Comparative energy barriers for hydrogen activation by homogeneous and heterogeneous metal oxide catalysts

Triethylene glycol solutions of alkali and alkaline earth metal hydroxide complexes are well-defined soluble oxide water-gas shift catalysts which equilibrate the reaction of carbon monoxide and water to yield hydrogen and carbon dioxide at temperatures ranging from 150 ° to 250 °C and carbon monoxide pressures of 1 to 300 atm. Significantly, catalysis proceeds cleanly, even in the complete absence of a metal center in the soluble oxide system. Thus, the rate of hydroxide ion catalyzed hydrogen evolution is highest in the presence of a noncoordinating organic cation: Bu_ΔN⁺>Cs⁺>Na⁺>H⁺>Ca⁺². Furthermore, the activation energy for the homogeneous sodium hydroxide catalyst in triethylene glycol solution, 26±1 kcal, is comparable to that exhibited by a commercially used heterogeneous iron oxide catalyst, 27±0.2 kcal. The alkali metal hydroxide system may be modified for metal cocatalysis. Thus, lead (II) oxide dissolves in the triethylene glycol solutions to yield a new species which exhibits a²⁰⁷Pb NMR resonance shifted 3350 ppm downfield from lead perchlorate. The activity of this lead modified system is improved by three orders of magnitude. Yet, the activation energy is unchanged, 26±1 kcal, suggesting that entropic factors may be important in these homogeneous metal oxide hydrogen evolution/activation systems.