Comparison of biomechanical properties of the incisor periodontal ligament among different species

BACKGROUND: The aim of this study was to obtain a more precise understanding of the mechanical properties of the periodontal ligament in continuously erupting incisors by comparing the shear stress-strain relations among teeth from four closely related species. METHODS: Four species of experimental animals (mice, hamsters, rats, and rabbits) were used. Transverse sections of the left mandibular incisors were cut from the incisal, middle, and basal regions of each incisor. The tooth was pushed out of the alveolar bone in an extrusive direction at 5 mm/min using a materials testing machine. The maximum shear stress, maximum shear strain, tangent modulus, and failure strain energy density were estimated from the resulting stress-strain curve. Polarized light microscopic observations of collagen fibers were also made. RESULTS: All the biomechanical measures tended to decrease from the incisal toward the basal regions in all species. There were large species differences, especially in the incisal region, with the greatest maximum shear stress and failure strain energy density in hamsters. The greatest tangent modulus and the smallest maximum shear strain were observed in mice. The birefringent fiber architectures of the periodontal ligaments in the four species appeared to be similarly organized; the incisal periodontal ligament appeared to have more organized and thicker collagen fibres than did the middle and basal ligaments in the four species. CONCLUSIONS: These results suggest that the regional differences in the biomechanical properties of the periodontal ligament depend upon the developmental stages of the periodontal collagen fibers that may be related to the general arrangement, diameters, and densities of the collagen fiber bundles and the fiber insertions into the alveolar bone and cementum. The species differences in the biomechanical properties may be due to differences in the width of the periodontal ligament and the waviness as well as the strength and stiffness of the periodontal collagen fibers.