Optimal External Memory Planar Point Enclosure

In this paper we study the external memory planar point enclosure problem: Given N axis-parallel rectangles in the plane, construct a data structure on disk (an index) such that all K rectangles containing a query point can be reported I/O-efficiently. This problem has important applications in e.g. spatial and temporal databases, and is dual to the important and well-studied orthogonal range searching problem. Surprisingly, despite the fact that the problem can be solved optimally in internal memory with linear space and O(log N+K) query time, we show that one cannot construct a linear sized external memory point enclosure data structure that can be used to answer a query in O(log  _B N+K/B) I/Os, where B is the disk block size. To obtain this bound, Ω(N/B ^1−ε ) disk blocks are needed for some constant ε>0. With linear space, the best obtainable query bound is O(log ₂ N+K/B) if a linear output term O(K/B) is desired. To show this we prove a general lower bound on the tradeoff between the size of the data structure and its query cost. We also develop a family of structures with matching space and query bounds. An extended abstract of this paper appeared in Proceedings of the 12th European Symposium on Algorithms (ESA’04), Bergen, Norway, September 2004, pp. 40–52. L. Arge’s research was supported in part by the National Science Foundation through RI grant EIA–9972879, CAREER grant CCR–9984099, ITR grant EIA–0112849, and U.S.-Germany Cooperative Research Program grant INT–0129182, as well as by the US Army Research Office through grant W911NF-04-01-0278, by an Ole Roemer Scholarship from the Danish National Science Research Council, a NABIIT grant from the Danish Strategic Research Council and by the Danish National Research Foundation. V. Samoladas’ research was supported in part by a grant co-funded by the European Social Fund and National Resources-EPEAEK II-PYTHAGORAS. K. Yi’s research was supported in part by the National Science Foundation through ITR grant EIA–0112849, U.S.-Germany Cooperative Research Program grant INT–0129182, and Hong Kong Direct Allocation Grant (DAG07/08).