Comparative study of thermal post-buckling analysis of uniform slender & shear flexible columns using rigorous finite element and intuitive formulations

Thermal post-buckling analysis of uniform, isotropic, slender and shear flexible columns is presented using a rigorous finite element formulation and a much simpler intuitive formulation. The ends of the columns are axially restrained to move and consequently any temperature rise above the stress free condition of the column produces an equivalent constant compressive mechanical load that causes the column to buckle at a critical temperature. Further increase in temperature beyond critical temperature results in the thermal post-buckling phenomenon. As a result of constraints imposed on the axial displacement at the ends of the column, the post-buckling phenomenon is governed by the von-Karman strain displacement relation applicable to one dimensional problems. Empirical formula for ratio of nonlinear axial load to critical load (equivalent constant mechanical load for a given temperature rise) as a function of the central deflection are obtained using both the rigorous finite element and intuitive formulations for various boundary conditions. The boundary conditions considered are the classical such as hinged-hinged, clamped-clamped and clamped-hinged conditions and nonclassical boundary conditions like the hinged-guided or the clamped-guided conditions. Post-buckling analysis results pertaining to nonclassical boundary conditions are meagre in the literature. It is observed that results obtained from both the formulations are in excellent agreement for all boundary conditions considered. Also the accuracy and simplicity of the intuitive formulation is aptly demonstrated to slender and shear flexible columns.