A comparison of fragmentation models

The key to conducting an accurate lethality assessment is the use of a robust assessment methodology. One of the critical components of a lethality assessment is the characterization of the debris cloud created by the initial high speed impact. Without a proper characterization, it is impossible to obtain an accurate prediction of the response of an interior target component to subsequent debris cloud impact loadings. The fast-running codes FATEPEN2, KAPP-II, and PEN4 contain fragmentation models that characterize the debris cloud fragment population resulting from a high speed impact. The objective of the work described in this paper as to compare the predictions of the fragmentation models within these three codes over the 1–16 km/s impact velocity regime. This objective was achieved through a parametric study of debris cloud material characterization using the fragmentation schemes in the FATEPEN2, KAPP-II, and PEN4 semi-empirical lethality assessment schemes for a variety of projectile and target materials and configurations.