关于反转构造的几个问题--与蔡希泉、王同和先生商榷

对由蔡希源、王同和编著的《中国油气区反转构造》一书中的观点，提出了不同的看法。指出，该书关于反转构造的内涵前后自相矛盾，在书中所例举的大量实例中也常违背识别反转构造的原则；将反转构造分为正反转构造和负反转构造是正确的，但却未能阐明如何识别它们的标志；在阐述反转构造对形成油气藏有利的一面时，忽视了它对油气成藏的破坏作用。指出，书中引用了大量的他人资料，却未能注明其出处，这是很不妥当的。

Questions on Reverse Structure in China Petroleum Provinces--A discussion with Mr.CAI Xi-quan and Mr.WANG Tong-he

Different c omments are proposed on the viewpoints of a book Reverse Structure in China Petr oleum Provinces written by Mr.CAI Xi-quan and Mr.WANG Tong-he.The author po ints out that the meaning about reverse structure was a contradiction in terms ,and great numbers of cases listed in this book disobeyed the principles of rev erse structure recognition;to divide the reverse structure into positive one an d negative one was acceptable,but no recognizable indicators for them were giv en;the aspects for favorably forming oil-gas reservoir were expounded,but th e destructibility of reverse structure to oil-gas accumulation was ignored in t he book.In addition,it is improper to cite so many others' litera-tures witho ut any notes of derivations.