responses and susceptibility of 14 human glioblastoma cell lines to human natural tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF) were studied in vitro. Susceptibility of glioblastoma cells to TNF varied in experimental conditions applied. Most of glioblastoma cell lines were resistant to cytotoxic activity of TNF in a MTT assay at concentrations below 16 U/ml for 72 h exposure. However, TNF at higher dose, in prolonged exposure and against low density of target cells was antiproliferative for certain glioblastoma cultures. TNF exposure at 10 U/ml for 48 h suppressed DNA synthesis in 9 of 14 glioblastoma cultures, but increased in 3 cultures. In addition, colony forming assay showed anti-clonogenic activity of TNF in 5 of 6 glioblastoma cell lines tested. In spite of their low susceptibility to TNF, glioblastoma cells well responded to TNF stimulation at low dose (10 U/ml) for a short period in the absence of cell damage. Productions of Interleukin-6 (IL-6), IL-8-like activity, granulocyte-macrophage colony stimulating factor (GM-CSF), prostaglandin E2 (PGE2) and manganous superoxide dismutase (Mn-SOD) were enhanced or induced by the low-dose TNF stimulation. Mn-SOD, a protein protective against oxidative cell damage, was well induced in time- and dose-dependent manner, however did not correlate with TNF resistance. Whereas the levels of PGE2 in TNF-susceptible cell lines, H-4 and SF-188, were higher than those of other lines. In conclusion, most of glioblastoma cells are resistant to TNF cytotoxic effects, but highly responsive to TNF stimulation. Its effect on glioblastoma cells appears to modulate cell differentiation rather than to kill the cells.