An Investigation of the Measurements Systems Analysis “Analytic Method” for Attribute Gages

Three automotive corporations have developed and sanctioned the recently revised reference manual entitled Measurement Systems Analysis. This “standard” contains a procedure, called the “analytic method,” whose purpose is to estimate the gage bias and gage repeatability of an attribute gage. An improved estimation procedure for this standard is presented. The improved estimation procedure yields more accurate estimates than those obtained using the procedures currently presented in the standard. In addition, the improved procedure allows more flexibility in data collection than the current test protocol. A simulation study that evaluates the estimation procedure of the current standard and compares it with the improved estimation procedure is presented. Errors that are contained in the present standard are also noted.